salon vs. slate vs. atlantic

Wow these three sites have been ILX’s collective punching bag. This thread is just seven years worth of bitching. Why is it every time a site gets redesigned everyone hates it?

i wouldn't have expected a white knight for salon, slate and the atlantic to appear at this hour and for that white knight to be mr. snrub

xp every redesign is a betrayal

it's sad, it was an american century

https://pbs.twimg.com/media/D30q0pvXkAIxSPx.jpg:small

my fuckin dentist

rat bastard

The Atlantic is cutting 68 staffers - 17% of the total. Imagine having a staff of 400 and not being able to produce anything better than The Atlantic.

The shrinking of media jobs is depressing but if it must happen...

That's too bad. I don't usually think much of the Atlantic but they've been rocking their pandemic coverage imo.

i guess laurene powell jobs ran out of money : /

the greatest #slatepitch of all: the dark side of coloring books

https://slate.com/culture/2020/08/coloring-books-history-coronavirus.html

Basically, the center-right is terrified of the far-left and the center-left is terrified of the far right, and that is causing both to be less willing to criticize the fringe that is closest to them, which many earnestly see as obviously the lesser threat.

— Conor Friedersdorf (@conor64) September 6, 2020

Brain genius stuff

Seems like a weakness for a political journalist.

Maybe! I certainly worry about far right terrorists more. But I don't trust my ability to know who is the bigger threat and assiduously oppose both

— Conor Friedersdorf (@conor64) September 6, 2020

what if there were one stop shop for greenwald, megan mcardle and slate cultural criticism. wouldn't that be your homepage too?

for me to poop on

Atlantic on Atlantic crime

Saying nothing at all is an option that is permanently available to you, and that I urge you to more frequently consider. The same goes for tagging me into your thoughts.

— Ed Yong (@edyong209) February 24, 2022

The Atlantic has run the "you just can't say ANYTHING these days" essay again. This time, it's credited to Sarah Hepola. What's infuriating about this essay, no matter whose byline it carries this week, is that it pretends there are "forbidden" opinions that cry out to be debated, but...never tells you what they are. Because they're "forbidden," you see. I would love it if just one of these pieces offered a list of the topics you "can't write about." But they never do. "I’d grown terrified of being banished for views I considered reasonable, or at least worth discussing" — LIKE WHAT? COME ON, GIVE US JUST ONE. I DARE YOU. She gets SO close, too: "suddenly we were living in a time when so much that was once considered fair game for discussion (education, biological differences, the benefits of policing) had become dangerous." Love that second one, tucked carefully into that parenthetical... I'm sure someone at the Atlantic would be happy to give Hepola Charles Murray's email address; they could talk "biological differences" all day long and into the night. Oh, but she wouldn't be able to "discuss" it with readers of the Atlantic! The loss to our culture is incalculable, truly.

Why do artists and designers keep doing this? And why don't editors tell them, "I see what you did there, ha ha. Now put together the real version by deadline."

https://pbs.twimg.com/media/FO72AjvXIAUKEsu.jpg

Stupid, but funny.

Fact Check-Fabricated image purports to show racist headline published by The Atlantic on Judge Clarence Thomas
By Reuters Fact Check

A digitally altered image circulating online purports to show a racist headline published by The Atlantic about Supreme Court Justice Clarence Thomas following the Court’s reversal of Roe v. Wade. No such headline was published by the outlet, and the image is digitally altered.

The Atlantic logo is viewable at the top of the image, while the purported headline reads: “It’s Not Racist To Call Judge Clarence Thomas The N Word.”

A user who shared the image on Twitter said: “The “tolerant” Left is only tolerant of those who agree with them. Step out of line and the true nature of the Left presents itself”.

One iteration of the image gathered more than 1,000 likes at the time of writing.

...

A spokesperson for The Atlantic told Reuters no such headline was published by the outlet.

“This is a fabricated article, and we are reporting it as fake and a trademark infringement,” the spokesperson told Reuters.

This article is completely insane. It's like something out of National Review. I half expect the author to be on Tucker Carlson by the end of the week.

https://pbs.twimg.com/media/FcaV2e6XoAE5le0?format=jpg&name=large

They should have gone with Vox. The Atlantic is home to like 9,000,000 alarmist essays about campus cancel culture

https://slate.com/culture/2022/12/white-lotus-finale-hbo-sex-scene-nudity.html