Orbital - Snivilisation

Also come on, Nirvana >>>>>> any Britpop band.

so tempted to start a list thread

it is possible to celebrate album-oriented electronic music without the "finally, INTELLIGENT dance music" nonsense. i mean it makes sense that writers would mostly focus on dance music, that's where most of the action is and it's a bigger rupture from your parents' record collection than AOE, which did have its reactionary component.

still, unique stuff happened there and i would love to read about it, now that we've moved past the "this is it, brilliant white men will finally realize the potential of electronic music" phase.

Yeah I mean no one has this sort of conversation around, say, Kassem Mosse or Terrence Parker or Moodymann or anyone else who's put a great dance album out this year, I think it's more railing against the perception of the album as only worthwhile format.

I actually think around the time of Britpop was at its peak the British music press was at its best. They used to have a dance section and actually bother to write about rap music. Looking back now it's pretty cool that the NME had Tricky as their album of the year ahead of Blur/Oasis/Pulp. Those magazines actually used to try and cover different scenes and give their audience a mix of genres that probably suited their tastes. I'm not sure exactly when but at some point the NME just decided that it's audience could only handle one kind of music (It got even worse by the time they made up the New Rock Revolution)

If you look at the Melody Maker end of year lists from around this time they include a lot of dance music and some other really interesting records, none of which will be celebrated on 6Music's Britpop week, I'm sure.

http://www.rocklistmusic.co.uk/mmlists_p2.htm#1990

Also Insides is by far my favourite Orbital album.

The thing is, the Britpop thing just took over and crushed all that - as the big moment in the gentrification of indie it (and Matthew Bannister at Radio One) just killed the friction between the alternative press and the mainstream, it became a way of pitching bands straight at prime time and they lost interest in everything else, especially by the Conor McNicholas era. I'm with Jeremy Deller on this one.

Nirvana dominated grunge

When I think of grunge, I don't really think of Nirvana. Not that they weren't a 'grunge' band, indeed they WERE excellent and they were very much integral to it. But when I think of grunge now, I think of Pearl Jam, Alice In Chains and however many other plaid-shirted dudes with longhair you care to mention. Grunge's reputation immediately after Kurt's death was a bit of a mockery. 'Complaint Rock' 'Just dudes whining' 'Someone moping in a corner and then screaming like he's been hit over the head with a frying pan' etc...

in a way that no individual band did with Britpop though.

I think when people think of Britpop they think of two-three very specific pieces of iconography - Noel's Union Flag guitar being one of them. And as mentioned upthread, that whole Cool Britannia best-buds-with-Blair thing was the beginning of the end thanks largely to media saturation and the gargantuan egos of Albarn and Gallaghers.

The significant thing about Nirvana was that they were something the media didn't quite understand and couldn't control, rather than something they were gleeful participants in. Also come on, Nirvana >>>>>> any Britpop band.

Nirvana were perfectly marketable, whether they willed it or not the media were perfectly capable of promoting their music and creating a scene around them. Whether they were better or worse than the Britpop bands isn't relevant to anything.

I love this album. The only problem that I have with it is that it feels much, much colder to me that the albums that came immediately before and after it.

*that=than.

Is anyone willing to defend Crash and Carry?

it's 2020, I could just replace Crash and Carry with Petrol if I wanted. And I don't see any reason why I shouldn't.

"Crash and Carry" is great

what on earth is wrong with "crash and carry"

and why would you replace it with a track from in sides

Crash and Carry isn’t even among the lesser tracks on Sniviliasation, but in any event I wouldn’t change any of them, the album is about the shifts between sharply contrasting moods.

agreed

its definitely one of the lesser tracks but it's fairly catchy for what it is

"fairly catchy for what it is" is the best anyone's been able to come up with. zero people voted for it in the poll. it bangs on for 4:43. the main riff is too insistent to ignore, but doesn't have anything to say. some flute-like noises in the background try to create the illusion that something exciting is happening, like people hiding behind papier-mâché masks on sticks. it doesn't groove, it's not repetitive enough to trance out to - it lacks a rationale.

I like Crash and Carry. I had a great time driving too fast to it on a Florida summer night.

and why would you replace it with a track the worst track from in sides

I don't mind Crash And Carry but yes it's the weakest thing on the album (Quality Seconds is more fun and thankfully quite brief)

This has grown on me a lot in the last five years or so and Crash & Carry in particular.

It does feel like a holdover from the Brown Album but they probably surmised they needed at least one banger on there.

"Crash and Carry" isn't my favorite track on the album but it's in my top 3. Getting no votes in a "top choice only" poll doesn't mean no one likes it.

it doesn't groove, it's not repetitive enough to trance out to - it lacks a rationale.

that's kind of the point of it isn't it? every track on the album is weird. this one's a banger but it stutters around and trips up the beat. it's obviously not a key track on the album but without it I feel like it would be missing something.

it's in my top 3

that means you like it more than 3 of the following:

Forever
I Wish I Had Duck Feet
Kein Trink Wasser
Are We Here?
Attached

my post was a little extreme but you've gone round the bend

and why would you replace it with a track the worst track from in sides

that's true but it's essentially the same track as Crash and Carry, but better

the best album ever

as a drummer all the tiny snare rolls in "sad but true" give me a visceral thrill

I'm not a drummer but same

This album provided substantial levity and brightness to my days in high school, when little else did. Even now, it still acts as an emotional salve when I put it on.

really opened the doors for me to realize what electronic music was capable of. I still very vividly remember driving down the highway at the age of 17 and when "I Wish I Had Duck Feet" came on and it just blew my mind. nowadays its all about the last 2 tracks for me but obviously the whole thing is very much classic. crazy they haven't repressed it yet!!

It really is such a good album.

I'm curious as to what (if any) external sources what feels like such a leap forward from the Brown Album in terms of production and sound design. Snivilisation feels like such an archetypally mid-90s electronic album to me (in the sense of Bjork's Post) but it's hard to think of anything that pre-dated it that might have provided the template for it except in fairly loose or sparing senses (A Guy Called Gerald and other early jungle for "Are We Here?" for example). Though I suspect they listened to the first two Black Dog albums a bit.

* sources inspired what feels like...

Rapidly heading towards being 30 years old. Holy shit.

man how did they come up with this stuff. like "Are We Here?" dropping the main hook 10 minutes into the track, completely turning it from this crazy jungle build up to what sounds like an actual pop single, without really losing any of the stuff from the first part. that's such a cool way of thinking of a 15 minute epic.

my favorite song of theirs I think

the first version I ever heard was the "They Did It" remix

just like the original post, i was not ready to hear this album at the time. always thought InSides and the brown album were masterpieces; but this never caught on with me. and it is kinda of like an awkward in between album - but also very good. can't believe i didn't realize it's brilliance until 25 years later.

At least where I grew up, I remember hearing Are We Hear in DJ sets but *just* the early bits. I was extremely confused when I later saw the video for it and it was practically a different song.

I agree with the favorite song of theirs bit tho.

Kein Trink Wasser is my favourite Orbital track

this is the greatest album of all time

I rank In Sides over it but I think it’s their 2nd-best album

yeah I agree with that, here's how I break it down to an extent

In Sides > Snivilisation > Brown > Green > Middle of Nowhere > others