Sight and Sound 2022 Round 2: 21-40

Hmm.

It's nice to see Daisies get recognized, it was pretty obscure when I saw it in an Eastern European humanities class in the early 90s.

Godard and Tarkovsky are my two favourite filmmakers, but Mirror never connected other than as a stylistic exercise, and Breathless is good but atypical. I saw M again last year and loved it a lot more than before, but I think I'll end up voting Balthazar.

I’ve seen more of these. Probably torn between Playtime and Balthasar.

Those two plus Daisies are to me fully realized visions that happen to attack the idea that a movie is a single kind of thing

Night of the Hunter

Taxi Driver — maybe a boring answer but also a top ten movie for me for many reasons.

I think Pather Panchali is the one which is closest to my heart.

Mirror is so good I'm afraid to say something cheap about it.

do the right thing was my #1 when we did the films poll recently. so that one.

Out of the 5 or 6 of these that I've seen, the only one I've rewatched recently is 8 1/2 (well actually only the last half or so, which I caught randomly on TCM one evening). Based on that, I feel confident that it still holds up. I saw it for the first time on the big screen, at a repertory cinema in SF in the mid-90s.

Voted donkey

My top 5, probably:

1. Pather Panchali
2. Taxi Driver
3. Rear Window
4. Night of the Hunter
5. I did, I think, really like Late Spring ages ago, but I'm not even sure it was that; it could have been Early Spring or Late Autumn. If not that, Psycho or Joan of Arc or Portrait of a Lady.

Two of these I haven't seen--Mirror and Daisies--and some I'm indifferent to: Some Like It Hot, Breathless, 8-1/2, and--I saw it again recently and was surprised how little I responded to it--City Lights. One of them, Playtime, I truly hated.

You have to watch Playtime knowing that it's a comedy where every joke falls flat.

I just didn't get it at all.

Just realized the coincidence of Night of the Hunter and Do the Right Thing being in the same group.

My tops:

L’Atalante
Pather Panchali
The Passion of Joan of Arc
Late Spring
Playtime
Do the Right Thing
Au hasard Balthazar
The Night of the Hunter
Psycho
Rear Window

One of them, Playtime, I truly hated.

― clemenza, Friday, January 20, 2023 11:04 AM (eleven minutes ago)

boooooooo

Night of the Hunter is great, cuts to the heart of how fucked up american protestants are

Just realized the coincidence of Night of the Hunter and Do the Right Thing being in the same group.

So coincidental that I don't get the significance.

yeah, clem, I'm not seeing the coincidence?

Both have four word titles with “the” in them

Bill Nunn recites Mitchum's love/hate speech.

finger tattoos

oh right!

electorate hasn’t watched do the right thing recently enough, poll results invalid

Night of the Hunter today, on another day it could be Mirror. With Balthazar and Do the Right Thing just behind

Seen all but Shoah and Some Like It Hot. Not sure I'll ever sit down and watch Shoah right through

One of them, Playtime, I truly hated.

― clemenza, Friday, 20 January 2023 bookmarkflaglink

This is one where it really helps for everything to be blown up in the big screen.

You get the idea of Shoals after an hour. Or less.

Shoah. Lol

I feel like you'd get the idea after reading about it but maybe that's unfair. I mean obviously it's important

Lots and lots of moments in these films I have vivid memories of and Shoah has as many as any of them.

For what it's worth I saw Playtime in a theatre. When you're really disliking a film, that's a minus, not a plus.

only one of these featured the music of Public Enemy, so it's pretty easy

xp lol ok. I was thinking the sets look great in the theatre but nevermind.

I really don't mean to disparage the film. I think it's meant for a temperament far from my own.

only one of these featured the music of Public Enemy

M was about a public enemy though

I went with Playtime, but M is a close second.

(I've seen all of these but Shoah.)

voted for Taxi Driver, one of my favorite films of all time. It is totally surreal and seems to take place in a dream. the music is ravishing and seems out of time, and the cinematography is lurid and intoxicating

Late Spring and Mirror would be my other choices. I'm drawn to 8 1/2 because it is my film mentor's favorite film, but I think La Dolce Vita and La Strada are my favorite Fellini films. I like Le Mépris more than À bout de souffle. Some Like It Hot still creeps me out

and I'm still not sure what it is about The Night of the Hunter that warrants its placement in the top 40 films of all time.

The only American film that approximates Poe and Gothic horror; it's a fable in the 19th century sense. It looks nothing like contemporaneous American film? Laughton + Agee + Gish + Mitchum is an (un) holy combination.

I’ve seen even fewer of these.

xp

ok, that makes some sense of it for me

I’ve seen even fewer of these.

― The Triumphant Return of Bernard & Stubbs (Raymond Cummings)

Which have you seen?

Taxi Driver and Do The Right Thing.

Went M over Psycho

DAISIES every time

― pilk/pall revolting odors (wins), Friday, January 20, 2023 3:31 PM (yesterday)

^^^^ easy vote

that is the only film on the list I haven't seen yet. I will watch it

It’s choice

is it me or is this list way better than the top 20?

Late Spring vs M is not a choice i would want to make irl

actual-LY, as Tom Lehrer would say.

It's amazing how it gives us the literal facts of Mitchum's character right away in his very first scene. We know right off the bat that he's a serial killer, that he's hunting a widow... but he achieves so much more depth and menace the more we listen to his voice, and finally becomes a kind of nightmare abstraction as this silhouetted figure on horseback.

yeah i might be swayed to night of the hunter tbh

Watched Daisies and--as I suspected--not really for me. I know it's an angry film, but in execution it's whimsical and slapstick-y; much as with Playtime, when it comes to whimsy, I'm like Lou Grant responding to spunk on The Mary Tyler Moore Show. I liked the surf music during the mock fashion show, and it looked like no other film I've ever seen, and that's an achievement.

Absolutely crazy that this is Laughton's only directed film.

Peter Lorre had a similar post-war fate. He returned to Germany to direct and co-write a great movie called 'Der Verlorene' ('The Lost One') in 1951, but was never asked to direct again.

This was probably because, at a time when West German cinema was churning out soft-focus Heimatfilme for a traumatised audience, 'Der Verlorene' focuses on the remorse of a scientist who had done secret research for the Nazis and murdered his fiancée when he discovers that she had been working with the Allies. The film didn't go down well at all with German cinemagoers.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=v_q3FcVsLr8

I hate to say it, but I wouldn't mind seeing this series of polls carry on for the directors' poll results, as well (where La Jetee was in the top 35, its highest ranking ever to my knowledge).

I thought we might poll the films on the directors' list that didn't make it to the critics'.

Do you know if the 101+ results might be out by then?

They've got two more days to make good on releasing the ballots in January. My hunch is maybe by the end of February tho.

wonder what's keeping them

They're watching Jeanne Dielman.

They've got two more days to make good on releasing the ballots in January. My hunch is maybe by the end of February tho.

― عباس کیارستمی (Eric H.), Sunday, January 29, 2023

I thought I read that they were going to release the top 250 this Tuesday

Ah, indeed:

Get ready for round two: the top 250 of the #SightAndSoundPoll will be revealed on Tuesday 🍿 pic.twitter.com/w2wK0QKle0

— Sight and Sound magazine (@SightSoundmag) January 27, 2023

I would be happy if we continue to poll the films in groups of 20 for both the critics and directors

I'm reading Robin Wood's book on the Apu Trilogy right now, and it's wonderful. I keep wanting to post quotes here.

I feel like before I watch The World of Apu I should rewatch the first two again

I definitely would. I'd rewatch the first as a standalone, but I think the other two are best seen in sequence.

Re-watched Balthazar last night. Hits differently when you get to know an animal.

Besides all that whenever I watch Bresson it's such a reset. The acting, mannerisms, Balthazar is so obliquely told.

Boccaccio was a reference point for the multiple changes of fortune.

Anyway this is mad hard. I have just reasoned out Tarkovsky and Late Spring but I cannot decide between this pair.

The Passion of Joan of Arc (Dreyer, 1927)
L’Atalante (Vigo, 1934)

Automatic thread bump. This poll is closing tomorrow.

Automatic thread bump. This poll's results are now in.

good winner, Balthazar deserved more votes probably

Love the spread of votes (went for L'Atalante in the end). Shoah not getting any votes is interesting.

I'd vote for any Lanzmann because some of his interviews are like the most heightened drama I've ever seen. The Rabbi who had Eichmann threatening to murder him if he didn't do ridiculous amounts of scholarly research within the hour (so he could pass himself off as a Jewish emigration expert). Dude that planted an axe into a Nazi deathcamp commander's head. It's god's work that he captured this stuff while the people were still alive.

Shoah perhaps needs some updating for contemporary audiences, you could insert pop songs and a narrator saying "but this was an illusion".

Snark aside tho a nine hour documentary about one of the most horrific events in human history is a tough sell, and even if you've gotten around to watching it (my DVD box has been staring at me unwatched for years) you're prob unlikely to think of it as a "favourite", it feels v apples and oranges to compare it to anything else on this list.

BBC2 screened it over two Sunday evenings. I definitely watched the first part, but now come to think of it I don't think I watched the 2nd.

I guess few would think as a favourite. Guessing you didn't vote in the poll, Calzino?

ILX Shoah watchalong club when

Christmas?

xxp

no didn't vote! for anyone put off by the sheer length of Shoah there is Sobibor, October 14, 1943, 4 p.m. and The Last of the Unjust which are both essential and unforgettable.

well, I'm glad my lurker vote for playtime made the difference