Neil Young's TRANS: An Underrated Masterpiece, or Justly Ignored?

In case anyone cares, a whole raft of recordings from the Solo Trans tour have just been upped on D1mead0zen.

He wasn't terrible in the 1980's.

he's reissuing Eldorado!

no fan need own this travesty, in which Young and the International Harvesters treat country like Sid Vicious did “My Way.”

Lol, nice.

haha yeah, for my money his worst album

the unplugged cast-off recording of "sample and hold" is well worth finding. "hold on to your love" is one of those great, lyrically simple songs of his that i would hope older takes exist.

trans

i buy used copies of this vinyl on the cheap whenever I see it with the intention of handing them out to bring new members into the blessed Trans fold.

Well. I wish I was an Aztec,
Or a runner in Peru
I would build such
beautiful buildings
To house the chosen few
Like an Inca from Peru.

such a weird record, and the "sad robot" vibes ARE Dicsovery-onwards Daft Punk 20 years early

love the extended mix of Mr Soul on the Sample & Hold single

It's almost hard to imagine people hating on Neil's vocoder vocals now that processed vocals are so ubiquitous in popular music. Like, Transformer Man sounds downright quaint now. He'd have to type the lyrics into a computer and build up the songs 100% digitally rather than just processing analog inputs if he wanted to make a futuristic statement these days.

such a good album

cis crusher
cis crusher

said it before and I’ll say it again- if you haven’t heard the “sample and hold” castoff from his mtv unplugged session yr missing out

sample and hold is sick, industrial

satisfaction guaranteed

the archives release i want the most is the "real" trans - the all synth album that was eventually turned into the existing trans where the more traditional rock songs were taken from the scrapped 82 album "johnny's island"

neil is releasing johnny's island, i hope that clears the way for the complete trans.

https://www.rollingstone.com/music/music-news/neil-young-johnnys-island-1121757/

it's supposed to contain my most desired neil unreleased track, an all-synth version of "razor love" which ended up on silver & gold, this would sound so amazing w/sequencers

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OKNCAQQaNP8

omg want

also interestingly, on some of the first pressing of trans there was a song "if you got love" that was cut so late in the process that it's actually on the back cover tracklist, that song has never been heard either as far as i know

https://cdn.shopify.com/s/files/1/1779/8843/products/trans3_1024x1024.jpg

I read about "Razor Love" in Shakey, but I couldn't find the original

yeah I don't think it's ever surfaced, tyler would know for sure but i've never seen anything

assuming if you got love went all the way through mastering if it was listed on the cover art

I kind of prefer the shorter version of "Sample and Hold" to the 8-minute CD version, would be good to have both easily available.

I first knew sample and hold and transformer man via the lucky thirteen comp

me too! that was a cool comp back in the day esp when that era was largely unknown (to me at least)

it's amazing that the catchy, accessible, occasionally moving (now unintentionally retrofurist) electronic stuff is what people took issue with on this album considering how dire the more traditional stuff is (the first track, my god). if had been all synth based it would be great rather than pretty good

Been saying the same for years. As I understand it, the electronic stuff was recorded first but I don't think there was enough of it for an entire album.

... typographic mistake. The album is actually called TRAINS

i don't think the trad stuff is that bad, but it's obvious the real meat of the album is the trans-ass trans tracks

Like An Inca is great, the rest of the non-electronic tracks not so much

we know you'll be satisfied
when you energize

As stated, the opening track is terrible.

"Hold On to Your Love" is nice though, if a bit wet.

because i love thematically messy albums, i have to say that —while i love trans quite a lot and consider it one of the last hurrahs of truly classic neil— it could be improved by adding 'wanderin' from everybody's rockin' because why the hell not.

the wiki for trans says "After a year of work, the album was mixed in a hurry because Young was eager to go out on tour (documented in the home video Neil Young in Berlin), and a last-minute change in the running order is evident in the inclusion of a song called "If You Got Love" in the track listing and lyric sheet, even though it is not on the album.[3] Portions of several tracks appeared in Young's 1982 feature-length comedy film Human Highway.[11]"

i've never seen human highway, so i'm not sure if this means that portions of songs that were ON trans were featured in human highway or if some of the cut songs were?

I had that Berlin vhs, it’s great - don’t know what happened to it ☹️

Nils Lofgren is wonderfully hamming it up in that Berlin performance iirc

that i know is supposed to be re-released

I rented it from Netflix in the mid '00s.

ha me too. nils' interpretive dancing is unforgettable

I had that Berlin vhs, it’s great - don’t know what happened to it ☹️

Ditto!

if you got love has been bootlegged for ages — kind of a Santana groove meets "Flying On The Ground Is Wrong" haha.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-2xasVHiL6s

The synth "Razor Love" has never shown up as far as I know.

I'm pretty sure the Human Highway film doesn't contain any unreleased Neil songs.

i find this a middling album because it's not cohesive for the reasons as noted by a bunch of people above. although i actually don't mind "a little thing call love" and I love "hold on to your love"

Didn't Human Highway have the Devo/Neil synth version of Hey Hey My My?

I'd consider that a Devo cover with Neil guesting, not an unreleased song?