King Crimson: Classic Or Dud

Just wondering if not picking up the KCCC 46 Live at the Marquee 10th August 1971 was a mistake or not. It was one of the cds that were in HMV before it closed down for good yesterday.

Or to expand on that what volumes of that KCCC series are thought of as essential. I'm far more interested in the early 70s stuff than the 80s reunion.

71 is the islands/"earthbound" band, so you should base it on how much you like that group. most '70s people (myself included) for the 8/72 through 7/74 lineup with cross, bruford, wetton (and muir on '72 dates); the zurich, central park, and zoom club concerts are all very good, with the best quality being zurich (the source for "the mincer" on starless and bible black, with an audience patch). but ultimately the great deceiver box set is still the best statement on the era...

yeah I love that incarnation of the group but 4 discs of live material spanning less than two years is about the limit

all the KCCC content, reworking of past material, and Fripp diary entries are just distracting them from working on a new album, imo

i used to feel this way but then realized king crimson hadn't done anything i really like since around 1981, so i'm ok with them just going on tour and playing "starless" and "schizoid man" until fripp dies.

Too soon

yeah I agree, at least they're revisiting material that hasn't been played to death (recently) and doing it in a new way.

i don't need to hear deception of the thrush part XVII

i hate thrak era more than anything so this latest iteration is exactly what id like to go see.

thrak itself is a great song

well I wasn't complaining that KC is on tour

I never gave up on them choosing a new direction after the samesyishness from the last 20 years which has been a steady decline

there's nothing utterly thrilling about the post-thrak albums, certainly. there are highlights here and there, but for the amount of stuff they did (two full albums and a huge number of live releases) of this time, only a small portion of it is at all 'great'. I'm not counting the last album which didn't really have a KC name of it (Scarcity of Miracles)

agreed. but thrak is still my theme song

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=I784J-xM1Ak

Wanna make an official KC video?
http://www.dgmlive.com/news.htm?entry=5464

http://www.dgmlive.com/archive.htm?&show=2011

"Easy Money" is one of Wetton's dumber lyrics (and that's saying something), but boy howdy, the guitar solo on this version...

Robert Palmer James wrote those lyrics. I've always enjoyed them – particularly the line that didn't make the studio version.

You're right -- if Wetton had written them, there'd be a "eyes/rise/thighs" rhyme. But the "judge/budge/fudge" verse -- ugh.

I bought the download of this show Monday when it was announced and have given it one good listen-through so far. It's a little sanitized-for-my-protection, imo. I don't feel any real sense of danger or high stakes like I do with Absent Lovers or USA. It's a crack band running through a well-oiled repertoire, but I don't think Music enters the room, as Fripp would put it.

Please note a 2-disc Collectors Club Special Edition of this show (identical to this download) will be available mail order from March 17th

Thinking of buying this one...

I'm waiting for the 2CD live album, culled from multiple shows and featuring every song performed on the tour, which is coming in the fall. I might check this one out just as a tease, though.

So are these physical versions only available on the dgm site, or will they be available elsewhere, like the Collectable series?

But the "judge/budge/fudge" verse -- ugh.
this is hilarious

My favorite verse.

crimson to that point had been so poncy in their lyrics that easy money sticks out as kind of refreshing to me

also like the 'zipper' sounds in it

Stone headed Frisco spacer
Ate all the meat I gave her....

So poncy.

i forgot about that song
(for some reason)

the toronto show download is wonderful, everyone should check it out. loved the show last year, good reflection of it, really ties all the different eras together, though sadly ignores the 80's (no belew, no good or respectful way to represent those I imagine)

Heard "Elephant Talk" on the radio today as the lead-in to a piece on the GOP debate.

also, didn't realize they'd played a 'new' song (meltdown) last fall

wish they'd just do a studio record

I'm guessing they're going to do one after the live record in the fall.

Listening to the '74 Central Park show. Starless is fucking killer, Wetton's bass sound is absolutely monstrous. Might be the best version of the tune I've ever heard.

Yeah I think somewhere upthread I was in apoplexy over that particular performance. It's one of those 'holy shit, people stood there and saw this' things.

That Penn State '74 show is awesome, too. Maybe disc 17 of the Road to Red set?

Rieflin taking a sabbatical, will be replaced by Jeremy Stacy on fall 2016 dates.
http://www.dgmlive.com/news.htm?entry=5474

So ... session guy.

That's cool, Pat was a session guy, too.

Yeah, when King Crimson needs a new member, grab the guy who worked with Sheryl Crow for 10 years.

Or, you know, REM.

Or Mr. Mister.

Fripp should spice it up and hire Yoshimi, she's used to playing with other drummers

Session guy from Bournemouth who has played with a lot of prog dudes and good live pop bands, but hey, y'all keep pre-judging!

ugh they got the guy from MOGUL THRASH to play bass for them? lame.

Yeah, and the one guitarist worked with the dude from Hall & Oates. Puke.

For the longest time, I've had a hard time with Thrak-era KC and related proje(k)cts often because of the processing – everything kind of blares and seeps together into a big mush.

But surprisingly, as I've noted on a few other threads, I've found myself really taken of late with Fripp's Soundcapes releases – in part because of the processing which, perhaps unsurprisingly, is a direct descendant of Eno's latter day treatments. There are tons of really great concerts on DGM Live to this effect – I dropped $30 or so on his World Financial Centre concert in 2000 and the"Churchscapes" tour of English cathedrals in 2006. They're really, really good – and demonstrate far more subtlety in the sound design process than I ever gave Fripp credit for, at least once he'd gone digital.

It's making me want to give this latter day-era Crimson a second chance, from the Projekcts to, particularly, the Thrak box, as Jakko specifically talks about how on the latter his remix work focused on de-stereo-fying everyone's parts to give them more separation and clarity in the surround and two-channel mixes.

Has anyone heard the box? And where would a good place to start with the Projekcts be if I were to dip a wary toe in?

I haven't heard the Thrak box, but I do know the initial Vroom EP released in advance of the album, the debut of the double trio, had a much more defined soundscape, with the speakers divided 3 and 3.

The Projekcts that I've heard are hit or miss, readily identifiable as the sum total of their contributors but pretty shy of KC proper, iirc. On one of them (that I also saw performed live), Belew plays V-drums exclusively, and Fripp is processing his guitar into sort of half-assed xylophone. Others are more aggressive, but I honestly can't remember the various sounds and combinations of the different line-ups.

This fall European tour has really ballooned into a big thing -- 41 dates now.

Clearly Fripp got the memo that 1) no one lives forever and 2) touring makes money.