Best book from the ads at the back of an old Bantam paperback of Crompton Divided

Was thinking same, as thats not my favorite Pohl (by some distance) either

lol @ their being a Logan's Run sequel

is Fredric Brown worth reading? why does he get so many entries on this list?

I must've read some of his short pieces at some point, but they left no impression

Janet E. Morris bridged two worlds.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/High_Couch_of_Silistra#/media/File:High_Couch_of_Silistra_front_cover.jpg

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/High_Couch_of_Silistra#/media/File:High_Couch_of_Silistra_front_cover.jpg

Can't load that image.

lol @ their being a Logan's Run sequel

is Fredric Brown worth reading? why does he get so many entries on this list?

I haven't read enough of these to vote in good conscience, but I'm basically a "Martian Chronicles" guy.

Earthsea over Dhalgren for me

I was just contemplating re-reading those McCaffrey books the other day but I'm afraid they won't have aged well as opposed to my pre-teen memory of them

The only thing I've read by here was an anthologized early Pern story: blanking on titles, but it was from the 60s, orig. in Analog, I think (editor commented that she was one of Campbell's last proteges). Was immediately drawn into complicated intrigue, world-building and customized dragons (bred by lost Earthling colonists to psychic powers and bonding in pairs with humans, 4 life). The reversion or extension of feudalism went with retro-futuristic play of the dragon card in power struggles and other cultural activities. SF with the trappings and flavor of fantasy, so yeah planetary romance, as this article says (I'd just read Dune, so was especially up for McC.):
http://www.sf-encyclopedia.com/entry/mccaffrey_anne
Though caveat:
McCaffrey and her collaborators and successors have, perhaps inevitably, allowed a touchy-feely Young Adult glow to soften the impact of its first volumes, losing in the process the clarity of her focus on strong women protagonists (see Women in SF), and her remarkable nuts-and-bolts attentiveness to the problems of living and gaining career success in Pern.
So, yet more stuff that gets better the farther back you go, maybe---then again, she wrote other interesting-looking books mentioned here.

There were at least two Logan's Run sequels, I owned the one on here as a kid.

My favourites are the Bradburys and the Delaneys and Earthsea but I'm conflicted about that one

Almost certainly Something Wicked for me

dow (and sfencyclopedia) generally otm about McCaffrey - I re-read some of those books recently and the writing and plotting and general ideas tend to devolve as the series goes on (and on, and on). It's important to remember that there was basically nothing like this before her, this kind of pulpy YA sf fantasy fiction with strong women protagonists, written by a woman. She invented that shit.

Norton's Ordeal In Otherwhere and Year Of The Unicorn pre-dates Pern by a few years. Don't know if they were the first.

idk anybody irl that read Andre Norton. Even as a kid, the only reason I knew the name was because of her foundation's grants to PBS lol.

but sure ok

She seems to have some staying power because recent writers like Aliette De Bodard, Ann Leckie, Craig Laurence Gidney probably a few others I'm forgetting have some love for her.

I didn't like one book I tried recently but I've got a bunch more to get to.

I'm sure the anthology Dow is reading has one of her stories.

Yep, this one: ANDREW NORTH: All Cats Are Gray | 1953. Haven't gotten there yet. Title seems familiar, but I don't recall ever reading anything by her. Very good selections so far.

title is from Mervyn Peake/Ghormenghast

Okay, reminder that I still need to read all that too!
I don't know how her whole life-cycle might compare to those of Norton and McC.'s valiant women, but already, in this 1934 Weird Tales tale I tripped on above, Jirel of Jorey is a badass with emotional conflicts to match or overmatch physical violence, of which there is plenty, in a pulpy yet non-gratuitous way. I don't know that such a combo would have been acceptable in a comparable male character (don't recall Conan having those feels, although creator Robert E. Howard seemed to flame out after his mother's death, right? So maybe Conan did have some perceptible vulnerabilities somewhere--or Red Sonja? Never read stories of her).
Here, at least, Jirel seems like an ancestor of 60s teen angst Peter Parker->Spiderman--and his future peer Paul Atreides, who will have not wanna be no Dune Messiah for the Universe--and all or many such subsequent superheros and heroines.

lol idk if you need to read *all* of it, I stopped after the first Ghormenghast book lol

Yeah, me too.

title is from Mervyn Peake/Ghormenghast

All Cats Are Gray

although huh I guess there is some idiomatic saying that predates Peake? idk

Poor Richard’s Almanac, if not earlier, I would hazard to guess.

No, that's "All Cats Are Gay."

"Like Horses!"

You guys have got to be kidding.

Usually see that quote attributed to Ben Franklin, although Wikipedia seems to have an earlier citation as well.

it's french you rubes

https://translate.google.com/translate?hl=en&sl=fr&u=http://www.linternaute.com/proverbe/75/la-nuit-tous-les-chats-sont-gris/&prev=search

voted tombs of atuan btw, where earthsea starts to get interesting (i.e. not patriarchal).

Hello James Redd,

We found something we think you might like.

Song of the Pearl
$48.28

Shop Now

Automatic thread bump. This poll is closing tomorrow.

Automatic thread bump. This poll's results are now in.

Rachel Bloom to thread!

Poor "The Farthest Shore" -- always the bridesmaid, never the bride.