Radiohead - Pablo Honey POLL

yep

i agree

There's the occasional pearl, but just as often they're unremarkable (sometimes purposefully so) and sometimes a little silly when looked at cold.

you're gonna have to expand on that

Yorke's approach to writing lyrics on Kid A and Amnesiac is well documented and pretty much common knowledge - I don't have to expand on that at all, they're basically there to vaguely push buttons and not shake the tree*. Personally, I think "jumped into the river, what did I see/black clad angels swam with me" to be a really silly lyric when read cold off paper, basically sixth-form poetry nonsense, although I appreciate that the person who once wrote "These are the brake lights bruising the dark, making impressionistic arcs in time with your cigarette" might not see this.

*'Agadoo' - Black Lace.

ayo, you're a huge piece of shit for bringing a lyric i wrote into this

a huge piece of shit

please get your dumb ass banned and join your intellectual equals on the steve hoffman boards

Well, we are talking about the topic of lyrics here, and you did ask me to expand. What better way of understanding what a person sees as a yardstick for a great lyric than an example of what they've created themselves? By the way, being a critic and being unable to take it quite as well as you give it is not a good look.

what the fuck is wrong with you

that wasn't criticism, you've never written something that qualifies as "criticism" in your entire fucking life, that was a jibe at something i wrote

FUCK OFF TURRICAN

However you perceive it, the same thing applies.

(x-post)

If you feel that you’ve been misunderstood during this one particular incident, you are failing to remember the last trillion times you’ve been a fucking prick. You don’t get the benefit of the doubt anymore because everyone saw through your disingenuous bullshit the 10th time you puked it out

Only one way to get this pestilent off the board.

In retrospect, evangelizing Pablo Honey as a misunderstood masterpiece album probably should have been seen as an attempt to goad the mods into banning him

ending your thread with a protracted and unpleasant blow out is a bit on the nose, Turrican

LOL

Putting aside the fact that I could wax lyrical about how interloping guitars evoke a miasma of anguish like a piece of unwelcome correspondence puncturing the false comfort of the ante meridiam or how a lone brass line swells and splinters into chords like light from a sunrise bursting through a prism placed just beyond a crack in the curtains or how hi-hats flicker across the stereo field like a canine tongue on its own testicles, but I very much choose not to, would you guys like to put forward some examples of legitimately great lyrics you think that Yorke wrote?

first of all, i don't take requests from thom-yorke-didn't-write-his-own-lyrics truthers

In retrospect, evangelizing Pablo Honey as a misunderstood masterpiece album probably should have been seen as an attempt to goad the mods into banning him

― Arugula Raccoon (DJP), Thursday, June 6, 2019 6:09 PM (eight minutes ago) Bookmark Flag Post Permalink

Who was evangelizing this album as a misunderstood masterpiece? Nobody was saying that, least of all me. I do think it's better than its reputation, though, and I felt we'd reached a point in time where it was worth discussing.

Putting aside the fact that I could wax lyrical about how interloping guitars evoke a miasma of anguish like a piece of unwelcome correspondence puncturing the false comfort of the ante meridiam or how a lone brass line swells and splinters into chords like light from a sunrise bursting through a prism placed just beyond a crack in the curtains or how hi-hats flicker across the stereo field like a canine tongue on its own testicles, but I very much choose not to, would you guys like to put forward some examples of legitimately great lyrics you think that Yorke wrote?

― Le Baton Rose (Turrican), Thursday, June 6, 2019 11:17 AM (four minutes ago) Bookmark Flag Post Permalink

aiiight i'm out, enjoy your own personal music message board turrican

pablo honey is better than its reputation. now please be like pablo honey.

it's not terrible. it should probably stop at 3:40

― Cecil replies to your e-mails (Sufjan Grafton), Thursday, June 6, 2019 5:11 PM (one hour ago) Bookmark Flag Post Permalink

the way it drags on and kinda fades out also doesn't read as a 'blow out'

― Cecil replies to your e-mails (Sufjan Grafton), Thursday, June 6, 2019 5:14 PM (one hour ago) Bookmark Flag Post Permalink

Really? I'm not sure I couldn't imagine it any shorter, it would just feel wrong to me. The band themselves haven't really felt the need to chop any bits of it or rearrange it in a radically different way, so I'm assuming they feel the ending appropriate. I agree that the lengthy ending doesn't read as a 'blow out', but whoever said the title was a description of the contents?

i suppose it could be a reference to turning everything to stone. it's just not a very interesting bit for me. it's not beautiful or jarring. the particular sound is like something you'd get from turning on every effect in your built-in amplifier effects box. reverb and distortion kind of cancel each other.

as a closer, it also has this "we've given you everything we've got!" feel, which is a bit embarrassing because they just gave us Pablo Honey

would go over better with me as a set closer today, for sure

re: thom's lyrics - i think most lyrics suffer when taken out of their musical context. so i doubt i can grab an ok computer lyric that will wow you in isolation the same way i doubt i could serve you sesame seeds with a glass of sherry vinegar for lunch and wow you. ok computer on, thom's lyrics serve the songs well, and nothing is jarringly bad. you could take the sherry vinegar and sesame seeds and make something fantastic with them. some of these pablo honey lyrics are real turds, and you cannot dress a salad with a turd.

it is lunch time here

I'll admit that when Yorke sings "I'm playing with myself" on 'Thinking About You' it stands out in a glaringly unnecessary way, like a juggalo's fashion sense at a funeral, but I can't think of any other lyrical moments like that which interrupt the listening experience for me. I find the lyrics on this album, on the whole, just as easy to ignore as any other Radiohead album, and upon closer listen they mostly don't strike me as being any better or worse than Yorke's usual standard.

As lyricist:

Bernard Sumner >>>>>>>>> Thom Yorke

but where does Mellencamp fall in there?

fwiw, Genius and others (and my memory) have the Ripcord lyric as "that you don't understand". Where does Google pull lyrics from? That's the only place I'm seeing "she"

Bernard Sumner >>>>>>>>> everyone, this is settled ILM law.

Automatic thread bump. This poll is closing tomorrow.

i almost didn't read this thread because radiohead but then i heard there was a flagworthy post and boy howdy

Yeah I haven't been following this thread but...I kinda agree with Turrican about the lyrics?

Thom's shallows have been my major obstacle in enjoying this band, although it's usually not a big deal because the music (and Jonny's melodic touch) is lyrical enough that the words are just icing. But generally I have a hard time with fragmentary post-Stipe rock lyrics unless I can find humor or pathos or a writerly sense of craft that elevates them above refrigerator magnet poetry. It usually sounds good enough and suits the music but I often get the feeling that he's just stringing phrases together hoping that a subject will appear

He might have a point about Radiohead lyrics but throwing in a jab at Brad's own writing was p uncalled for.

Weirdly, my partner put on this cassette yesterday. I voted for "Anyone Can Play Guitar".

my point was never "thom yorke is a good lyricist," it's that the lyrics are so all over the place on pablo honey that you can't identify a consistent personality behind the lyrics, and that isn't true of later radiohead records even if you think the lyrics are just weird cynical slogans he's stitching together or whatever

lyrics

anyway compare "ripcord" to any post-bends radiohead lyric for an object lesson in what i mean

Apologies all. I should've read the thread more closely before posting. Def didn't intend to feed the troll. Anyway BradNelson I agree 100% that his lyrics post-Pablo have a distinct and consistent personality, fwiw.

Hmm. I'm not sure I completely agree.

1. I agree that Yorke got better as a lyricist, but then I said as much above.
2. Even with that in mind, the lyrics on Pablo Honey are recongnisable as being written by Yorke as any of his lyrics are. He's certainly got a style, which has been there from the very beginning, it has just evolved as you would expect from someone who has been doing it over the course of several releases.
3. Brad's point may have never been that "Thom Yorke is a good lyricist", but he blatantly agreed with someone on that point above - it's there in black and white, scroll up and you'll see it.
4. People on here have been quoting/ripping apart/critiquing/whatever other people's lyrics since these forums began. Apparently this isn't out of order unless the lyrics in question were written by a pal or a music critic.
5. I am absolutely, categorically not a troll.

4. Mocking lyrics written by the person they happen to be debating with on ILM? I think you came up with a first there.

Yeah, you’re a fucking asshole. Assholes do what you did. Fucking assholes stick around and make disingenuous “no what about this, what about that, wah” comments instead of just owning what they obviously did

Anyway, ended up voting for 'I Can't' in the end - a few people have praised various songs from this album throughout the thread, but not that one.

Why don’t you apologize, douche

I've already gone into great detail of why I love that particular track, and I'd love to hear what the band these days would make of it in a live situation. The bit where it comes thundering back in for the ending section, I could imagine that absolutely soaring live if they chose to do it now.

Plus, going through the thread, it seems that although 'Creep' - somewhat boringly - will top the poll, so many people have mentioned so many other favourites from this record that it makes the stock stance of this record being "'Creep' with filler" out to be, well, nonsense actually.

(x-post)

Turrican is pretty much my least favorite poster and I like pretty much everyone. He doesn't actually want to talk about music with anyone, just bludgeon with his opinion. Reminds me of a less polite Geir.