A thread about the Denis Villeneuve-helmed reboot of DUNE

That second sentence wasn't directed at just you though, it just seems like there are so many people just looking for any excuse to hate this pre-emptively.

I liked Bladerunner 2 fine and I don't understand the hate for Villeneuve but I really do hate that kind of jokiness, it definitely put me off a bit.

also Dune is pretty special to a lot of us and we have been hurt SO MANY TIMES

https://m.media-amazon.com/images/M/MV5BMTIxMjQ2OTU4M15BMl5BanBnXkFtZTYwNzY0MTQ2._V1_.jpg

It's been a few years of worry, yes

https://www.vulture.com/2017/03/looking-back-at-all-the-utterly-disastrous-attempts-to-adapt-dune.html

But the Lynch and Jodorowsky versions were the best types of disasters

for a truly faithful adaptation, each screening of dune should have someone dressed up as princess irulan sitting in the front row, and she would pause the movie every five minutes to read a paragraph or two from one of her dozen books

go on

Princess Irulan is the Adrian Mole of Arrakis

https://www.theguardian.com/film/2021/sep/03/dune-review-denis-villenueve-venice-film-festival

Xan Brooks gives it five stars and says calls it "quite often sublime"

DUNE is a *massive* disappointment.

the cinematic equivalent of getting a novelty-sized check for six dollars.

hype is the mind-killer. here's my review: https://t.co/CcYaboWjFi pic.twitter.com/YeyDojfT85

— david ehrlich (@davidehrlich) September 3, 2021

Opinions are divided!

i always love the early “LISTEN UP NERDS: IT SUCKS”

Haha. Yeah, that IndieWire review is swinging for the clicks.

Read a few reviews for this and even the lukewarm ones seem to readily offer up “breathtaking” etc. when talking about it as a visual spectacle and that’s kinda 80% of what I’m here for.

otm me too

And then it turns out it's just wall to wall scenes of Jason Momoa wearing only that Sting-style jockstrap, something which would NEVER appeal to anyone I know amon--what?

Variety’s review of #Dune has me feeling like #Bakka*. The whole thing’s sprinkled with a faux-dumb tone, a cool kid trolling for nerd. “Oh, you like Star Track? Who’s your favorite character, Dr. Spock?”

*The One Who Weeps

— Michael Chabon (@michaelchabon) September 4, 2021

I've reverted back my 12 yr old state of mind that watched the Lynch one 30 odd years ago, not even hearing it!

honestly the only thing i like about Momoa being in it at all is that he ~spoilers~
(though admittedly he seems well-cast as Duncan)

not much of a fan myself

Ok, saw this last night **spoilers**
This is a very sombre movie, sombre colour palette/ costuming, positively, its faithful to the books, the bits I remember, much more than Lynch (who was all over the place, in that regard). I thought I would feel the same about this as I did about blade runner 2049 and that proved to be true. It's not completely style over substance but I did struggle with the dialogue and attitude to storytelling, there's a real lack of weight in so many scenes that it flits by leaving you struggling to connect with the characters. I thought immediately afterwards, was there a single line of dialogue that felt delicious, that cuts through a scene and leaves you smirking with joy or gasping? No, not for me...I know this ensemble is way more capable than this and you do wonder if many scenes were finished and they looked at each other and thought, 'well, I hope that will come good in post". It left me feeling I need to stop watching movies and read more books or go to the theatre.

"Step one: be Jason Momoa."

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=A8y30Uyqc1E

US tickets on sale.

And one last trailer

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=w0HgHet0sxg

Separately, though, of all the mockbusters that ever mockbusted thanks to Asylum...wow. Just wow.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZwVZ-2WuJo4

“There’s more than one worm!?”

camp is the mindkiller

should I watch this or

um YES

Watch all the versions at once.

now?

Whenever you’re of a mind.

leaked

Sean Young is in Planet Dune? Wtf?

Is she in the David Lynch version? Is it some sort of tribute?

Very much loved this, but was expecting to given I loved Villeneuve's last two sci-fi movies. Kinda feel Swanswans' point that the dialogue could be sharper, but the visuals, the atmosphere, the characters... it's what I wanted a Dune movie to be

I did too, watched it last night, I couldn't help but run dialogue from the Lynch version in my head though, to see what the contrasts were like. Agree about the dialogue, v sad not to have seen a Guild Navigator also.

Saw it tonight and I vote...pretty good! No, not perfect -- and I won't compare it to Lynch as that's its own thing with his own obsessions -- but I liked it a lot better than his Blade Runner film and it generally hits a really solid run of key beats from the book. I would like to see part two happen for sure.

v sad not to have seen a Guild Navigator also

We do get that one...thing, though. The 'pet' on Giedi Prime.

hey, this was good

Know nothing about the lore, never read the books or seen other adaptations: really enjoyed this. Wanted it to keep going.

i didn't know it was only part one and was increasingly like 'wait how are they gonna fit all this other stuff in' until i realized

I think it was smart of them to have the 'Dune Part One' on the title card, honestly.

I only just figured out that they have not filmed part 2 yet - thought it was filmed but the expensive post-production was not done. It's gonna be an eternity to get that second part, if indeed it happens at all

Yeah part of me is all "They really should have just done this like LOTR and did the whole damn thing," but on the flip the book covers three years' time so...it could work? Though there's still a key moment in the book that hasn't been reached before the big time jump to the final section said three years later.

I assume Tiny Tim will need to eat some protein between shoots.

My guess would figure the cut off would be after Jessica takes the water of life and then Paul rides the sandworm for the first time being the end.

You’ll see!

I don't expect to read the novel, so when I watch this weekend I hope to enjoy it at the level of Tolkienland, whose books I also haven't read.

Yeah part of me has been so steeped in the whole thing all this time more than once I was asking myself "How would I be taking this in if I didn't know anything about it?" It was kinda hard to do! But it seemed like it would land?

does Chalamet appear in a loin cloth or