Best Roxy Music Album

Had no idea For Your Pleasure was so highly regarded

I agree with that grouping. For me FYP is still the best one. I actually have grown to really like both Flesh and Blood and Manifesto; partly because I ignored them for so long that I never really gave them their fair due, and now I'm much less familiar with them.

I'd probably move Mamouna from "solid" to "great" and move Bete Noir down to "solid" myself.

I'm on the akm train. Bete Noir is my least favorite of his smoothie session cat records. Also, Bride Stripped Bare has some incredible stuff ("Sign of the Times," "When She Walks In the Room," "This Island Earth") and some blech stuff (mostly the soul stuff: "Hold On I'm Comin'," "Take Me to the River"). I'd swap it with In Your Mind, which has "Tokyo Joe" and "This Is Tomorrow Calling," among other things. And as noted up-thread, Let's Stick Together probably has more tracks I love on it than any other Ferry album, notwithstanding its grab bag nature.

Agree that Stranded is the best one.

i used to think stranded was my favorite, and tho the highs are probably the highest, song for europe and sunset weigh it down a bit. as amazing as they are, avalon is the only truly filler-free roxy music album imo. maybe siren.

"Song For Europe" is a slight slog, but "Sunset" is one of the most perfect album endings by anyone, ever.

and "filler" isn't even a problem for a band like roxy, which so emphasized mood-creation and experimentation that there are bound to be two or three weird cuts per record. i'm glad that they're there.

xp

There's some missteps but I don't they ever went in for filler, as such.

"Song For Europe" is a slight slog, but "Sunset" is one of the most perfect album endings by anyone, ever.

― Montgomery Burns' Jazz (Tarfumes The Escape Goat), Thursday, October 10, 2019 10:20 AM (eighteen seconds ago) bookmarkflaglink

sunset is a nice comedown from mother of pearl, and definitely works in the context of the album, but i've never had the urge to listen to it by itself.

There's some missteps but I don't they ever went in for filler, as such.

― Terry Micawber (Tom D.), Thursday, October 10, 2019 10:21 AM (twenty seconds ago) bookmarkflaglink

yeah, that's why i qualified--failed experiments aren't the same as filler.

F+B's got the filler.

I love "Song for Europe" with every cell in my body. When Ferry starts singing in French, man, what a warped, emotionally charged, ridiculous and overflowing with europeanness moment.

I, for one, am glad to see some love for Olympia. I can listen to it from beginning to end without a single skip.

he starts singing in Latin before he switches to French!

It's such a marvelous mess, all of it.

Ferry singing in French reminds me of Kenneth Williams singing Crepe Suzette and I still love it.

.. only more camp.

The Pitchfork Sunday review today is 'For Your Pleasure.' Some intriguing points were made concerning connections between British art schools and British art rock. I don't care. The rating score he gave for the album is 9.5. Everybody knows that this is a 10 album, if there is such a thing as a 10 album. It is perfect in every way and one cannot even conceive of how it could be improved upon. So for the love of God, what sort of logic could lead to a 9.5 score? Do I even want to know?

I'd rate FYP an 8 and I love Ferry more than you love your girlfriend.

I’m as gay as a unicorn ranch Soto, which reveals the inherent illogic of this discussion so, checkmate Mary!

yeah i don't know, FYP would be a 10 to me. It's one of my favorite albums of all time.