Contrarian Dickhead Fite!

hart to mould easily

I like Carl and Dan equally but I thought Dan was largely more-celebrated? Carl is fucking great though

Dan's solo records are more widely celebrated in general, but I for one don't like him - particularly when his songs crop up in the middle of a NP album.

i think the ultimate contrarian move is to argue that george is a better songwriter than john and paul

I prefer Phife to Q-Tip

Hart to Mould x1000

Excuse me, I am not a dickhead!! Regarding songwriting, Hart > Mould and Cale > Reed imo.
The others I have mild feelings about but I do genuinely prefer those two.

Dickhead. I am so sure!

I do think I like this Benjamin Orr album better than any of Ocasek’s solo stuff tbh

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=W4pDWgIlBRA

I prefer Dan Bajar to AC Newman

i don't think this is that controversial?

i don't think any of these are that controversial AND y'all called me a dickhead!

and dan bejar is pretty far from non-celebrated. actually probably currently the more zeitgeisty of the two surely?

when i was young i remember preferring mccartney to lennon being controversial but not anymore i don't think

Wow - I really shouldn't start polls after drinking.

Signed,
A dickhead

My rationalization for some of these comparisons is output. Like Bejar only writes about 2 songs per NP album, right?

Oh man - I totally forgot Robert Pollard/Tobin Sprout.

ah, i suppose if you mean "strictly within the confines of the band in which they collaborate i prefer x to y" then it would be a different kettle of fish potentially

Automatic thread bump. This poll is closing tomorrow.

Cale to Reed sometimes

Ringo to Paul

Did Orr write any Cars songs?

Yule to Cale and Reed.

Several of those non-celebrated songwriters are super-celebrated, and "contrarian" is up there with "pretentious" and "elitist" in the "words only a buffoon would use with a straight face" stakes

John Cale famously ignored by the critics

My contrarian position is that I have no idea who half these people are and I'm not that interested in finding out.

I've never heard of Dan Bajar or AC Newman tbh.

I probably listen to the chris bell album more than any chilton solo album. voted "super dickhead".

I've never heard of Dan Bajar or AC Newman tbh.

― Let them eat Pfifferlinge an Schneckensauce (Tom D.)

it's actually dan bejar - i think they're in the band with the thread that's been erroneously labeled NSFW for over a decade?

Tucker to Yule. Case to Bejar and Newman duhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh

cooley to hood

levon to robbie

brix to mark

love to wilson

weir to garcia

(...syke on both counts)

Automatic thread bump. This poll's results are now in.

Bryan Ferry to Brian Eno