overqualified backing vocalists

honestly, one of the songs I thought of was a weird example -- "Debris," by the Faces. No guest vocals, Rod and Ronnie are permanent members of the band, but Ronnie sings lead and Rod's backing vocals on the chorus are sublime.

U2's "Love Rescue Me" featured a pretty well-buried Bob Dylan

Neil Tennant and Neil Hannon both on Robbie Williams' 'No Regrets'

lol "the passenger" backing vox always sounded so loutish and unschooled to me, thought it was one of the band members. Same with "success".

You’re so vain - Mick Jagger

Neko Case provided background vox on Jakob Dylan's 2010 album Women + Country.

I feel like Case was also a background singer (with a few others) for another artist on a recent TV performance, but don't know what I'm thinking of.

Michael McDonald on Steely Dan's 'Peg' ...

Here's a heavily f'd-with clip (presumably to avoid a DMCA takedown) of Sam Jayne singin' backup and shakin' maracas for Modest Mouse:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aP-W-0h4Zu4

Does Sting on Phil Collins' 'Long Long Way to Go' count?

Neil Young, singing backup on the great Warren Zevon song Splendid Isolation

See also: overqualified rhythm guitar players. Thinking of Steve Lukather on Beat It

Michael McDonald on Steely Dan's 'Peg' ...

― Le Baton Rose (Turrican), Thursday, November 29, 2018 6:46 PM (thirteen minutes ago) Bookmark Flag Post Permalink

And on Christopher Cross' "Ride Like The Wind":
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=b0HzWMqLeiE

there's no such thing as an overqualified backing singer. michael mcdonald is the perfect backup vocalist but also better than anyone he sings backup for. there is no contradiction

love that SCTV clip so much

Robert Plant's Now and Zen has both Kirsty Maccoll and future Curve vocalist Toni Halliday on backing vocals.

Luther Vandross on Richard Marx’s “Keep Coming Back”.

George Michael (and Nik Kershaw apparently) on Elton John’s “Nikita”.

David Bowie is also on Arcade Fire’s Reflektor.

Here’s a few:

https://www.pastemagazine.com/articles/2015/07/9-famous-backup-singers-on-classic-pop-songs.html

And this one is fairly more interesting:

https://www.officialcharts.com/chart-news/unsung-heroes-18-songs-with-secret-superstars-on-backing-vocals__17833/

Several in there that I had no idea existed like Robyn on a Britney song.

Neil Young, on the live version of "Downtown" on Tonight's the Night (though he pretty much takes it over by the end).

Stephen Stills, moaning over the outro on Neil's "Til the Morning Comes".

Barry Gibb (or is it all the Bee Gees?) backing Dionne Warwick on "Heartbreaker". Not sure if "Emotion" counts given how he dominates the chorus.

Don't know about overqualified but I want to include the Jesus & Mary Chain shouting "guilty" on Drama! by Erasure

Debbie Harry guesting as D.H. Lawrence jr on several tracks on the Gun Club's Miami. It was produced by Chris Stein and Jeffrey lee Pierce had been Blondie's fan club head.

Chrissie Hynde (billed as “Mrs. Christine Kerr") on U2's "Pride (In The Name Of Love)"

Of all people, Joe Satriani is credited with backing vocals - vocals - on the first Crowded House record.

！

Pete Townshend sings backup (but doesn't play guitar, for some reason) on the Ramones' cover of "Substitute."

Squeeze's Black Coffee In Bed has both Elvis Costello and Paul Young (No Parlez, not Sad Cafe guy)

EC is all over those squeeze records (the ones he produced, anyway)

I know Eno does a lot of backing vocals on some of the albums he produced too

Maya Angelou on Herbie Mann's The Common Ground

Springsteen has an uncredited cameo on Lou Reed's "Street Hassle," but I think cameos like that are almost a totally different thing. Like, I dunno, Tom Waits popping up in "Tommy the Cat" by Primus or Iggy Pop popping in "New York City" by the Cult.

Back to Phil, "Take Me Home" has both Sting and Gabriel on backing vocals.

EC didn't produce Black Coffee In Bed, Phil Wainman did (it's on Sweets From A Stranger). The only other song he sings on is Tempted (from the album he did produce): "The people keep on crowding, I'm wishing I was well"

I mainly hear Eno in the Once In A Lifetime chorus, same for U2's Lemon

Squeeze's Black Coffee In Bed has both Elvis Costello and Paul Young (No Parlez, not Sad Cafe guy)

Talking of Paul Young and "No Parlez", Dagmar Krause provides backing vocals on his version of "Love Will Tear Us Apart".

Just listening to it now and she actually does a spoken word section - a bit like Nico does on Tiny Tim's first album.

Eno is all over the place on he albums he's produced. That's his thing. But, like, Joe Ely as part of the Spanish call and response in the Clash's "Should I Stay Or Should I Go?", yeah, that's a bit closer to the thread theme.

... talking of unlikely appearances by female German vocalists. (xp)

Certainly Aimee Mann popping up on Rush's "Time Stand Still," that was always pretty random. "Girls," by Dwight Twilley, has Tom Petty on backing vox.

I thought about Mann, but that feels like a real "featured" guest vocal, as you (and I) both dissected upthread

Yeah, it's more a lead part.

(I apparently posted a lot in this thread y'day, and none of my answers were on-point, lol)

Neil Tennant on Boy George's 'The Crying Game' and Dusty Springfield's 'Nothing Has Been Proved'.

Squeeze again, both Difford & Tilbrook not exactly hidden in the mix here
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ArXL7uEQsEg

I'm not sure Tennant counts in those contexts. PSBs produced "The Crying Game" and "Nothing Has Been Proved."

Fair point. So onto...

Liam Gallagher on Echo & The Bunnymen's 'Nothing Lasts Forever'.

a few from the grandest listening thread of them all:

Billy Joel, "My Life" - Peter Cetera and Donnie Dacus of Chicago
Billy Joel, "Everybody Has A Dream" - Phoebe Snow
Billy Joel, "Storm Front" - Richard Marx
Billy Joel, "All About Soul" - Color Me Badd, and Frank Simms aka the Kool-Aid Man
Cyndi Lauper, "Maybe He'll Know" - Billy Joel
Mick Jones, "Just Wanna Hold" - Billy Joel

and the alt-rock edition:

Dave Matthews Band, "Don't Drink the Water" - Alanis Morrissette
The Wallflowers, "Sixth Avenue Heartache" - Adam Duritz
The Urge, "Jump Right In" - Nick Hexum

Steely Dan, "FM" - Frey, Henley and Schmitt of the Eagles

can't believe i misspelled "morissette," shame on me

Can't believe nobody has mentioned Stevie and Lindsey on Bob Welch's "Sentimental Lady." Or David Crosby and Graham Nash on "Doctor My Eyes."

guest harmonies from Carl & Dennis Wilson and Al Jardine
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=41s69oNimZg

Rob Halford on QOTSA's "Feel Good Hit of the Summer".

Elton John, Mark Lanegan, Trent Reznor, Jake Shears and Alex Turner provided backing vox on various "...Like Clockwork" songs too.

the jackson 5 sing background on stevie's you haven't done nothin

the liner notes of the warren zevon s/t is just one overqualified backing vocalist after another

according to the credits on the promo 12-inch to jellybean's "sidewalk talk"...

lead vocals: catherine buchanan
background vocals: madonna, cindy mizelle, audrey wheeler

madonna wrote the song and her vox are quite discernible in the chorus. she had already become a pretty big crossover star by the time it got released on 45 so if you look on discogs you'll see some sleeves for the single that pretty prominently display "written by MADONNA" lol

Prince on so many of his productions for other artists (777-9311, Glamorous Life iirc, etc)

Dumbstruck that Chrissie Hynde sang on U2's "Pride"... I've never heard a female vocal anywhere in that track in my hundreds of listens to it. Guessing she's a part of the oh-oh-ohs at the end?

singers who sang backup on covers of their own songs:

Dobie Gray, on Uncle Kracker's cover of 'Drift Away'
Dolly Parton, on Mindy Smith's cover of 'Jolene'

Pete Townshend sings backup (but doesn't play guitar, for some reason) on the Ramones' cover of "Substitute."

― Montgomery Burns' Jazz (Tarfumes The Escape Goat), Friday, November 30, 2018 10:56 AM (one year ago)

Does this count?

"The Longest Time" is a doo-wop single by Billy Joel. The song was released as a single in 1984 as the fourth single from the 1983 album An Innocent Man. Following the theme of the album in paying tribute to Joel's musical influences, the song is presented in the style of Frankie Lymon and the Teenagers. It reached number 14 on the Billboard Hot 100 and number 1 on Billboard's Adult Contemporary chart. In the United Kingdom the song reached number 25 on the UK Singles Chart.

The song features Joel on lead vocals and all backing vocals. Two musical instruments are present in the song: a bass guitar and a snare drum being played with brushes. When the song is covered by vocal groups, the bass part is typically sung. All other sounds in the song are Joel's vocals, along with percussive sounds such as finger snaps and hand claps. Phil Ramone and Joel had intended to feature a vocal group but Joel recorded each of the parts himself.

I knew Angel Olsen sang backup for Will Oldham for a bit but didn't realize for a long time that she's in the video for the second version of "I See A Darkness"
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4iV4NwSbscg

now in her band she has Heather McEntire of Mount Moriah, who's got a great Dolly Parton-y voice herself
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2J7E5hqjX0o

Hardly proper "backing vocals" given that she sings much more than the billed artist, but: Annie Lennox on the 1984 solo single "Darling Don't Leave Me" by Robert Görl of DAF:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=M95Dws35cKQ

Lindsay Pagano - So Bad (ft. Paul McCartney)

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RQgLrQRaXIY

a literal nobody who was best known for appearing in an AOL commercial in 2001

Pagano was recording the album at the same Los Angeles studio where McCartney was recording Driving Rain when he introduced himself and asked to hear some of her music.

"I played him some, and he was dancing all around the studio," Pagano recalled. "Everyone was freaking out that it was Paul McCartney, and I would be like, 'Oh, I just saw Paul. Whatever.' He just became a regular person. He asked how the album was doing one day, and I said, 'Well, I'm just looking for a really simple acoustic song for the end of the album, just to end it.' And he said, 'Well, I wrote this song called 'So Bad,' which I think would go really good with your voice.' I laid down a rough track, and when I came back to work on it again, I hear this vocal in the back, and it's Paul's vocal. He was singing on it as kind of a surprise. So it became a duet."

that aol commercial song could have been legitimately great if they had just redone the entire song other than the chorus

not sure if this sort of thing counts, but two 90s hiphop tracks immediately came to mind:

inspectah deck on 2pac's 'got my mind made up' and busta rhymes on capone n noriega's 'driver's seat.'

both were cases where the "featured" mc had a guest verse that was later cut and all that remained in the final mix were their adlibbed parts. like i said, kind of a grey area.

Not quite on topic but I was revisiting Lou's "Street Hassle" the other day and was startled I'd forgotten the uncredited cameo verse by the Boss.

Stevie Nicks and Lindsay Buckingham on "Magnet and Steel"

xp Bruce also does the almost inaudible backing vocals on John Prine's "Take a Look at My Heart."

...and that's also Bruce, very audible, on Graham Parker's "Endless Night"

Q-Tip, Slick Rick, and Biz Markie back up Jay-Z on “Girls, Girls, Girls”

A Tom Waits song is the only possible context where Keith Richards would count as an "overqualified" backing vocalist.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UgG4rxq8DhY

David Crosby on "Another Day in Paradise" (phil colins)

James Taylor on "Back in the high life" (steve winwood)

Shannon Hoon on "Dont Cry" (gnr)

Liz Phair on "Work" (jimmy eat world)

Liz Phair on "Soak Up The Sun" by Sheryl Crow.

apparently michele phillips and diane warren harmonize on the chorus of “heaven is a place on earth”

Billy Ocean on Scott Walker’s Track Three

Billy Ocean sings the high harmony for about 90% of the song, to be fair it's practically a duet.