I'm at the DC Rebirth retailer road show

This was such a hit I didn't even get to read it to find out if it was complete shit (as I assume) before selling out.

seriously?!

Yep. Every retailer I know has blown through these. IDGI, but whatevs.

Moore has much to answer for wrt modern day DC's embrace of the grim and the grit.

Yes, it's definitely his responsibility.

yr literalism is striking as always

although he has answered, raised incantations, and summonses protective beards many a time against such accusations

https://www.instagram.com/p/BF6Mx7lm_F4/?hl=en

Tom E on Rebirth: http://tomewing.tumblr.com/post/145207290801/danare-we-the-baddies

The ad for Wonder Woman Rebirth at the back has copy along the lines of “EVERYTHING she KNOWS and TRUSTS will be TAKEN FROM HER”. Marketing quiz! Do you think this copy is written to appeal more to a) a woman who wants to jump on board the adventures of DC’s most iconic female superhero or b) a guy who likes the idea of women being taken down a peg?

headline is a reference to this sketch btw America

Tt, we may be generally pig-ignorant over here but we aren't complete savages.

Mitchell and Webb are taught in most American public schools these days.

I definitely appreciated "The Case Against Dan Didio". I don't follow the comics scene anymore because it's too toxic and depressing, so it's nice to have a digest-form version that explains _why_ I stay as far away from anything having to do with DC Comics as possible.

I know the business side isn't something ILC particularly gives a damn about but sales on the other Rebirth titles are absolutely insane today. IDGI, I just can't get excited about what I've read from either this or Civil War II.

do you think people buy that stuff thinking it's an investment because "it'll be worth money someday" or is it a legit proof of a sucker born every minute? or both?

I really like getting that kind of updates. I don't understand it either. Perhaps people just think it will be a good jumping on point?

if i was DC i would just number every issue of every comic i put out "1".

I don't think DC has a lot of readers, outside of select titles. Buyers, yeah, but it's people who buy every fucking Batman/Superman comic and two copies if it's #1 on the cover

Or more depressingly, they read them and actually want this shit

I don't hear about many speculators these days. I have one guy who buys one of every Image #1 because a few of their titles like The Walking Dead and Saga have gone way up, but no one that I know of with Marvel or DC, people have figured out that they print tens/hundreds of thousands of copies and a significant chunk of those are bagged and boarded even by people who just read and collect so scarcity is unlikely.

Only being able to sell Batman has been DC's biggest issue, the weird thing here is that all the other characters are selling at the same pace or even a little better than today's Batman. Let's say I normally order 20 Green Arrow, I ordered 50+10 of the monthly variant (because they were returnable) and they're all gone now. I would guess people actually believe that DC is going to push the rest of the universe this time instead of just Batman. Whether that sticks, God only knows.

if i was DC i would just number every issue of every comic i put out "1".

This is Marvel's strategy - everything is a miniseries. Darth Vader is one of their top-10 titles and is getting wrapped at 25, presumably to see an All New Darth Vader three months later.

I get it but I don't like it.

i'm fine with that, at least it kinda guarantees a closed story arc / hopefully continuous creative team for that run

btw milo I am super interested in your business takes. i know very little about that side

Yeah, my comics speculation begins and ends with speculating about why people buy the stuff they buy. It's fascinating to get the inside scoop.

The Darth Vader writer has been pretty clear that he'll have told the story he wanted to tell, it could of course be a line.

It fits in with Gillen's style for short-medium-ish self contained runs.

Comics were always a huckster business to some degree. I guess hucksters are in their reboot phase.

I get wrapping up a creator's run before things get stagnant, but I don't like the series jump - even if you take a few months off, just have a new team for Darth #26 unless you really intend to retire the book (which I find highly doubtful). That's how we get stupid titles like All New All Different Avengers.

I am very possibly being naive, but I think they might retire it. It started up with three questions unclear - what were the repercussions of being the senior survivor of the largest military disaster in history, when did he find out he was Luke's father, how did he know those bounty hunters in Empire - and by the end of Gillen's run they'll have answered those and left him roughly where he is at the start of Empire.

Which is not to say that I wouldn't read 25 no-effect issues of Ellis's Darth Vader Escapades, but I can see restarting the series.

The Darth Vader book is almost certainly immune to this phenomenon, but it seems more often that titles are being stealth cancelled to give the illusion that they were meant to be limited series all along. The frequent lack of a satisfying resolution (as if the creative team were scrambling to tie up all of their threads) and the weird lengths of some of these runs (several Marvel series have ended at issue 11, for example) seem to back this up. I guess I'd be more okay with everything being a miniseries if the approach seemed more intentional in its execution.

To clarify, I don't think the people buying up books are "collectors" in the aftermarket sense, but in the way that they will buy at least one Batman comic regardless of writer and artist and might not even know who the writer is.

I have heard some anecdotal evidence to support that. It seems like an eight-year-old's approach to buying comics but whattayagonnado (says the dude who buys pretty much every Earth-616 comic just because it says 'Marvel' on the cover).

i understand that completionist approach but can't imagine doing it with paper.

as of late i found the online "complete marvel" / "complete dc" torrents (about two terabytes total) and am slowly absorbing full years

Speaking of ill-gotten DC torrents, I just spotted this precocious letter writer at the back of a Neal Adams Batman issue:

http://i.imgur.com/28M5BzQ.jpg

dave sim, champion of grim and gritty

I came across a few George R.R. Martin letters in silver age Marvel titles.

is there a tumblr or something for scans of before-they-were-famous letters that appeared in comics and magazines?

(or just scans of letters pages from old comics in general, I love that stuff.)

these scans of letters that appeared in 50s and 60s Superman comics and Mort Weisinger's responses are quite something

http://goodcomics.comicbookresources.com/category/dont-send-me-no-more-letters-no/

The crazy thing is that the Darth Vader boo being stopped it is selling well. Vader and Star Wars are like #2 and #3 of all the books at my small local shop on the pull list with Walking Dead being #1.

To me, I think if Marvel really wanted to get it together they should do what they did on those Star Wars titles, which are in someways the most old school Marvel books they have done in a while. They have an inner continuity, they are written for a wide audience and are both stylistically and content wise true to the original creations with room for the creators to tell a story.

What could be fun if they do Empire Strikes Back as like a 25 issue (4 trade series) both adapting the movie and filling in back story with Jabba, Boba Fett and other players in the background like the search for Hoth etc.

like the radio play adaptions

the star wars radio play, which i listened to obsessively as a child before we had a vhs machine, was 13 30-min episiodes, so there was a LOOOOT of extra material

I came across a few George R.R. Martin letters in silver age Marvel titles.

― What's Your Definition of a Dirty Baby? (Old Lunch)

true fact: he was the first paying attendee at a comics convention

http://awoiaf.westeros.org/images/4/4b/George_R_R_Martin.jpg
You'd never guess from his physical appearance

To me, I think if Marvel really wanted to get it together they should do what they did on those Star Wars titles, which are in someways the most old school Marvel books they have done in a while. They have an inner continuity, they are written for a wide audience and are both stylistically and content wise true to the original creations with room for the creators to tell a story.

I think they had the same rules with the previous (pre-Episode VII) canon? All comics, games, novels, etc. had to be approved by Lucasfilm's continuity guards, and they were all considered canon... And then what happened was that, once The Force Awakens was in the works, obviously a lot of the old canon would have to be abandoned (since it depicted post-Episode VI events in ways that would contradict with Episode VII), so they decided that all of the old canon except for the movies + the Clone Wars TV series was now set in an alternate universe. I think the old canon is now called "Star Wars Legends" or something.

AFAIK Star Wars has been pretty unique in this regard that they've tried to include all stories in different media into the canon, so that the timeline of their universe includes all that material, and different stories shouldn't contradict each other. With Star Trek, for example, only the TV series and the movies are considered to be official canon, everything else is non-canonical.

IIRC there were levels of canon, so the book level was canon unless it was contradicted by the films, the comics were canon unless it was contradicted by the books or the film, and so on.

I like earlnash's point about the Star Wars books being "old school Marvel" - i.e. mild continuity, one author just getting on with it for several years, each new story really *is* a potential starting point for new readers, etc

i.e. the days before continuity was a beartrap and american otaku and children were the key demographics