POLL: Neil Young - Decade (Disc 2)

I'm saying it's not on Decade.

hard

20 years ago I would have voted "Cortez," but now it's "A Man Needs A Maid" all the way.

Damnit I used to have this CD - someone gave it to me - and then I ended up giving it to someone else! STOOPID.

"like a hurricane"

plenty of great songs there, but that one's just one of my favorites by anyone.

"ohio"
the outrage is immense and perfect

I went with Cortez. 20 years from now, I will go with "A Man Needs a Maid"

Hurricane: I like the Live Rust version better, and I couldn't not vote for Heart Of Gold ultimately.

"The Needle and the Damage Done," the brevity of which (it's the shortest on Decade) just hurts.

Came down to Hurricane vs Winterlong, went for the otherwise unreleased

hey wait, that is disc three and half of disc two...

Which is my way of saying that I prefer Decade on vinyl, as it is more manageable on three discs and six sides.

"Winterlong."

Needle and the Damage Done

hurricane. might seem obvious -- just as my vote for after the gold rush might seem obvious on the other disc -- but i don't give a shit. these fucking songs.

what he says

Do you think Neil heard Big Star before recording "Winterlong?"

Heh. Eric Weisbard said as much in the big SPIN book.

somewhere, on an old tape of a show from picadilly radio, i have the pixies' version of "winterlong". it is incredible.

"Harvest"

I wish "Ambulance Blues" were on here instead of "For the Turnstiles", so I'll have to go with "Harvest" too

yeah "ambulance blues" would be my pick for song-not-on-decade-that-should-be. or possibly "only love can break your heart."

grimly, the pixies version is on the b-sides CD if you dont have it http://www.amazon.co.uk/Complete-B-Sides-Pixies/dp/B000056Q1P/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&s=music&qid=1210451620&sr=8-1

(yes it is great)

"Hurricane" my sentimental choice over "Cortez". Close, though.

song-not-on-decade-that-should-be

Should've had more than one representative from Zuma. Barstool Blues maybe. Or Lookin' For A Love.

'tired eyes' or 'ohio' or 'cortez'

can't decide on this one

There may be lots of great songs on "Harvest" and just one on "American Stars'n'Bars". But that one is one of his best ever songs, so I voted "Like a Hurricane"

Maybe Needle and the Damage Done. Otherwise Old Man, which might seem obvious or played out to some, but it knocks me out every time.

Tough to chose between "Ohio", "Tonight's the Night", "Tired Eyes", "Winterlong", "Like a Hurricane", "Cortez the Killer"

May i please have 11 votes?

i have gone with tonight's the night. Decade was the most beloved item of mine in my parents record collection.

Tempted to go for 'Winterlong' - it being the main reason I bought this in the first place - but opted for 'Like A Hurricane' after hearing it playing on vinyl at ear-splitting volume in a Relics Records the other week.

"Do you think Neil heard Big Star before recording "Winterlong?"

How is this possible? Neil was playing Winterlong as early as March of '70

do you think it's possible both neil and big star had heard the byrds?

plus is winterlong that out of character from the guy that wrote cinnamon girl?

winterlong!

Automatic thread bump. This poll is closing tomorrow.

Regarding Big Star, it may be the other way round. There is a lot of Neil Young in the style of Big Star, particularly after Chris Bell left.

Automatic thread bump. This poll's results are now in.

"Deep Forbidden Lake" should have gotten one vote.

yeah I almost voted for it, love that song

"Do you think Neil heard Big Star before recording "Winterlong?"

How is this possible? Neil was playing Winterlong as early as March of '70

do you think it's possible both neil and big star had heard the byrds?

plus is winterlong that out of character from the guy that wrote cinnamon girl?

Well, at least Soto (typically) knew what I was talking about.

It's possible because the version on Decade was recorded in late 1973/1973.

To the next question: um...er....uh...

To the last question: um, no...

late 1973/1974

was “winterlong” intended for release before it appeared on decade? odd to be that such a lush huge sounding track was just filed away

it’s interesting that “don’t cry no tears” was one of the first songs he wrote back in 1964. I guess a live version was originally going to appear on Decade?

I imagine the Whitten era Crazy Horse tried recording "Winterlong" at some point (maybe in summer of 69), but maybe it never quit got there. They certainly nail it on the Fillmore East disc.

Here's the embryonic "Don't Cry" ...

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ug2LJR_h_zw

interesting, per the Decade wiki, I'd never read anything about it being on TNN

"Winterlong" – 3:05

Previously unreleased; recorded in November 1973 and appeared on certain acetate pressings of Tonight's the Night

yeah it's on this, along with some other on the beach-y type things: https://www.discogs.com/Neil-Young-Tonights-The-Night-Acetate/release/4138624

i love "winterlong." a lot. like, really a lot.

and tyler's neil knowledge never ceases to impress.

that is all.

haha, imagine if all that knowledge was actually useful!

I'm glad "Soldier" has a second life on this record, rather than languishing unheard on the Journey Through the Past soundtrack.
On the other hand, "Ambulance Blues" may be my favourite Neil Young song, but it wouldn't fit on Decade, it needs to stay at the end of side 2 of On the Beach.

Apparently 'Winterlong' was recorded at Larrabee Studios in Hollywood on 10/17/69. I imagine it was intended for the second Crazy Horse album that was swallowed up by After the Gold Rush.

aha, yeah that makes sense. maybe that recording will be on Early Daze, which Neil has been talking about forever ... might have the crazy horse version of "helpless," and early take of whitten's "look at all the things," maybe some additional recordings from the 1970 tour.

I'd say it's pretty useful tyler. I mean, it's much easier to hear what you have to say than to wade through some of the other, more toxic Neil related websites out there.

I believed Neil when he said that 'Helpless' didn't get recorded in Shakey, until he somehow 'found' another CH take of 'Birds' with the second verse, haha. I really hope Early Daze actually comes out at some point, in some format, etc.

that first crazy horse album rules I would love to hear if there were any outtakes from that (though I guess that wouldn't really be Neil's to release)

a few outtakes can be found on this (kinda scarce) compilation: https://www.discogs.com/Crazy-Horse-Scratchy-The-Complete-Reprise-Recordings/master/394322

“look at all the things” owns

I'd say it's pretty useful tyler. I mean, it's much easier to hear what you have to say than to wade through some of the other, more toxic Neil related websites out there.

Anyway, thanks, tyler! The Neil well runs deep!