Rolling Country 2006 Thread

Message Bookmarked
Bookmark Removed
Not all messages are displayed: show all messages (2098 of them)
i used to have a boot of coe singing the line working like a nigger for my room and board--and it always made me a little sick.

i think that for a variety of reasons (research, vehement anti censorship, free speech, the only thing that kills mould is sunshine, historical value) that johnny rebel should be availble, and that it was wrong to ask cd baby to take it down. though i am often a hypocrite about this, and sometimes my analysis and yellign seems like a calling for censorship, and i most lilkely feel worse about other words

anthony easton (anthony), Saturday, 18 March 2006 03:09 (eighteen years ago) link

Who asked Cdbaby to take it down? I'm just surprised they didn't remove it on their own. (And of course it'd only be "censorship" if a law was passed demanding they take it down. Which I would oppose.) (Though not as much as I'd oppose a law telling them to take down the sundry r&b records for toe fetishists and goth records for s&m fetishists I've seen on there.) (Maybe Anthony misunderstood my remark about the moderators? I was referring to the ILX moderators; Don suggested the J.R. link be removed from *this thread.* Which I agree with; in fact, if you look above, I was regretting posting it mere seconds after I did.)

xhuxk, Saturday, 18 March 2006 03:20 (eighteen years ago) link

No, we weren't asking cdbaby to take it down. The "working like" line has never seemed gratuitous to (old white Southern) me, because it(cunningly, re xpost ambiguShadyploitation) fits the context of declaring his redneck credentials, and adds to them: not only cause of using the word, but because rednecks were given to understand that they weren't *quite* as exploited as the lowest caste/class was, or so they were spozed to think (and thank G-d for). But in practice, they (at least the lowest, White Trash, sub-Salt Of The Earth) shade of red might well find his or herself working like that. (Coe presents his family as being pretty no-class, in that song, some live renditions of which are epics of bad tooth, if-you-don't-got-it-flaunt-it selfloitation that preempt almost everything except maybe Larry The Cable Guy in Vegas, Ah suspect.)(when LTCG's not doing Family Entertainment on the Blue Collar Comedy Tour). By the way, I spell out "redneck" not because of reverse discrimination, but because it seems (somewhut)less likely to be googled by trolls than the other one. I hope so, anyway.

don, Saturday, 18 March 2006 04:44 (eighteen years ago) link

The URL was either altered or you posted it including an error, xhuxk. What is in the message is www.cdbaby_com/cd/johnnyrebel and that's the equiv of a nothing address. It looks altered by mod so anyone can see it and correct it to get to the page, which is what I did, with no fear of attracting trackbacks.

Anyway, the guy's voice in "Looking for a Handout" resembled David Allen Coe's.

George 'the Animal' Steele, Saturday, 18 March 2006 05:28 (eighteen years ago) link

And may be his, no matter what he said later (he says and does allkinsa)

don, Saturday, 18 March 2006 05:52 (eighteen years ago) link

Not that his singing isn't pretty easy to imitate (even I can do it, to an extent).

don, Saturday, 18 March 2006 06:04 (eighteen years ago) link

apologies, misunderstood.

anthony easton (anthony), Saturday, 18 March 2006 06:52 (eighteen years ago) link

Coincidentally, there is a current radio show from the white power
organization, National Vanguard, that deals with this. Like it or not, across the net Coe is tied to Johnny Rebel, through a combination of denials, assertions that he did do some of this music, all coupled with an examination of some of his letter choons, so noted by xhuck. Wiki's biographical entry includes it. You can read the rest of the article by cutting and pasting the thing into your locator bar. The voice on the second tune cited again sounds, perhaps vaguely, like Coe.

========
During America's sharp decline in the 1960s, there were a few bands that tried to compose some patriotic and pro-White music. I heard a few of these songs and they are really just god awful. The only pro-White music of any quality to come out of the 1960s and early 1970s, was with some American Country music, which has been lumped together to be called "Johnny Rebel." There were many different musicians touring the Southern honky tonks, playing these Johnny Rebel songs. There was one rather famous country singer that is rumored to have written most of the really popular of these songs, such as "Coon Town" and "Move those Niggers North," but if true, he wants to keep his identity private. There was even George Lincoln Rockwell who made an attempt at pro-White music with the band "Otis and the Three Bigots." Otis and his Bigots meant well, but the music was bad.


There were no mainstream record labels that would touch these songs, so they had no ability to become heard, let along rise in popularity. There was one famous Country music singer named David Allen Coe who used the word "Nigger" openly in a song in the 1970s. This song can still be heard in maybe 1,000 jukeboxes currently across America in small bars and restaurants. This song is "If that ain't Country." David Allen Coe also wrote another song that his mainstream record label refused to release. The name of this song says it all: "White Girl and a Nigger."

natvan.com/adv/2006/03-04-06.html

George 'the Animal' Steele, Saturday, 18 March 2006 16:23 (eighteen years ago) link

From metal thread; nothing about this guy is really country per se except the way he looks and sounds could EASILY appeal to Tim McGraw and Shooter Jennings fans respectively. (And also, Gretchen Wilson ably fills the Alison Moerer/Sheryl Crow role in "Picture" on the quite entertaining new live album by Kid Rock, who Huck is connected to, apparently):

>Also top of the playlist this weekend: Huck Johns, Detroit transplant to LA who google seems to suggest turned down a Velvet Revolver opening slot at least once. Looks like Tim McGraw to me, though I'm guessing he gave a lot more thought to picking his truckers hat and those Fleetwood Mac and Muddy Waters albums on the couch on the CD's back cover than Tim might give to more apparel choices. I won't hold that against him though. Album very much rocks, even the grunge parts, but especially maybe the tributes to "Highway to Hell" and ELO's "Turn to Stone", and the Seger "Ramblin Gamblin Man" cover and maybe more. (Which reminds me I need to get back to that live Kid Rock album soon too.) (Pretty funny too that Huck's Capitol Records subsidiary is called Hideout, same name as Seger and the Last Heard's label from Persecution Smith/East Side Story/Heavy Music daze.)
-- xhuxk (xedd...), March 18th, 2006.

Huck Johns is sounding better and better. Turns out he's apparently from Lincoln Park, MI, and wrote a song for Kid Rock once, though I didn't know that when I put them in the same paragraph up above. Album is basically mostly '70s Ford assembly line singer-songwriter hard rock; the "grunge" I refer to above has to do with ballads that remind me somehow of Stone Temple Pilots, one of one which, "One Good Man" (which I guess doesn't remind *that* much of STP) may have a possible gay undercurrent, given that Huck's searching for one good man in it. In his liner notes Huck thanks not only eternal Detroit AOR station WRIF and Seger but also Johnny "Bee" Badanjek of Rockets/Ryder fame, and the producer is one Arthur Pennhallow Jr--interesting, since I swear I remember a guy named Arthur Penhallow being a longtime DJ on late '70s/early '80s Detroit rock stations. So now I'm wondering if Huck's some kind of local Michigan hit. Weird that the CD's on Capitol, given that it seems to have way more in common to what you'd find via cdbaby.
-- xhuxk (xedd...), March 18th, 2006.

xhuxk, Saturday, 18 March 2006 17:30 (eighteen years ago) link

Huck Johns' influences from his myspace page. Frankie Miller and Ted too, hmmm.

Bon Scott, MC5, Bob Seger, AC-DC, Chris Cornell, STP, Rolling Stones, CCR, Pink Floyd, J. Geils, Ted Nugent, Frankie Miller, Faces, Otis Redding, Iggy, Foo Fighters, Pearl Jam, Johnny Cash, Merle, Waylon, Willie

Sounds like I might even like it. If there's a pr e-mail or contact, send it my way so I can make a request.

George 'the Animal' Steele, Saturday, 18 March 2006 17:48 (eighteen years ago) link

That info would be at work, George. I'll check on Monday, though.

xhuxk, Saturday, 18 March 2006 17:55 (eighteen years ago) link

Huck sounds like he's of the house and lineage of Akron-born, Grand-Funk-touring-with late 60s Coe. Were there other such back then? I'll have to dig up my early Creems, but the closest I can remember is a folksinger with attitude, not a country singer: Jonathan Round, who is decribed, in Rock-a-Rama, as doing a mock-Shakespearean "Sympathy For The Devil." (Before Bryan Ferry did his Tiny Tim Karloff version, and while the Stones were usually taken very seriously elsewhere in those pages.) And the reviewer say, "Aww whattya expect from a DEETROIT folksinger?" Made it look pretty good, but I never found it.

don, Saturday, 18 March 2006 19:44 (eighteen years ago) link

re "on Capitol, but seems more like what you'd find on cdbaby": isn't Tea Leaf Green on cdbaby? But, despite being credited to "Greenhouse Music under exclusive license to Reincarnate Music" also says "manufactured in the USA by SONY BMG MUSIC ENTERTAINMENT (st address) under exclusive license from Reincarnate Music." so what still possibly passes for the Majors, infiltrating the indie frontier? Bet Tea Leaf Green hasn't seen any big bucks from Sony yet. Strange album. My opinion still hasn't firmed up yet, but the auteur, Trevor Gerrard, seems like he's got his own (lived)version of the riddling spiritual-emotional crisis-quest of Hunter-Garcia.(Singing kinda Garcia-Furay, which shouldn't suit my tastes at all, but somehow it kinda does.) But he isn't a guitarist, which might help the vocal, cos keeps resemblence from being the usual jamband-begging-and-faring-badly-by-close-comparison. (Plus it's not really a jamband.) He plays piano, more like Chuck Leavell than the Dead's keybists. The whole thing is tied to (and kept in line by)his electric piano: as aural metaphor/setting (sparkling waters! Stream, creek, sometimes river) for the early songs about struggling/sticking with his roots/insularity, or venturing forth. So he does both. the piano also sets the overall rhythmic pace, so the other instruments tend to rustle, except the guitar[kinda Duane or Derek T. or Warren Haynes most of the time, though can be a bit like Dickie or Eric or yeah Tom V.] is maybe something in the sky, but over and through the backside of the trees. "5000 Acres" an interesting change of stylistic shading, cos the most Verlaine-ish, and it does deal with a forest fire, and suddenly reminds me of Patti Smith's Television profile in mid-70s Rock Scene (before they'd recorded, except as Neon Boys): she says that Tom and Hell started a forest fire in Alabama, just to watch it burn. (Perhaps inspired by Randy Newman's "Let's Burn Down The Cornfield" ["and make love while it's burning"]?)Plus, it's one of the few Tea Leaf Green lyrics that seems to acknowledge something happening in the present-day outdoors, that's not yet totally processed by Trevor's diffusion. I mean his methods (as bandleader-composer, dynamically, and making the guitarist seem like a hireling) get a bit too same-o, after a while, same as so many CDs. (LPs were shorter, so same-o couldn't spread so far, not as often as on CDs.) But I still listen, and maybe Trevor's programming me, we'll see.

don, Saturday, 18 March 2006 20:28 (eighteen years ago) link

from metal thread w/ typos fixed:

One caveat I gotta state about the Huck Jones album is that he probably does *too many* Stone Temple-style ballads. They're fine (less coagulated than STP's own early ballads were -- I'm talking STP in Pearl Jam not powerpop/glam mode here -- and, in Jones's "Forgiveness," almost more like a *Use Your Illusion* ballad done in a lower register), but they're really not the guy's best songs (so far I'm leaning toward lead cut/single "Oh Yeah," "Infatuation," ELO "Turn to Stone" rip "Kill Everything," and the Seger cover for those), and they seem too plentiful compared to his faster hard rock. Also STP's best songs weren't ballads anyway. But maybe a la Cargun, I'll decide Huck's aren't as grunge as they seem.

xhuxk, Saturday, 18 March 2006 23:43 (eighteen years ago) link

This song can still be heard in maybe 1,000 jukeboxes currently across America in small bars and restaurants.

I'm betting Johnny Rebeltunes-type material is also popular in some enclaves of soCal. The LA Times went out and surveyed the white voters after the Bush victory, the counties that went for him which are in the interior deserts and such, also out to the Sierra's, and they sounded like Johnny Reb's. Mostly wanting to vote for Bush because they felt the Reps were better ready to do something about the 'illegals' and here's one quote paraphrased, 'cuz they carried/carry diseases and that's a threat to security. Same as 'Move them Niggers North," only 'Move Them Pickers South.'

George 'the Animal' Steele, Saturday, 18 March 2006 23:51 (eighteen years ago) link

"Pickers" sought out (if not brought here, or mailordered) by those Free Enterprisers who pay without taxes or Workmen's Comp to worry about, if indeed they end up paying los illegals at all. (What are they gonna do, complain to Uncle Sam?)Somehow such employers never seem to be the targets of such ire: if the pickers parade like crack-flaunting jailbait, right under the nose of Mr Businessman, what else can the rich man do? End of Editorial.Somebody should write a song. (Just now on the radio. Hazeldine's doing a female-sung, assertively folk-rocked "Whiskey In The Jarro": sounds like Thin Lizzy's, but kinda better)

don, Sunday, 19 March 2006 02:12 (eighteen years ago) link

Back from Austin and I'd just like to say The Mammals are more stomping live than you'd ever guess from their record.

And new Dixie Chicks single is streaming here:

http://music.msn.com/artist/?artist=16097852>1=7702

I dig. It's like the Chicks fronting the Hearbreakers. Oh wait, it basically is.

Roy Kasten (Roy Kasten), Monday, 20 March 2006 21:51 (eighteen years ago) link

Listening to this lo-fi New Zealand art-folk indie-rock album (EP?) by Pumice on Soft Abuse (which is very very pretty and I like a lot), I'm realizing that some Flying Nun-style New Zealand stuff is sort of country in the way the Mekons circa 1980 (*Devils Rats and Piggies* era; very early but not *extremely* early in their career) were sort of country. Frank wrote once (in *Why Music Sucks* I think) that New Zealanders did prettier things with Velvet Underground music than anybody (except maybe the occasional Clevelander), but I hear as much country Mekons here as Velvets. My favorite song is "Worsted," I think.

xhuxk, Tuesday, 21 March 2006 12:01 (eighteen years ago) link

at risk of offending someone mightily, and im not sure who, i got rough shop's new album in the mail today, and though the ocver art is amazing, its kind of dull in that rough shod earnest indie way...

anthony easton (anthony), Tuesday, 21 March 2006 13:41 (eighteen years ago) link

who or what are or is rough shop??

xhuxk, Tuesday, 21 March 2006 13:47 (eighteen years ago) link

Rough Shop's a St. Louis group that Roy's working with. I posted about their "Far Past the Outskirts" above--basically, it sounds like good ol' tortured drone-country, sort of on that Mekons/Fairport Convention wavelength. I think it's pretty good, and just ugly enough for me. I like the songs that Anne Tkach sings, like "Destination Everywhere."

and Moody Scott's record is real good, the best kind of semi-pro you'll never see on Nashville Star...his raps are good (he doesn't really rap, but he definitely has some things to say about our particular moment in time), and it's all post-Malaco/I-55 bluessoulfunk, with a few cheeseball synthin-kitsch-sink keyboard ballads that because they're coming from Moody, aren't even unlistenable. and the "Something You Got Baby" he does links him definitively to some kind of weird New Orleans tradition I don't have all the links for--'cause it is Chris Kenner's '61 "Something You Got" except very slightly different words, same arrangement/melody. And good--so did Kenner cop his hit (which is really important New Orleans record, as far as that goes, since it started the "Popeye" dance/song craze of late '61, blues skolars) from somewhere else?

xps

edd s hurt (ddduncan), Tuesday, 21 March 2006 15:22 (eighteen years ago) link

Detroit Disciples' Saving Grace has stuff belongs on current CMT. A lot of stuff. They're from Sonoma in my state, they tell me, and xhuxk must have liked them. And I can see why because the first three tunes, "I Can't Complain," "Government Man," and "Fallen In Love," are stellar singer/songwriter roots rock and very very catchy.

In fact, I'm astonished by the songwriting craft on just about ever cut, it only faltering by the last couple of tunes when they turn off the electric guitars. And at one point they even do something that sounds like Jackson Browne around "Running On Empty."

And I didn't think it would grow on me as much as it has. Also belongs in the category of heartland rock staked out by the Michael Stanley's of the country.

George 'the Animal' Steele, Tuesday, 21 March 2006 16:41 (eighteen years ago) link

xhuxk: you should have gotten the Rough Shop CD by now. If it doesn't show up in a few days, I'll resend. Anthony: No offense remotely taken. Thanks for taking the time to listen. And I'll take some credit for the cover art 'cause it was my design, though Bob Reuter, St. Louis's best rock 'n' roll photographer, took all the photos. Anybody else want a copy, feel free to email me.

I got the new Bottle Rockets, and on first listen, it's pretty good, tougher than the last album, though I'm not so sure about the mastering. Kinda bright for what the band is going for. Release date is early June on Bloodshot.

Roy Kasten (Roy Kasten), Tuesday, 21 March 2006 17:25 (eighteen years ago) link

Yep, George, I do like Detroit Disciples! (See upthread, circa Feb 2).

xhuxk, Tuesday, 21 March 2006 17:51 (eighteen years ago) link

But Roy! Tellus about SXSW!

don, Tuesday, 21 March 2006 17:58 (eighteen years ago) link

I agree, it made me immediately think of Michael Pare in the Eddie & the Cruisers movies. (There were two of them and the sequel was really really awful!) But Detroit Disciples overcome most of the bowling alley and roadhouse stodge with the actually great songs. It's obvious they mean it in the sincerest manner and that counts on some things, this being one of them. I can listen to it a lot easier than I can Yep Roc's roots-rock-with-paprika-and-other-spicy-weirdnesses CDs these days.

George 'the Animal' Steele, Tuesday, 21 March 2006 18:05 (eighteen years ago) link

All kinds of thoughts swimming in my aching head about SXSW but I have 1000 words on these here Nina Simone reissues due in like 2 hours, so it'll have to wait--mostly. Of the 60 odd bands I caught I didn't see all that much country-ish that knocked me out. Biggest thrill was a full set by Roky Erickson (the resurrection is as real as anyone could hope for and something I never thought I'd see). Also: total funk tightness from Sharon Jones and an 8 piece version of Margot and the Nuclear So and So's and a very very rocking Willie Nile show, pick-up bass player and drummer not withstanding. But could someone explain the appeal of What Made Milwaukee Famous? They're like an even more faceless Emerson Drive (if that's even possible) with bogus hipster pretentions. Somebody must have thrown a lot of money at Esquire to get them on the Saturday finale at Stubb's.

Roy Kasten (Roy Kasten), Tuesday, 21 March 2006 18:38 (eighteen years ago) link

Somebody should write a song

Well, obv. Woody did, but so did the Hag; if I recall correctly, it goes "The illegal immigrant is making America grow."

Frank Kogan (Frank Kogan), Tuesday, 21 March 2006 18:52 (eighteen years ago) link

Speaking of Kid Rock, people (me) tend to forget how great Devil Without a Cause is. Was thinking about him because I recently borrowed Rage Against the Machine's Los Angeles from the library and basically felt sad listening to it, how these guys seemed to have the moves, the noise, the dance, the energy, but ended up dry-as-dull-dust, the splash of music not even there as a mist or a droplet - though the album went platinum, so someone heard something. And it clobbered Kid Rock in Pazz & Jop, though the Kid went 9 times platinum so what does he care? Anyway, Rage seemed to just be short of someone like a Kid Rock to find them tunes and emotion and humor. But Kid has been a mystery to me since then, mainly because I stopped following after that boring second album, but the little I've heard after that left me puzzled. So, any more thoughts, especially his would-be country escapades, but not restricted to those? It seems to me that though Rage needed someone like him, he also needed something like Rage, some rhythm and noise to put his nonlegit voice in full effect.

Frank Kogan (Frank Kogan), Tuesday, 21 March 2006 19:17 (eighteen years ago) link

(xpost illegales songs)Don't know the Hag's; also, was thinking about Woody's "Deportee" and maybe "Plane Wreck At Los Gatos," if that's even the right title, but I don't know the words to either, well enough to know if they fit the condemnation-exploitation I was preaching about. Roky's revival was also mentioned in Parales' SXSW report,linked from the SXSW thread--that is really amazing. xpost Yep Roc spices, Shack Shakers' Pandelrium is mostly pretty solid, and although they're not (yet?) as accomplished as Gogol Bordello, I was comparing favorably even before I saow the Gogol link on the Shack Shakers site (and G.B. does tour the South fairly often, for that.) But also, if I could've figured out how to squeeze this into the forthcoming review, I would've added that my personal faves are the country-est, like "No Such Thing,"("Is that a bone in my leg? No, there's no such thing") and (country with rolling horizons)"Nelly Bell." Which could be a real obit set to music, and reminds me of a plainer "For The Benefit Of Mr. Kite," at least some of the words of which came from an old circus poster, Lennon said. Also the one on prev. Cockadoodledont, about Wilkes's neighbor, who gets drunk and sits on his horse in the front yard everyday. Man and steed are old, and don't race no more, but not falling down, not in the song, anyway.

don, Tuesday, 21 March 2006 19:42 (eighteen years ago) link

don't know if anyone else caught Billy Joe Shaver at SXSW but I'd never seen him live before and it was a real treat, equal parts hammy and heartbreaking, a sly, salacious old polecat who did an unbelievable song about "faxing" all night long with a girl from Kinko's that also compared cellphones to dick size and lamented that nowadays the ladies all wanted the "cowboy troy model." thought i'd die laughing. did almost all his classics ("old chunk of coal," "honky tonk heroes," "georgia on a fast train") and proved he could still hold a crowd with his latest "live forever."

also saw Rosanne Cash and The Little Willies (feat. Norah Jones) do an instore - Rosanne only did five songs and forgot a line or two from "Tennessee Flattop Box" but that was fine by me cause the other four she did were all from Black Cadillac and personally I'm loving that album.

oh yeah, and I caught Elizabeth McQueen and the Firebrands twice too, once right before Billy Joe - she threw out a bunch of free swag during "All I Need is Money" and I helped myself to a beer cozy.

Josh Love (screamapillar), Tuesday, 21 March 2006 19:59 (eighteen years ago) link

I got to see the Rosanne set at Stubb's, first time I'd ever seen her with a full-on band, and I was surprised at how well she does chunky and loose rock, maybe it was the drummer (no idea who) or Larry Campbell holding forth on rhythm guitar so that her hubby could just play without atmospherizing as he tends to. I hope she's touring this band.

Roy Kasten (Roy Kasten), Tuesday, 21 March 2006 20:14 (eighteen years ago) link

Ha, Frank, I can't even remember which "boring second album" by Kid Rock you mean! "Amercian Badass*? *Cocky*? There have been so many rip-off stop-gaps (most recently the live one, which I like just fine this week), I have trouble remembering which were the official ones. (Plus, *Devil Without a Cause* was something like his fourth; he actually had hinted at going the redneck route with *Early Morning Stoned Pimp* before that.) Anyway. All the ones since have had music I enjoy on them (more "music" than "songs"), and they're all pretty much been completely forgettable, and I assume I'll say the same thing about *'Live' Trucker* in two years, and I really don't mind for some reason. It's like the guy has taken a clue from his coked-out '70s country and rock heroes and settled on just being a dependable journeyman; I seriously doubt he has any interest in making an album as great as *Devil Without a Cause* again. And I disagree about him needing his own Rage Against the Machine. The Rage-style stuff on *Devil* (including, uh, the song with "rage" in the title) was the album's worst stuff, and the Twisted Brown Trucker Band have "the moves, the noise, the dance, the energy" at LEAST as much as Rage ever did to my ears, plus they've got a sense of fun and sense of humor and, hell, sense of funk that I never heard in Rage, so they *don't* end up dry as dust. (Though it's very possible I just never listened to Rage enough, or their vocalist got in the way of me hearing their music, like what happens to me with hip-hop so often.) I mean, Twisted Brown Trucker are more a hard rock boogie band than a complex Zep-style metal band I guess (I *assume* that's what people hear Rage as; am I wrong?), but that doesn't bug me. The first song on the live CD, "Son of Detroit," boogies quite funkerociously to my ears, and it's fun how they end with the Gap Band's "Outstanding". Oddly, the song that holds up worst for me on this CD (compared to its studio version) is "Only God Knows Why," which I think was my single of the year in Pazz and Jop the year it came out -- then again, maybe it's just that there's been such a huge and unexpected deluge of great Southern rock since then that it doesn't sound so special anymore, who knows. And I still kind of like "Picture," whether Sheryl or Alison or Gretchen are duetting on it, and I know you don't, Frank (not sure why, though.)

xhuxk, Tuesday, 21 March 2006 23:40 (eighteen years ago) link

(I mean, I've talked about this on other threads plenty, gotten in arguments with Miccio about it and stuff. And I totally understand why people feel let down by the guy; he *did* pretty much turn into a hack, lost his sense of punchlines as much as the Beasties ever did, and so on. But I feel like his band has kept his head above water somehow, and some day I'll handpick a great CD-R out of his post-*Devil albums, and 10 years from now maybe some smart whippersnapper will argue convincingly that *Devil* wasn't even his best after all. Anyway, here's what I wrote about his last one, for whatever it's worth:

http://www.villagevoice.com/music/0350,eddy,49290,22.html

xhuxk, Tuesday, 21 March 2006 23:54 (eighteen years ago) link

Two other small thoughts in his favor:

1) There are definitely good arguments available for moving from Limp Bizkit type music to Lynyrd Skynyrd type music (or even from Rage Against the Machine type music to Bad Company type music). (For example, here's one: melodies are *good* things.)

2) He makes better albums now than Eminem does (which I wouldn't have predicted.)

xhuxk, Wednesday, 22 March 2006 01:14 (eighteen years ago) link

And I gotta say I really love how he identifies so much with Bob Seger, since in some ways (local Detroit City fame years before he exploded nationally, etc) their careers do have certain parallels. Though of course if Kid had done it right he would have put out his *Live Bullet* tribute *before* *Devil Without a Cause*. Still, it should be noted that, in hindsight, *Stranger in Town* doesn't seem near the artistic dropoff from *Night Moves* it was once seen as, and maybe someday it'll make just as much sense to the same about *Cocky* in relation to *Devil.* And Seger's '80s hackwork could be distilled into a great CD-R, too.

And by the way, speaking of *Cocky* (and Iraqis) the last line of this great RJ Smith review from late 2001 now seems eerily prescient; I wonder if Kid read it and took it to heart?

http://www.villagevoice.com/music/0151,smith,30841,22.html

xhuxk, Wednesday, 22 March 2006 01:38 (eighteen years ago) link

(Okay, maybe not a great CD-R, but a RESPECTABLE one. For the late works of Bob S and Bob R both.)

xhuxk, Wednesday, 22 March 2006 01:59 (eighteen years ago) link

More thoughts on new Brox: It's their best record since 24 Hours A Day, which is probably their best record over all, and it comes up with compelling answers to the eternal question "What would Neil do?" They've had guitar crush before, but not with the gravity of the opener "Better Than Broken" and they've never been quite this universally dark (Zoysia, I've since learned, is a strain of creeping grass, and a metaphor for how the suburbs are destiny and not a pretty one), though any record with a song that celebrates the individualism of sobriety (the one dud to my ears) won't be confused with Tonight's the Night. But there's aesthetic coherence here, not greasy or gritty or trashy really, just a diamond hard chiseling of who the Bottle Rockets are, even if, on the best acoustic number, they claim they're not from where they're from. I don't think it's too much to say there's something existential going on here--and it rocks too.

Roy Kasten (Roy Kasten), Wednesday, 22 March 2006 04:46 (eighteen years ago) link

Am watching Nashville Star right now, predicting I'll be checking out after thirty minutes. Gretchen is the guest music star and I'm overworked on the redneck shtick which is the theme of the show, straight down to the hack slob/fool Larry the Cable Guy. Show us your buttcrack, hey? It was old and odious when Dan Aykroyd did it on SNL.

So everyone is talking 'bout how redneck revolution means rocking and they can get fucked as far as I'm concerned. Being a redneck is coincidental, poxy fules.

The sound is noticebably off in this epidsode. It's reverberant, shrill and the crash makes it difficult to decipher what Cowboy Troy is going on about. Troy is up, he's so up it seems he's taken a pill, maybe one too many. He's talking too fast and a Prilosec logo, the drug for curbing heartburn acid reflux, is flashing next to his face and if there's someone who looks like a bigger fool tonight, you're going to have to go a long way to find him or her.

Rock, rock, rock, redneck rock is the mantra for tonight, adds Wy. Let's all rock through the show. It's so irritating my teeth are rattling.

Last week was fair. This week the meat wagon's being driven over the cliff. Were the ratings bad?

George 'the Animal' Steele, Wednesday, 22 March 2006 06:25 (eighteen years ago) link

i watched the first hour
the voices arent v. good, arent even v. good bar band good, and the two i like i didnt know how they did.

only one id like to fuck, too, which is why i msotly watched last year

anthony easton (anthony), Wednesday, 22 March 2006 06:27 (eighteen years ago) link

The sound continues to be bad. The vocals, which were good last week, are obscured by the crash in the hall which tells me the PA is too loud and there aren't enough bodies in the hall to soak it up. Troy's mike made him mostly incoherent.

Gretchen did her second song, Politically Uncorrect or something, and the fiddles and Telecaster were way too loud and I like loud instruments. But the Tele player was just a goon hack with a shaved head and the fiddles, eh. And you know I'm sick of Gretchen who appears to have lost weight which tells me she's taking pills on the advice of her management. Plus, they were phoning it in because they had the look of people who expected the audience to go wild every night while playing it, which is what the studio audience did.

One girl came on -- Torres -- and she looked great and her jeans were spray painted on, but the song was boring and everyone fawned over her because she was HOTT.

Another of my big objections is that none of the contestants show any human superciliousness or enmity, both of which are necessary qualities in pop rock and dealing with any audience live. It stands to reason the guy who did the Big & Rich cover OK, after being drubbed by Anastacia the dick for two weeks running, would have snarled back at her. But no, all the contestants, when fed shit, ask for more. Good character traits for working in cubicles at corporate America USA, maybe convincing to sheep watching on TV, not so good for anything else.

Quote of night: "I love to have a great time." Wow, pearls before swine.

George 'the Animal' Steele, Wednesday, 22 March 2006 07:12 (eighteen years ago) link

the weird thing, is that with the big and rich song, there has to be a swagger, same with the messina, and well no swagger at all, they care too deeply to be loose with the material,

and well, lets not talk about the guy who did the charlie daniels, the desperation and exhaustion and sadness and esmaculation and all of it hiding behind this played out masculinity...its a hard song to sing, and he was so safe, people shouldnt play broken hearted drinking songs until theyve had enough time to be well be broken hearted and drunk--last week the same thing happened with tequilla, unless you actually have spent time on a bender, the lavisoucness just doesnt slither out...

and cowboy troy is just awkard, he doesnt know where to go and what to say...

anthony easton (anthony), Wednesday, 22 March 2006 08:13 (eighteen years ago) link

> Brox: best record since 24 Hours A Day, which is probably their best record over all<

Really? *Blue Sky* is the only album by them that's ever really clicked for me, and that one only half way; I mean, I liked "Baggage Claim" just fine, but despite their trappings they always seemed to wind up on the wrong side of the alt-country vs. southern rock divide to my ears. Haven't listened to the new one yet, though. And perhaps I should listen to their old ones more (though outside of *Blue Sky,* none are around here anymore.) (I was thinking I liked some almost pub-metal/Count Bishops song they did in the mid/late '90s with "rural route" in the title, but I'm not finding it on AMG; maybe I'm confusing them with somebody. Either way, I always wished their guitars were louder, a la the Cactus Brothers.)

ps. I never knew Bottle Rockets' nickname was "the Brox" til now. But I figured it out!

xhuxk, Wednesday, 22 March 2006 12:08 (eighteen years ago) link

"Rural Route" is on their first album, which could be out of print for all I know. I'm not sure what you mean about the alt-country vs. southern rock divide though. Maybe not enough r&b in their sound? If that's the case, then you might like that sobriety tune on the new record--first Bottle Rocket song with female back up vocals? But "Baggage Claim" always struck me as stilted--I have no beef with Bread but that's not why I listen to this band. I think you'll like the guitars on the new one.

Roy Kasten (Roy Kasten), Wednesday, 22 March 2006 13:14 (eighteen years ago) link

Not enough rock in their sound is more what I mean, Roy. "Kinda rock for an alt-country band" is nice, but not enough. But yeah, I'll check out the new one, and I can see how some funk or soul might help matters too. (And though "Baggage Claim" is the track that sticks in my head from the last album, I'm not claiming that was necessary its best cut. Don't think I've played that CD since the year it came out.)

xhuxk, Wednesday, 22 March 2006 13:52 (eighteen years ago) link

It's a mark of my taste that I tend to get interested when (especially) Chuck mentions on this thread that something "doesn't have enough rock in it". I can't really stomach the rock, or the rock end of country.

There's no reason whatsoever you should be interested in this fact.

Tim (Tim), Wednesday, 22 March 2006 14:14 (eighteen years ago) link

Don, as far as I know, "Plane Wreck at Los Gatos" is the correct title of the Woody song that people tend to refer to as "Deportee." The plane crashed by the South Bay, the newscaster described the victims as "just deportees," that's what inspired the song. (I wouldn't be surprised if there were several songs called "Deportee," but I doubt that they'd be by Guthrie.)

Xhuxk, I was thinking that "Devil" was Kid's first. I think American Badass is the one I was calling his second. And of course I don't necessarily believe it needs to be Rage-type guys who back him up. Just someone to lay down some fire. My impression (and this may be very wrong, since I haven't listened to nearly enough of it) is that his singing nowadays is trying to be straight-up legitimate, whereas I think he needs something to provide him cover so that he can do what he does best, which is to do some variation on sing-talking. As I said, this could be all wrong, including my opinion on what he does best.

"Picture" felt like slow, dead sentimentality pinned to the near calm sky. But I've not heard it more than 3 or 4 times, and not recently.

Frank Kogan (Frank Kogan), Wednesday, 22 March 2006 16:11 (eighteen years ago) link

(I listened to the Rage Against the Machine because I was impressed with how Flyleaf seemed to be finding the dance in Rage and Nirvana and using it to lift a live-wire wailer to the spotlight, where she pours her melodic-harmonic heart out in the higher registers, and roar with the wolves in the lower. But I wouldn't claim that Flyleaf are close to country, so if I need to say more I'll take it to the teenpop thread.)

Frank Kogan (Frank Kogan), Wednesday, 22 March 2006 16:17 (eighteen years ago) link

did nathalie merchant do a cover of ...los gatos?

anthony easton (anthony), Wednesday, 22 March 2006 16:24 (eighteen years ago) link

Maybe Flyleaf belong on the metal thread, too, Frank! (Girlie says they're sending me the album, but I haven't seen it yet. And oh yeah, I'm going to call you about your review of it later today.)

Turns out I goofed; there's no Kid Rock LP called *American Bad Ass*. Shows what I know. That was the single off *The History of Rock,* which was mainly sort of an odds-and-sods early years comp, duh:

http://www.villagevoice.com/music/0027,eddy,16173,22.html

"Picture"'s beautiful-loser bullshit actually sounds fairly lush and billowing and good-humored to my ears, not dead or draggy at all.

xhuxk, Wednesday, 22 March 2006 16:32 (eighteen years ago) link


You must be logged in to post. Please either login here, or if you are not registered, you may register here.