~~~ 2014 ILM METAL POLL TRACKS & ALBUMS COUNTDOWN! ~~~ (Tracks top 30 first then Albums)

Message Bookmarked
Bookmark Removed
Not all messages are displayed: show all messages (849 of them)

9 ASG - Blood Drive, 668 Points, 17 Votes
http://i.imgur.com/Gu60Vkz.jpg
http://i.imgur.com/hD6fxC7.jpg
http://open.spotify.com/album/7AdrkC8Ul8z9dBtxsHbwra
spotify:album:7AdrkC8Ul8z9dBtxsHbwra

http://www.deezer.com/album/6622399

#16 Revolver, #13 SPIN, #13 MetalSucks, #34 Captain Beyond Zen, #18 Pitchfork, #633 Pazz & Jop

http://asgnation.bandcamp.com/
http://youtu.be/EHe4awX8UnQ

At one point, Wilmington, North Carolina's ASG (aka ALL SYSTEMS GO or any of the jokey alter acronyms that have cropped up in the spirit of hardcore icons MDC) could tear up the air hovering overtop a myriad of quarter and half pipes. Modern skate and snowboarding had one of its aural champions and thus MTV came a-calling to ASG to profile their punk and stoner-driven chops across such shows as "Viva La Bam", "Rob & Big" and "Living Lahaina". Further, ASG's music can be found scattered across numerous snowboarding and surfing videos.

It's been six years since ASG's put out an album (not counting their 2009 split with BLACK TUSK, "Low Country") and the most glaring difference in their work as of their latest release "Blood Drive" is its settled yet forceful attack plan. Now in-arms with BLACK TUSK and the mighty BARONESS at Relapse Records, ASG kicks things back a few clicks to drum up a less in-your-face spell with "Blood Drive", an album that allows for a deeper extraction of songwriting sure to please many in the sludge underground.
As ever, there remains the blueprints of KYUSS, TORCHE and JANE'S ADDICTION guiding ASG's craft, yet there's less full-frontal static of their last album, "Win Us Over", and more of a well-groomed dig for tuneful sprawls.

"Blood Drive" is often lazy in a good way through the grunge-meets-stoner drag of "The Ladder" and the shambling slogs of "Day's Work". With less bombast, the acoustic-led grafts of "Good Enough to Eat" open up gaping psychedelic territories for Jason Shi and Jonah Citty to decorate with echoing detachment, even while the grounded feel of the songs keeps their listeners vested in-tow. The striking wonderment of the acoustic delicacies introducing "Children's Music" creates a beautiful serve up to the heavier plows of the song, which retains dazzling effervescence on the straggly choruses. If ASG's music is still to be inclusive of snowboarding footage with these sophisticated modifications, those choruses would be perfect bedfellows coupled with Lien airs in slo-mo.

While Jason Shi wields a nifty range of pitches, for certain Perry Farrell has affected him to such measures "Blood Drive" frequently comes off like JANE'S ADDICTION with less shred and more surefire melody. The superb loft of "Earthwalk" tweaks the trippy sluices of BLACK SABBATH's "Planet Caravan" into ASG's reverb-filled parlay, then they blossom into a near-titanic reflection of JANE'S ADDICTION's "Summertime Rolls". ASG makes no pretentions who their idols are, yet "Earthwalk" gets away with bloody murder because it's delivered with such finesse you submit instead of condemn. Prior to, Jason Shi dips his vocals to match the slow, jabbing twirl of "Blues for Bama" while finding a happy medium on the stepped-up crunch of "Scrappy's Trip".

A band that was already sharp to begin with, ASG may alienate a handful of their skate and surf rat followers with the more refined "Blood Drive", but their advancement into a slow and steady schism reveals tremendous growth and maturity. The Atlantic Ocean at their backs is hardly considered a surfer's paradise, but there's no denying the purity and grandeur of the body's natural progression. This album might as well have been concocted in a dune outside of Nag's Head in the northward haven of the Outer Banks. "Blood Drive" defies possibilities of hurricane forces that may come another day and instead, ASG sticks to their guns, delivering a confident embracement of the winds of change that have compelled them. - Ray Van Horn, Jr., Blabbermouth, http://www.blabbermouth.net/cdreviews/blood-drive/#6BFuyE4dC1yTdalC.99

pfunkboy (Algerian Goalkeeper), Friday, 17 January 2014 16:30 (ten years ago) link

really impressive album and very different to what i was expecting. almost a Jane's Addiction vibe to some of the tracks. discovered this one very late in the piece.

charlie h, Friday, 17 January 2014 16:33 (ten years ago) link

either Ihsahn or Melt-Banana's a goner, then, I take it. Intriguing!

Simon H., Friday, 17 January 2014 16:33 (ten years ago) link

the asg album is superb

pfunkboy (Algerian Goalkeeper), Friday, 17 January 2014 16:39 (ten years ago) link

ppfff... i preferred Deafheaven to ASG.

An embarrassing doorman and garbage man (dog latin), Friday, 17 January 2014 16:40 (ten years ago) link

You're the first on here to admit to liking deafheaven (apart from me) but I think i ranked the asg higher

pfunkboy (Algerian Goalkeeper), Friday, 17 January 2014 16:44 (ten years ago) link

my #1 was the Atlantean Kodex I think (dont have ballots to hand)

pfunkboy (Algerian Goalkeeper), Friday, 17 January 2014 16:45 (ten years ago) link

I will come out of the Deafheaven closet, though I didn't vote in the poll!

Kim Wrong-un (Neil S), Friday, 17 January 2014 16:46 (ten years ago) link

i normally hate the indie-metal stuff but Deafheaven manage to get a bit of oomph behind them without sounding like a pisstake like Liturgy do.

An embarrassing doorman and garbage man (dog latin), Friday, 17 January 2014 16:46 (ten years ago) link

I dont get how they sound like a pisstake? the musics genuine its triple H's bullshit that annoys everyone!

pfunkboy (Algerian Goalkeeper), Friday, 17 January 2014 16:50 (ten years ago) link

I bet none of the fans of this band turn up to post about this next one..

pfunkboy (Algerian Goalkeeper), Friday, 17 January 2014 16:56 (ten years ago) link

deafheaven seemed way more emo than metal to me but I only listened to that record one time and it was a while back

original bgm, Friday, 17 January 2014 16:57 (ten years ago) link

I am not against emo either. I've been known to put an american football record or two on. it just seemed really emo is all.

original bgm, Friday, 17 January 2014 16:59 (ten years ago) link

8 Melt-Banana - Fetch, 686 Points, 18 Votes, One #1
http://i.imgur.com/mZOcoyl.jpg
http://open.spotify.com/album/4C8VqFE4h4KWIsbAViqIby
spotify:album:4C8VqFE4h4KWIsbAViqIby

http://www.deezer.com/album/6941431

#7 Decibel, #42 Rock-A-Rolla, #110 Pazz & Jop

http://youtu.be/C6cKMDO5fAs

Since they started back in 1993, Melt-Banana have remained like an eye of a hurricane that’s 10 times crazier than the hurricane itself. One of the core bands to emerge from the same roiling soup that birthed art-damaged titans such as the Flying Luttenbachers and the Locust, the female-fronted Japanese group added a few twists to the genetic makeup of 90s noise rock. Japan’s own rich noise tradition was little more than a touchstone for Melt-Banana, and the group’s cryptic otherness elevated it above its peers. It was easy to see that Weasel Walter was a virtuoso slumming it, and that Justin Pearson was a snotty powerviolence kid with a schtick. But Melt-Banana? Who knew what they were thinking? After a six-year break from making studio albums, the new full-length fetch doesn’t answer that question. But it makes that question even more head-spinning.

Melt-Banana left listeners on a curious note with 2007’s frighteningly poppy Bambi’s Dilemma, but that dissonance has been resolved on fetch, in true Melt-Banana fashion, with more dissonance. This is the Melt-Banana of their mid-90s prime: salivating Pavlovianly over the acceleration of culture, twisting the tools of psychedelia into things of surgical precision, and envisioning cyberpunk grindcore before reality knew it could bear the weight of such a thing. It still might not—but fetch at least harmonizes more disharmoniously with the tenor of the times. Gleeful terror pours out of tracks like “Candy Gun” and “Then Red Eyed”; the fact that they’re the longest and shortest song on the disc, respectively, only bookends the dilation of spacetime that guitarist and effects technician Ichirou Agata is able to accomplish. Like a proto 8-bit composer using a looping delay pedal to preemptively echo a deterministic future, he’s a watchmaker winding up a thousand thrash riffs at once then letting them go.

It’s up to Yasuko Onuki to lend a human voice to Agata’s nanotech contraptions. She’s never sounded more savagely ecstatic. On “Red Data, Red Stage” she’s like Dog Faced Hermans’ Marion Coutts sprinting on bipolar impulse, all Situationist cheerleader chants and sugary chirp. Phonetically, it’s all splinters and crystal. Melt-Banana’s grindcore roots, vestigial in the first place, are now only dim memories. Just as the quaint notion of sudden, cataclysmic apocalypse has been replaced in the new millennium by gradual, nonlinear collapse, so does fetch frolic in anachronism, a swarm of data-fragments retroactively reordered and held together with hair and bubblegum. “The Hive” is proof: An intro that resembles “Eruption”-era Eddie Van Halen eaten some yet unimagined remake of Tron opens space for Onuki’s sideways singsong, the filtered cry of bitmapped anxiety.

That Melt-Banana is making some of the best music of their career—over 20 years into the band’s existence—speaks to the universal and transcendent quality of their noise. The landscape of media, society, and even the microcosm of noise rock has changed greatly, but Onuki and Agata have locked jaws on the diametric constants: energy versus agitation, phobia versus euphoria, and instant nostalgia versus the relentless pursuit of the upgrade. fetch is Melt-Banana’s own upgrade, a bleeding-edge reiteration of their fractured and manicured chaos. There’s a moment in the album’s closer, “Zero”, in which Onuki punches her way through a web of Möbius-strip riffage to project a fleeting, Technicolor afterimage of Dilemma’s pop-punk melodicism; then it seizes up, hits the gas, and splatters against a brick wall. A moment later, it reconstitutes itself and barrels forward as if nothing happened. In a breathless whirlwind kind of way, fetch does the same for Melt-Banana. - Jason Heller, Pitchfork, http://pitchfork.com/reviews/albums/18577-melt-banana-fetch/

Melt-Banana’s music is extremely difficult to classify for a few pretty good reason. Firstly, they do not really sound like anyone else, and no other band really sounds like them. Secondly, they have continuously reinvented themselves throughout their career, showing their fans different aspects of their sound while always sounding unmistakably like themselves.Thirdly, and perhaps most critically, once the listener has been catapulted into the feral, manic, lunacy that is any given Melt-Banana track, attempts at reflexive, lucid genre categorization starts feeling unimportant pretty darn quickly. Usually by the end of the average minute and a half Melt-Banana track, the listener has destroyed most of their personal belongings in a fit of wild-eyed ecstasy. If the person in question was in a public place when first exposed to the mighty Melt-Banana, they have probably been arrested or otherwise institutionalized within four or five minutes of hitting the “play” button, depending on the response time of their local law enforcement or medical professionals. Symptoms of Melt-Banana exposure often include wild yelping, foaming at the mouth, super-human strength, and a deep sense of joy and well being. The Japanese duo’s new record Fetch marries the lupine, atypical grindcore of their mid-‘90s output, with the lunatic pop sensibility of 2007’s Bambi’s Dilemma with results powerful enough to destroy entire continents.

Yasuko Onuki and Ichirou Agata have always been the core members of Melt-Banana, although they have been joined at various times by a number of temporary members and famous collaborators. On Fetch Onuki and Agata are pretty much left to their own devices, with a drum machine given the formidable task of providing the percussion for this breathtaking, hypertensive track list. As they indicated on 2003’s magnificent Cell-Scape, Melt-Banana are not tethered to half-assed, restrictive notions of humanity or musicality; if a machine can effectively turn the listener’s brains to jam like a nasty case of rabies, than that’s good enough for them. The sometimes synthetic quality of these beats frequently adds to the intensity and surrealistic nature of Fetch, and I can attest that the drum machine comes off just as well in the live setting. In many ways Fetch is the amalgamation of everything that Melt-Banana have done throughout their career, drawing on all of their experiments, splicing them together, coming up with a sound that is unmistakably their own, and unmistakably wonderful.

One of the primary misunderstandings that people who do not listen to extreme metal or punk frequently articulate is that extreme music must be angry and negative. When I am listening to Emperor shrieking from their icy northern fantasy world, or the overwhelming roar of Napalm Death, I hear ecstasy and exaltation, not anger and negativity. One of the coolest things about Melt-Banana is that the mirth, whimsy, and elation in their music is almost unmistakable, even to people who cannot wrap their minds around extreme music. Fetch is relentlessly playful, without ever seeming like just a joke, or like some tired exercise in hipster irony. These tracks are often breathlessly intense, while never sacrificing the fun. There is more imagination and personality on Fetch than on any other record you are likely to come across. Fetch is ten times more intense than any death slam or tough guy hardcore record that came out this year, and about ten billion times more fun to listen to.

Melt-Banana continue to prove to us that no one on this earth makes extreme music with more style, ingenuity, and inventiveness than they do. This is music for uncontrollable giggle fits, playing fetch with over excited border collies, and sledding down steep, snowy hills with your kids; this is music that makes you feel intensely alive. - Benjamin Hedge Olson, PopMatters, http://www.popmatters.com/review/177836-melt-banana-fetch/

pfunkboy (Algerian Goalkeeper), Friday, 17 January 2014 17:00 (ten years ago) link

yaaay

lovely cuddly fluffy dope (imago), Friday, 17 January 2014 17:01 (ten years ago) link

yeah, not even a little metal really but this record rules. their last 5 or so have all ruled.

original bgm, Friday, 17 January 2014 17:02 (ten years ago) link

I'm a bit surprised to see Belt-Mañana in the top 10. I know there are folks here that love it, but still.

EZ Snappin, Friday, 17 January 2014 17:02 (ten years ago) link

i will get that ASG album ..
totally hits my spot.
melt banana : nope.

mark e, Friday, 17 January 2014 17:04 (ten years ago) link

Melt Banana kicked ass live, but much less so on record.

EZ Snappin, Friday, 17 January 2014 17:07 (ten years ago) link

terrific album. They have a lot of fans outside of metal thread but dunno if they are reading this thread.
If it charts in big poll they will be shouting yes so please do so here! NUMBER EIGHT folks you can get excited!!!

pfunkboy (Algerian Goalkeeper), Friday, 17 January 2014 17:07 (ten years ago) link

It's not so much that I liked Liturgy that I absolutely adored Greg Fox's drumming

a chance to cross is a chance to score (anonanon), Friday, 17 January 2014 17:08 (ten years ago) link

#110 in Pazz & Jop is impressive too. Again, zero metal content, but a pretty amazing album. Swamped with meetings, bad day for me to try to keep up and comment sorry. Deafheaven can suckit ;) Lots of other better hard rock options than ASG too.

Fastnbulbous, Friday, 17 January 2014 17:13 (ten years ago) link

7 Uncle Acid And The Deadbeats - Mind Control, 707 Points, 20 Votes, 2 #1s
http://i.imgur.com/6Rjnthk.jpg
http://open.spotify.com/album/7GCWs2hmWYvS1OOiRcbLbW
spotify:album:7GCWs2hmWYvS1OOiRcbLbW

http://www.deezer.com/album/6390338

#25 Decibel, #3 SPIN, #35 Stereogun, #15 Rock-A-Rolla, #6 Obelisk, #4 Obelisk readers, #3 Captain Beyond Zen, #15 Stoner HiVe, #4 Metal Hammer, #371 Pazz & Jop

"Mind Crawler" - http://youtu.be/yACaB6fzt_c

In the years between Black Sabbath's 1970 debut and Judas Priest's galvanizing late-'70s ascendance, critics dubbed practically any band that turned their amps up past "4" and played heavy-handed chord progressions as "metal." Even poor little guitar-talker Peter Frampton and his bluesy Humble Pie bandmates suffered the description "heavy metal-leaden shit rock" in a 1970 issue of Rolling Stone. And now, over the past decade, scores of groups have surfaced, all owing an unabashed debt to the quasi-boogie shit-rock of yore. Although it's questionable whether the members of recent metallurgists Uncle Acid & the Deadbeats, Purson, and Ghost B.C. are old enough to credibly claim influences like Pentagram, King Crimson, and Blue Öyster Cult, respectively, all three bands project a selfish naiveté or, maybe more precisely, a purposeful arrogance about any metal recorded after the Sabs booted Ozzy in '79.

This sort of innocent divination seems to ooze from Uncle Acid & the Deadbeats, the cream of this particular crop. The quirkiness of the British group's name pays homage to Metal Mk I artists like Alice Cooper and BÖC, but the music on their third album, Mind Control, shows a broader vocabulary of anachronism. In addition to a few riffs very possibly pilfered from Tony Iommi's rehearsal tapes, songs like the swinging desert blues of "Poison Apple" and the jamming drones of "Follow the Leader" seep psychedelia via Deep Purple-via-Nuggets organ work on the former, and coolly relaxing vocal melodies and twangy acoustic guitar on the latter. More than that, though, the lyrics often seem to owe an equal debt to the spirit of '69 — just like those early-'70s bands! — especially when Charles Manson allusions sneak into the woozy, Mellotron-infused "Valley of the Dolls" (sorry, Sharon Tate) and "Death Valley Blues." The latter's sinewy chorus goes, "Let's hide out in the Valley," and (inadvertently?) references the location of the bottomless pit where the Manson Family would hide out during Helter Skelter, making chilling use of Uncle Acid's deathlike vocal harmonies, which might sound a bit like Alice in Chains if it weren't for the plodding drums and muddy production. In fact, as a whole, the record suggests the same sort of breezy cool that Josh Homme uses on his Desert Sessions series, but something, maybe Uncle Acid's inherent Britishness, makes them sound more nostalgic, rather than like something new. - Kory Grow - SPIN, http://www.spin.com/reviews/uncle-deadbeats-mind-control-ghost-infestissumam-purson/

After debuting in 2010 with the so-rare-it-barely-exists Volume 1 and following it in 2011 with the landmark arrival that was Blood Lust – an album for which one can still hear the hyperbole echoing on the wind if one listens just right – British horror rockers Uncle Acid and the Deadbeats emerge with another round of malevolent fuzz on Mind Control. Though Blood Lust was reissued by Rise Above last year, Mind Control marks the Cambridge four-piece’s debut proper on the label (Metal Blade in the US), and if the response to the advance single “Poison Apple” and the sold-out live debut at London’s The Garage venue are any indication, the monstrous hype that swelled for Blood Lust is primed to take hold again for the new collection, which is longer at nine tracks/50 minutes than the second album. More importantly than the visceral nature of the blind praise it’s almost predestined to receive, Mind Control showcases some distinct changes in Uncle Acid’s approach, taking their late-‘60s garage fuzz to far-out psychedelic ranges while also balancing those influences with the strong pop sensibilities that came to fruition the last time out, so that a song like the later “Valley of the Dolls” is languid, fuzzed mellotron’ed and meandering – also doomed – but still proffering one of Mind Control’s strongest hooks. While one of the most distinct aspects of the band’s sound two years ago was their ability to capture a classic horror aesthetic in their songwriting, Mind Control is less tied to that single idea specifically, and though it doesn’t want for foreboding atmosphere or an underlying sense of ill intentions, the impression is delivered through what’s at times a strikingly sweet package. To wit, “Follow the Leader,” which owes more to The Beatles’ Revolver than to the Hammer House of Horror, or the progressive soloing that arises in the second half of the earlier “Desert Ceremony.” They’re on a different – though no less individualized – trip, still putting the overarching affect of the material at the fore rather an any one member’s performance, but taking the means of their methods to new and more evolved ends.
One of the great strengths of Blood Lust was its use of classic pop structures, and that’s something Uncle Acid and the Deadbeats have carried over into Mind Control as well, though as much as that album transferred verses and choruses into felonies of surgical precision, some of these songs’ best moments are their most drawn out. The opener and one of the longer cuts, “Mt. Abraxas” (7:09), hints at some of the psychedelia that comes up later in the closing trio, but really does most of its work in heralding the tonal consistency with the band’s prior outings while also showcasing the uptick in production value accomplished through working with Jim Spencer at Chapel Studios in Lincolnshire, showing also in its midsection just how much of Uncle Acid’s tonality – fast becoming their signature – is owed to circa-1974 Black Sabbath, the guitars taking on classic Iommi layered interplay between lead and rhythm lines. I was left wondering though why the song had been chosen to lead off Mind Control until the crashes and slowdown after the 4:30 mark that leads the way instrumentally through the remainder of the track, which hone directly in on Uncle Acid’s psychotic cabaret stomp and give the record one of its most lasting grooves, duly ridden. Perhaps also “Mt. Abraxas” is meant to signal a departure from the form of Blood Lust, since it functions not so much as a direct chorus hook as did that album’s launch, “I’ll Cut You Down,” but instead as more of a lead-in to the rest of this album as a whole, the pace picking up with the ensuing “Mind Crawler.” With a synth line buried beneath the guitars, bass and drums to offer a sense of urgency fitting the more upbeat tempo, “Mind Crawler” is both a strong hook and an immediate contrast to the opener, finding companionship shortly with the more metallic “Evil Love” in a quicker rush that builds to a stop in the second half before repetitions of the title at the end give it a second chorus as much as an outro. The swaggering jaunt of “Poison Apple” follows, its initial verse following a simple pattern of proclamations rounding out with the lines, “Don’t you worry baby, you’re safe with me/I’m the poison apple in your tree.” From there, it’s riffy groove, spiders in the brains, infections and a host of other threatening images to go with one of Mind Control’s best basslines and a toe-tapping rhythm. The vocals, almost always delivered by more than one member of the band at once, are rarely at the fore, but present enough in the mix to carry across the hook of “Poison Apple” well, setting up the more spacious “Desert Ceremony,” which takes some of the Sabbathisms that showed up in “Mt. Abraxas” and makes them the core of the progression.

One can look at Mind Control as functioning on a couple different levels. Cuts like “Mt. Abraxas,” “Follow the Leader,” “Valley of the Dolls” and “Devil’s Work” are longer, and particularly in the case of the last three, working in more psychedelic realms, where “Mind Crawler,” “Poison Apple,” “Evil Love” and “Death Valley Blues” keep a more straightforward – structurally – feel, the latter nonetheless providing transition atmospherically into the rest of side B’s freakout. At very least I’d argue that’s the case, and if so, “Desert Ceremony” is where the two sides of Uncle Acid’s sound meet and get down on some drawn-out lysergics while smoothly shifting into some of the album’s most satisfying riffing, the guitars harmonizing here and there and setting a table for the end of the first half that arrives with “Evil Love.” Classic proto-NWOBHM chugging – more biker movie than otherworldly horror creep, but well done – shows up in the chorus, but the sound is stripped of the lushness that “Desert Ceremony” hinted at in its midsection, and that’s the biggest change. The momentum already established by the time “Poison Apple” ends carries through “Desert Ceremony” to “Evil Love,” so that the shift back to a faster tempo isn’t jarring, and the simple chorus of “You need our love/Our evil love/You are dear/To our purpose” (that third line might be something else) showing off the band’s ability to make the most out of near-minimalist lyricism. The song ends cold, marking a distinct break between the first halves of Mind Control even on a linear medium (CD or digital), and “Death Valley Blues” starts with a quiet introduction to its chorus guitar line, establishing a theme with “Desert Ceremony” even as the sweet first verse turns sinister with the heavier guitar that enters for the chorus at full breadth. Its threat made clear, “Death Valley Blues” plays off the I’m-harmless-watch-me-kill-you contrast of the airier pop verse and the vicious chorus, moving after a couple turns through to a near-vaudevillian riff that seems to echo the ending “Mt. Abraxas” even as vocals are introduced over top, the chaos coming to a head as the murderous vibe loses consciousness in its own repetitions, crashing and ringing out to start “Follow the Leader” from a base of total silence.

Which is as fitting a place to start, since “Follow the Leader” essentially redefines the course of Mind Control for the remainder of its duration. Amp rumble meets with Eastern-sounding acoustic guitar lines, shaker percussion and the most acid-caked feel I’ve yet heard from Uncle Acid. On that level, it’s their most adventurous single track to date and in large part the source of the Beatles Revolver comparison above, the vocals made Lennon-esque in the context of the droning guitar line and righteous psych melody. There’s movement to it thanks to the already noted percussion, but the absence of a full drum kit makes a big difference in the overall sound, allowing for more of a wash as the layers of guitar intertwine in an active, but nonetheless stiller feel. Because its sensibility is more or less bringing the album to a halt, and because of its hypnotic wanderings, it would be easy to think of “Follow the Leader” as worthy of closing the album, but Uncle Acid have more in store as “Valley of the Dolls” reintroduces the drums, albeit at a lumbering, slow pace. Doomed. Classically so, but hardly traditional. The psychedelic context of “Follow the Leader” isn’t lost, thanks in large part to the vocals, which are drawn out over the slower riffing, but the guitar line that leads the way through the track is darker, slower and more downtrodden than anything yet on the record, and the mellotron that accompanies only adds to its miseries. With the recent death of Roger Ebert, one can call “Valley of the Dolls” – named for the 1967 original film from which the Ebert-penned 1970 sequel, Beyond the Valley of the Dolls, which is also referenced in the lyrics here, is derived – timely, but the band could hardly have planned it that way, so it doesn’t really seem fair. More to the song’s credit, the chorus hones in on a fitting barbiturate, drool-from-out-the-side-of-the-mouth stoned feel, so that I don’t even know how many times Uncle Acid have intoned the line “valley of the dolls” before they shift gears after the halfway mark and start adding “beyond the” to the front of it, but the dual-guitar solo that carries the track past its midpoint offers a bit of momentary respite. As much as anything could, anyway.

The bass picks up a “Heaven and Hell”-type line, slowed down considerably, and “Valley of the Dolls” rounds out with single hits ringing out between, eventually giving way to rumble and a fadeout into the immediate guitar march of “Devil’s Work.” This single riff – chug, chug, chug, chug – will comprise much of Mind Control’s closer, opening for a bit for the chorus, but never moving too far out of focus. Melodic oohs and soon enough the verse take hold, but the drums and bass follow the guitar line such that Uncle Acid in their final moments are united in the expression of just this one idea, the line in the chorus, “I am the devil/And I’m here to do the devil’s work,” meeting the sporadic-but-not-random lead guitar notes and tom fill with like-minded effective simplicity. A semi-build emerges with the chugging progression as its foundation, guitars emerging to space out over the fading line as Mind Control weaves its way toward the closing rumble that comprises the final few minutes of “Devil’s Work,” which, though its ending is more for that of the album as a whole, winds up with a deceptively catchy hook, slow and drugged as it is. That balance speaks to Uncle Acid’s strength of songwriting overall, however, and though they share little sonically in common, it’s a distorted pop influence they share with Sweden’s Ghost, who’ve been able to take classic structures and bend them to their own sonic will to considerable critical (not to mention commercial) success. Whether such lies in store for Uncle Acid and the Deadbeats in the wake of Mind Control, I don’t know and won’t bother to speculate. More pivotally, the band have underscored the point that although they owe their hearts to a very specific set of atmospheric principles – the horror, the late ‘60s fuzz, etc. – they’re able to take those and create something of their own with them. As much as Blood Lust caught many off guard with its ultra-cohesive presentation, Mind Control is primed as the follow-up to surprise with what it adds to that already established formula. An easy pick for one of the year’s best and most anticipated albums. - The Obelisk, http://theobelisk.net/obelisk/2013/04/08/uncle-acid-and-the-deadbeats-mind-control-review/#sthash.1Tmw3QFw.dpuf

pfunkboy (Algerian Goalkeeper), Friday, 17 January 2014 17:17 (ten years ago) link

oh yes.

glad to see the ilm crew and me agree on something.

mark e, Friday, 17 January 2014 17:19 (ten years ago) link

Remember when we got Uncle Acid & The Deadbeats into the top 10 of the general ilm albums poll?

pfunkboy (Algerian Goalkeeper), Friday, 17 January 2014 17:21 (ten years ago) link

that was a better album

Mordy , Friday, 17 January 2014 17:22 (ten years ago) link

tru

Johnny Fever, Friday, 17 January 2014 17:22 (ten years ago) link

My #49! Knew it was top 10. A nice improvement over Blood Lust which you all overrated.

EZ Snappin, Friday, 17 January 2014 17:23 (ten years ago) link

6 Windhand - Soma, 732 Points, 19 Votes, One #1
http://i.imgur.com/AilwDRC.jpg
http://open.spotify.com/album/1uT455zoyeabAFnd8er1F3
spotify:album:1uT455zoyeabAFnd8er1F3

http://www.deezer.com/album/6791520
#8 Revolver, #6 SPIN, #7 Stereogum, #7 Obelisk, #11 Captain Beyond Zen, #3 Stoner HiVe, #28 Pitchfork, #32 Terrorizer, #141 Pazz & Jop

http://windhandva.bandcamp.com/album/soma
http://youtu.be/IcpBJgxV47Q

Windhand's Sophomore Album Is an Ironclad Piece of Ethereal Doom Metal Mastery.

Before ever having actually heard Windhand, I stumbled across an ad for their first release, a self-titled released on a label called Force Field. What happened next seldom happens to me, if ever at all. I was instantly driven to order it, sound unheard, based on album art alone. I’m not usually that impulse driven, but there was just something about their spectral white logo (unfortunately omitted from gracing this album cover), floating over a shot of some dilapidated house (a la Black Sabbath’s debut). There stood the eerie manor, polarized in purple and screaming silent desolation… probably containing unspeakable horrors within its gates… If that isn’t an allegory for the relationship between the cover art and the musical contents then I don’t know what is! At no point throughout this all did the fear of a sucky record being delivered to my mailbox cross my mind.

Needless to say, their debut did not disappoint, and it quickly became my go-to music to enhance certain habitual illicit activities. Evidently, I was not the only one that seemed to think so, since Relapse certainly scouted and signed them into their roster faster than an underground buzz could build. With a new record deal in tow, Windhand followed up the self-titled with their Relapse debut on “Reflections of the Negative”, a very F-ing heavy split with new label-mates Cough. With a wider reach now at their disposal thanks to their new “higher-profile-than-typical” Metal label, Windhand was able to waft into the ears of hundreds, if not thousands of awaiting Doomsayers like swirling clouds of hash and amplifier smoke. The stage was now set for the unveiling of Soma…

On Soma, Windhand does not attempt to fix what isn’t broken. They aren’t trying to reinvent themselves, or Post/Prog themselves up, they have simply cooked up another batch of their distinctly hazy Stoner Metal to turn minds into mush with. Even the album art is relatively similar, if not fundamentally the same (the one notable bummer about this album, I thought). They further their anthology with their distinct sound, a paradoxical marriage of overdriven guitar heaviness over a hard hitting yet sloth-like swing, paired with the ethereal lamentations of Dorthia Cottrell’s ghostly, banshee wail. As the Doom scene quickly becomes more of an equal opportunity genre with more than a fair share of female vocalists to nocturnally emit to, Cottrell is by far the most celebrated.

Early album cuts such as “Orchard” and “Feral Bones” are saturated in the quintessence of what this band does best, big scary riffs that result in the listener screwing their face up into classic “mean-guitar” pouty grimaces. “Evergreen”, however, shows a deviation from their form as they go unplugged for a spell, letting Cottrell prove that those pipes work well even without the accompaniment of distortion pedals- knobs twisted to thirteen. It has a warm, earthy feel that doesn’t get outweighed by its folkloric, looming melancholy. Almost more remarkable is that the song never once gets buried beneath the wall of sound that is the rest of this album, holding fast an identity all its own that fits perfectly into the overall tone of the record.

The epic, half-hour closer “Boleskine” is also worthy of mention. This frosty number begins with a molasses-rich sounding acoustic bit, warmly strummed beneath the howls of freezing northern winds. The quiet lull comes to a crashing end under the weight of what may very well be the heaviest (albeit most minimal) riff on the entire album, saddled of course by a grieving howl courtesy of Windhand’s fabled chanteuse. The crestfallen melody of this big finish hits you like a sledgehammer to the chest, leaving you breathless with its sullen beauty. After a 13 minute trampling under foot of this saturnine behemoth of a song, clean acoustic guitar resurfaces to lure you into a momentary sense of security, only to bury you again under the riff equivalent of a mountain of rubble.

Soma is a stellar effort on this Virginia band’s behalf. It may be a tough listen for Doom Metal passers-by, as the droning guitar approach and snail’s-crawl tempos can be off-putting to unscarred ears. On the other hand, I actually think that this album is as great an introduction to this band as any. For followers of the Doom Metal genre whom by now are perfectly capable of resisting its trademark funeral dirge delivery, this thing is top-shelf material that will make many bongs rattle from its low-end roar. Enjoy! - Frank Lopez, PopMatters, http://www.popmatters.com/review/174830-windhand-soma/

I imagine that somewhere on the outskirts of Richmond, Virginia, a lone technician sits in a room with an impossible array of gauges, measuring tectonic pressure, general atmospheric conditions, etc., only to have the emergency lights kick on an unspeakable siren of chaos every time Windhand plugs in to rehearse. Call it “tone overload.” Our poor technician — who went to college for this, mind you, and is a skilled professional — gradually loses his or her mind, quits the job, and spends all remaining days wandering RVA, trying to find the source of that maddening rumble. Thus another existence destroyed by the ascendant dual-guitar five-piece, who made their debut on Relapse Records earlier this year with the Reflection of the Negative split with Richmond countrymen Cough, whose bass player, Parker Chandler, they also share. Windhand‘s full-length Relapse debut — their second album overall following a 2011 self-titled on Forcefield Records (streamed here) and a not-inconsiderable amount of touring — has been dubbed Soma, the drink of the gods. It’s a title Windhand share the most recent My Sleeping Karma LP, though the two bands have really nothing in common, as Windhand push forth low-end mud at a horrifying, lung-filling rate from Chandler‘s bass and the steady riff and lead interplay of guitarists Asechiah Bogdan and Garrett Morris, march to a wash of crash and stomp from drummer Ryan Wolfe (The Might Could, ex-Facedowninshit) and top with the ethereal vocals of Dorthia Cottrell, giving Soma a bleak, otherworldly sensibility to go along with its unbridled heft. If it’s the drink of the gods, the beverage is opaque. Clocking in at a full 75 minutes with six tracks and closing with the monster “Boleskine” that comprises just over half an hour on its own, Windhand‘s sophomore outing is dense even beyond the levels shows on the self-titled and fuller-sounding, bigger and more crushing. Early cuts “Orchard” and “Woodbine” establish the nod that the fivesome will carry through the next hour-plus, the opener in particular — also the shortest cut at 6:38 — harkening to some of the Electric Wizard influence that showed up last time out in the guitar work, but giving clear indication that Windhand‘s road time has helped them figure out who they are and who they want to be as a band.

To say Soma crushes doesn’t really do it full justice. It is impeccably mixed to maximize murk — a dense fog begins with “Orchard” and is consistent throughout. Cottrell‘s vocals and Wolfe‘s drums reside deep within the overbearing thrust of guitar and bass, lending the songs an even larger sound, and especially considering it was self-recorded and self-mixed (Morris also helmed the self-titled), the atmospheric bludgeon that Soma carries portrays Windhand as all the more cohesive in its styilstic take. They know what they’re doing, in other words. The riffs of “Orchard” proffer malevolent swirl and Cottrell sings through the churning progression, but there’s a structure to the song as well, a verse and a chorus trading off, as hard as they might be to discern initially, and the ringing feedback that caps the opener crashes directly into the similarly drugged-out “Woodbine.” Both the drums and the vocals seem more forward here, as though they’ve stepped up to meet the more insistent riff, and though by most standards it’s hardly a thrasher, in comparison to “Orchard” and the penultimate “Cassock” still to come, “Woodbine” moves at as quick a pace as Windhand show on Soma. Of course, the guitars and bass are so thick that even as it moves forward quickly, it still sounds slow. A memorable melody line through the vocals and guitars make “Woodbine” something of a landmark in terms of the album overall, but with a record that makes so plain its intent to swallow the listener whole and keep them for the duration, any landmark is only going to be so helpful. The idea is you lose yourself in it and are more subject to the overall impression than any particular standout, and that makes the album an even more satisfying front-to-back listen, though a “hook” for lack of a better word is certainly appreciated as well. Following a big slowdown as “Woodbine” hits the seven-minute mark and collapses to its finish, one gets no such mercies from the subsequent “Feral Bones,” which lets up some on the tempo and finds the vocals receding to deep under the tonequake, ghostly in echo but still definitely a presence. Peppered by regular crashes, “Feral Bones” is Windhand sounding the most their own as they have yet on the album. It doesn’t have the immediate familiarity of “Orchard,” but that’s also what makes it exciting. A striding lead takes hold near the halfway point, but the riff is maintained and soon returns to its prominent place, a last verse and chorus returning to round out the eight-minute track with more deceptive structuring.

“Evergreen” marks a well-placed departure from Windhand‘s bury-you-in-distortion methodology, switching to acoustic ambience that borders on minimalism in its strumming. No drums, no bass, no feedback-drenched leads, but “Evergreen” has a resonance anyway, its light strum reminding of the mood evoked by Down‘s “Jail” while remaining distinctly the band’s own thanks in no small part to Cottrell‘s capable handling of the morose melody. Perhaps most impressive of all, they keep it up for just under seven minutes, so that it’s not half a song or a moment to catch your breath before diving into the pit of riffs again with “Cassock,” but an essential piece of Soma and one of its most effective atmospheres. Slow moving and finishing with a repetition of the line “stay evergreen” that’s no less hypnotic than anything Windhand have offered to this point of the album, it’s a display of breadth they might not have been prepared to make on their self-titled, but which suits Soma perfectly where it occurs. What follows is nothing short of a mountain. Two songs remain and comprise nearly 45 minutes of Soma‘s runtime — more by almost half than the four tracks so far. “Cassock” and “Boleskine” are a record unto themselves — they easily could’ve been — with the first of them a tonal abyss unprecedented in Windhand‘s relatively short career and the second not only a summary of everything Soma has accomplished before it, but an expansion to new levels of sonic cohesion for the band. Feedback takes hold following the end of “Evergreen” and the lurch of “Cassock” is immediately potent. Wolfe builds up the drums, but even when the song launches — which it does with a riff worthy of Electric Wizard‘s “Drugula,” only slower — it crawls with a tension yet unheard on the LP. There’s a verse and a chorus, but the sway is maintained one into the other such that there’s no getting out of it. Bogdan and Morris are steering the progression, its changes driven by their guitars, but the band is united around the push and four minutes in, after the second chorus, an echoing solo takes hold to drive into the next movement of the piece overall, which is even more tidal in its crashes — almost a waltz, come to think of it — before the wailing chorus returns and a midpoint slowdown leads to a final verse and an even more grueling, noise-soaked rumble that builds over the course of the next five minutes to a contorted apex of Lovecraftian proportion, near unrecognizable by its end from the riffing that started it, though that could just be hearing loss.

In direct conversation with “Evergreen,” “Boleskine” spends its first two minutes and 40 seconds — less than a tenth of its seemingly insurmountable 30:30 runtime — dedicated to an acoustic intro, just the guitar, that seems to signal a tying together of the sundry threads thus far opened. In particular, that they’d go back to the acoustics as the opening of the final track on Soma underscores the symmetry and cohesiveness at the heart of the album, and of course once “Boleskine” crashes in, it hones a riff huge enough to capsize any mind bold enough to set sail on it. Drawn out soloing, ultra-weighted plod, and, eventually, Cottrell‘s commanding echoes — “Boleskine” is less about the swirl than was “Woodbine” or even “Feral Bones” and more about the excruciating, overwhelming mass of sound. Still, there’s a chorus. It’s slow, it’s covered in sludge, but it’s there. With each verse taking more than a minute to play out in slow motion, the band’s two-verses-two-chorus-then-change modus shown on earlier cuts is even harder to decipher on “Boleskine,” but the underlying method is the same, even if it takes a gloriously grueling eight minutes to get to the solo. Windhand work well at this pace, and Soma has felt like it’s leading toward “Boleskine”‘s considerable looming presence the whole time, but the closer isn’t just acting as payoff for the songs preceding, instead setting up Windhand not only as willing to challenge themselves but rising to take up that challenge head on with confidence and poise. Unsurprisingly, the solo takes its time — plenty of room to work with — but motion is maintained back toward the chorus and as they pass 10 minutes in, they slow again to step back into the verse, which is a gripping shift, but not a surprise given their by-now-established penchant for structure. The chorus takes hold again and crashes to a break at around 12:40, feedback taking hold in layers of sweet humming and bass rumble, the waves audible, and fade out to wind and soft, barely-there acoustic strumming of the riff. This turn is more unexpected, but after 15 minutes, when they kick back in at full-onslaught volume, it’s a clear sign that “Boleskine” is coming to its end. Over the next 10 minutes or so, Windhand ride that riff, top it with solos, punctuate it with slow drum fills from Wolfe, drench it in noise, and gradually, slowly, over the course of three minutes or so, fade it to its ending, leaving more sampled wind, clicking sounds and what sounds like footsteps to comprise Soma‘s last few moments.

Maybe that’s our technician wandering the earth aimlessly, with a psyche thoroughly demolished by Windhand‘s voluminous pummel. Either way, Soma ends in a suitably foreboding manner, considering the potential the band shows throughout for future works. They’re not toying with cult idolatry, and they’re growing out of their Electric Wizardry, and if songs like “Feral Bones,” “Evergreen” and “Boleskine” — really the whole record — are a sign of things to come from Windhand, there’s a real chance the Richmond outfit could leave a lasting mark on American doom. As their Relapse debut, Soma will no doubt be many listeners’ first experience with Windhand, and it’s got a palpable landmark feel. Helps that it’s of such staggering substance, but as someone who generally champions single-LP-length albums, the additional runtime of Soma is neither excess nor indulgence, but instead a necessary manifestation of Windhand‘s oppressive approach. One of the year’s best in doom, hands down. - The Obelisk, http://theobelisk.net/obelisk/2013/09/10/windhand-soma-review/#sthash.OS30ZsCF.dpuf

pfunkboy (Algerian Goalkeeper), Friday, 17 January 2014 17:47 (ten years ago) link

I'm gonna quote myself, because why the fuck not:

Take current doom darlings Windhand. Their latest album, Soma, has three of the best songs this young Richmond band has yet written: "Orchard," "Woodbine," and "Feral Bones." The first three songs on the album, they find the band in the fine Southern-rock-meets-Electric-Wizard mode they captured so well on their self-titled debut. There is power in those riffs, and a haunting sense of loss in Dorthia Cottrell's voice. Please note that none of those songs reaches even the ten minute mark. Two tracks do break that barrier, and neither is good. "Cassock" is an acceptable if unmemorable song, without either the power of "Orchard" or the hooks of "Woodbine" (though at nearly 14 minutes it approaches their combined length). Album closer "Boleskine," on the other hand, is entirely unacceptable. It's 30 interminable minutes, with unnecessary intros and outros (nearly three minutes of slow fade-in and nearly nine of slow fade-out), a stock doom riff as its core building material, and despite Cottrell's always wonderful delivery, nary a hook of any kind to hang a hat on. The first solo is excellent, but a short burst of smoldering lead guitar can't buttress a 30 minute song. It doesn't work, and torpedoes the great first impression Soma makes.

EZ Snappin, Friday, 17 January 2014 17:52 (ten years ago) link

Voted for last 3. Melt Banana was v high.

the legend of rapper chance (Drugs A. Money), Friday, 17 January 2014 17:59 (ten years ago) link

5 SubRosa - More Constant Than The Gods, 741 Points, 19 Votes, 2 #1s
http://i.imgur.com/aqHsVgc.jpg

#4 Decibel, #11 SPIN, #2 PopMatters, #8 Stereogum, #26 Captain Beyond Zen, #9 Stoner HiVe, #9 Pitchfork, #30 Terrorizer, #79 Pazz & Jop

http://subrosausa.bandcamp.com/album/more-constant-than-the-gods
runnerjma review - http://youtu.be/I05u0skJl2A

“Fat of the Ram”—the pugnacious and swirling fourth track on the new album from fascinating Salt Lake City doom metal band SubRosa—is a folk song. Never mind the weighty guitars that hang like thick shadows or the forceful drums that punch through them. Forget the enraged voices that bellow the lyrics and the slide guitar line that closes tight like a noose, too. Instead, listen to what Rebecca Vernon has to sing: She sets a scene of accepted and quiet suffering, where lakes go septic and unhappiness gets swept under the rug. Dreams are dreamt only in the privacy of homes and otherwise suppressed. The rich lords expect to be left alone, to be given time to “anoint themselves in their finest.” Vernon ends with a glimpse of possible redemption, a Plato’s Cave moment where the narrator intuits life outside of the town’s shadowy desolation. This is the lament of a layperson holding onto the distant promise of hope, a tune not unlike one that Harry Smith might’ve collected.

This isn’t surprising for SubRosa. On 2011’s No Help for the Mighty Ones, the band covered the morose, damned-to-hell Scottish ballad “The House Carpenter”, a song Vernon admits she first heard through Smith’s Anthology of American Folk Music. But that was just an eerie a cappella interpretation. “Fat of the Ram”, like the rest of More Constant than the Gods, is an exceptionally articulated full-band assault, arranged to give each song and story beneath it maximum impact. Often in doom, the impulse can be to turn up and drown out, treating the song mostly as a reason for amplifier massages. (To wit, see the recent Windhand LP, Soma.) This quintet—two violins, three vocalists, bass, drums and Vernon’s wonderful guitar—are much more meticulous than that, treating each number like its own opera rather than an excuse for an onslaught. Combined with Vernon’s uncommonly keen ear for hooks (however dark-hearted they may be) and the band’s grand sense of dynamics, that approach keeps More Constant than the Gods moving throughout its 68 minutes. It’s too active and involving to become a slog or a bore. Instead, it’s one of the year’s most exhilarating heavy metal records.

The members of SubRosa seem to understand these songs and what Vernon is trying to communicate with them, as if she workshopped the lyrics in front of them. The playing is never too deep or too wide, always moving in service of her meaning. The irritation and insurrection written into “Fat of the Ram”, for instance, shows up in the music, with its start-and-stop lashes of sound directed at the blindly content townsfolk and their scheming leaders. “Everywhere I look/ all I see is famine,” Vernon sings at one point, her voice suddenly downshifting into droll scorn. The music slows into a formless blur behind her, underlining the desperation in her observation. It’s Leadbelly kicked forward several decades. Likewise, “The Usher” opens with a duet above a twinkling bed of noise, Vernon trading lines with the gentle-voiced Jason McFarland as a violin etches curlicues against the din. The band finally lunges forward in unison, affixing their heaviness to a surprisingly forward tempo. This is a love song to the dark and to mortality, so SubRosa afford it a sinister romanticism. Bright violin leads peeking out through the down-tuned glumness, and the feeling is terrifying but warm.
The spirit doesn’t dovetail with the song only in these epics. Each of Constant’s six tracks either ignores or approaches the 10-minute mark, except for the seven-minute “Cosey Mo”, practically making it a radio single. SubRosa lend the tale of immortal grievances and obsessions appropriate drama. The strings are essential here. In the chorus, the violins of Sarah Pendleton and Kim Pack surge behind the guitars and vocals, helping to brand the refrain into memory. During a slinking little midsection, they trace pizzicato patterns around the gathering storm of Vernon’s voice. Finally, as the coda crests, they mirror and then fight against Vernon’s riff, reflecting the unresolved tension of the song’s quest to avenge or at least vindicate a death. Though “Cosey Mo” is the record’s shortest and most immediate song, it’s not the only one capable of planting a hook. “Affliction” turns its imprecation into an indelible if understated chorus. “Ghosts of a Dead Empire”, a send-up of missions for purity and perfection, doesn’t necessarily have a refrain, but its conclusion is memorable and haunting. Vernon’s tune moves evenly with the blown-out riff, matched by harmonies and the emphatic wallop of the rhythm section. It’s a moment of post-metal triumph, with splendor and volume spiraling into one radiant climax.

SubRosa’s first two albums were strong testaments from a doom band with an interesting lineup and manifest interests outside of metal. On More Constant than the Gods, they’ve not only managed to synthesize those enthusiasms but to do so while this strange tangle of musicians works together—unselfishly and with complete subservience to the bigger picture of song, statement, and album. There’s folk storytelling and alt-rock worthy choruses, doom intensity and classical grandeur. It’s hard not to be caught up in the incredible power of SubRosa’s sounds and the wide-screen permanence of their songs. - Grayson Currin, Pitchfork, http://pitchfork.com/reviews/albums/18395-subrosa-more-constant-than-the-gods/

I think it is very safe to say that most metal bands don’t particularly value songwriting. This is more prevalent in some permutations than others, but particularly in the doom/sludge/stoner vortex, the only considerations for some seem to be “are we playing the riff?” or “are we playing a clip of one of us ripping a bong?” Granted, I love that clip, and it’s kicked off many a classic riff, but those two in combination can only keep a song, let alone a career, going for so long. Eventually, I want something more.

Subrosa has just the skills to fix that. This Salt Lake City band’s fourth release, More Constant Than The Gods, moves and sways like the deck of a sinking ship, tilting from crushing riffs to night-sky expansiveness with a crucial ear for harmony. “Cosey Mo” builds from a bluesy riff into its protracted, four-minute climax of swirling violins and soaring vocals, as singer and songwriter Rebecca Vernon monastically repeats her mantra of “burning/instead of you.” She repeats that image, adding “ire” on closer “No Safe Harbor,” this year’s sludgy piano ballad to beat, droning flute and electric strings flying high overhead.

Doom with a taste for atmosphere isn’t new, however, and it isn’t only what Subrosa does right here. Rather, most of these songs inhabit structures that your parents or grandparents would recognize. Though stretched past the 10-minute-mark in all but one case, these are undeniably songs, with melodies and refrains and codas that betray a band interested in craft and polish, the days of insular noisemaking long passed.
Take the record’s most successful song, opener “The Usher.” Three minutes of slowly-picked bass thrum under first female and then male voices, the two never quite meeting as feedback loops and violin saws and tension builds. After a few seconds of silence, the hammer comes down, and sludgy guitars and drums enter the picture, eventually joined by delay-drenched pizzicato strings that swirl wildly-dissonant figures to a furious downbeat. As music goes, it’s explicit, illustrating more than evoking. “All of my life I’ve been waiting for you” Vernon howls in harmony with Kim Pack and Sarah Pendleton, the group’s violinists, and you see, instead of simply feel, her meaning. It’s powerful stuff.

The central trio of Vernon, Pack and Pendleton, the only constants throughout Subrosa’s career, are its most powerful forces. Though not always omnipresent, the latter members’ violins are the band’s most distinctive element, oscillating between Godspeed-style elegiacal tones and distorted madman swirls, like those of Dirty Three’s Warren Ellis. When their vocals harmonize with Vernon’s, as on the mournful minor-chord sludge of “Fat of the Ram,” the result is of a non-corporeal hallucination, echoes of echoes fading through time.

Though some of their vocal melodies and within-song transitions feel a little rough, in need of a guiding hand or a little more practice, Subrosa display a phenomenal gift for subtlety, one that is pretty much unknown in a genre defined by Dopesmoker and Dopethrone. “No Safe Harbor” closes out with a droning hammered dulcimer solo, and the tiny plinks and plunks of a xylophone intimate their selves elsewhere on the record. And to their credit, the violins of Pack and Pendleton never become generic place-markers for beauty or melody, instead generating more noise than the more traditionally ‘rock’ part of the group.

More Constant Than The Gods is a high-water mark for Subrosa, as well as among their peers. It thriftily balances tone, noise and nuance in a really, truly exciting way. Dreadlocked dudes with terrible tattoos: the ball is in your court. - Cvlt Nation, http://www.cvltnation.com/subrosa-constant-godsstream-review/

pfunkboy (Algerian Goalkeeper), Friday, 17 January 2014 18:02 (ten years ago) link

I was never in doubt about fetch. placing tho

the legend of rapper chance (Drugs A. Money), Friday, 17 January 2014 18:03 (ten years ago) link

Mind Control was so disappointing.

An embarrassing doorman and garbage man (dog latin), Friday, 17 January 2014 18:04 (ten years ago) link

three of the top four are nailed on but who's the fourth

a chance to cross is a chance to score (anonanon), Friday, 17 January 2014 18:06 (ten years ago) link

I'm kind of amazed SubRosa was #79 in Pazz n Jop. SubRosa have come a long way from their early albums!

Regarding Uncle Acid, I remember AG's relentless campaigning for that second album. His enthusiasm was infectious for sure. I really love a couple songs on the first album, surprised Rise Above hasn't reissued it.

Fastnbulbous, Friday, 17 January 2014 18:11 (ten years ago) link

To avoid confusion, Uncle Acid's first album was Vol. 1 (Killer Candy, 2010), possibly cassette only? I think it was "Witches Garden" that was my favorite.

Fastnbulbous, Friday, 17 January 2014 18:14 (ten years ago) link

cdr only

pfunkboy (Algerian Goalkeeper), Friday, 17 January 2014 18:16 (ten years ago) link

Important question, is "heavy metal-leaden/quasi-boogie shit rock" included under the "lava lamp bullshit" category?

Fastnbulbous, Friday, 17 January 2014 18:19 (ten years ago) link

sounds like an xgau-ism

pfunkboy (Algerian Goalkeeper), Friday, 17 January 2014 18:20 (ten years ago) link

i have a red, RED, cd edition of uncle acids blood lust

and i'm with AG, i really really like mind control.

that said i am not a metal man, so no idea as to how it fits in ...

mark e, Friday, 17 January 2014 18:24 (ten years ago) link

<quote>deafheaven seemed way more emo than metal to me but I only listened to that record one time and it was a while back</quote>

yeah, reminded me of bands like Envy, things that were labeled as post-rock/screamo more than of anything else. But better.

antoni, Friday, 17 January 2014 18:26 (ten years ago) link

sorry about the quote formatting

antoni, Friday, 17 January 2014 18:27 (ten years ago) link

Mind Control is a lot less poppy and immediate than blood lust so i can see why some arent as excited by it.

pfunkboy (Algerian Goalkeeper), Friday, 17 January 2014 18:27 (ten years ago) link

4 Gorguts - Colored Sands, 779 Points, 19 Votes, 2 #1s
http://i.imgur.com/WklnoM4.jpg
http://open.spotify.com/album/0MbEcbEOCXgCSoJELQO5NS
spotify:album:0MbEcbEOCXgCSoJELQO5NS

http://www.deezer.com/album/6771531
#20 Revolver, #3 Decibel, #7 SPIN, #5 PopMatters, #2 Stereogum, #2 MetalSucks, #2 MetalSucks musicians, #5 Pitchfork, #34 Terrorizer, #68 Pazz & Jop

http://gorguts.bandcamp.com/track/colored-sands
theneedledrop - http://youtu.be/XV6nHQJMe7g

Let me know if you can find a metal band that utilizes dissonance and technicality to a large degree that doesn’t cite Gorgut‘s masterful work as an influence. I’ll probably be waiting a long time so I’ll bring a good book – it’s called “The Band That Pioneered Dissonance and Technicality in Death Metal” and it has the word ‘Gorguts‘ repeated over and over. But it’s that huge sense of respect for the band and the enormous anticipation for this release that made it such a tricky one for the legendary act. 12 years is not only a long time for hype to build around a record, but it also gives newcomers and pretenders a chance to overtake the legends should they prove unable to live up to their own mammoth legacy. After all, a lot of bands are remembered for their creative peak, even when they can’t maintain that level indefinitely. So perhaps Obscura and From Wisdom to Hate era was their peak and all they’ll really conjure up this time is a solid record, right?

Enter Colored Sands, the long-awaited opus that exceeded the expectations of just about the entire metal community and became the strongest death metal release of 2013 (so far). A record that doesn’t simply repeat the successes of Obscura and From Wisdom to Hate, but puts a completely new spin on it. No doubt the process was heavily affected by new members who brought their all to the crusade to defend the band’s legacy which was built with some of the most forward-thinking death metal records ever. The huge wall of dissonant lead work and dizzying rhythm riffs have been crafted into something far more atmospheric, but with the heaviness and weight only Gorguts could take to this level, making Colored Sands not only near-immaculately put together, but perhaps one of the most absorbing albums of their genre.

It’s almost difficult to wrap my head around just how perfectly everything came together on this album. Despite Luc being the only original member and the sole reason the band reunited, the new additions are amazing and everyone seems right at home in the swirling, abrasive murk that this album creates so masterfully. Taking this huge, crushing soundscape and pairing it with interesting and unpredictable song structures bordering on progressive was a great decision and it’s executed with pinpoint precision. The massive walls of rhythm guitar with the noodly, technical leads flying over it are immaculately done and create many layers to get lost in while keeping the album on an amazing pace.

gorguts_2013The riffs are absorbing, dizzying and uncompromisingly heavy. Despite the sound palette being unusually airy for a death metal record, none of the heaviness is sacrificed for atmosphere thanks to the stellar production work of their bassist, Colin Marston. The mix is dynamic, well-balanced and above all, crushing. It may well be one of the best metal production jobs this year. The guitar and bass work are as impressive as you’d expect from members of Dysrhythmia and they have absolutely no trouble keeping up with the creative mind and guitar-work of Luc Lemay. The drumwork by John Longstreth is no small feat either. It’s a much more subtle affair than you’d find with many modern death metal bands, but it’s full of interesting beats that become absolutely huge when needed as they build up to the album’s many climaxes. The man’s experience in other technical death bands like Origins obviously puts him right at home here and he does not disappoint.

There isn’t a track here that isn’t interesting or doesn’t have a hugely memorable moment. The lead guitar near the end of “An Ocean of Wisdom” and the absolutely massive rhythm guitar explosion towards the end of “Forgotten Arrows” are simply brilliant. Even the purely orchestral track “The Battle of Chamdo” is far from a throwaway interlude and is an incredibly well put together string piece. After the interlude, the album takes what the first half had and ascends to even more dizzying heights, getting better and better until the brilliant closer “Reduced to Silence.”

Colored Sands is the album Gorguts needed to make to cement their relevancy among bands that have taken their sound and forged it into something new, but it goes even further and affirms their legacy as the best of their trade. Ulcerate have released some truly superb albums in their time, Portal have been arguably more dissonant and dark and Deathspell Omega did a great job of taking their riffing style into the black metal posture, but none are Gorguts, and they’re back and performing stronger than ever. - Noctus, Angry Metal Guy, http://www.angrymetalguy.com/gorguts-colored-sands-review/

It has been 12 years since Gorguts last released an album.

It has been a full 15 years since they dropped The Album That Changed Everything.

But it has only been about half of that time since I truly got to know Luc Lemay’s innovations. Being the late bloomer that I was, when Obscura dropped during my senior year of high school I was too busy listening to Pantera to dig into the actual underground, and didn’t truly dive into death metal until my college years. So getting to an album as game-changing as Obscura took a backseat to catching up on the Morbid Angel and Death records I’d known about for ages.

Therefore, I was not only absent for the wave of change that the album represented, I was also not on board until the dust had settled and imitators had long been failing in their quest to duplicate the kind of one-time genius that simply can’t be duplicated. Gorguts themselves could "only" follow up the album with the brilliant-but-less-than-innovative From Wisdom To Hate. I won’t get too detailed here, but refer to the personal blog of our own Ian Chainey, who offers a much more detailed telling of what Gorguts and Obscura meant for heavy metal music late in the millennium. He was around to hear the bomb drop, and he quite accurately describes the feeling that the album gives when it truly “clicks.” I likewise had such a clicking moment, but it was blurred by knowing what the album represented, and lacked the purity of what Ian and many others must have experienced way back in nineteen hunert’n’ninety-eight.

All of this is a way to say that in many ways, Colored Sands feels like my Gorguts album. The one that I will get to know with everyone else, not later after the surprise has settled. So reviewing the album was an exciting proposition, and an act that seems to provide a strange maturity to my life as a metal fan. Not that you, dear reader, really give much of a shit about this history, but perspective for such a monumental release is an important ingredient in understanding one person’s analysis.

So now you have this perspective… onto the album we go…

Much has already been made about the band that Lemay has assembled for the modern incarnation of Gorguts, with fans assuming the worst or best, depending on their opinions of the talent involved. Regardless of said opinions, considering any of the band members less than a master of his craft would be an error; each brings a music school nerd kind of flair to Colored Sands. On second guitar, Lemay brought in Dysrhythmia’s Kevin Hufnagel; on bass, Hufnagel’s bandmate Colin Marston (also of Behold… The Arctopus and Krallice); and on drums, tech wiz John Longstreth (Dim Mak, Origin, etc.). These names will obviously elicit certain impressions, but any trepidations should be set aside, and right the fuck now.

The foursome not only sounds like Gorguts, but is Gorguts, and that success is due to one very important point: despite these songs being largely constructed by Luc Lemay, he allowed each member to shape their parts and be themselves. Hufnagel adapts his Dysrhythmia style into a kind of Lemay-on-atonal-steroids approach, enhancing the already signature dissonances of the band. Marston’s bass is fucking bonkers here, simultaneously acting as a third guitar in harmonies, providing counter-melody, and being produced in such a hard-edged manner as to also sound like an additional percussion instrument. (Really, the album is worth buying for the bass work alone.) Longstreth, meanwhile, is what you would expect him to be: a consummate professional with immeasurable technical talents, and a crucial ingredient in the album’s massive dynamics. Finally, there is Lemay himself, whose riffage is as brutal and beautiful as ever, combining slowly-developing melody with harsh atonality and clinical precision, while his vocal performance is the best of his career, finding a way to be more aggressive and forceful than ever.

The collective talent of these aces means that Colored Sands sounds like an updated, denser version of Obscura, and damn near just as thrilling. This is dense, immaculately performed and produced, dynamic, and insanely exciting music, to say nothing of how it stands within death metal. Each of these eight tracks (and one interlude) is a journey, and each adds to the journey of the whole, with songs often leading directly into another. There is nary a dull moment, and even orchestral interlude “The Battle of Chamdo” – which initially feels more like an intro to a Dimmu Borgir album than a Gorguts track – eventually worms its way into the brain of the listener. In fact, the only perceivable flaw on the album is how penultimate track “Absconders” could easily have been a few minutes shorter. But this is a minor nitpick, as the track remains strong, and the plodding finish merely slows the album’s momentum a tad as it reaches towards its hour-plus run time.

But the rest of that hour? Good gravy does it tickle the ears, folks. It takes about five seconds for opener “Le Toit du Monde” to reveal its quality, changing between guitar-and-bass twitchery and the band’s signature “trapped” melodies (cyclical and super active, but unable to break out of the brutal prison in which they operate), with the band constantly piling on the nuts. The clincher is when Gorguts employs their almost inconceivable ability to vaguely reference earlier song themes, as if in some compositional attempt to catch a listener off guard and make them question exactly what they have heard; and they do it all over the album. At the other end of the same spectrum is the title track, which aims to show off exactly how vastly dynamic this music can be. Beginning with a minimal “ping” of the guitar, it crafts a slow crescendo, sounding almost like a clean Meshuggah section before the flood is unleashed. The heavy comes, and the heavy overwhelms. The moment when Lemay’s vocals arrive might be the most naturally headbangable thing the band has done since their Suffocation-esque early days, and the track just keeps growing. The heft is like some giant, thinking, cybernetic tank, and the jazzy lead lines are like wires that desperately try to tangle in the tread, but are only absorbed and assimilated into the greater, demented machinery.

The temptation to give a full account of each song is indeed quite high, because the level of rich detail and thought that went into Colored Sands is staggering, and I just so much want to talk about it. I’d love to get into every last drop of the Morbid Angel-by-way-of-Obscura feel of “An Ocean of Wisdom,” or how the finale of “Forgotten Arrows” just takes everything fucking down as the song conquers itself. Then there is the neck-breaking riffage and ludicrous soloing in “Enemies of Compassion,” you might want to hear more about that. Or perhaps how a particularly percussive passage of “Ember’s Voice” comes across as an extreme metal version of a Stomp concert. Or even that relentless hook in closer “Reduced to Silence,” and how the band suddenly abandons it only to constantly tease its return. I’m sure you’d love to know more about that, and I’d love to get into every minute nuance, but something has to be saved. Just know that each of these passages are only small nuggets of the songs that house them, and that the richness of detail on Colored Sands will likely reveal new secrets just as long as Obscura has.

Granted, this album can never mean to death metal what Obscura did; it is utterly impossible. But it can add to one band’s musical legacy in massive ways, and if the short time I have spent with Colored Sands has anything to say, it is that this will indeed thrill any and all fans of the band, and those of adventurous music in general. (This is said while realizing that the closed-mindedness about heavy metal will mean that most “adventurous music fans” will never give the album a chance, but it really needs to be shoved into the ears of every blue-blooded Julliard freshman.) At this juncture, Colored Sands feels to be even stronger than the monstrous From Wisdom To Hate. Again, this will be up to time to decide, but it isn’t up to this review to look into the future. I can’t predict that any more than I can go into the past and experience the shock of Obscura with everyone else. All I can say is that this is the type of music that must be heard at least once, and even if you come away not enjoying it, the notes within will have bent your perception of the possibilities of music, if only a little.
And that, more than anything else, makes this a Gorguts album. - Zach Duvall, Last Rites, http://lastrit.es/reviews/7075/gorguts-colored-sands#sthash.KtwLKwEu.dpuf

pfunkboy (Algerian Goalkeeper), Friday, 17 January 2014 18:30 (ten years ago) link

Heard this for the first time and went in my full-poll top 5 quicker that you can say 'holy progdeath motherfucker'

lovely cuddly fluffy dope (imago), Friday, 17 January 2014 18:47 (ten years ago) link

I guess this means that Gorguts aren't number one.

J3ff T., Friday, 17 January 2014 18:47 (ten years ago) link

Two days ago, I mean. It's a ridiculous & staggering achievement and trust me I know a ridiculous & staggering achievement when I (rarely) hear it. Would have been my #2 had I voted

lovely cuddly fluffy dope (imago), Friday, 17 January 2014 18:49 (ten years ago) link

This got an impressive amount of support (see the #68 ranking in Pazz n Jop) for such a challenging album. I admire it more than lurve it. What, you didn't vote Imago? WTF!

Fastnbulbous, Friday, 17 January 2014 18:50 (ten years ago) link


You must be logged in to post. Please either login here, or if you are not registered, you may register here.