what artist, if any, is worth doing an ILM tracks poll?

a) nobody needs a comprehensive knowledge of a genre to have favorite songs from that genre and b) c'mon everybody has favorite rap songs, even gier.

did geir send in a list? how did that go over?

where's the harm?

too many at one time, predictable results, bit depressing seeing new answers topped by threads reinforcing ILM's indie-centricity (based on the bands that get this treatment first)

― blueski, donderdag 16 juni 2011 16:10 (12 minutes ago) Bookmark

The Pavement poll that ended yesterday was a glorious run-down of tracks, a whole band's career, people going back in time not just returning to the music but also life. Presented in a great way by Johnny Fever, unpredictable outcome, fun was had by all. If you don't like Pavement that's tough then, sorry it makes you depressed seeing it top the 'new answers' list. But that poll and it's countdown really has been an ILM highlight for me, with a great turn-out and participation too. What more could you want?

Thing is, there are artists I'd want to *watch* a top 50 of, so I could find out more.

Trying to think what artists I'd both care and be knowledgeable enough to participate. Without getting nailfiles at dawn over the Supremes or anything. Heck, I'd love to see a 60s Girlgroups poll, but that's a genre poll not an artist so I don't ever have to choose between the Crystals and the Ronettes.

tbh I can rarely be arsed to actually vote in any of those send in a whole big ordered list type polls but I have no problem with other people doing them, or with reading the results threads if I have any passing interest in the band.

Hey maybe there should be a separate I Love Polls board!?!?!?!1

yeah but ballots cast by casual non-knowledgeable fans lead to that familiar ILM scourge: polls that are more predictable and less interesting as they head towards the top (<-though this may in fact be unavoidable)

gotta say, i'm surprised the manics one is getting so much mileage, but then i'm not a huge huge fan.

i'm always surprised when people say ilm is overly indie-centric (whatever that means, uh-oh close that can'o worms) - i hear more people complaining about indie on here than actually discussing it.

that's how you know it's indie-centric

Well, there you go, the intelligensia vote, the cognoscentii watch.

I have no idea if that makes sense or not.

gotta say, i'm surprised the manics one is getting so much mileage,

I'm not.

Thing is, there are artists I'd want to *watch* a top 50 of, so I could find out more.

Yeah me too, and I think that song by song discussions for some of those artists could be really interesting.

lex check yr fb, i sent you the hiphop poll winners

haha i kind of meant that i wanted to continue happily assuming shawnna won!

hey before the flood can we make a rule that only one of these can go on at once

Consign x1000. I don't really care as long as ILM isn't suddenly full of loads of these things, even if polling every Oasis song or whatever is k-lame.

In fact I might actually enforce this.

Geir didn't send a list but he totally should have! he might've helped Pac place more stuff

xp to Lex: LOL that's why I asked first!

Thing is, there are artists I'd want to *watch* a top 50 of, so I could find out more.

yeah - but not canon artists like prince or wu-tang clan (two examples of acts i basically love but don't have anywhere near the knowledge of to vote on). cuz you can get recommendations of canon artists anywhere, you know? probably right here, if you look at past threads on those artists.

everyone should be able to create whatever the hell poll they want, but if they all do it at once, it's gonna be a 'thing'

keep a strict time-limit and make a list of volunteers

The Pavement poll that ended yesterday was a glorious run-down of tracks, a whole band's career, people going back in time not just returning to the music but also life. Presented in a great way by Johnny Fever, unpredictable outcome, fun was had by all. If you don't like Pavement that's tough then, sorry it makes you depressed seeing it top the 'new answers' list. But that poll and it's countdown really has been an ILM highlight for me, with a great turn-out and participation too. What more could you want?

― ...wow! (Le Bateau Ivre), Thursday, June 16, 2011 3:28 PM (1 minute ago) Bookmark

qft

well I took part in the hip-hop, blur, and pavement polls cos I'm really into all three. The hiphop def lead me to hearing some great stuff that I had blanked on (black moon, camp lo, smoothe da hustler) and the blur and pavement ones kinda gave me good vibes. Out of the list at the top The Cure is the one that I'd find hardest but best 'qualified' to take part in and the Prince one is the one that would be most helpful in identifying which stuff I should get acquainted with given that I haven't been paying attention to his stuff for a decade.

Matt DC that would be awesome

this poll is well on its way to accruing 100 new answers before the hour's over; go figure this would turn into a clusterfuck

agree it should be a "one at a a time" thing, if it is a thing.

my vague metric for these things is "if this artist has a peak period of 3 or fewer albums that will dominate the top 20 songs then it's not really worth doing," which is totally the case for Pavement

I think 2 at a time wouldn't be too many.

I guess I could just go read my Aphex Twin: Pick Only 3 and put it into a spreadsheet to tabulate the most favoured tracks.

But I suppose anyone could do that with any POX thread and have the same fun.

agree it should be a "one at a a time" thing, if it is a thing.

― the Sandalled Vandal (dog latin), donderdag 16 juni 2011 16:35 (18 seconds ago) Bookmark

An 'ILM Poll Registration and Reservation Bureau'-thread could deal with that, yes

when that volunteer list is made, I'll do beach boys. (I don't have to go first.)

Seems to me like there's a level of commitment required for one of these polls that I don't possess. I miss POXes!

I enjoyed the pavement poll even though I didn't participate (mostly because I felt there was too much material I was unfamiliar with). it got me to listen to wowee zowee, which I had owned for several years but never really gave enough of a chance.

I wish there were polls like this for other bands I'm not overly familiar with, if only to incite me to dig deeper into their catalog.

i completely support vigorous unrelenting enforcement of 1 at a time but can we wait until after the MC Tunes results thread?

^ was gonna say

I think one at a time, and one nominations thread running at a time. Otherwise people will just go mad for polling ever-more niche interest bands in this fashion and clogging up New Answers. Very reticent to fully take the breaks off the nerdy listmaking juggernaut.

LBI that's fair enough re the success of the Pavement poll. It's just the combination of numerous polls (not really interested in big ILM polls anymore) and focus on these kinds of bands irking me.

I actually really like the Poll Reservation & Registration Thread idea

You don't need a nominations thread for a single band, though, do you? It's pretty obvious what's in their catalogue and not.

to fully take the breaks off the nerdy listmaking juggernaut

board description etc

Okay but put me down for a Nolan Sisters poll next cos I wanna break up the patriarchy a bit.

Not to beat a dead horse here, but I was really thrilled with that Pavement results thread. Tons of chatter and excitement, but the results weren't in the least predictable! Also, surprising, virtually no bitching! Anyway, if all the poll results threads could be that much fun to read, I'd love to see a lot more.

Sorry, Karen D, I forgot that's not how the Blur thing ran.

i have a decent familiarity with Pavement's catalog (heard all the proper albums before i realized i dislike them more often than i like them) and the results of that poll didn't look at all unpredictable to me tbh.

"one at a time" partisans, can we at least agree that once the reveal starts for X, the voting can start for Y?

Suggested format:

MC HAMMER Tracks Poll (Next up: The Cranberries)

lol

now i want to make a "Zombie" vs. "2 Legit 2 Quit" thread

2 Legit all the way

Puuuuuullllllllllppppppp

i love Pulp but any poll would that MOST predictable results ever it's that one

but if any poll would have the most etc.

i have a decent familiarity with Pavement's catalog (heard all the proper albums before i realized i dislike them more often than i like them) and the results of that poll didn't look at all unpredictable to me tbh.

Just because "Summer Babe" won and "Gold Soundz" placed high, didn't mean the rest of the poll was predictable. There were lots of non-album tracks and rarities, very cool to see which ones were the most loved.

I voted in the Blur poll, didn't in the Pavement poll and won't vote in the Manics. However even though I'm not a Pavement fan the enthusiasm and debate made it an interesting read. I don't know why some dude's so worked up about them, it's not as if they're hard to ignore. Matt DC's one at a time option seems a good compromise.

I agree the choices so far have been too indiecentric but those bands will soon be worked through and other bands/producers will get their chance to shine.

ps I bags the Pet Shop Boys poll.