Post a controversial music opinion

Grunge was great at its best, like any other genre. Some genuine classic groups and albums and musicians. Been revisiting a bunch of it lately. Imo a lot of it sounds so much better even now.

yeah sorry "historical revision" is wrong. tbf i can't think of anything more boring than invoking chart positions or w/e but def remember hearing Alice in Chains on z100. xxp

By "pop charts" I meant "Billboard top 40." Sorry.

I sympathize with Austin because I discovered Pulp in what I thought was a "reaction" to grunge despite liking a lot of Soundgarden and later Pearl Jam.

Austin, I think yr wrong, and frankly cloaking yr distaste in contemporary language of “wokeness” doesn’t make your point any stronger, sorry.

Also expect pushback since what you said is controversial.

Amazing how people who like the worst music in the world will get up in a huff about a great band like Green River

Also “historical revision that grunge was mega mainstream” seems to be in response to something nobody said

so many jackoffs on this board.

it all seems like easy listening for meglomaniacs and narcissists

how old are you?

Nobody said this! Straw man point awarded!!!!

til liking smooth jazz is woke

i also like smooth jazz you fucking asshole

omar otm, like all genres there’s good and bad, which is pretty much what i said in my response before being lumped in with some strawman of a flannel-bedecked toxic racist

lotta post flagging itt

Amazing how people who like the worst music in the world will get up in a huff about a great band like Green River

― Goose Bigelow, Fowl Gigolo (the table is the table), Sunday, May 7, 2023 5:34 PM (eight minutes ago) bookmarkflaglink

lmao this has gotta be a joke right

WoRsT muSiC in thE WoRlDDD stfu you arrogant child

https://y.yarn.co/c8f17fe8-bf40-4dd5-b7b2-45ea898e9567_text.gif

how old are you?

Also expect pushback since what you said is controversial.

Thread doing its job afaict.

and i didn't want to start such a vitriolic thing here. controp means controp and mine is that some shit should be erased.

Thinking that certain genres are for narcissists is certainly a challenging opinion.

WoRsT muSiC in thE WoRlDDD stfu you arrogant child

I'm always bummed out when I remember just how many of the great singers of the genre are no longer with us. I mean all of the best ones except for Eddie vedder. Or so it seems.

i also like smooth jazz you fucking asshole

board description?

there were also like tons of kids who were listening to both!

― Blues Guitar Solo Heatmap (Free Download) (upper mississippi sh@kedown), Sunday, May 7, 2023 10:23 AM

also this is a fair and valid point and i fully concede that it is possible to appreciate both sides respectfully and evenly.

but i'm biased af, so ¯\_ (ツ)_/¯

_i also like smooth jazz you fucking asshole_


board description?

oh fuck off dude, it’s stuff that people outside of ilx have been talking about too

lol ok silly me

look im flannel-bedecked and i take shit from no one

You know what, there are way too many genres of music. There should only be like, 4. Grunge shouldn't get to be considered an entire genre of music. Rock probably shouldn't be either.

What a harsh realm

You know what, there are way too many genres of music. There should only be like, 4. Grunge shouldn't get to be considered an entire genre of music. Rock probably shouldn't be either.

^^^quality controp. word to yusef lateef; jazz doesn't exist.

also this is a fair and valid point and i fully concede that it is possible to appreciate both sides respectfully and evenly.

but i'm biased af, so ¯\_ (ツ)_/¯

i actually can't stand smooth jazz ... now there's a genre that's probably more popular among megalomaniacs and narcissists than grunge ... though maybe it's a generational thing?

There’s only folk music, art music, dvd pop music THATS IT

We play both kinds of music: vaporw and ave

xp otm

Austin is the one being arrogant, proposing wiping out an entire genre of music.

― Goose Bigelow, Fowl Gigolo (the table is the table), Sunday, May 7, 2023 10:47 AM

genuine question: are you equating my proposal of erasing grunge to, like, "woke cancel culture gone mad" or... ?

i'm genuinely confused by your mention of "wokeness" in this context. please expound.

I'm sympathetic to the idea that there's good in all subgenres but otoh there is swingbeat.

i actually can't stand smooth jazz ... now there's a genre that's probably more popular among megalomaniacs and narcissists than grunge ... though maybe it's a generational thing?

― sarahell, Sunday, May 7, 2023 10:59 AM

the real culture war!

(but honestly, good point! this is the sort of stuff that needs anthropological studies imo)

probably related to this:

yeah i hate all that bullshit, table. it's all very trash. sorry?

why? idk, lack of dynamics, tunnel vision syndrome, distaste for diversity. it all seems like easy listening for meglomaniacs and narcissists. i understand not everything needs to be a melting pot, but enough is enough with dudes chugging shittily away at guitars and talking about pseudo philosophy.

disliking a popular genre is having a controversial opinion, implying that anyone who does like that music has some sort of pathology crosses the line to dickhead behavior

xp- though in reality, people could probably come up with examples of music that they would categorize as "smooth jazz" (e.g. Sade) that I like, and then we'd have the moving goalposts discussion of "well, that's not actually the genre I hate" ... but in general, I find it painful to listen to

but that's always how i've felt about it?

(to quote a smarter person than myself, "i stay woke." apparently?)

Sade is… not… jazz? Though?

I like grunge.

I like rap

I like you all

don't think austin was using "diversity" in idpol terms but it's difficult to read the word in any other way now. lolef when I heard an old Cary Grant quote about doing "Gunga Din" because he wanted more diversity.

8 Way Santa behbeh

I feel like this is all just bullshit and that every genre of music attracts good people and horrible people and in-between people and everyone just makes stuff like that up because it's a convenient cudgel to beat on something they just don't like on a gut level.

Sade is… not… jazz? Though?

― ian, Sunday, May 7, 2023 11:09 AM (twenty-four seconds ago)

idk ... maybe i really just loathe all smooth jazz and i'm trying to be nice and saying, "hey, I'm not a monster, I like Sade?"

Austin, I like you (believe it or not) and don’t want to argue with you anymore.

I simply don’t think that music should be discarded or ignored because of who makes it, unless they’re yknow actual fascists. “Dudes playing guitars” aren’t automatically good or given a pass, obv, but to be like “fuck them and their music” seems like lazy and without much nuance, assigning moral wrong in a way that is nonsensical

everyone just makes stuff like that up because it's a convenient cudgel to beat on something they just don't like on a gut level.

isn't that one of the primary uses of this thread?