Mulholland Drive - theories please.

thats weird

That film is weird and nobody last century would have convinced their editors to let them analyze it.

what?

those scenes are key

I see what you did there.

Chaki I was half kidding about the glory days. All the same no mainstream print media would ever devote so much space to a Lynch dissection.

you've obviously never read Cinemafantastique!

we need to watch this every now and then

Ya gotta love the man.

is Cinemafantastique still around?

i met lynch once, really sweet guy, he was very patient with my drunken fanboy friend

you always talk in the sec person about yrslf? ;-)

He came into my office at my last job. Evidently, he's "really into cows" at the moment.

still never seen this movie, because it is not part of the Friday the 13th series

fair enough.

It will be when Freddy vs. Betty comes out

that youtube clip is great

I guess all the girl-girl kissy scenes are completely removed from bowdlerized broadcast cuts?

I still can't look/think about that homeless Trent Reznor guy without a ton of anxiety.

likewise. As one reviewer said, it gets in your head and STAYS THERE. Although now I'll never look at Trent Reznor the same way again.

I had a DVD of the original TV pilot version - it was ok, didn't have the atmosphere of the movie at all. Maybe would have worked for Twin Peaks fans, though.

this movie is way overrated, i was so disappointed when i finally saw it. "blue velvet" is light-years better.

no

? Blue Velvet is way clumsier

http://www.indiewire.com/biz/lynchcow1.jpg

http://www.davidlynch.de/lynchcow2.jpg

Blue Velvet is not light years better. Why is it light years better?

adheres to conventional thriller narrative structure...? (just guessing)

i mean "blue velvet" is driven by a strong story and has countless indelible moments and still leaves me feeling like i've witnessed something astonishing and complex. MD just leaves me feeling like i've seen a long string of marginally related scenes that don't add up to anything. what exactly do you guys get out of it?

well, the lights go down, and you go into this WORLD...

More multi-plot TV pilots should be given "it was all a dream" endings and released in theatres!

could any other director get away with that kind of ending? Rob Reiner didn't.

MD just leaves me feeling like i've seen a long string of marginally related scenes that don't add up to anything.

Huh? Really? It seems pretty straightforward, honestly.

Blue Velvet has never struck me as particularly complex - its a "coming of age"-type story about a young guy discovering the dark underbelly of America, etc. It has a clear beginning, middle, and end; a villain; a classic "femme fatale", etc. "Mulholland Drive" is so much more dense and intricate - involving the mutability of identity, the Hollywood "dream" (of making it big, of being in a movie, of being someone you're not); its about creative control, obsession, and denial; the nature of recorded media... so many things in there.

Including thirty minutes of "and you were there, and you were there, and you were there..."

Other pilot producers must be SO fucking jealous of this movie.

Lynch has always had a thing for the Wizard of Oz

Huh? Really? It seems pretty straightforward, honestly.

Hmm...Do you have theories about Gravity's Rainbow?

gravity's rainbow is about transcendence

You seem far more convinced about the 'dream' ending than anyone I know, Anthony.

It's admittedly not as fun as the other theories, even though it makes perfect sense and there's nothing in the film that really contradicts it. You might wonder why her dream has subplots, but that's because Lynch didn't bother to change anything about the pilot to fit the ending he was paid to tack onto it.

Hmm...Do you have theories about Gravity's Rainbow?

It's all Octopus Grigori's fantasy of human life.

Ending is more Return To Oz than Wizard Of Oz, though.

The dream theory is otm. But it doesn't just end with "it was all a dream lol!" The harsh reality gives the dream a lot of weight.

i dunno the tiny tourists were pretty lol in my row

tourists = her parents irl

monster/homeless guy = her high school gym teacher

cowboy walking across the restaurant = god

This was a better abstract look at the agony of being Naomi Watts than <i>Ring: Two</i>, I'll admit.

billy ray cyrus = toto

that look at her breasteses sure wasn't abstract!

the titty scene was amazing, I've never claimed otherwise