HBO's adaptation of Game of Thrones - Thread 2. There are a lot of nerds.

LOL yeah I missed that ref was to Sheehan as well, fuck if I'dve twigged who "eddie" was tbf

My leaderboard of favourite performances (with 'how well the character was written' as a factor')

Main cast

Top tier

Tywin
Olenna (not main but too good not to rank)
Catelyn
Ned
Hound
Margaery, oddly enough, I feel like her part was really hard to do as well as she did
Robert

Excellent

Bronn
Jorah
Tyrion
Arya
Cersei
Jaime
Varys
Tommen (best of the kids imo)

Good

Sansa
Davos
Robb
Gendry
Roose
Shae

Whatever

Grey Worm
Ygritte
Tormund
Ramsay
Jon Snow
Theon
Joffrey

No Thank You

Missandei
Bran
Talisa
Samwell (though the actor is good)
Brienne
Littlefinger
High Sparrow
Jaqen
Daenerys

Raspberries!

Ellaria Sand
Stannis
Melisandre
Gilly

Supp. cast

Hon. mention: Pycelle, Hodor, Osha (weirdly? odd choice of performance but she committed to it and I liked it), Luwin, Aemon

No mention: Lancel, Alliser, Loras, Beric, Pod, Yara, Qyburn, Meera, Jojen,

Dishonorable mention: Euron

i actually kinda liked dillane as stannis. he was so dour that it was funny.

Every time I think of anything related to Stannis/Shireen/Melisandre I get a headache, I mean, Euron is the worst but at least he's quotable. I cannot remember a single word that Stannis uttered and am happy about that

I gotta give to Joffrey one of my favourite laughs in the series. "I hear that Stannis never smiles." *pulls out his sword about four inches* "I'll give him a red smile. From ear to ear."

My favorite voices on the show: Roose Bolton, Beric Dondarrion.

I must be the only person who liked Littlefinger!

Hey, wither Podrick?

xp jorah mormont has my favorite voice on the show

and yet here i stand

Couldn’t care less about Daenerys but something about Jorah confessing his undying love and devotion toward her makes me emotional

Jorah was intriguing in the first season but has become probably the most tediously one-note character in the whole show, even if the actor is good. There are characters like Tyrion or Bronn or the Hound where you feel yourself internally cheering whenever they appear on screen, and he's at the other end of the spectrum for me, just an enthusiasm drain. (See also Jaqen, Missandei & Grey Worm, frankly Theon at this point).

I just can’t forgive Bronn for his crimes against the pop charts in the 1990s, or Littlefinger for that wandering accent. Robert Barathian has the best past life, having been a Full Monty stripper.

Considering the limitations coming from the writing, I feel most of the actors in the main roles have given performances ranging from decent enough to excellent, except for Harington, Clarke and the dude playing Euron (Pilou Asbæk). I've no problem believing Asbæk is a good actor, but his performance belons to Pirates of Caribbean, not this series. (Though I guess part of the blame for that goes to the showrunners as well, as I can't imagine he chose this approach to the role all by himself.) And Harington and Clarke are just dull and wooden, which is particularly unfortunate given that Jon and Daenerys become the two biggest characters by now. With Harington it doesn't of course help that Jon Snow is a dull character begin with, being the only classic fantasy hero in a show that otherwise tries to avoid that stereotype.

Can't forget Asbæk in the Danish historical drama '1864' where he plays a landowner who has sex with a cow.

https://news.avclub.com/rob-mcelhenney-martin-starr-were-brutally-murdered-in-1834077456

Martin Starr and Rob McElhenney played two of the random House Greyjoy jamokes who got killed during Yara's rescue.

https://i.kinja-img.com/gawker-media/image/upload/s--h_yAtypl--/c_scale,f_auto,fl_progressive,q_80,w_800/ffsy5sg7gjsq6qtb5mwq.jpg

I cannot remember a single word that Stannis uttered and am happy about that

RIP Ted Leo the grammar pedant

He's supposed to be a drab middle management type who has somehow become a king, which Dillane sells well.

I just can’t forgive Bronn for his crimes against the pop charts in the 1990s, or Littlefinger for that wandering accent

I never had a problem with that. Littlefinger’s a slippery, shifty guy. Why should his accent be any different?

It'd have been interesting to see Charles Dance reading for Stannis and vice versa I think

I think the scene where Tywin lectures Jaime while skinning the deer is one of my favourite scenes in television tbh!

Hey, wither Podrick?

I didn't think anything of him. He has one expression on his face the entire series. The only interesting thing about him/his character is the whole "he's good at fucking" note

I forgot to list Ros but obv she was amazing, love the post-coital scene with her and Pycelle

lol @ BBQ Becky of Winterfell

this episode was fan service + daddy issues. Kinda feel like the characters that don't gaf about their dads or have moved past that are the best adjusted

oh wait, also conflating next episode's preview in there -- looks like we get another daddy issue scene at least

Also Sansa was the best thing about this episode, followed by the Grey Worm/Missandei glance when riding past the assembled white ppl

"I must be the only person who liked Littlefinger!"

I really liked it when he got murdered, does that count?

Sansa rules.

I was rooting for Littlefinger :( More in the books than on the show, though

this episode was fan service

Awful fan service (for awful fans) as hardly anything of note happened and the big bad was absent once again. Weren't there five (maybe longer) episodes initially planned for s8? Felt like they padded the first one out into two.

I read an astonishing theory about how the show could pan out, on /r/asoiaf yesterday.

I can link to it here if anyones interested but its so otm it may feel spoilery.

please link!

Yes pls

This one?

https://www.reddit.com/r/asoiaf/comments/bdwuse/spoilers_extended_my_night_king_is_not_stupid/

Yep thats the one! It blew my mind.

omg i want to watch that happen

Esp Cercei. "Valonqars hands around her pale throat" eh.

oh shit

if that theory holds, and with valonqar meaning "little brother", i have two questions -- just whose little brother is it, and how long does one have to be dead before the night king can no longer raise you.

i like that theory

Kind of lol that we’re making it through the entirety of GoT with two threads when we had like 80 Lost threads

one going theory is jamie killing her but its arya wearing jaimes face, i dunno about that tho

I hope there isn't too much faceless-man shit in this season. that was always my least favorite bit of magical lore in the show

does Euron count as a little brother ...

Unless of course in the final episode Arya takes off her face and reveals she's been Sean Bean all along xp

just whose little brother is it, and how long does one have to be dead before the night king can no longer raise you.

― omar little, 18. april 2019 02:22 (six hours ago) Bookmark Flag Post Permalink

Tommen

read that as
MY night king is not stupid

Nothing but respect for My Night King

my night king brings all the boys to the yard etc

The valonqar part of the witch's prophesy didn't actually appear in the series, only in the books. In the series she just prophesied the deaths of Cersei's children, not her death. So it'd be a bit weird if the writers would bring that up all of sudden, several seasons after the prophesy scene happened. "Guess what, the witch prophesied other things too, but we cut those out back then..."

https://www.theverge.com/2019/4/17/18412156/george-lucas-game-of-thrones-got-season-8-hbo-final-behind-the-scenes-jon-snow-daenerys-targeryen

According to a 17-minute behind-the-scenes video that HBO released on YouTube, Lucas was hanging out on the Game of Thrones set while director David Nutter was directing the season 8 premiere. The former Star Wars director was sitting by Nutter’s side while they were filming a scene with Jon Snow (Kit Harington) and Daenerys Targaryen (Emilia Clarke). Nutter asked Lucas to speak to Harington and Clarke about their performances.

So the scene we've been unfavorably comparing to an awkward couple hanging out in a secluded area in a Star Wars movie.. might have had some direction from George Lucas?

This is amazingly funny