Thinkin' the Blues

Impressive.

Here's a collaboration I am curious about. Not big names though--

http://www.clarionledger.com/story/magnolia/entertainment/2016/12/01/barretta-natchez-blues-come-light-collaboration/94695706/

Natchez is one of Mississippi’s cultural treasures, but its rich blues heritage is often overlooked. Evidence of it is plentiful on the recent CD “Natchez Burnin'” (Broke and Hungry Records) by veterans Hezekiah Early and Robert Lee “Lil' Poochie” Watson.

Early and Watson have played together regularly in Natchez over the last decade, but their collaboration goes back to the 1980s, when Watson performed with the Early-led Hezekiah and the Houserockers at festivals in Chicago and Toronto. The duo’s music is refreshingly loose, tackling mostly blues standards in a style true to the sounds of the house parties where both men started their musical careers....

Liking Jimmy Duck Holmes latest album, Cypress Grove. He lives in Mississippi and has his own place , the Blues Front Cafe in Bentonia, Ms.

The album reminds me more of RL Burnside style blues than city of Chicago 12 bar blues

Listening to tons of Bob Dylan tracks that draw on old blues produced this thought:

In the history of Blues (or R&B, if you prefer?) there is a major tradition of bawdy, of desiring sexual gratification or lamenting that it's been lost:

"Come here baby, put some sugar in my bowl"
"Ain't got no fur slippers no more"
"Press my button (ring my bell)"

etc.

But what I don't hear, at least in what Dylan revives, is love, or romance. Either it exists in the genre's history, but Dylan doesn't touch it; or it wasn't really part of the genre -- and was rather something that belonged to other genres, like Tin Pan Alley songs.

Maybe it's as if the Blues narrator has to have a certain toughness, to survive, that precludes him saying things like "I loved her so much, my heart is broken and I can't go on without her".

A whole list of "Dirty Blues" can be found here:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dirty_blues

Maybe it's as if the Blues narrator has to have a certain toughness, to survive, that precludes him saying things like "I loved her so much, my heart is broken and I can't go on without her".

Come on:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-BkPm8JIJJQ

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3rd9IaA_uJI

Sure, Sund4r -- happy to be corrected -- I was just creating tentative hypotheses on the basis of what I happen to know.

Would you say, then, that the emotion of romantic love IS prevalent in the blues, compared to other genres?

From that first song:

When the train come in the station
I looked her in the eye
Well, the train come in the station
And I looked her in the eye
Whoa, I felt so sad so lonesome
That I could not help but cry

When the train left the station
It had two lights on behind
Yeah, when the train left the station
It had two lights on behind
Whoa, the blue light was my baby
And the red light was my mind

Those last lines are good!

Is this the song that the Stones recorded in about 1969?

Yes, the same, and, yes, songs about romantic loss, heartbreak, and betrayal are so common in the blues as to be a cliché!

This is a fantastic proto-rock-n-roll electric rhythm and blues from the mid-40s:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kzCEOINEjng

I agree with pinefox that when Dylan wants to convey romantic loss or longing in his recent work, he tends to pastiche Tin Pan Alley songs; his blues songs tend to be picaresque or apocalyptic scenarios.

Probably someone will come up with a bunch of counter-examples, but with a lot of the blues artists I've been listening to recently, it seems like "consistency of artistic persona" is not the priority it would become in modern music. Like the same singer will do a sad, resigned song about a breakup, and then a song about loading up his shotgun to get revenge on a scornful lover. There are a lot of modern artists who do one or the other, but fewer who would do both.