teaching mark s a *LESSON* response three: FUNKADELIC

Sooooo is it totally heretical to acknowledge Maggot Brain as an undisputed great and classic album and think that America Eats Its Young is an even greater and more classic album? Because get ready to excommunicate yrs truly, if so.

Also, gahdamn, mark s, when does your 33 1/3 book about the album drop?

America Eats Its Young is their worst album.

Like let's make a baggy sprawling incoherent rock album that Zappa fans might like. Where is Shakey when he's needed?

where is Shakey?

kidnapped by chaki iirc

Don't worry, he's just taking a break.

America Eats Its Young is their worst album.

― Video reach stereo bog (Tom D.), Thursday, February 22, 2018 1:56 PM (seven minutes ago) Bookmark Flag Post Permalink

Okay, I thought *I* was bringing the challops itt, but (bows to the master).

What's worse? Remember this on the proviso that the worst Funkadelic is n times better than the best Zappa album, or whatever.

The album has felt especially resonant to me over the past year. I can't even count how many times I've listened to it.

The repeated refrain of 'y'all see my point' in 'Biological Speculation' might be my favorite slow-burn, super-subtle delivery of a casual threat ever.

If Zappa had recorded albums like this album I would probably like Zappa, but as it stands IDGI.

But yeah, I'll grant you that even the worst Funkadelic album (whichever it is) is better than most things.

Great tracks on it - it's Clinton/Funkadelic - but it's still my least favourite.

"If You Don't Like the Effects, Don't Produce the Cause" is one of the greatest, aptest adages that George Clinton stumbled on. I quote it often.

That's another winner!

wowee zowee this thread is a nostalgia rush...

The worst period of Funkadelic is the period between Let's Take It To The Stage and One Nation Under a Groove, but that's only cuz Clinton was focusing more on Parliament's releases during that time. America Eats Its Young isn't in my Top 10 p-funk albums (then again, neither is Maggot Brain) but I like it just fine.

Been listening to/liking a lot that Reworked By Detroiters thing that came out last year. Embarrassed to admit I'm not familiar with at least half of the originals!

Bravo Mark, that was like crawling over the cover of the album as you described it, only it was already like that before you got to the cover (also reminded me of the cover of Uncle Meat etc). Lots of good points and info (I knew some of that, being old, but also have another unwelcome memory of a promo of Process hymns re Jesus alternating with hymns re Satan, released and I think recorded this century by hipsters).
A lot of amazingly good music has been made by people with beliefs I don't particulary give a shit about, especially jazz.
A number of ilxors would include Dylan's Trouble No More, but for me the musical (incl his vocal) powers of the sampler are too supportive of his paranoid rants, much more about what another poster called cocaine dreams or thoughts and the excitement of (after midlife crisis of Street Legal, Dylany imagery now sounding homeless on "Changing of the Guard), he's righteous Boy Dylan back bitch and better, having finally found The Point and Winning/Saved and having the biz means to rant big---
Speaking of "rock and soul speaking to each other, reminds me of the precariously hopeful cosmic poetic ballads and guitar punks defiantly celebrating "My Black Uncertainty" and non-rhetorically asking of their album mates/selves and others, "Are You Insaaane?"---on Burnt Sugar's 2017 All You Zombies Dig The Luminosity.
It's all here: https://burntsugarthearkestrachamber.bandcamp.com/album/all-you-zombies-dig-the-luminosity