Top games of 2018: Twelfth Coint & Plick RESULTS

i didn't have a ps4 in 2017 alas

#16. Florence — 29 Points — 2 Votes — 0.1 First Place Votes
https://i.imgur.com/15UjBx3.png

i know nothing abt this one so i hope someone comes to tell us about it!!

it's cute! it's a visual novel sorta about a relationship and breakup that is genuinely affecting. iirc either no or barely any words so it's all told visually/musically and thru little puzzles.

Oh, I played that! It was pre-released for download on Valentine's day iirc. It was very short, but aesthetically promising.

I'm enjoying this countdown btw. I only really play games on my phone (and board games) these days, but I should really put in a vote next year. Is there a minimum for voting?

no minimum for voting! you get 100 points to allocate and up to 30 for any individual game. if you vote for one game you can give it 30 points and be done!

#14. Pillars of Eternity II: Deadfire — 30 Points — 1 Vote — 1 First Place Vote
https://i.imgur.com/20tWEa9.png

(the tie for #14 is the last tie in the rollout!)

there's an example of such voting

#14. Warhammer 40,000 Kill Team — 30 Points — 1 Vote — 1 First Place Vote
https://i.imgur.com/oHGv2J0.png

our first ever board game! welcome to the rollout you weird dice-rolling luddites, WE LOVE YOU HERE

i couldn't finish the first pillars of eternity tho i did enjoy what i played. there's just so much text and most of it isn't great. they should borrow a page from alexis kennedy on how to write memorable scenes and dialogues without just drowning the reader in words.

oh that reminds me if i had played it in time i would've voted for Root - fantastic asymmetrical game w/ a woodland creatures theme for those of u who are really interested in the COIN games but find the topics too depressing.

if Gandhi comes out next year tho i'll prob vote for it if i can play it in time!

root is neat ive only played it once though and was the cats who seem like they play the most basic game. the birds mechanic looked really clever

#13. NES Switch Online — 30 Points — 2 Votes — 0.3 First Place Votes
https://i.imgur.com/4omDSvU.png
One Disappointment of 2019 vote

i couldn't finish the first pillars of eternity tho i did enjoy what i played. there's just so much text and most of it isn't great. they should borrow a page from alexis kennedy on how to write memorable scenes and dialogues without just drowning the reader in words.

The second instalment tries to address some of these issues, not always successfully, but isometric-style CRPGs are my nostalgic opium of choice so I go easy on the writing (which is still upper-tier shlock compared to the usual fare).

hmm i should put those "disappointment votes" above the images instead of below, easy to lose them

donut county had one disappointment vote, and NES switch had one.

i'll tell you what had more than one, though

#12. Red Dead Redemption 2 — 32 Points — 4 Votes
DISAPPOINTMENT WINNER: Five Disappointment of 2019 votes
https://i.imgur.com/MBwILLj.png

I voted for Florence, a love story told via WarioWare-esque game mechanics. A cool little experience.

Take THAT, game I never intend to play!

wow kinda shocked how low it came out

it's a game with a lot of problems but the stuff that's good about it i think mostly ends up being the takeaway: it's a gorgeous cowboy simulator

no way, top 10 is gonna be all indies this year those are what had ~mindshare~

indie hit rdr2

- Mordy, Tuesday, April 16, 2019 3:39 PM (twenty minutes ago) Bookmark Flag Post Permalink

i meant to post that immediately after posting the result lol

the wrinkle detail on the horse testicles got downgraded from the prerelease trailer footage and there was really no saving it from gamer dismissal after that

looking forward to posting some version of "ultimately tho too iterative and too long and bloated but somehow still made my list" later on in the poll

― Mordy, Tuesday, April 16, 2019 5:39 PM (yesterday)

and now for 11 games that ilx likes more than cowboy game 2

#11. Minit — 33 Points — 3 Votes
https://i.imgur.com/HtpaGFK.png

this game managed to piss me off in the like one hour it takes to finish though i don't remember why now

i think i was just disappointed that it had changing respawn points which is the least clever way to lock in progress with the game's mechanic

#10. Super Smash Bros Ultimate — 37 Points — 3 Votes
https://i.imgur.com/fnRix6s.png

this will become a good game in roughly 6 hours when they add persona music to it

#9. God of War — 46 Points — 4 Votes — 0.33 First Place Votes
One Disappointment of 2019 Vote
https://i.imgur.com/mK2kG3x.png

Game of Overrated! (I still voted for it.)

does c&p permit the power move of voting for a game in the main poll and also most overrated?

err biggest disappointment i mean

Yes, because I was the DISAPPOINT vote.

#8. Spider-Man — 50 Points — 4 Votes — 0.6 First Place Votes
https://i.imgur.com/jju3rao.png

xp i've seen people rate a game GOTY and disappointment of the year!

i heard this was the game that really made you feel like spider-man

it stars spiderman

who's that

i bet that's a fun game i'd like to pay it (when it costs $5)

i dare say it's worth more than $5! its great!!

#7. Yoku's Island Express — 52 Points — 5 Votes — 0.1 First Place Votes
https://i.imgur.com/rQPC8lq.png

i picked up this one because i saw how high it ranked and played it for a bit. i felt a little lost fairly soon, and kinda fell off and started playing one of the other many little games i have on my switch. i guess i will go back to it but i don't see what the hype is all about yet! good idea tho

it's only 2 hours or so - so it doesn't wear out its welcome.

it's longer than that maybe 5 hours if you just play to the credits

#6. Tetris Effect — 53 Points — 3 Votes — 0.5 First Place Votes
https://i.imgur.com/r6Csp2b.png