Thread for coordinating the order and timing of ILM ballot polls

haha yeah kinda. except i should be so lucky to have an entourage like that :(

I'm confirming! I'm going to need some hand-holding running the thing (I heard there's a spreadsheet or something to make the tabulation easier? I am terrible at using Excel however), if someone doesn't mind helping me?

I'm excited that, after The Cure, I get to take a lengthy break from these. Y'all have fun with your polls I care very little about! I'll be back for The Boss.

(note: I like Kate Bush, Hüsker Dü, Kraftwerk and The Who okay enough, but not enough to participate)

Mordy, I'll email you the Excel file. I don't know anything about spreadsheets either, but Finefinemusic's notes in the file are pretty clear, so I was able to figure it out after a few minutes of staring at it and going 'wha?'

hmm... should we poll Peter Gabriel or would that just be me and Alfred, back and forth, forever?

As much as I love Peter Gabriel, he's not the most prolific dude in the game.

by that, I mean we'd be working with a pretty shallow pool of material.

seven studio albums, four soundtracks, at least two of which have tracks i could see getting votes, and a grab-bag of, like, covers and one-offs ("party man"!), so about as much material as e.g. Pulp, PJ Harvey, Roxy Music, The Clash, New Order, Saint Etienne etc etc

Point taken.

Realistically, though, all my votes are likely to come from five of his first six albums (and maybe his cover of "The Book of Love").

Should his years in Genesis be included?

just thinking out loud fwiw. my belly agrees that a PG poll would be sparsely attended.

genesis years would confuse things, I think, and should accrue to some future Genesis poll rather than a PG solo poll. I get why Roxy/Ferry got combined but genesis seems its own thing.

hey ppl, I'm checking in to confirm my Neptunes poll! I just haven't kept up with ILX for some time now (and recent polls didn't interest me that much), so thank you WmC very much for your email! just one q - when is (approx.) my poll going to have to start? I just don't really know how fast do these things run these days.

They're going about 2 weeks per poll right now, so probably the end of September? I can send you another reminder when we're about 2-3 weeks out from Neptunes if you'd like.

I think a 'Genesis Family' poll could be good xp - Genesis, Gabriel & Collins solo work, Mike & The Mechanics, Philip Bailey (duet with Phil Collins), etc. I always like seeing completely different styles & eras competing. Maybe it covers too much ground, but there are enough mighty singles there to tempt the casual voter.

am I missing the Bob Dylan poll?

no.53

ah, missed it indeed. cheers.

You aren't missing the Talking Heads poll, however

33. Velvet Underground solo careers - iatee


honestly already have like half my ballot worked out in my head for this lol

Cure results in progress here! -- POLLography: The Cure poll results, ILM artist poll #23

Ismael, ready for Kate Bush?

I think I'm gonna go ahead and bow out in advance for "Classic Rock Canon" - - the classic rock radio thread is reminding me how difficult it will be even to figure out the parameters...and more to the point, I'm about to go back to school and just don't know if I'll be swamped with work when my number gets called. Anybody else is welcome to the idea if they think they can make it work!

Classic rock stations add one new song to their playlists each year; it could also be postponed until you graduate, get your doctorate, get tenure, and write a few books. The results will be more or less the same.

I like the idea of that Classic Rock Canon poll, using the database from some dude's industry contact. Hope somebody will claim it.

Bumpin' for Ismael.

I'm here, matey. I'll probably put it up this evening, make sure the Cure one has proper momentum first.

All You Cruisers - THE KATE BUSH VOTING THREAD (ilm artist poll #24: deadline Saturday 25 August)

i think i flaked out on ever sending casino my spreadsheets, but if anyone else wants to do it i'll send it to them. i may volunteer to run it down the road but i don't want to sign up for anything until after i've gotten through the Jay-Z poll.

My Cure spreadsheet turned out pretty good, it cross refs against album lists and generates the text (position, name, points, votes, no. of first place votes) to c&p into the ILM thread. It's available to anyone who wants it, I'll put it in a dropbox folder.

Thinking Moka should do images for ALL the polls.

Seriously!

btw i'd be more than willing to assist clemenza with ylt, assuming i'm alive in 2014

Sure, that'd be great. Same caveat--and if I don't make it, I'll leave a Top 30 as part of my will.

hi can you put me on the list for "iggy pop"

also please don't hesitate to webmail me if i don't respond or remember when my turn is up, my ilxmail goes to my current address & works fine

definitely including stooges

ps thanks a lot

http://24.media.tumblr.com/tumblr_m54hnftTnu1rqgtoqo1_500.gif

hahaha

put me down for The Boo Radleys please.

that will mean i will do New Order (80's), Steely Dan(70's) and The Boo Radleys (90').

I'll add you next time I post the full list. Shakey, if you want more separation between P-Funk and XTC, I'll put Bee at 67.

Do the Boo Radleys have a big enough discog for a ballot poll?

yeah we have discussed this: Boo Radleys Tracks Poll - Interested or not?

they have 6 albums plus another 3 albums full of b-sides.

and Thanks WmC!

Don't know if it has been done before but can I get in line to do an "Italo" poll?

If anyone wants an in at #55, I think I'm going to back out of doing a Replacements poll.

uh oh, i guess this is my opportunity to make a todd akin joke with this song

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BDSxRZSDv2Q

i thought about it while i was washing dishes yesterday and loled

Italo would be awesome btw

Any objections to moving P-Funk to JF's vacated #55 spot, or would y'all rather I just moved everything up one notch?

I have no idea what Italo is but will add it after Boo Radleys.

I'm doing a general disco poll, so the Italo one will probably have some overlap with it, but I've no problem with that.

We Become Panoramic - THE KATE BUSH RESULTS THREAD (ilm artist poll #24)

New results thread means new voting thread! Tarfumes, are you ready for Maximum R&B?

wait I thought it was The Who next?

PLEASE TELL ME THE WHO IS NEXT