yes FRAGILE

How did this arrangement treat the organ solo? The mind reels.

ah, i would have to think about it, but lacking a guitarist they gave the opening bit to a flugelhorn soloist, who then soloed later on too in the guitar slot, maybe on trumpet, so i think probably the lead trombone took the other solo

That outtakes' lyrics and melody ended up on Topographic Oceans

no complaints about any of the solo jams, or the "we have heaven" reprise 28 years later

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mhpnb5kLRRs

The fish is so cool

Btw I like having the date so far out. In six months we get to talk about this album all over again

I don't care if I am accused of being a popist, it is and will always be "Roundabout."

shine delirium prima toward us

Just listened and decided my vote in favour of "Heart of the Sunrise", surprising myself. That introduction is one of the most dazzling moments in all of rock.

The river can disregard the cost

Alan White was good but Billy B was in a different league

This album was epic in the car driving around in an April snow storm.

Easy choice with "heart of the sunrise" I think "long distance runaround" might be second.
I love the whole album since the first time I heard it, along withThe Yes Album and
Close To The Edge. of course.

I'll have to listen again to check LDR and SSOTS - HOTS is obvious frontrunner. I don't like this album so much, weirdly enough, and I really don't get Runaround at ALL

Same re: roundabout. Unless you’re talking about the blues traveler song

I get it so little I don't even know what it's called ffs

But to be unambiguous, I don't get the opening track of Fragile. I don't even know how it goes. I've listened to it several times but it slides off my ear on each occasion

"tell the moon don't tell the marcher"

is that the lyric? I thought it was "tell the moon dog, tell the march hare". I'm disappointed. mine is better.

I always thought the same, akm, and the Internet seems to agree, but it's not printed in the sleeve to my LP.

I'll have to listen again to check LDR and SSOTS - HOTS is obvious frontrunner. I don't like this album so much, weirdly enough, and I really don't get Runaround at ALL

― imago, Wednesday, April 18, 2018 8:26 AM (two hours ago) Bookmark Flag Post Permalink

Same re: roundabout. Unless you’re talking about the blues traveler song

― calstars, Wednesday, April 18, 2018 9:32 AM (one hour ago) Bookmark Flag Post Permalink

I get it so little I don't even know what it's called ffs

― imago, Wednesday, April 18, 2018 9:37 AM (one hour ago) Bookmark Flag Post Permalink

But to be unambiguous, I don't get the opening track of Fragile. I don't even know how it goes. I've listened to it several times but it slides off my ear on each occasion

― imago, Wednesday, April 18, 2018 9:38 AM (one hour ago) Bookmark Flag Post Permalink

threadban plz

Alan White was good but Billy B was in a different league

― calstars, Sunday, April 15, 2018 1:19 AM (three days ago) Bookmark Flag Post Permalink

Agreed. I remember reading an interview with Eddy Offord where he said that White had difficulty getting the older material down when he first joined the band - having said that, I find it difficult to imagine Relayer with Bruford for some reason.

(I prefer Relayer to Frragile and even Close to the Edge, fwiw)

yea that's understandable in the sense that someone may prefer heroin to cocaine

Score another one to Relayer. Actually The Yes Album is better than all of them and Going For The One is the one I'd save in the event of apocalypse as it has Awaken on it

idk GftO is where you can hear them going off and I don't bother with anything after that. If I had to choose one Yes album for me it would be extremely difficult to choose between Relayer and CttE

Relayer has the better main course, CTTE the better side dishes

Ha, that's a good way to put it!

I'm surprised that someone would love prog-era Yes and hate "Roundabout" tbh.

It's not hate, it's just never clicked

listen to it harder

your brains never clicked

I don’t know, Roundabout just sits on E throughout the song, sure it modulates major to minor but meh. Surely not as exciting as the other epics.

I posted one of these on the yessed out thread. See if you can make it through 11 minutes of just that one riff over and over.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=82ISpg1VdrE

(I didn't watch the whole thing, btw. My apologies if there's any bullshit on there that needs to be flagged.)

Every time I listen to this album, it becomes clearer and clearer to me that Chris Squire was the Yes MVP

i love the jojo's bizarre adventure roundabout meme... so much

that comp has a lot of unsettling and boring variations on it unfortunately

I don’t know, Roundabout just sits on E throughout the song, sure it modulates major to minor but meh. Surely not as exciting as the other epics.

― calstars, Wednesday, April 18, 2018 9:36 AM (seventeen minutes ago) Bookmark Flag Post Permalink

i know something else that sits on E throughout the song hehehe

Every time I listen to this album, it becomes clearer and clearer to me that Chris Squire was the Yes MVP

It's a whole band of MVPs.

too funky for jager

xp Yeah but I'm pretty sure Squire is the MVP of MVPs

Can we agree that maybe Rick Wakeman is the least MVP?

Just in case anyone missed the epic Yo La Tengo cover of Roundabout:

https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=r-68yHpJTw4

Really captures the spirit of the track

i have appreciated this a time or two

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PVdV5-QimdI

Hearing Alan White play 'Heart of the Sunrise' is always depressing.

lol yeah LCD launching into that brought a real smile to my face. felt a bit like a coming out of the closet moment.

Can we agree that maybe Rick Wakeman is the least MVP?

― Mario Meatwagon (Moodles), Wednesday, April 18, 2018 4:44 PM (forty-two minutes ago) Bookmark Flag Post Permalink

motion carried

roundabout is the track on here that most presages new wave yes, therefore it is awesome

Nothing sounds less appealing than yo la tengo covering roundabout

to be fair it was part of their WFMU pledge drive show where they have to cover whatever the donors request.

Nothing sounds less appealing than yo la tengo covering roundabout

i'm told Ira talks while chewing with his mouth open which killed dead any appreciation the person who told me this had for him.