~~~ 2014 ILM METAL POLL TRACKS & ALBUMS COUNTDOWN! ~~~ (Tracks top 30 first then Albums)

Message Bookmarked
Bookmark Removed
Not all messages are displayed: show all messages (849 of them)

Two days ago, I mean. It's a ridiculous & staggering achievement and trust me I know a ridiculous & staggering achievement when I (rarely) hear it. Would have been my #2 had I voted

lovely cuddly fluffy dope (imago), Friday, 17 January 2014 18:49 (ten years ago) link

This got an impressive amount of support (see the #68 ranking in Pazz n Jop) for such a challenging album. I admire it more than lurve it. What, you didn't vote Imago? WTF!

Fastnbulbous, Friday, 17 January 2014 18:50 (ten years ago) link

that Gorguts album is so awesome, as were the several preceding it... a pretty great top ten so far, imo.

Viceroy, Friday, 17 January 2014 18:50 (ten years ago) link

he refused to

xp

pfunkboy (Algerian Goalkeeper), Friday, 17 January 2014 18:51 (ten years ago) link

I predict Amaranthe for number two.

J3ff T., Friday, 17 January 2014 18:52 (ten years ago) link

I decided I wasn't metal enough. Next year when I've heard more than 5 nominated albums maybe

lovely cuddly fluffy dope (imago), Friday, 17 January 2014 18:53 (ten years ago) link

betting AoP, Carcass, IS

Simon H., Friday, 17 January 2014 18:53 (ten years ago) link

too low for Gorguts

nakamura, Friday, 17 January 2014 18:54 (ten years ago) link

If you do you might hear more ridiculous and staggering achievements...

Fastnbulbous, Friday, 17 January 2014 18:54 (ten years ago) link

I'm surprised (but not too much so, considering the source) that ASG made the top 10. Good album, though.

Why is everyone so convinced that Altar of Plagues is going to be in the top three?

J3ff T., Friday, 17 January 2014 18:58 (ten years ago) link

(Which others in this top 10 might I enjoy btw?)

lovely cuddly fluffy dope (imago), Friday, 17 January 2014 18:59 (ten years ago) link

Windhand is amazing. Don't listen to EZ; it has some of the best dirty production of the year.

J3ff T., Friday, 17 January 2014 19:01 (ten years ago) link

I didn't vote for either in either poll but we be rad if Carcass and Gorguts made the reg ILX poll

the legend of rapper chance (Drugs A. Money), Friday, 17 January 2014 19:02 (ten years ago) link

we = wd

the legend of rapper chance (Drugs A. Money), Friday, 17 January 2014 19:02 (ten years ago) link

I'll have to double check but I think Carcass got my #1, I imagine a lot of people put it right near the top.

Viceroy, Friday, 17 January 2014 19:03 (ten years ago) link

IIRC Alter of Plagues didn't even make my top 20, there was just so much more awesome stuff this year!!

Viceroy, Friday, 17 January 2014 19:03 (ten years ago) link

Thought altar of plagues would at least have made the 101 but top 3...

a chance to cross is a chance to score (anonanon), Friday, 17 January 2014 19:05 (ten years ago) link

3 Altar Of Plagues - Teethed Glory And Injury, 798 Points, 22 Votes
http://i.imgur.com/3ubvcm9.jpg
http://open.spotify.com/album/3UtbJfUb7I1U4UdXIXdg3a
spotify:album:3UtbJfUb7I1U4UdXIXdg3a

http://www.deezer.com/album/6489118
#7 PopMatters, #20 Stereogum, #11 Rock-A-Rolla, #7 MetalSucks, #17 MetalSucks musicians, #36 Pitchfork, #2 Terrorizer, #633 Pazz & Jop

http://profoundlorerecords.bandcamp.com/album/teethed-glory-injury (Just $7.49 CAD!)
http://youtu.be/XEMpI2PjNQ0
theneedledrop - http://youtu.be/vwsM7UihYoY

Two years ago, Altar of Plagues frontman James Kelly talked about his band’s enormous black metal landscapes as though his Irish trio played free jazz: The group, he said, would lay dormant for extended periods and then work obsessively in an isolated, caffeine-fueled state for two-week bursts, using that sporadic schedule to create music that capitalized more on feeling than technicality. “With us, it’s almost let it write itself. That allows us to engage with it more, too, because it’s so repetitive,” Kelly said, explaining the oblong and unordinary structures of the four massive songs on Mammal, the band’s second LP. “We just let it grow.” Kelly also called Miles Davis’ Bitches Brew the most inspirational music he’d ever heard, compared Arvo Pärt to Emperor, mentioned his excellent muted dance productions under the name Wife, and called jazz “fire from the soul.”

Kelly’s references and enthusiasms did not adhere at all to any metal-dude stereotypes, and to an extent, that’s long been the fount of intrigue at the center of Altar of Plague’s music. Their post-metal, if one must call it that, took unexpected turns, with moments of ruthless industrial slink or minimal improvisations that turned suddenly to mournful throat signing embedded within more standard forms of aggression. They could roar, too, working themselves into sustained roils that gave any accusations of hipster or dilettante metal a direct and devastating gut punch.

Teethed Glory and Injury, the third LP from Altar of Plagues, is again intended to do exactly that but in a much different way than before. “I just found that the type of black metal we were being associated with was not exciting to me anymore,” Kelly told Terrorizer in an in-studio interview earlier this year. “What a few years ago was a very exciting and promising template for a genre … has also just been watered down.” Both Mammal and 2009’s White Tomb comprised just four tracks each, with the shortest pushing past the eight-minute mark. But Altar of Plagues pushes the action back toward the center of the song on Teethed Glory, a nine-piece set that favors a more immediate four-to-five minute range. This is a dense and demanding record, where fragments of black metal slam into shards of industrial throb, where sheets of noise work alongside diaphanous electronics. Moments suggest the heyday of Touch and Go Records and, alternately, Nine Inch Nails in Trent Reznor’s commanding prime or Swans at their vitriolic apex. Several electronic impasses are as dense as those of Altar of Plague cohorts the Haxan Cloak, while others could pass as tinted Boards of Canada fragments.

If that matrix of touchstones sounds intriguing, it often is; indeed, with Teethed Glory and Injury, Kelly’s reputation as an avid and eclectic listener feels fully represented by the music his band makes. However, the other alluring aspect of Altar of Plague’s music-- the jazz-like ease with which it was made and, consequently, unfolded-- has almost altogether disappeared. Every moment of Teethed Glory feels like a deliberate plot point, built to fly squarely in the face of any expectations for this brand of aggrandized heaviness. The omission of that free-and-easy mentality isn’t a problem because of the songs’ relative brevity; rather, the pieces within Teethed Glory often feel forced together, coerced into collisions that don’t meld the components so much as stack them side by side.

Altar of Plagues overthinks and overstuffs here, creating a gauntlet that defaces its own delight. “Burnt Year”, for instance, opens with an almost phosphorescent surge of distorted guitar and bass thrum, funneling into a belligerent, howl-along march that suggests the work of Ministry. By song’s end, Altar of Plagues has ripped through an atavistic black metal sprint, dipped into dreamy moments of rest and ultimately arrived at an instrumental surge that suggests the rocky peaks of Pelican. On “A Body Shrouded”, Altar of Plagues' seesaw between post-punk simmer and doom-like pounce adulterates both aspects. Individually, they’re interesting, but taken together, they simply feel claustrophobic. It’s a problem that hounds most of Teethed Glory, a string of compelling parts that does not compel as a whole

The album’s most successful songs are also its most fully synthesized: “Twelve was Ruin”, for instance, pairs Kelly’s blossoming electronic touch to Altar of Plagues' previous sense of sprawl and current sense of attack. It builds through icy keyboards and scythe-shaped guitars, culminating in a coda that’s urgent and intricate, two qualities that often combat one another throughout Teethed Glory. And the record’s first single, “God Alone”, is written so well that its most brutal stretches dovetail perfectly with its more delicate moments. It all cascades into a chorus that sounds as soft as Alcest but as savage as Immortal.

Though Teethed Glory and Injury doesn’t deliver the systemic and singular rupture Kelly and his band might have intended, it should not diminish the excitement for Altar of Plagues’ revolutionary compulsion. If anything, the trio have proven here that they’re driven only by the need to subvert and shock, to weld rather traditional ideas into strange new hybrids. The possibilities that Teethed Glory and Injury present are more interesting than the album itself--and, really, more interesting than the possibilities presented by any Altar of Plagues music to date. Maybe next time, they’ll write themselves into reality. - Grayson Currin, Pitchfork, http://pitchfork.com/reviews/albums/17854-altar-of-plagues-teethed-glory-and-injury/

Instrumental introductory tracks have been a staple of black metal albums since Bathory opened their self-titled début with the sound of a clock tower chiming in the northern wind while thunder rumbled ominously in the distance. The best tracks set the mood for the album to follow, truly opening it, like “Al Svartr” or “Ceasuri Rele.” The worst are explorations in ridiculous self-indulgence, like the symphonic bombast that opens every Cradle of Filth album or the pitch-shifted “Satan vocals” of early Teutonic black-thrash. Many of the more self-aware modern black metal bands have eschewed the instrumental intro, choosing instead to dive straight into the music that we’ve come to hear. Altar of Plagues has always been one of those bands, until now. Fortunately, the intro to Teethed Glory & Injury is among the best.

“Mills” is stuffed full of guitar feedback that sounds more like a violin being tortured to death. The track contains a remarkable amount of electronic noise and some intentionally rough loops that give the impression of the great gears and wheels of industry grinding away in Ireland. The highlight of the song, however, is a synthesized bass which we hear fold in upon itself from a beautiful sine wave to an excruciatingly passionate growl that transitions seamlessly into the pulsing guitars of “God Alone,” the first single. It is that pulse that defines this album, and anchors it to the work that Altar of Plagues has done in the past. It isn’t the cold 0/1 dichotomy of the modern digital world. It is a pulse; heart and lungs. A living thing. A seething eroticism. It slows and accelerates; it strengthens and weakens. It sometimes seems to fade away. But it is there, always, from “Mills” through the descriptively named album closer “Reflection Pulse Remains.”
Teethed Glory & Injury is only the Irish trio’s third full length, but their three EPs are each about thirty-five minutes long, which is six minutes longer than the average Anaal Nathrakh release, and even the song they released as a split with Year of No Light was over sixteen minutes. Simply put, Altar of Plagues has put out a lot of material since forming in 2006, and their sound has been well established. On Teethed Glory, however, Altar of Plagues seems to abandon everything that they’ve spent seven years perfecting. Gone is the four-song structure, gone are the quarter-hour plus track lengths. Gone even is the green-and-brown earth-tone palate that defined the band both visually and aurally. Instead we receive the stark black-and-white aesthetic of the modern dancer, the sterile landscape of the concrete jungle, and the thrum of electronic machinery. And yet, the signature sound of Altar of Plagues is still present. The distinctly organic wash of electric guitars that dominated their previous albums shines through the machinery and the passion and talent of the band has only increased.

“God Alone,” for which the band created the greatest metal music video since Triptykon’s “Shatter,” fully displays Altar’s new sound. The guitars and bass of James Kelly and Dave Condon have a wonderful growl to them that can only be achieved by real analogue tube amps, and they shriek and pulse with an alarm clock ferocity at times reminiscent of “Future Breed Machine” and at other times glide as smooth as glass. “God Alone” is an infectious song that you will not be able to get it out of your head. It isn’t the traditional frostbitten forests of the Norwegian TRVE, or even the verdant greenery of Altar of Plagues’ previous work. This new sound is distinctly urban and uniquely human. And lest you think that the introduction of heavy electronic samples would have in some way degraded the drums in some way, Johnny King serves up his most staggering performance yet, often infusing passages with polyrhythmic complexity that tears against the pulse of the album.

Both Kelly and Condon lend their voices to the music with a passionate dynamic that is missing from much of modern black metal. The clean vocals, although sparse, are delivered in waves that sound almost like another instrument, and not vocals expressing a message. This nebulous peace contrasts sharply with the harsh vocals, which could be nothing other than a message. Altar of Plagues has spent years singing about Mother Earth’s response to man. Now they’ve turned their attention to the men in their concrete cities, bereft of the care of their Mother. I can imagine that Kelly’s eyes must be bulging out of his head while he delivers the tortured lines “I watched my son buried” in “Burnt Year.”

Even though Altar of Plagues chose to divide Teethed Glory & Injury into nine separate tracks, it's more natural to view the the album as a complete work rather than as individual songs. The album is full of highlights, from the drum solo underneath a floor-shaking synth bass in “A Body Shrouded” to the octave-shifted guitars that create a near-lullaby feeling in “A Remedy and a Fever,” to the circular maelstrom of “Scald Scar of Water,” to the almost hardstyle breakdown in “Refection Pulse Remains,” Teethed Glory & Injury fascinates and astonishes. Don’t let this one just fade into the background. Sit down and take the fifty minutes to experience everything it has to offer, start to finish.

But still, a ten? It was slightly over a month ago that I gave a perfect score to Aosoth's Arrow In Heart, but the album just hit the streets two weeks ago. Perhaps I risk my credibility here by rating two albums so highly in such quick succession, and people will start saying "Oh, just give him some weird black metal. He'll love it." I don't think I'm that easy, though. After twenty years, it takes a lot to do something new within the confines of the genre. Dodecahedron did it, Blut Aus Nord tried it, but left the genre completely to do so. Even fewer bands do so flawlessly. Altar of Plagues is not the first band to add synthesizers, syncopation, and electronic manipulation to black metal, but the way in which they do it is unlike Emperor or Deathspell Omega or Aborym. If Aosoth is the flagbearer for TRVE Satanic black metal, Altar of Plagues is the humanist, stripping away fantasy and evil posturing to say "this music describes our daily lives."

Altar of Plagues realized that they had pushed their old sound to perfection with Mammal and made the bold choice to turn in an entirely new direction. Their ability to so evolve has probably only been matched by Blut Aus Nord, and that only because they’ve built a career around reinventing themselves. By introducing electronic elements and a never-ending pulse to their music, Altar of Plagues has crafted their most human record yet. Be moved. - Keith Ross, Last Rites, http://lastrit.es/reviews/6998/altar-of-plagues-teethed-glory---injury#sthash.egfAtaeS.dpuf

pfunkboy (Algerian Goalkeeper), Friday, 17 January 2014 19:10 (ten years ago) link

Oh. I guess that's why.

J3ff T., Friday, 17 January 2014 19:14 (ten years ago) link

2 In Solitude - Sister, 831 Points, 21 Votes, 2 #1s
http://i.imgur.com/CTjGigG.jpg
http://open.spotify.com/album/7dozEDYcswMbvJTnEBBLGU
spotify:album:7dozEDYcswMbvJTnEBBLGU

http://www.deezer.com/album/6956168

#2 Decibel, #1 PopMatters, #6 Stereogum, #13 MetalSucks musicians, #5 Captain Beyond Zen, #15 Pitchfork, #13 Metal Hammer, #5 Terrorizer, #89 Pazz & Jop

http://youtu.be/R4EiRvFHrCo

Before I started listening to this album, the first thing I thought of was: "funny they gave it the name Sister, there's an old Sonic Youth album with the same name!" But as it happens they are not a Pitchfork-friendly indie re-hash band, but a pure, no-nonsense heavy metal band from Sweden.

After an unusually compelling introduction on "He Comes", we are brought into a rocking, riff-laden hook-fest with "Death Knows Where". One strength that becomes immediately clear is Pelle Åhman's voice, which is perfectly suited for a classic heavy metal sound. His low-to-mid range allows him to sing in a way that's epic-sounding without coming off as silly.

For this achievement alone, the man probably deserves a medal. His voice reminded me of The Cult's Ian Astbury, My Dying Bride's Aaron Stainthorpe, or perhaps a less-mopey Robert Smith who decided to start singing for a metal band. In addition to this, I was extremely impressed with the rest of the band, especially Niklas Lindström and Henrik Palm's talent for crafting righteous riffs throughout the entire album.

Forgoing the blast beats and breakdowns common with much of contemporary metal, In Solitude relies on their ability to compose a great song with fully developed verses, choruses, and bridges that flow together in a very entertaining and compelling way. When I saw A Buried Sun come on, I was a little worried by the 7:22 song length. But to my pleasant surprise, the song was excellent from start to finish.

And in fact, I could probably say the same for the entire album, undeniably one of the essential releases of 2013. Though the album contains barely a blemish on it, my favorite song at the moment would have to be the title-track. The riffs spiral in your head, and the chorus lines echo around you:

And the hour begins
Night was no longer as we knew her
The ailing hour became the way
Sister, sister!
That said, I'm sure there are some readers who are rightly scared at the entire idea of a neo-classic heavy metal band, as it conjures images of bands who are either hopelessly derivative or simply unbearable in their cheesiness. Far from either of these terrible cliche's, In Solitude has somehow made the old, evil Mercyful Fate-style sound fresh all over again. They have great riffs, great melodies, memorable songs, and yes, that all-important quality: identity. And by that I mean that when you listen to them, you know who it is, and you're damn glad to hear it. - James Zalucky, Metal Injection, http://www.metalinjection.net/reviews/album-review-solitude-sister

Sister, the third album from young Swedish heavy metal band In Solitude, captures the group as they step out of the shadows of their fore bearers to stake a claim on their own patch of darkness. No longer can they be pegged as a Mercyful Fate tribute band. Their last album, 2011’s The World, the Flesh, the Devil, was such a successful channeling of the classic early work of those Danes that it was eerie to behold. That prior album could only be heard in terms of heavy metal as defined in 1984. Sister, on the other hand, has inroads into goth, death rock, post-punk and more, and yet stays tremendously attached to its metal roots.

Recorded at Stockholm’s Studio Cobra by producer Martin “Konie” Ehrencrona, Sister sounds like neither a typical modern nor retro-metal album. Ehrencrona, known in Sweden primarily for film and television soundtracks, has never before produced or mixed a heavy metal band. What he’s done when given the chance is astonishing. Rarely has an album so dark in content been so warm and open to the ears. It’s a soft mix, with rounded highs and full, resonant bass. Whether played loudly in a cement-floored club full of beer drinking metalheads or quietly through headphones alone in a darkened bedroom, Sister beckons the ear and is a captivating listen from start to finish.

A great deal of Sister‘s malevolent charm comes from Pelle Åhman. In the past, he was beholden to the low- to mid-range delivery of Mercyful Fate’s King Diamond, but here he expands both his influences and his style and has found his own voice. His singing on this album is its biggest revelation. From the softest croon to gutsiest howls he’s ever recorded, Åhman sounds confident, assured, and strangely free. He’s no longer just the singer but a front man, able to direct the listener, hold attention, and carry a song with only his delivery. He fearlessly takes chances and succeeds every time. For example, on “A Buried Sun” he manages to pull off both a Danzig-esque purling and a soul-bearing howl that is reminiscent of Nick Cave. Few would be so audacious.

It’s not just Pelle Åhman that has broken out of the proverbial shackles. As a band, In Solitude has made huge strides toward finding their own distinct sound. Though there are moments where the music is a bit too reminiscent of another artist—opening track “He Comes” could be the best track Mission U.K. never thought to record—those are the exceptions to their successful hybridization. Album centerpiece “Pallid Hands” is not only the best song In Solitude has written, but its mix of Killing Joke post-punk assault (accentuated by Pelle Åhman summoning a touch of Jaz Coleman’s feral power) meshes perfectly with the chugging rhythm straight from the New Wave of British Heavy Metal. If ever a song could be called galloping goth this is it.

Yet there is more to In Solitude’s growth than just incorporating sounds outside of metal’s standard lineage. They’ve also drawn deeper from metal’s past. The retro-rock hearts of “Lavender” and “Horses in the Ground” show the strength of those classic sounds, without falling prey to the trap of slavish recreation that has, sadly, become the norm for any who venture too close to 1972. Throughout the album, guitarists Niklas Lindström and Henrik Palm explore a broad variety of tones and styles outside their prior wheelhouse built by Mercyful Fate’s Hank Shermann and Michael Denner. There are moments of harmonic interplay reminiscent of Judas Priest’s K.K. Downing and Glen Tipton, and tonal nods to the classic Scorpions pairings of both Uli Jon Roth and Matthias Jabs with Rudolf Schenker.

With Sister, In Solitude did the one thing that seems unforgivable in the increasingly orthodox world of metal. They changed. Yet few, if any, who choose to listen will find those changes a step in the wrong direction. For Sister is the sound of a band growing and coming into their own, drawing on disparate influences inside and outside the genre. They’ve taken Fate into their own hands and in the process made one of the best records of the year. - Erik Highter, PopMatters, http://www.popmatters.com/review/175947-in-solitude-sister/

pfunkboy (Algerian Goalkeeper), Friday, 17 January 2014 19:30 (ten years ago) link

So I guess Amaranthe is going to be number one, then?

J3ff T., Friday, 17 January 2014 19:32 (ten years ago) link

Set the Nexus free at last!

glenn mcdonald, Friday, 17 January 2014 19:33 (ten years ago) link

The In Solitude is great, though. Good choice, nerds.

J3ff T., Friday, 17 January 2014 19:35 (ten years ago) link

Yeah Sister is an incredible album. It was in my top five.

Viceroy, Friday, 17 January 2014 19:35 (ten years ago) link

Who's this "Erik Highter" guy people keep quoting? His credentials seem suspect.

J3ff T., Friday, 17 January 2014 19:42 (ten years ago) link

1 Carcass - Surgical Steel, 1,121 Points, 27 Votes, 8 #1s
http://i.imgur.com/IixBSRd.jpg
http://open.spotify.com/album/7ncsoREb5KN50j3wfJ2peo
spotify:album:7ncsoREb5KN50j3wfJ2peo

http://www.deezer.com/album/6926167

#6 Revolver, #1 Decibel, #5 SPIN, #3 PopMatters, #5 Stereogum, #8 Rock-A-Rolla, #1 MetalSucks, #1 MetalSucks musicians, #14 Obelisk readers, #11 Stoner HiVe, #8 Pitchfork, #2 Metal Hammer, #1 Terrorizer, #37 Pazz & Jop

http://youtu.be/IrvOIeMTSwM
"Unfit For Human Consumption" - http://youtu.be/5KKYJD09qCk
coverkillernation - http://youtu.be/Jztbkx8D7Ss

Reek of Perfection

As time passes by and popular trends cycle and mutate, the internal and external pressure pressed upon respected bands who begin to write music after lengthy sabbaticals increases significantly. This pressure piles up because the chance of a great “comeback” album is about as rare as catching a rational soundbite coming from the mouth of Dave Mustaine these day, and the fruit of the band’s labors usually highlights their middle-aged fallibility; consequentially the “comeback” album slots unremarkably behind the classics and in front of the glaring horrors of their discography. How bands handle this pressure when writing a “comeback” speaks a multitude about the intestinal fortitude of the musicians involved, and whether they cope with the pressure (not to mention whether their technical abilities still stand up) will ultimately inform the quality of the end result. To what degree of pressure death metal legends Carcass suffered from in the run up to their first album in 17 years is unknown, but judging by Surgical Steel’s incisive and instantaneously memorable songs, the band has taken the weight of anticipation by the scruff of the neck and torn it limb from tattered limb.

Carcass’s colossal role in fathering repugnant genres such as grindcore, death metal, and melo-death needs little explanation, as the (medical) textbook according to Carcass has been plagiarized, bastardized, and capitalized upon by a horde of bands that formed in Carcass’s absence. So, as much as Sabbath directly or indirectly influenced every metal band that has (dis)graced our ears since the release of their earth-shaking eponymous debut, Carcass has arguably inspired just as many extreme metal bands with the band’s run of Earache classics: the John Peel-approved gore of their first two albums and the band’s landmark releases Necroticism: Descanting the Insalubrious (1991) and Heartwork (1993), which followed.

Thousands will tell you that 1993’s Heartwork was the last real Carcass album, as the band’s final studio album before splintering, 1996’s Swansong, has been literally tossed into the same discount bin as Celtic Frost’s Cold Lake and Cryptopsy’s The Unspoken King. The reason why fans rejected Swansong back when it was released is still the point of much debate, and metal-heads who still haven’t even heard the album continue to jump upon the bandwagon to label the album a disaster because of its reputation alone. Swansong, for all its supposed failings (which seem to be mostly centered on the reality that metal fans weren’t ready for the rock-centric version of Carcass), still has plenty to applaud (a topic for another time), and the catchiness of Swansong informs Surgical Steel’s immediacy, whether haters can hear it or not. Songs like “A Congealed Clot of Blood” and the dominant “The Granulating Dark Satanic Mills” both wield the same kind of persistent vocal hooks that confused so many back in ‘96, but the difference this time around is that the music backing vocalist/bassist Jeff Walker’s gut-busting hooks gleams with the razor sharp metallic edge of Carcass’s prime period between 1991 and 1993.

Carcass’s intention for this “comeback” album is clearly to emphasize everything that fans loved about the band, as well as revitalize their style to show those who have stolen their riffs by the cadaver-full how it’s done. The sly wit and ingenious wordplay of Walker delivered with his signature throat-scraping intensity and guitarist/vocalist Bill Steer’s pinpoint melodic soloing and vicious riffs, which are extreme metal serrated and steeped in heavy metal classicism, are perfectly in place. Driving all this forward is drummer Dan Wilding (ex-Aborted, amongst others), who shows real commitment to honoring the loose yet puncturing style that drummer Ken Owen would have brought to the record were he physically able to contribute. But not only that, the 24-year-old Wilding injects the likes of “The Master Butcher’s Apron” with a lethal dose of blasting rhythmic force consistent with the enthusiasm and schooled abilities of a young metal drummer with a point to prove and legends to appease.

Owen is still involved in Surgical Steel and he contributes some backing vocals and acts as a surgical advisor, and in the case of “1985” and “Thrasher’s Abattoir”, Carcass reaches fully back in time to the band’s days living on Margaret Thatcher’s breadline, with an opening pair of songs ripped and reformed from an early Carcass demo and given a 2013 polish courtesy of Colin Richardson (production) and Andy Sneap (mixing and mastering). Richardson and Sneap are another essential part of the success of Surgical Steel, as their slick touch has made Carcass sound exactly like latter-day Carcass should—those who were hoping for Symphonies of Sickness slop ought to reconsider a few life choices. Thus, this record sounds like ‘90s Carcass without being forcibly so and there is just the right amount of contemporary sheen.

The fact that Michael Amott (Arch Enemy, Spiritual Beggars), who played on heavyweights Necroticism and Heartwork, did not contribute to this album is a massive point to consider. The reason being: it is clear by the stature of the songwriting on Surgical Steel that while Amott did play a substantial role in Carcass’s legacy, his input in the year 2013 is non-essential. Steer and Walker bandied together as an imposing songwriting team and have written to Carcass’s bloody blueprint, whether it be the twisted chugging riffs, sickly blasts, and grandstanding solos of the ridiculously titled “Noncompliance to ASTM F 899-12 Standard”, the sheer rush of thrash metal on “316 L Grade Surgical Steel”, or even the choice cut of Rust in Peace-era Megadeth fed through the teeth of a meat-grinder that is “Unfit for Human Consumption”. And from the opening strains of lead guitar on “1985” to the fade out of the truly ‘90s sounding, eight-minute finale “Mount of Execution”, each moment has been crafted and placed with supreme precision and sounds pleasingly familiar yet as fresh as an hour-old corpse.

The biggest impression that Surgical Steel imparts is that this album has been fun to make for those involved. It is the sound of veterans who have been away from the genre that made their names creating the kind of music that fueled their youth and defined them, and doing so with a steely eye on the fact that they have a legacy to maintain and some naysayers to silence. To this effect, Surgical Steel is everything that Black Sabbath’s 13 was not. This is the metal album of 2013, and proof that Carcass still hold the tools of the trade to show all and sundry how to write a winning (“comeback”) album. - Dean Brown, PopMatters, http://www.popmatters.com/review/175492-carcass-surgical-steel/

Like football fans have certain dates marked on their calendars for potentially colossal matches, death metal fans have September 17th swirled within a blood red circle, heralding the new album from British grind-gore lords, CARCASS. As we can never have Chuck Schuldiner and DEATH back, then let chaos reign upon the formidable shoulders of CARCASS. Their new album "Surgical Steel" is what death metal pundits have been chalking their hopes on. Fret not, pundits. Only bassist/vocalist Jeff Walker and guitarist Bill Steer remain from the original lineup, but "Surgical Steel" is all that and a gleaming rachiotome ready to pare.

While Michael Amott and Daniel Erlandsson hung around for a five year interim when CARCASS officially reunited in 2007, they've made ARCH ENEMY their priority. TRIGGER THE BLOODSHED's Daniel Wilding and PIG IRON/DESOLATION/LIQUEFIED SKELTON guitarist Ben Ash have since stepped in their place, and their additions compensate huge.

For the band's first recorded output in 17 years since 1996's "Swansong", CARCASS makes no pretentions about where their future lies. "Surgical Steel" logically sits next to "Swansong" and 1993's celebrated "Heartwork". Likewise, everything on the new album is traded between grinding force and mid-tempo stomp, all delivered with dominant craftsmanship and a premeditated link to CARCASS' past.

The shivery cover art alone is reminiscent of their '92 EP "Tools of the Trade", while the lush opening instrumental "1985" is not just a nod back to the year of CARCASS' birth, it's so eloquent and unearthly you'll feel not so much graced by its presence as propelled somewhere out of this existence.

Immediately thereafter comes the letter-perfect "Thrasher's Abattoir", a blistering rework of a vault track from "A Bomb Drops", a demo when the core elements of CARCASS (Bill Steer, Paul and former drummer Ken Owen) were known as DISATTACK. The drums lance and gallop in varying sets of thrash and grind patterns while Steer and Ash's riffing is so precise they amaze beyond expectation. A whirlwind guitar solo touches in the eye of the storm, providing elegance to the manic brutality. What CARCASS had done prior to their split in 1996 was to refine death metal and grind to nearly the same effects as DEATH. "Thrasher's Abattoir" 2013 is so flawless one can hardly imagine anything getting within its league, no matter the level of experience.

Consider the same retracting excellence applied to the next song, "Cadaver Pouch Conveyor System". You can literally feel the layers being peeled by Jeff Walker's prolonged ralphs and yelps while the band slices away with thrashing evisceration. Only slowing things down enough to deliver a punctuated breakdown and solo sequence (metalcore holdouts, take note), the vigor of "Thrasher's Abattoir" and "Cadaver Pouch Conveyor System" will beat you blind, stand by.

CARCASS allows their listeners to catch their breaths with "A Congealed Clot of Blood", which might be as apropos a title as one can come up with to describe a song that marches then crawls through its coagulating solo segment. Nevertheless, expect some nifty back beats and rumbling bass drum kicks along with defined chugs to keep the song moving lithely. Next, "The Master Butcher's Apron" is one of the most hectic songs of the album, always threatening to jettison but skidding each time on the fourth mark of the successive grind rips. The blitzed-out payoff comes later after a wallowing solo section and yet CARCASS continues to employ a brilliant halting scheme every time they hit the gas on this track. By the time they're done teasing, you're in full headbang mode with a glorious solo swirling overtop the crunching pace.

Prepare to be amazed once again by the exquisite guitar flushes on the opening of "Noncompliance to ASTM F 899-12 Standard" and the spiraling fastidiousness of "Captive Bolt Pistol". If you want to simply cut to the chase, "Surgical Steel" is master's degree material all the way through.

Bill Steer has not just found a new supplement with Ben Ash, he has full extension of his abilities since Ash is equally dexterous. Daniel Wielding gives a technical clinic in all modes of blast and grind. With Jeff Walker's veteran shrieks and yowls and bottom-end tornados, CARCASS are as fearsome as ever. Better yet, they remain at the height of their talents, as if it's 1997 instead of 2013. Endpoint, "Surgical Steel" will be a lock for many metalheads' year-end best lists. - Ray Van Horn, Jr. - Blabbermouth, http://www.blabbermouth.net/cdreviews/surgical-steel/#wslmFSj0Y1L0072Y.99

Spotify Albums Playlist

Big thanks to my co-runner fastnbulbous especially for providing all the blurbs and also to seandalai for tabulating the results. And thanks to all who nominated/voted and took part in the countdown.

Remember you can still vote in ILM 2013 | End of Year Albums & Tracks Poll | VOTING THREAD (Voting closes MIDNIGHT EST on Friday, January 17th, 2014)

pfunkboy (Algerian Goalkeeper), Friday, 17 January 2014 19:48 (ten years ago) link

Great job AG!

J3ff T., Friday, 17 January 2014 19:48 (ten years ago) link

now that's a blowout, holy shit!

thanks AG!

Simon H., Friday, 17 January 2014 19:49 (ten years ago) link

Thanks to the poll runners and all the voters! Another great year & another great poll!

Viceroy, Friday, 17 January 2014 19:49 (ten years ago) link

Wow, I didn't even look at the point spread – yeah, that wasn't even close.

J3ff T., Friday, 17 January 2014 19:50 (ten years ago) link

Who's this "Erik Highter" guy people keep quoting? His credentials seem suspect.

He's a hack.

Excellent job, gents.

EZ Snappin, Friday, 17 January 2014 19:55 (ten years ago) link

Yeah, that was rude of me to leave FNB and Sean out of my thanks – thanks for putting the effort in, guys!

J3ff T., Friday, 17 January 2014 20:02 (ten years ago) link

My pleasure. Man, Carcass. Who knew when it first came out that they'd dominate like this? When I first listened to Reek of Putrefaction back in '88, I was delighted, but assumed they would stay very, very underground. But they were truly innovators, and despite the widespread hatred of Swansong (1996), the metal community really gave these guys a warm welcome back.

Fastnbulbous, Friday, 17 January 2014 20:08 (ten years ago) link

feel free to post your ballots in here

Atlantean Kodex - The White Goddess
ASG - Blood Drive
SubRosa - More Constant Than the Gods
Melt-Banana - Fetch
Kylesa - Ultraviolet
Fen - Dustwalker
Shining - One One One
Morne - Shadows
Altar of Plagues - Teethed Glory and Injury
Beastmilk - Climax
Windhand - Soma
Carcass - Surgical Steel
In Solitude - Sister
Jesu - Everyday I Get Closer To The Light
Hell - Curse & Chapter
Queens Of The Stone Age - Like Clockwork
Vaura - The Missing
Church Of Misery - Thy Kingdom Scum
Coliseum - Sister Faith
Moss-Horrible Nights
Deafheaven - Sunbather
Ghost - Infestissumam
The Ocean - Pelegial
Trouble - The Distortion Field
True Widow - Circumambulation
Ulver - Messe I.X-VI.X
Follakzoid - II
Ellende - Ellende
Summoning - Old Mornings Dawn
Earthless - From the Ages
Arckanum - Fenris Kindir
Jute Gyte -Discontinuities
Obelyskkh - Hymn to Pan
The Body - Christs, Redeemers
Sungod - Contakt
MUTation - Error 500
Manilla Road - Mysterium
Monster Magnet - Last Patrol
Lumbar - The First and Last Days of Unwelcome
Indricothere - II
Gnaw - Horrible Chamber
Castevet - Obsian
Age Of Taurus - Desperate Souls Of Tortured Times
Argus - Beyond the Martyrs
Bardo Pond - Peace on Venus
Oranssi Pazuzu - Valonielu
Orchid - The Mouths Of Madness
Raspberry Bulbs - Deformed Worship
VHOL - Vhol
Vista Chino - Peace

pfunkboy (Algerian Goalkeeper), Friday, 17 January 2014 20:11 (ten years ago) link

Thanks again to AG for doing most of the work. This whole enterprise was nearly dead and he busted out the defibrillator and shocked it back to life.

Fastnbulbous, Friday, 17 January 2014 20:13 (ten years ago) link

How bout 102+ list?

Fastnbulbous, Friday, 17 January 2014 20:15 (ten years ago) link

I can post it but wasn't sure if I should include usernames of those who voted certain albums #1 on their list.

Fastnbulbous, Friday, 17 January 2014 20:16 (ten years ago) link

Full List of Results


1    carcass - surgical steel    1121.0    27    8      
2    in solitude - sister    831.0    21    2       
3    altar of plagues - teethed glory and injury    798.0    22    0   
4    gorguts - colored sands    779.0    19    2       
5    subrosa - more constant than the gods    741.0    19    2       
6    windhand - soma    732.0    19    1        knaaq
7    uncle acid and the deadbeats - mind control    707.0    20    2       
8    melt-banana - fetch    686.0    18    1        matt
9    asg - blood drive    668.0    17    0   
10    deafheaven - sunbather    666.0    18    3       
11    kylesa - ultraviolet    637.0    18    1       
12    atlantean kodex - the white goddess    615.0    15    1       
13    avatarium - avatarium    613.0    16    1        Paul R
14    darkthrone - the underground resistance    597.0    17    0   
15    nails - abandon all life    561.0    16    1       
16    hell - curse and chapter    560.0    14    1      
17    queens of the stone age - like clockwork    557.0    15    1       
18    beastmilk - climax    529.0    15    1       
19    ghost - infestissumam    502.0    15    0   
20    summoning - old mornings dawn    500.0    14    0   
21    oranssi pazuzu - valonielu    477.0    14    0   
22    gris - a lame enflammee lame constellee    466.0    13    0   
23    vhol - vhol    453.0    12    1      
24    jesu - everyday i get closer to the light    436.0    14    0   
25    vaura - the missing    419.0    14    0   
26    shining - one one one    418.0    13    0   
27    blood ceremony - the eldritch dark    416.0    12    0   
28    inter arma - sky burial    408.0    12    0   
29    moss - horrible night    401.0    11    0   
30    jute gyte - discontinuities    393.0    10    0   
31    satan - life sentence    386.0    11    0   
32    follakzoid - ii    383.0    10    0   
33    bardo pond - peace on venus    377.0    12    0   
34    kvelertak - meir    375.0    12    0   
35    anciients - heart of oak    370.0    11    0   
36    earthless - from the ages    368.0    11    1       
37    inquisition - obscure verses for the multiverse    362.0    10    0   
38    pinkish black - razed to the ground    358.0    9    0   
39    church of misery - thy kingdom scum    335.0    11    0   
40    manilla road - mysterium    326.0    10    0   
41    castevet - obsian    325.0    11    0   
42    paysage dhiver - das tor    316.0    9    1       
43    body - christs redeemers    307.0    8    0   
44    power trip - manifest decimation    303.0    9    1       
45    black sabbath - 13    294.0    10    1       
46    stara rzeka - cien chmury nad ukrytym polem    287.0    7    3       
47    portal - vexovoid    282.0    8    0   
48    vista chino - peace    276.0    9    0   
49    progenie terrestre pura - uma    275.0    7    1       
50    voivod - target earth    266.0    7    0   
51    cathedral - the last spire    263.0    8    0   
52    fen - dustwalker    261.0    9    0   
53    ocean - pelegial    261.0    8    0   
54    morne - shadows    259.0    8    0   
55    autopsy - the headless ritual    258.0    9    0   
56    ulcerate - vermis    258.0    8    0   
57    kadavar - abra kadavar    253.0    7    1       
58    aeternus - and the seventh his soul detesteth    251.0    6    0   
59    argus - beyond the martyrs    248.0    9    0   
60    coliseum - sister faith    247.0    8    0   
61    orchid - the mouths of madness    244.0    8    0   
62    ruins of beverast - blood vaults: the blazing gospel of heinrich kramer    243.0    6    1       
63    amon amarth - deceiver of the gods    240.0    7    0   
64    raspberry bulbs - deformed worship    238.0    7    0   
65    tribulation - the formulas of death    230.0    7    0   
66    indricothere - ii    228.0    8    0   
67    bolzer - aura    225.0    6    0   
67    cloud rat - moksha    225.0    6    0   
69    ken mode - entrench    223.0    8    0   
70    cult of fire - ???????????????????    223.0    7    0   
71    mutation - error 500    221.0    6    1        L
72    coffins - the fleshland    219.0    6    0   
72    true widow - circumambulation    219.0    6    0   
74    exhumed - necrocracy    216.0    6    0   
75    magic circle - magic circle    214.0    5    1       
76    intronaut - habitual levitations (instilling words with tones)    208.0    7    0   
77    agrimonia - rites of separation    208.0    6    1       
78    hey colossus - cuckoo live life like cuckoo    205.0    6    0   
79    clutch - earth rocker    205.0    5    0   
80    russian circles - memorial    204.0    6    0   
81    purson - the circle and the blue door    202.0    5    0   
82    suffocation - pinnacle of bedlam    196.0    7    0   
83    mammoth grinder - underworlds    193.0    6    1       
84    obelyskkh - hymn to pan    184.0    6    0   
85    sungod - contakt    178.0    6    0   
85    ulver - messe ix-vix    178.0    6    0   
87    batillus - concrete sustain    173.0    6    1       
88    palms - palms    169.0    6    0   
89    deveykus - pillar without mercy    168.0    7    1       
90    baptists - bushcraft    167.0    5    0   
91    cult of luna - vertikal    166.0    6    0   
92    ataraxie - letre et la nausee    166.0    5    0   
93    lumbar - the first and last days of unwelcome    164.0    7    0   
94    ovo - abisso    163.0    6    0   
95    obliteration - black death horizon    162.0    4    0   
96    goatess - goatess    158.0    4    1       
97    sahg - delusions of grandeur    155.0    5    0   
98    corrections house - last city zero    154.0    5    0   
99    woe - withdrawal    153.0    4    0   
100    watain - the wild hunt    150.0    5    0   
101    monster magnet - last patrol    146.0    6    0   
102    noisem - agony defined    146.0    5    0   
103    gnaw - horrible chamber    143.0    5    0   
104    orphaned land - all is one    143.0    4    0   
105    naam - vow    142.0    4    0   
106    age of taurus - desperate souls of tortured times    141.0    7    0   
107    shooting guns - brotherhood of the ram    139.0    4    0   
108    peste noire - peste noire    138.0    5    0   
109    brimstone coven - ii    138.0    4    0   
110    full of hell - rudiments of mutilation    136.0    4    0   
111    pissed jeans - honeys    136.0    3    1       
112    trouble - the distortion field    135.0    5    0   
113    beyond - fatal power of death    133.0    3    0   
114    blockheads - the world is dead    128.0    4    0   
115    ensemble pearl - ensemble pearl    128.0    3    0   
116    cultes des ghoules - henbane    126.0    4    0   
117    kayo dot - hubardo    124.0    4    0   
118    arabrot - arabrot    123.0    4    0   
119    aevangelist - omen ex simulacra    123.0    3    1       
120    rotting christ - kata ton daimona eaytoy    121.0    6    0   
121    motorhead - aftershock    119.0    5    0   
122    immolation - kingdom of conspiracy    117.0    4    0   
123    body - master we perish (ep)    113.0    3    0   
124    celeste - animale(s)    110.0    4    0   
125    ellende - ellende    109.0    5    0   
126    toxic holocaust - chemistry of consciousness    107.0    4    0   
127    ihsahn - das seelenbrechen    106.0    4    0   
128    red fang - whales and leeches    105.0    3    0   
129    secrets of the sky - to sail black waters    101.0    3    0   
130    corsair - corsair    99.0    3    0   
131    primitive man - scorn    98.0    3    0   
132    skeletonwitch - serpents unleashed    95.0    4    0   
133    aosoth - iv: an arrow in heart    93.0    3    0   
134    shitfucker - sucks cocks in hell    92.0    4    1       
135    pelican - forever becoming    92.0    3    0   
136    wolf people - fain    91.0    2    0   
137    bombus - the poet and the parrot    88.0    3    0   
138    seremonia - ihminen    87.0    3    0   
139    acid mothers temple and the melting paraiso ufo - in search of the lost divine arc    87.0    2    0   
140    lustre - wonder    86.0    2    0   
141    cult of dom keller - the cult of dom keller    85.0    2    0   
142    omnium gatherum - beyond    83.0    3    0   
143    iceage - youre nothing    83.0    2    1       
144    abyssal - novit enim dominus qui sunt eius    83.0    2    0   
144    nonexistence - antarctica    83.0    2    0   
146    grave miasma - odori sepulcrorum    82.0    3    0   
147    barbez - bella ciao    82.0    2    0   
148    horisont - time warriors    81.0    4    0   
148    vattnet viskar - sky swallower    81.0    4    0   
150    lycus - tempest    81.0    3    0   
151    fates warning - darkness in a different light    81.0    2    0   
152    enshine - origin    80.0    2    0   
153    amaranthe - the nexus    79.0    3    0   
154    amorphis - circle    78.0    2    0   
155    arckanum - fenris kindir    76.0    3    0   
156    bone sickness - alone in the grave    76.0    2    0   
157    jex thoth - blood moon rise    75.0    3    0   
158    hawkeyes - poison slows you down    75.0    2    0   
159    pest - the crowning horror    74.0    2    0   
159    usnea - usnea    74.0    2    0   
161    arsaidh - roots    73.0    3    0   
162    satans wrath - aeons of satans reign    73.0    2    1       
163    shining - 8 1/2 feberdrommar i vaket tillstan    72.0    4    0   
164    beastwars - blood becomes fire    71.0    4    0   
165    yellow eyes - hammer of night    71.0    2    0   
166    black capricorn - born under the capricorn    70.0    2    0   
166    hessian - manegarmr    70.0    2    0   
168    falkenbach - asa    69.0    2    0   
169    doomriders - grand blood    68.0    3    0   
170    devil - gather the sinners    68.0    2    0   
171    a storm of light - nations to flames    66.0    2    0   
171    twilight of the gods - fire on the mountain    66.0    2    0   
171    vastum - patricidal lust    66.0    2    0   
174    weekend nachos - still    64.0    3    0   
175    noctum - final sacrifice    64.0    2    0   
176    all pigs must die - nothing violates this nature    62.0    2    0   
177    cauchemar - tenebrario    61.0    2    0   
178    byzantine - byzantine    60.0    2    0   
179    locrian - return to annihilation    59.0    2    0   
180    csejthe - reminiscence    58.0    2    0   
181    wolvserpent - perigaea antahkarana    57.0    2    0   
182    altaar - altaar    56.0    2    0   
182    fall of every season - amends    56.0    2    0   
184    nice hooves - nice hooves    55.0    2    0   
184    meads of asphodel - sonderkommando    55.0    2    0   
186    mouth of the architect - dawning    54.0    3    0   
187    nero di marte - nero di marte    53.0    2    0   
188    ampacity - encounter one    51.0    2    0   
189    (victor griffins) in-graved - (victor griffins) in-graved    50.0    2    0   
189    caladan brood - echoes of battle    50.0    2    0   
191    ovids withering - scryers of the ibis    50.0    1    1       
191    pentagram chile - the malefice    50.0    1    1       
193    cosmic church - ylistys    49.0    2    0   
194    endless boogie - long island    49.0    1    0   
195    germ - grief    48.0    2    0   
195    iron man - south of the earth    48.0    2    0   
195    magister templi - lucifer leviathan logos    48.0    2    0   
195    rosetta - the anaesthete    48.0    2    0   
199    concrete cross - concrete cross    48.0    1    0   
200    pestilence - obsideo    46.0    2    0   
201    devil - the devil lp    46.0    1    0   
201    sacriphyx - the western front    46.0    1    0   
203    dark tranquility - construct    45.0    2    0   
203    sofy major - idolize    45.0    2    0   
205    ancient shores - the overwhelming wave    45.0    1    0   
205    erang - another world another time    45.0    1    0   
205    obscure sphinx - void mother    45.0    1    0   
205    wormlust - the feral wisdom    45.0    1    0   
209    ancient shores - cynarae    44.0    1    0   
209    phantom glue - a war of light cones    44.0    1    0   
209    strzepy - smierc we mnie nicosc poza mna    44.0    1    0   
212    lesbian - forestelevision    43.0    2    0   
212    sinister realm - world of evil    43.0    2    0   
214    hacride - back to where youve never been    42.0    2    0   
214    mutoid man - helium head    42.0    2    0   
214    white wizzard - the devils cut    42.0    2    0   
217    a fall of every season - amends    42.0    1    0   
217    kultura kureniya - ??????????    42.0    1    0   
217    transient - transient    42.0    1    0   
220    entrails - raging death    41.0    1    0   
220    grime - deteriorate    41.0    1    0   
220    profanatica - thy kingdom cum    41.0    1    0   
223    gog - ironworks    40.0    1    0   
224    holy grail - ride into the void    39.0    2    0   
225    blindead - absence    39.0    1    0   
225    call of the void - dragged down a dead end path    39.0    1    0   
225    selim lemouchi and his enemies - earth air spirit water fire    39.0    1    0   
228    botanist - ep 1: the hanging gardens of hell    38.0    2    0   
229    impalers - impalers    38.0    1    0   
229    wounded giant - lightning medicine    38.0    1    0   
229    zodiac - a hiding place    38.0    1    0   
232    reproacher - nothing to save    37.0    1    0   
233    mountain witch - cold river    35.0    2    0   
233    sivyj yar - the dawns were drifting as before    35.0    2    0   
235    tentacle - ingot eye    35.0    1    0   
236    church of void - dead rising    34.0    1    0   
236    demon lung - the hundredth name    34.0    1    0   
236    imperium dekadenz - meadows of nostalgia    34.0    1    0   
236    jucifer - the russian album    34.0    1    0   
236    lycia - quiet moments    34.0    1    0   
236    wedrujacy wiatr - tam gdzie miesiac op?akuje swit    34.0    1    0   
242    newsted - heavy metal music    33.0    2    0   
243    havok - unnatural selection    33.0    1    0   
243    tengger cavalry - the expedition    33.0    1    0   
245    earthen grave - earthen grave    32.0    2    0   
246    old wounds - from where we came is where well rest    32.0    1    0   
247    finntroll - blodvsept    31.0    2    0   
248    abandoned places - giantlands    31.0    1    0   
248    ephemeros - all hail corrosion    31.0    1    0   
248    officium triste - mors viri    31.0    1    0   
248    shooting guns - spectral laundromat    31.0    1    0   
252    convulse - evil prevails    30.0    1    0   
252    dead in the dirt - the blind hole    30.0    1    0   
252    honduran - street eagles    30.0    1    0   
255    at devil dirt - plan b: sin revolucion no hay evolucion    29.0    1    0   
256    angizia - des winters finsterer gesell    28.0    1    0   
256    noothgrush/coffins - split    28.0    1    0   
258    death angel - the dream calls for blood    27.0    1    0   
258    haken - the mountain    27.0    1    0   
260    meek is murder - everything is awesome nothing matters    26.0    1    0   
260    prophecy - salvation    26.0    1    0   
262    zatokrev - the bat the wheel and the long road to nowhere    25.0    2    0   
263    de arma - lost alien and forlorn    25.0    1    0   
263    mansion - we shall live    25.0    1    0   
263    secrets - fragile figures    25.0    1    0   
263    thy light - no morrow shall dawn    25.0    1    0   
267    joel grind - the yellowgoat sessions    24.0    1    0   
267    reptilian death - the dawn of consummation and emergence    24.0    1    0   
267    seidr - ginnungagap    24.0    1    0   
270    fall city fall - victus    23.0    1    0   
270    persefone - spiritual migration    23.0    1    0   
270    sombres forets - la mort du soleil    23.0    1    0   
273    killswitch engage - disarm the descent    22.0    2    0   
274    author and punisher - women and children    22.0    1    0   
274    terra tenebrosa - the purging    22.0    1    0   
274    uzala - tales of blood and fire    22.0    1    0   
277    elevators to the grateful sky - cloud eye    21.0    1    0   
277    vallendusk - black clouds gathering    21.0    1    0   
279    funeral circle - funeral circle    20.0    1    0   
279    sacred steel - the bloodshed summoning    20.0    1    0   
279    spiritual beggars - earth blues    20.0    1    0   
282    audrey horne - youngblood    19.0    1    0   
283    dream death - somnium excessum    18.0    1    0   
283    witchburn - bathed in blood    18.0    1    0   
285    diesto - for water or blood    17.0    1    0   
285    cerna - restoring life    17.0    1    0   
287    black pyramid - adversarial    16.0    2    0   
288    pyres - year of sleep    16.0    1    0   
288    wall - wall    16.0    1    0   
290    anathema - universal    15.0    1    0   
290    moth gatherer - a bright celestial light    15.0    1    0   
292    cara neir - portals to a better dead world    14.0    1    0   
292    voices - from the human forest create a fugue of imaginary rain    14.0    1    0   
294    code - augur nox    12.0    1    0   
294    high priest of saturn - high priest of saturn    12.0    1    0   
294    revocation - revocation    12.0    1    0   
294    space witch - the alchemy paradox ep    12.0    1    0   
298    black tusk - tend no wounds ep    11.0    1    0   
298    yidhra - hexed    11.0    1    0   
300    lustre - lost in lustrous nights    10.0    1    0   
300    shade empire - omega arcane    10.0    1    0   
302    obsidian tongue - a nest of ravens in the throat of time    9.0    1    0   
302    vulture industries - the tower    9.0    1    0   
304    svartsyn - black testament    8.0    1    0   
304    tesseract - altered state    8.0    1    0   
306    norma jean - wrongdoers    7.0    1    0   
306    ultra-violence - privilege to overcome    7.0    1    0   
308    caligulas horse - the tide the thief and rivers end    6.0    1    0   
308    doublestone - wingmakers    6.0    1    0   
310    pensees nocturnes - nom dune pipe    5.0    1    0   
310    rhapsody of fire - dark wings of steel    5.0    1    0   
310    xciii - like a fiend in a cloud    5.0    1    0   
313    october tide - tunnel of no light    4.0    1    0   
313    sandrider - godhead    4.0    1    0   
315    graveland - thunderbolts of the gods    3.0    1    0   
315    hatebreed - the divinity of purpose    3.0    1    0   
317    attila - about that life    2.0    2    0   
318    powerwolf - preachers of the night    2.0    1    0   
319    brainbombs - disposal of a dead body    1.0    1    0   
319    jeff treppel and ozzy hamster sings/sqeaks - the best of nightwish    1.0    1    0

pfunkboy (Algerian Goalkeeper), Friday, 17 January 2014 20:16 (ten years ago) link

cant believe 2 people voted for attila and only one for jeff & ozzy

pfunkboy (Algerian Goalkeeper), Friday, 17 January 2014 20:18 (ten years ago) link

I dont know if seandalai has any stats

pfunkboy (Algerian Goalkeeper), Friday, 17 January 2014 20:21 (ten years ago) link

My ballot, bold didn't place:

Earthless - From the Ages
In Solitude - Sister
Pinkish Black - Razed to the Ground
Shooting Guns - Brotherhood of the Ram
SubRosa - More Constant Than the Gods
True Widow - Circumambulation
VHÖL - VHÖL
Clutch - Earth Rocker
Blood Ceremony - the Eldritch Dark
Gorguts - Colored Sands
Coliseum - Sister Faith
Oranssi Pazuzu - Valonielu
The Cult of Dom Keller - The Cult of Dom Keller
Hawkeyes - Poison Slows You Down

Power Trip - Manifest Decimation
Russian Circles - Memorial
Lycia - Quiet Moments
Vaura - The Missing
Cathedral - The Last Spire
Bombus - The Poet and the Parrot
Avatarium - Avatarium
Argus - Beyond the Martyrs
Church Of Misery - Thy Kingdom Scum
Satan - Life Sentence
Inter Arma - Sky Burial
Mammoth Grinder - Underworlds
Mutoid Man - Helium Head
Nails - Abandon All Life
Magister Templi - Lucifer Leviathan Logos
Vattnet Viskar - Sky Swallower
Horisont- Time Warriors
Audrey Horne - Youngblood

Carcass - Surgical Steel
Full of Hell - Rudiments of Mutilation
Pyres - Year of Sleep

Melt-Banana - Fetch
Motörhead - Aftershock
Noisem - Agonies Defined
Ampacity - Encounter One

Batillus- Concrete Stain
Altar of Plagues - Teethed Glory and Injury
Sofy Major - Idolize
Sungod - Contakt
Beastwars - Blood Becomes Fire
Darkthrone - The Underground Resistance
Germ - Grief
KEN Mode - Entrench
Lumbar - The First and Last Days of Unwelcome
Uncle Acid & the Deadbeats - Mind Control
oVo - Abisso

I was hoping more folks would vote for Shooting Guns, but alas, twas not to be.

EZ Snappin, Friday, 17 January 2014 20:31 (ten years ago) link

Amaranthe placed way higher than I was expecting it to!

J3ff T., Friday, 17 January 2014 20:40 (ten years ago) link

Motorhead not placing at all in the ILX Metal poll - this makes me sad

BlackIronPrison, Friday, 17 January 2014 21:04 (ten years ago) link

Average album by a great band and overrated as such. I think it's fine – we all love Motorhead, and it's not like they didn't see enough love this year anyway.

J3ff T., Friday, 17 January 2014 21:17 (ten years ago) link

The Motorhead album isnt bad but they can do much better.

It is funny how this collective hive mind of the metal community works - it's clear that Gorguts connects with a lot of people and it's undoubtedly an excellent record. But Pestilence, also an established big name band playing technical/dissonant/jazzy DM and (IMO) quality-wise not any worse, seems to have had no buzz at all. Did people not like Obsideo, or just never hear it?

Siegbran, Friday, 17 January 2014 21:19 (ten years ago) link

I'm not much of a death metal guy, but thematically and musically Colored Sands really grabbed me. I found the Pestilence album much more of what I don't like about death metal and thus less my thing.

EZ Snappin, Friday, 17 January 2014 21:22 (ten years ago) link

I still haven't heard the new pestilence. but, in general, I think gorguts have a head-nodding quality that makes all the death and dissonance a little more palatable. pestilence have this too, sure, but it's deployed in more of a "here's a riff to bang your head to, now here's another!" way (for the classic era stuff, anyway. that's all I've heard). but the constant groove is a defining quality for the gorguts sound (imo)

original bgm, Friday, 17 January 2014 21:48 (ten years ago) link

What grabbed me about Colored Sands, and why I can't compare it to anything else, is that Gorguts wrote and played like a death metal chamber orchestra, rather than, like just about every band to ever try something "symphonic," imitate things they'd heard orchestras do (or worse, plop an actual orchestra atop their metal). People have always said, "x or y band sounds like if Wagner/Beethoven/Stravinksy had access to distorted guitars" and maybe with the exception of some of Ihsahn's work in Emperor, this feels like the first time I've heard metal live up to that.

Pestilence is cool, and Obsideo was a step up from their last two, but I'm pretty sure Colored Sands did something that, like Obscura, other bands might only be able to start weakly emulating several years down the road. I'm sticking it in the same category as Mayhem's Ordo ad Chao, which is "stuff I can't even categorize yet." Totally transcends metal.

Devilock, Friday, 17 January 2014 21:52 (ten years ago) link

also dig all the lyrics about tibet, buddhism, meditation, etc. across the gorguts discog. has lemay ever expanded on this in interviews? don't meditate but I often find dense, noisy music like his own often puts me in a calm state. can feel the anxiety dissipating. curious if there's a relationship there for him as well.

original bgm, Friday, 17 January 2014 21:56 (ten years ago) link

Yeah, I agree – similar on the outside, maybe, but a big difference in ambition and execution.

J3ff T., Friday, 17 January 2014 21:57 (ten years ago) link


You must be logged in to post. Please either login here, or if you are not registered, you may register here.