Twin Peaks: Classic or Dud?

RIP Piper Laurie aka Catherine Martell.

Holy moly, it never clicked that Catherine and Carrie’s mom were the same person.

xp aw no

She was on a podcast only a few weeks ago talking about her experience making Carrie. Sounded so lively and healthy. RIP.

Well, my oldest daughter turned 14 and we watched the pilot tonight.

Man, it’s so good. The show definitely has its ups and downs but the pilot is so perfect.

i would like to add my voices to the general concern that this is not a good documentary about the fbi

So many of the cast are gone now. I've always felt that Piper Laurie was a somewhat "unsung" (or at least underappreciated) member of the original cast – maybe b/c her character didn't tie into the underlying mythology (and she also didn't return for S3).

But she was so good in that role. You could pair Catherine with any other character, and the sparks would fly in a specific & unique way. I feel like she kept the original series anchored in the "faux–soap opera" concept – almost like a "straight man" of sorts, gently villainous without chewing the scenery – and was able to handle even some fairly loopy developments without losing her way.

I guess that's why Lynch and Frost couldn't, or wouldn't, find anything for her to do in The Return, which excised those soapy elements. I thought it was too bad; an interviewer asked her about it and she had been interested in doing it.

yeah, there really wouldn't have been much for her to do in the Return (not that that stopped him bringing James back); I think she would have deserved a more prominent role but as packed as the Return is with storylines, even though it was 18 hours long, I'm not sure there was really space.

We started the Return last night, my first time rewatching in full since it aired. It really does make a lot more sense the second time through.

Yes did a second watch recently and it does

Xp could have just had a little unconnected scene with her regardless was my thoughts

I kind of like how not everyone, well, returns in The Return... it feels right, like Catherine probably still wouldn't be hanging around (notwithstanding that I would have loved to see her).

Yes fair cop

There seemed to be such a horrible spate of Twin Peaks actors dying in the aftermath of s3. Piper Laurie's passing reminds me that it has thankfully slowed, but maybe that's just cause so many are gone.

She also enjoyed a long life (with some interesting biographical details that I learned from an obit). Many of the others died younger, which was especially sad.

Personally have close to zero quibbles with s3 but I do feel they could have included at least one scene of Ben Horne looking wistfully at a framed photograph of her feet

Whatever became of Little Elvis?

He became bruno mars

ah loved Piper. Watched Carrie recently, and yeah didn't know she was the mother. But then realised that the Frasier episode with her as the over controlling mother figure made a lot more sense!

no one wants to know the number of times a day I've walked around the house saying "animal life" since rewatching FWWM

Very sad to hear of Piper Laurie's passing, though I'll be listening for reports of any elderly Japanese men appearing at her funeral...

Haha

There seemed to be such a horrible spate of Twin Peaks actors dying in the aftermath of s3. Piper Laurie's passing reminds me that it has thankfully slowed, but maybe that's just cause so many are gone.

It was pretty sad how many who actually appeared in The Return died before those episodes were even broadcast. And even new cast members like Robert Forster passed away after the series finished airing.

FWIW, my favorite Piper Laurie performance is still Sara in The Hustler, one of my favorite films, period.

Agree! One of my favourites for close to 50 years. (And she's amazing.)

well into the return now, episode 5. Struck this time by the sensitivity and pathos of Coop-as-Dougie. The breakfast scene was actually rather hard for me to watch as it reminded me so much of trying to feed my mother in the last week of her life, her mind just completely gone. I can't believe he didn't get an Emmy for this.

The purple room/eyeless woman/not-ronette scenes were terrifying when I watched them this time, I don't remember being so viscerally horrified the first time through. This stuff really recalled Eraserhead.

My only complaint is that some things actually make too much sense; the Mike/Dougie scene in the red room, for example. It's so expository ('someone manufactured you") I have to think Mark Frost wrote that.

I think that line is a useful grounding point for the viewer... it also shows that Mike (apparently) wasn't the one who "manufactured" Dougie, although I suppose even that is open for debate.

Outside the opening scene of Part 17, I can't think of many lines that I thought were too expository; one or two plot aspects are sort of presented as initially unclear and then are revealed to be what you thought they would be (but this is more the exception than the norm, ha ha).

xp yes I’ve always felt this series was primarily about ageing and the changes it wreaks.

https://scontent-bos5-1.xx.fbcdn.net/v/t39.30808-6/431572089_820552056777083_990553146318547682_n.jpg?_nc_cat=101&ccb=1-7&_nc_sid=5f2048&_nc_ohc=7dlM8CBYBwoAX9MShtu&_nc_ht=scontent-bos5-1.xx&oh=00_AfCTyHULMHPyEeBU4xaTN4C319jzR9th8GM4QcSw90V2zg&oe=660D1A24

aw. lynch looking very guru-like in his robe

Very david lynch voice “I SHOULD. HAVE. DIRECTED. JEDI. “

my biggest problem with the revive was that hawk wasn't sheriff. my other quibble was the "cherry pie" issue: i wouldn't have minded if it just stayed local and picked up where the og series left off and stayed in twin peaks altogether but in the future but the expanded universe way of exploring core concepts vis-a-vis judy and whatnot was ok too but they took too long to return cooper to his true self imo. other than that, all michael horse all the time.

my recent rewatch of the Return (the first time I'd rewatched the entire thing), I was much happier with the pace and the amount of time spent with Cooper as Dougie. But it was frustrating when these were coming out week by week.

New Frost interview: https://variety.com/2024/tv/features/twin-peaks-mark-frost-david-lynch-laura-palmer-mulholland-drive-1235955147/

April 8, 1990: "She's dead...wrapped in plastic."

https://media.mstdn.social/media_attachments/files/112/238/312/179/988/757/original/31fb1cc1cddf0e1e.jpeg

It first aired in Australia a little later in Feb 1991 - I was 14 and Twin Peaks + Northern Exposure was my ~entire~ personality in high school

I basically dressed and wore my hair like Bobby Briggs for a year or two

My friend's band played their first show on 4/8/1990* and THEIR 2ND GUITARIST stayed home to watch Twin Peaks instead lol.

*openers: The Melvins & TFUL282!

for my 15th birthday that year my friends gave me THE SECRET DIARY OF LAURA PALMER

xp The second guitarist, in his final moments:

https://static.wikia.nocookie.net/twinpeaks/images/8/8e/Rusty_Tomasky.jpg/revision/latest/thumbnail/width/360/height/360?cb=20161029002620

my mom watched the pilot and immediately roped me in for the first real episode. i was obsessed with Bobby and fancied myself more of an Audrey Horne type which, in retrospect, is kind of disturbing. But not surprising.

To this day I am spooked by men who look even remotely like BOB and I think it's because I was 14 when I saw him for the first time creepin out from behind the furniture

Imagine being the copywriter who had to figure out how to try to explain what Twin Peaks was in a newspaper ad.

I was 11 when I first watched the show and I literally threw the remote control out of my hand at BOB's first appearance.

The owner of the Palmer house is now doing paid tours of it, and has set up a BOB mannequin looming inside a cracked-open closet door.

She seems cool, I've seen her social media postings and whatnot

My wife and I stopped outside that house several years ago. Her license plate is TREMOND.

Did you see creamed corn on that plate?

Was watching The Searchers and there’s a log lady scene about an hour or so into the film to an equally horrifying effect.

Still blows my mind that Hank Worden (who plays Mose Harper in The Searchers) is also the waiter in Twin Peaks. I think that was his last role too. Anyway, he's in a lot of John Wayne Westerns.

My wife and I just spent some time in Washington and we went on a tour of loads of twin peaks locations. Felt very surreal being in these places we both new so well, huge recommend for the fans.

It was quite amazing how many of the scenes in woods were filmed in the same very small area.

that's cool, was looking into doing that myself. Did you stay in the Salish?