Peter Gabriel's self-titled fourth album POLL

'Wallflower' was the one that got my vote in the end - I just think it's a beautiful song. I've said it before, but I feel you'd have to go right back to 'The Lamia' (from The Lamb Lies Down on Broadway) to find anything as beautiful.

I may be misremembering or confusing it with something, but it rings a bell that the Pet Shop Boys claimed they wanted to use So as a title. Maybe not.

Wallflower ("May you not be deterred") vs. Don't Give Up shows how he grew as a songwriter.

Leaning towards San Jacinto, but gonna listen again just to be sure. I'm the weirdo whose favorite song on Melt is "Lead a Normal Life," so...

'Lead a Normal Life' rules!

All the 'Plays Live' versions are much more limber and enjoyable than the versions on Security - especially Rhythm Of The Heat which is an amazing opener - so for that, I vote Wallflower which didn't make the live album.

This album suffers in the digital age. The vinyl brought out every sampled wrinkle (I used to study those credits fascinated, tracing the triggered, sampled sounds).

"Shock The Monkey" will win - that video just grabbed me by the collar when it came out.

This is truly a bizarre (fantastic) album with a number 1 US hit. Do you suppose it blew kids minds who bought it on the strength of that one song?

I didn't hear this album until after "So", I have a distinct memory of checking the CD out from the local public library. It was definitely a little wtf

"Shock the Monkey" didn't hit #1. It was his first American top forty hit, though, and a central part of early MTV.

I checked the tape out of the public library!

OMG GUYS I DON'T THINK THOSE FAT MEN ARE PLAYING WITH THEIR GARDEN HOSES!!!

Of all the various versions of "I Have The Touch", there's a rare/alternate version (recorded by Peter Walsh of Penthouse & Pavement fame) of that I'm very fond of... and am pretty sure is a wholly different performance (vox/instruments) from the LP version:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=px4KcWq-ACo

I have it on the flip of this lol:
https://www.discogs.com/Peter-Gabriel-Walk-Through-The-Fire/release/1211782

Loved Shock The Monkey as a kid discovering MTV.

My favorite gag ever on South Park is when Stan was talking to the goth kids about how to win Wendy back and they told him to stand under her window playing Peter Gabriel with a boombox Say Anything-style.

Cut to... Stan at her window blaring "Shock the Monkey."

Albert, that mix is on Shaking the Tree, I'm sure.

Also: Gabriel was rather handsome for a while, no?

is he? kinda doughy

well, now

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ju85sA8UTjc

So I can see there's these studio versions of "I Have The Touch":

LP version, 4:36
'85 remix, 3:44 (found on "Shaking The Tree")
Robbie Robertson mix, 4:19 (found on "Hit")
Phenomenon soundtrack version, 5:27 (an extended version of the Robertson mix)

Did I miss anything? I don't see anything that's 5:00 long as stated on that Discogs entry.

Rhythm of the Heat is a strange opener.

But it made a great concert opener on that tour as the band entered drum corps style through the back of the theater.

I saw the tour for this album and "San Jacinto" was so spectacular that I completely forgot about the other songs on here.

Is the Deutsches Album version of "I Have the Touch" an alternate mix? There are a lot of differences between the two albums, but I don't remember if that's one of them.

Albert, that mix is on Shaking the Tree, I'm sure.

― You like queer? I like queer. Still like queer. (Alfred, Lord Sotosyn), Thursday, October 25, 2018 3:32 PM (four hours ago)

Negative, the shaking the tree version is 3m45s and the version I posted is 5m05s.

It's just shorter. Both versions have Gabriel adding ONLY...ONLY before "Wanting contact..." and those roller coaster synths.

one has Simon Phillips playing drums, I know that much.

xxxxpost

Yes! I remember describing the staging of "San Jacinto" to my dad the next day.

I Have The Touch slightly ahead The Family And The Fishing Net for me. This album to me is split between sound and production experiments and standard tunes and I think I Have The Touch is a good enough tune to warrant the vote. I wonder how feted Gabriel would be if he hadn't been in Genesis before making albums 1-4? He's one of those artists who is genuinely interested in sound - something you'd like to think is true of everyone who makes music for a living. Alas...

went for san jacinto

the album mix of I Have the Touch is def inferior to the Shaking the Tree one imo, loses some of the propulsion and eeriness

I have never heard the Birdy soundtrack and this thread is making me think I need to

Anyone read this? http://www.amazon.com/Without-Frontiers-Music-Peter-Gabriel-ebook/dp/B00FSV7JG4/ref=sr_1_3?s=books&ie=UTF8&qid=1540569670&sr=1-3&keywords=peter+gabriel

The Birdy soundtrack was for years my pre-bed album.

"Shock the Monkey" now and forever.

certainly in my list of top five favorite albums of all time. Voted FAmily and the Fishing Net which to me is basically the pinnacle of Gabriel's solo years along with Mercy Street. Dark, involving, mysterious, fucking weird.

"Dark, involving, mysterious and fucking weird" is pretty much OTM regarding that track. 'Lay Your Hands On Me' fits the bill, too.

Hi tried to revisit this territory on Up but it just didn't click.

I've just finished watching that South Bank Show documentary which I hadn't seen before, so it was great to watch Gabriel working on portions of this record. Somehow, I'd forgotten that David Lord was the producer on this one - the same guy who'd work on XTC's The Big Express in '84 and (if I remember correctly) was recently found running a brothel.

San Jacinto, especially the thrilling start to the climax

I HOLD THE LIGHT [ker-chungggg]

haha didn't know that about david lord. he did great work. was he a good brothel owner too?

it's "hold the line" xp

This record may be a bit cliched in its exoticism (“African drum sections!” “Headless chickens!”) but it sounds fabulous and is sequenced quite well. Even tho the whole thing feels very much of a piece, the pop songs (“I Have the Touch,” “Shock the Monkey”) and piano ballad (”Wallflower”) provide sharp relief to the more textural experiments here.

The individual tracks hold up a little less well. Tho Marotta‘s performance on “I Have the Touch” remains inspired, “The Rhythm of the Heat” that captivated my sixteen year-old mind feels a little facile today. And the great drama of “San Jacinto,” a close cousin of TH’s “The Listening Wind,” almost makes up for a narrative that is more or less the Crying Indian commercial from the 1970s. Not sure if it’s my favorite or not but “Shock the Monkey” may be the only thing here that works as well on the record as it does as a single.

First digitally recorded and mastered pop album IIRC.

The record cover is so great, wish I knew what it actually was.

As a kid I had the birdy soundtrack years before I had this album so that has a lot of influence over my favorite tracks here.

Lord how I wish I could have seen this tour

I saw him play the Brendan Byrne arena (meadowlands, NJ) on the So tour and he played a bunch of these. Opened with San Jacinto. Also played Shock The Monkey and I have vivid memories of Lay Your Hands On Me, which had some super cool hand movements.

I was at this same concert. My memories are vague but very positive. Bought the tour book which had all kinds of weird shit in it (an interview with Koko the sign language gorilla, some mildly disconcerting manipulated photos of Gabriel, etc.).

The arrangements on the So tour were super-neat.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=n3oub27yzpo&list=PLeE7IE2UYXF8dyglwIWt-zWtN378rr31a

This whole show is cool. Don't know why it wouldn't let me link to the complete one:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1lhxencRCCU

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JRCFKoCs9nk

The record cover is so great, wish I knew what it actually was.

From http://realworldgalleries.com/security/

“The artwork on album 4 was something that I’d been working on with a sculptor called Malcolm Poynter, who’s work I thought was really strong. There was a book I’d seen on distortions, a little like fairground mirrors, and we started using Flexi Mirrors”. Peter Gabriel

The final sleeve art is from an experimental video directed by Malcolm Poynter, with professional help from his editor friend David Gardner. The cover features the distorted image of Peter.

“My memory of this project, which was crucially pre Photoshop, was us dragging around Flexi Mirrors and Fresnel Lenses, and some sculptures, and then having a very creative (if chaotic) time. It was good!” Malcolm Poynter.

oh, that's nice to hear. I wondered about that for years. It looks like he's wearing a ski mask but maybe not. The images in the internal liners are great too.

I saw the So tour in Glasgow, sat in probably the farthest away seats at the SECC which is/was a big useless metal barn, still enjoyed the show but yeah, I recall it being quiet.

One thing I love about that South Bank Show episode is Gabriel sketching out 'I Have the Touch' and proper getting into it...

I saw Gabriel at the Human Rights Now tour a few years after So and it was so thrilling and amazing. He did the stage dive and everything. I saw him multiple times on the US tour and I think he'd dropped that by then (great though those shows were)

Weird that this didnt get auto-bumped when the results came in. Every track got a vote, though!

this is the best album ever made

I unfortunately heard and loved Plays Live first - the studio versions are weirdly awkward sounding to me, rhythmically :-(

it's my favorite. also the first album i ever got on cd, and for a kid who was used to just taping stuff off the radio with cheap cassettes, i was NOT prepared for the sound of PG's opening wail jumping out of the speakers and into, you know, my soulllllllllllllll

'Plays Live' was my gateway to PG as a kid, the versions of all the Security tracks are fantastic.

wait - there's a band that covers songs from the first four albums and Jerry Marotta is their drummer!?

http://securityprojectband.com/go/

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ju85sA8UTjc

The metallic flutes/scraping in the coda to "San Jacinto" scared the hell outta me.

"I unfortunately heard and loved Plays Live first - the studio versions are weirdly awkward sounding to me, rhythmically :-("

"'Plays Live' was my gateway to PG as a kid, the versions of all the Security tracks are fantastic."

i don't really like the plays live arrangements of these songs although I feel like I may have heard that first too, I can't remember. It's not that they're more commercial sounding, but they are less....idiosyncratic. This is true for the live arrangements of most of his stuff TBF.

"wait - there's a band that covers songs from the first four albums and Jerry Marotta is their drummer!?"

yes, with Happy Rhodes doing vocals now and they've expanded their repretoire to include Kate Bush. You can check out their live releases, they're all pretty cool.

I will, thx!

The Plays Live version of “The Rhythm of the Heat” def. struck me as inferior to the studio version. I remember hearing it for the first time and thinking the big African drum ensemble coda was less powerful and Gabriel did a much shorter “The rhythm has my/SOOOOOOOO-UUUUUUUUUUUULLLLLLLLLL.”

btw, Gabriel release a 62 track rarities collection digitally today. All the b-sides, etc.

but no "Out, Out"!

The cover of Joseph Arthur's "In the Sun" — one of the rarities on the new collection — is one of my favourite songs of his. All the brooding & menace of his sound (90s-fied, like the production on Us) but with more direct lyrics.

Flotsam and Jetsam is grayed out in my Spotify. Not available in the US?

The omission of "Out, Out" is puzzling, but then it didn't appear on Rated PG either. Kind of hard to imagine that there would be a rights issue — I assume PG controls all of his recordings at this juncture.

I'm a big fan of "Quiet Steam" and the Massive Attack remix of "Games Without Frontiers." So this collection is out now?

Tangentially related, I wonder how much Pearl Jam made for smartly releasing all of those live CDs when the getting was good, or certainly better? It must have been like minting money. Every time an artist like PG does something like this so late in the game, or Springsteen suddenly opens the vaults to studio stuff and especially live stuff, or Prince reissues not coming out until after his death and so on, I think, man, I know you're artists, but I wish you released all this shit people have been collecting and trading for decades when you could have made some moolah. I know Gabriel must still be swimming in it, but my first thought when this most forward thinking of artists did the anniversary "So" tour followed by a joint tour with Sting was that he needed the cash to support all his various endeavors.

He seems like a massive perfectionist though, so he probably had “plans” for all of it. I guess this is just a time to let go.

"but no "Out, Out"!"

yeah it's weird that's not on there when what I feel are duplicate or kind of useless remixes of other songs are. I'd actually forgotten what that song sounded like so I went to YouTube and it's hardly a bad track. Lovetown was left off too so I thought maybe there's some licensing thing, but who knows. Out, Out is one of two songs he did that were done with Nile Rodgers (the walk through the fire remix included was as well) and they're both overly clattery and cluttered sounding IMO; not the best creative fit.

flotsam and jetsam is available on apple music in the US, so there might just be a lag with spotify, dunno, I don't use it.

my favorite discovery on this release (aside from me and my teddy bear which i'd totally forgotten about) is the elbow remix of More Than This which is better than the album version. I know some on ILX hate Elbow and find the dull but I wouldn't mind Garvey producing a Gabriel album at this point.

I didn't care for it at the time but listening back, Curtains is a lovely song, but it's still called 'Curtains'

yeah I love curtains. I had it on the big time CD single.