A thread about the Denis Villeneuve-helmed reboot of DUNE

it's gnna be five films, the middle three nothing but worm stuff back and forth, back and forth, the worms getting bigger and bigger

This looks pretty cool despite the muted color palette, but it will take a lot to outdo the Lynch version, warts and all.

whispering and pugs and eyebrows is all i ask

the middle three nothing but worm stuff back and forth, back and forth, the worms getting bigger and bigger

I was thinking more like

https://www.sagindie.org/media/MeAndYou-kids.jpg

[opening of Dune trailer]

[Arnold Schwarzenegger as Baron Harkonnen]: SPICE to meet you!

— 🐢 (@smashedmcdouble) September 9, 2020

Also I'm seriously envious Geoff Barrow didn't recognize the music:

That’s literally the worst trailer music I’ve ever heard...

What song is it?

It sounds like a gospel version of
The back street boys https://t.co/MXhY0QR9Ot

— Geoff Barrow (@jetfury) September 9, 2020

music for trailer, DUNE 2: SARAUKAR DRIFT:

i've got a worm you can ride it if you learn / it's a nice worm
i'd give it to you if i could / kwisatz haderach

SARDAUKAR ffs

xxp lol he's not wrong

this looks pretty good to me, someone who has read the first dune book but isn't particularly invested in it and also really liked blade runner 2049

don't really like Villeneuve and blade runner 2049 was bad Imo but will watch the hell out of this

the shai-hulud looks good

i read dune #1 for the first time earlier this year and really enjoyed it while simultaneously thinking its just one of those books that if/when attempting to render it visually will just fundamentally always look & seem silly. That being said this looks pretty watchable and non-silly so I'm cautiously optimistic. Cant blame them for going super grim and monochromatic and somber bc theyve gotta fight against all that inherent silliness.

actually they don't have to and probably shouldn't but

Silliness?! In a giant worm flick?!

http://images2.minutemediacdn.com/image/upload/c_crop%2Ch_1133%2Cw_1685%2Cx_293%2Cy_0/v1592785618/shape/mentalfloss/61181-universal_pictures_home_entertainment.jpg

i have never read Dune, i think it’s finally time to attempt now that i’m trapped indoors

trailer looks cool
also OSCAR ISAAC

i'm gonna go out on a limb and suggest that Dune, cracked in your 40's, is likely not gonna be a lot of fun

I read it early this year, at 35, and enjoyed it

I read it less than 10 years ago (I am 48) and enjoyed it a lot more than when I tried and gave up in high school.

yeah i read it for the first time around 40 and i liked it. i've never been a big sci-fi reader either.

I'm mad that they skipped past "All that you eat" on the shot of the worm eating the spice harvester.

Ween would have been more appropriate than Floyd

― unpaid intern at the darvo institute (Simon H.), Wednesday, September 9, 2020 12:50 PM (four hours ago) bookmarkflaglink

Or TMBG.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bTxXVhdmdZc

my spouse just finished dune for the first time in her mid-30s and liked it a lot

hi, new to ILX, but after watching trailer all the "unneccessary" talk wayyyy upthread is OTM imho tbqh.

also: did they show the guild navigator(s) in the trailer? must've missed them.

holy shit, I had it playing in the background a while ago and in the back of my mind I thought, is that a slowed down spooky Pink Floyd cover, can't be, seems too on the nose even for one of these epic event films. And then just now I got to watch it properly all the through and, yep, slowed down spooky Pink Floyd.

xxps Maybe I'm Wrong About Dune!
I should probably try rereading it; my only memories are junior high school ones.

i (29) read dune for the first time this summer and liked it a lot!

guild navigators aren't even in the book - not that I wouldn't love to see them.

im not much of a reader of sci fi, had always been dune-curious but had been scared off by ppl saying its super dense, super boring, etc, but i dunno i got caught up in it and found it pretty fun

it is super dense, but that's part of the charm. i love how herbert refuses to hold your hand even as he throws all these weird terms and characters at you for the first couple hundred pages. and i don't think it's boring, it's just that the plot is a bit oblique and is secondary to the world-building.

how any of this will translate onto the silver screen is anyone's guess

guild navigators are in the second book

sorry

i recently managed to score a dune encyclopedia (pb, berkley 1984) ... i've been meaning to reread the first four (five and six are objectively bad) again with the encyclopedia at the ready but never got around to it. this might be the time.

also i'm excited for this because why the hell not

wow rare find! I've been looking for that for a while but copies on ebay are too costly.

holy shit! is it because of the movie? mine was like $40 at a brick and mortar

no it has been costly for a while - it's the only Dune adjacent book out of print (and will remain so) since Brian H de-canonized it.

dang didn’t realize it was such a score ... last I checked on internet most copies were in the $50 range

i like the cool british edition with the cotton candy pink and blue cover but the one i got matches my paperbacks which is cool too

actually i only paid $35, the receipt is still in it!

and look at the bookmark that fell out when i flipped through it

https://i.postimg.cc/fTk4xm88/72-F91981-9-B2-A-4-E7-E-B6-A4-DA75507-EF2-E7.jpg

https://i.postimg.cc/4xhr0Zkt/1-F3-ED44-C-E539-43-BC-A6-D0-A526777-BB628.jpg

i mean ... that explains it right? my copy is cursed :(

lmao

I should have held on to my copy of that -- fun slumgullion of random stuff. I especially liked the entry on Gamont, an actually truly funny bit.

Anyway, scene by scene breakdown:

https://io9.gizmodo.com/breaking-down-the-spice-worms-and-pain-boxes-in-dunes-1844676132

There is, admittedly, a truth here:

I tried explaining the plot of DUNE and DUNE MESSIAH to my wife recently while she was driving and she said if I didn't stop she would pull over

— Jordan Hoffman (@jhoffman) September 9, 2020

jeeze, Brian Herbert having dominion over Dune canon is like putting Jared Kushner in charge. I tried to read one of his prequels and it was the worst cringe fanfic I’ve ever slogged through.

I loved the Dune Encyclopedia as a kid, but don't have it anymore.

My sci-fi nerd cousin dragged me to the Lynch movie when were 10 and I did not dig it; I finally read it in my very late 30s and liked it more than I expected. Not enough to read any of the others but enough to read this thread

xps

If Herbert wrote it today, the 1965 novel would be at least three fat volumes. It's dense with characters and incidents he could have developed at far greater length (I suppose his recognition of what he'd left on the table prompted the sequels). It's fast-paced in a typical 1960s SF style, a bit disjointed like most fixups from magazine stories, but it kept surprising me and making me want to know and see more. Unfortunately the sequels didn't scratch that itch -- I read Dune Messiah and wasn't inclined to go farther.

I wasn't expecting that trailer to look so much like the Lynch film!

Repeating my reservations from elsewhere:

- Zimmer makes terrible movie music, I don’t trust him not to fuck this up even if what we’ve heard so far is pretty OK (for Zimmer).

- Everything on the screen could be recreated using three of the pages from my Benjamin Moore fan deck, namely the cold browns

- Chalamet’s not a total wimp, but is he up to this? His voice definitely isn’t in the same league as MacLachlan’s. I got expectations, man.

- the ornithopters and the shields don’t look weird enough. Dune is weird. Arrakis is weird.

The last two points are key for me. Still I appreciate the ornithopters looking strange enough.

Strangely, nothing about milking cats