Red Dead Redemption

is this ever coming out on PC :(

probably

gta 5 had a 18 month lag from console to pc for what thats worth as precedent

RDR2 coming to PC, nov/dec <3

Yeah I might finally get to play this

do not get this for PC

Why not

hey being a cowboy isn’t about asking questions like that, it’s about following orders

or maybe the opposite, i dunno i never finished the game

yeah heard the PC release was all hosed up.

i never finished it either. it's a stunningly gorgeous game, but man does it go on forever. i'd guess i probably have only ~5 hours left but it could be 25.

half of people couldn't even get the game to launch, many others (including me) had stutters and crashes that were seemingly unrelated to hardware capacity- like even those with top of the line machines had them. unplayable. i guess this is the curse of easy patching, not super surprising but just a horribly done port

Ah well that answers that then

the game itself is gorgeous but the plot just repeats itself. 'we need one last heist to stop this life of crime for good' (something goes horribly wrong) 'we need one last heist to stop this life of crime for good' (something goes horribly wrong) 'we need one last heist to stop this life of crime for good' (something goes horribly wrong)

that sounds like The Point even if its not well executed

Picked this up. It’s fun

so i basically have no idea what you're supposed to do in online, what the point is. the different challenges and icons/etc are basically just like game lobbies distributed around the map? free roam was really quiet, i know there are missions and other players join for parts of them, but other than that it just seems completely empty and there is no point in doing anything. seems like wasted potential

I've been playing a lot of this lately. If you can manage to do just one daily challenge per day (which can be as simple as (go to x place)), you build up a multiplier that makes it a lot easier to get the gold you need to do stuff.

You want to focus on the daily challenges and the roles. Doing those tasks regularly sort of teaches you to play the game the way they want you play it.

If I feel like I'm in a spot where I'm wasting my time in a remote location, I load up the quick menu and launch into a multiplayer story mission or pvp, which both generally pay out well. They can be a little boring but it's a great way to get back on track really quick.

Generally, don't waste your money on anything except for the most important stuff early on.

There isn't a point to it any more than there's a point to playing Animal Crossing. You have to enjoy being in the space and the expanse of it, I think.

It's the redheaded stepchild compared to gtao, no arguing with that.

i agree about the wasted potential remark, though, for both RDR and GTA Online. there's a way to have fun with it, but it seems so limited and...strange. just a very strange vibe in both of those online places, it's hard to explain

they both have the otherworldly feeling of an airport. only in this airport, every once in a while someone will just drive by and murder you as soon as you respawn

Doing those tasks regularly sort of teaches you to play the game the way they want you play it.

this was something i needed to learn during the campaign. it really got more enjoyable once i got used to the relaxed pace, got very immersive. better the slower you play it. thanks for the tip! i don't doubt there is something there, just thought a cowboy MMO would be amazing but it just wasn't what i expected

Also, typing "rdr2 (name of thing)" into youtube is your friend.

Thanks to my shitty internet and the game's hilarious size it took me a full week to download it from Xbox Game Pass.

so far i have to say i am appreciating that the economy makes sense now even if it's gamified to take advantage of 'whales'. like in the campaign money becomes irrelevant early on and the shootouts are so easy that tonics/food etc are basically meaningless which makes the RPG elements half baked

and the honor system is far less opaque

Suddenly clicked with me that I might like this game. It's down to $30 in the PS4 store. Seems like a good price for a 100GB monster. Think it will get much cheaper any time soon?

I should've made more of an effort with this as I'm sure it's great but it starts off so slow. Just felt like endless trudging through the snow.

yeah I liked the RDR1 but I got kinda bored with 2 halfway through it

the snow bits don't last long, game gets good.

My very casual survey of takes makes it seem like people generally like the first 3/5 of it but then get bored in the redundant endgame. I haven't played The Witcher yet, either, but that's another one where I hear people lose interest in the game, as such, even though they enjoy the world it offers for exploration.

I have started RDR2 twice but never got out of the snow. I found the controls quite arbitrary and floaty. Clearly got to get used to this, but it seemed to be 'Press square to draw your gun; press R2 to stand in a particular stance; press triangle to fire; press L1 to put the gun away' - I couldn't really work out how I was supposed to get used to this and it was reminiscent of other games like Last Of Us where you seem to just be playing a story and hitting buttons at the right times. I'm sure once I'm out the prelude it'll make more sense though.

i loved RDR and only made it a few missions into RDR2 before stagnating. a lot of that is me (i don't have time or concentration for big complicated games anymore, i have discovered the switch is the perfect console for me), but yeah the controls seemed chunky and confusing. he moves so slowly, even when "running," it's like moving in molasses.

i did love the witcher though.

I'm sure once I'm out the prelude it'll make more sense though.

definitely. the game hits a stride once you actually hit the open world and are free to go wander off on your horse and explore, shoot innocent birds all day, accidentally bump into drunk people and start a fight, etc.

There were elements of "press button now" to "The Last of Us," but mostly during cut scenes or ... QTEs? Is that the jargon? Anyway much of "Last of Us" was not like that, it was strategy and stealth and aiming and exploring. But I also like the idea of playing a story.

I played about a hundred hours of RDR2 Online but didn't finish the second half of the main story.

I really didn't want to fish or hunt or do other side mission stuff with Arthur Morgan, a dude is a precarious situation and actively being chased by his enemies. It just never made sense to me that he'd be like, welp, time to get that hunting achievement! John Marston felt more like a guy with time to kill.

-in

but guys there wuz a secret serial killer too!

'Press square to draw your gun; press R2 to stand in a particular stance; press triangle to fire; press L1 to put the gun away'

srsly tho this is a very accurate description of what I hated about this game

(but it is great)

(for about two thirds of the time)

there's a lot to be said for games that have an intuitive control system. obvs you get used to things, but I'm surprised at how different so many games of a similar flavour seem to choose entirely different buttons for jumping or dashing.
I think Death Stranding was very good at this, especially the top buttons working as bag straps, which really gave the impression of balancing on rough terrain. a stroke of genius to include this, and definitely a madcap decision that turned out to work

its absolutely worth 30 bucks

Definitely seems close to its lowest price so far. But if I'm being honest I'd be buying it just to buy it, since it's so far back in my queue that I have no idea when I'd get to it and even if I did, it's size is too unwieldy to even download and have on hand.

About 5 hours in. It’s good! I like getting on my horse and galloping around. Feels very slow / unresponsive somehow though, like GTA v.

I've never played GTA, but I have this one loosely slotted for, like, February.

started RDR2 properly last night! On the bit where you attempt to rob the train but I kinda died. Still getting used to the rather arbitrary controls and slightly slow/floaty walking. Also there are points where it seems to want me to read on-screen instructions, concentrate on story dialogue AND steer around rocky mountain paths all at the same time. My head isn't built for such things.

Re: GTA - after the Cyberpunk debacle, I'm kind of keen to play one of these as a placebo. Which is best for PS4?

5

i loved red dead redemption but didn't make it far into RDR2, and a big part of it was the clunky controls

i'm sure i'll; get used to them, but there's a lot to remember. I don't know why, for example, you press a different button to run faster on a horse than you do on foot. selecting items is also really complicated. and there are lots of instances where you have to long-hold buttons when really pressing once would have done fine. arthur walks extremely slowly too, and doesn't always respond well to being gee'd-up

it was mostly the slow walking that got on my nerves. and he handles like a station wagon. but i should probably go back to it and give it another shot.