thread of SZA

critic and substacker Brad Luen nitpicking SZA's SOS. Ba humbug

SZA: SOS
Billboard’s third-most successful album of the year after Wallen and Swift, so I’ve got six billion streams against me when I say it’s a huge step down from CTRL. Megahit “Kill Bill”, catchy and very dumb, is atypical only in that radio played it so many times that the catchiness won out. Her previously fetching vocal idiosyncrasies turn annoying when subjected to the letter-munching of late 2022 non-country production. A now-old story: best when she raps, which isn’t often enough. Grade: B (“Smoking on My Ex Pack”, “Kill Bill”)

Nope.

surely we can hold ourselves to a higher standard when it comes to thread revives…

The radio success of "Snooze" and "Kill Bill" has been one of the most surprising developments of the last couple years.

Maybe I asked on the thread already but I can't remember the answer, assuming anyone answered. Back some time around the release of her first record I saw her in a tiny club here (she was good). Then she went kind of quiet, iirc, and the next thing I know she's selling out arenas with hot ticket prices and her album is dominating whatever charts people follow. What did I miss in between? How did she go from rising star to superstar that my kids and their peers and their younger siblings all know and love? It seemed really sudden, at least from the vantage of someone that only passively knows about what's popular.

by first record, do you mean ctrl, or z, because ctrl was a triple-platinum, massively critically acclaimed hit album and z came out nearly a decade ago, at this point

i assume you mean ctrl. i remember when i first became aware of her she still seemed slightly under the radar for most -- i planned to go to her concert at a theater later in the year but didn't buy a ticket then. checked again after a few months (she had started getting traction on radio) and a second date had been added and they were both sold out. the album had tremendous legs so when sos launched she was well positioned to blow up even more, hence the upgrade to arenas etc.

Yeah, I meant "ctrl," sorry. It was the Concord Music Hall here in December 2017, about 1000 or so capacity. The next time she played Chicago was February 2023 at a very sold out United Center.

surely we can hold ourselves to a higher standard when it comes to thread revives…

― slob wizard (J0rdan S.), Sunday, November 26, 2023 7:32 PM (yesterday)

idk learning there's an IU stats prof cosplaying as Christgau on substack is kind of what ilm is for

lol I know him from a couple other message boards. Nice guy.

the xgau shtick is not for me, but in all sincerity, it's always nice to be reminded that people contain multitudes

Harold Bloom never got to write The Perfidy of Influence.

hi did i miss mentions of ' saturn '? did you know that sun ra was from saturn?

(i know, i know. but i'll take what i can get. isn't she great?!)