C or D : Guided By Voices.

Ironic as "Class Clown Spots A UFO" is just a re-recording of "Crocker's Favorite Song" a Bee Thousand era (earlier?) outtake... unless that's what you were trying to say.

Crocker's has always been one of my favourite GBV songs, ever since I got the first box set.

But I feel like I've heard so many songs by GBV now I honestly couldn't tell you with any confidence what my favourites were. You're right about Let's Go Eat The Factory, but Old Bones crushes me every time I hear it.

I played my old vinyl of Jellyfish Reflector yesterday morning, that's sublime GBV IMHO

I would have to include Imperial Racehorsing on any list of the best post-reunion stuff. Otherwise, that's a pretty good list!

Not sure if it's just because it was the 1st, but I've played _...Factory_ way more than the others.

I like Factory the best, and still play it moderately often. I was kind of surprised that most people seemed to prefer what came after.

This Spotify GBV playlist has made my week. Thanks!!!

also "waking up the stars" is insanely good

I really should be contributing to this thread revival but I never checked out the rest after being deflated by one listen to Factory when it came out. I'm a classic era super fan btw.

The new albums are like saying "here, you can have all this delicious ice cream in every flavor you can imagine, but first you have to eat this bowl of dogshit (i.e. Factory)!"

Yeah, I'll absolutely check out the others. That seems to be a majority opinion.

"Dropping the Bomb" on Suitcase 3 is freaking wonderful. Beautiful (!) harmonies. At a minute-and-a-half, I kinda wish it went on for another...minute.

i'm enjoying my playlist a lot right now because i'm just listening to it and i'm not worrying about if the song is "good enough" to make my playlist

officially...over

imagine this might be it for good

hell of a rock band

Yeah but what could've happened?! So weird to cancel/quit without fanfare.

i assume one of these guys will spill the beans soon enough

Almost every news article about this includes "for real" in the breakup announcement. I'm pretty sure every GBV breakup has been for real. They've just regrouped after a time.

they have long struck me as the kind of band who probably break up, in a not for real way, after pretty much every show.

drinky drinky motion

Saw the New Haven show a few months back. The band was great but after it was over I couldn't help thinking to myself that it would be very very hard to sustain that much inebriation night after night. Bob was quite wasted at the halfway point of the show and nearly incoherent after it was done. My guess is that the band got tired of it or that someone is in rehab...

As far as I know he has performed shows similarly to that for well over a decade now, hard to believe it's just now hit the breaking point.

could be a repeat of the kevin fennell thing only this time pollard didn't wanna bother amending the "classic" line-up any further

I'm awaiting the announcement of a regouping with the Cobra Verde lineup.

Cool Planet was my second favorite of the reunion albums so its a shame they break up now. Time to call up Tommy Keene.

I remember thinking a Keene/Pollard collaboration would work nicely and then I learned it already existed.

I remember getting a coupla of rekkids signed by him, along with the Jim Greer book as the two were going to book stores to promote it a few years back. I asked him, "so what have you been diggin' music-wise lately," and he quickly said, "the Moles." I was not at all surprised when he did the postal service band, "Cosmos," with Richard Davies literally two months later.
He's just an amazing, fun, modern psych/rock songwriter, and I'm sure we'll get a smattering of quality product that badly needs an editor for years to come. When I saw 'em at some street fair in Chicago this summer, I really thought it was Demos and March holding the whole thing together. Toby just looked super-pissed off, and Mitch kinda phoned it in on the songs he didn't obviously dig. Bobby was Bobby. It was a good run, and it truthfully felt over after the final show in '05. Of the 6 (!) Classic lineup rekkids, I only really liked 'Bears,' 'League,' and, 'Planet.' They coulda seriously done just one good double LP, and that woulda had a big inner groove. I always thought Fennel was a slow drummer, and was kinda glad they booted him after the drum set farce.

i had forgotten about that!
honestly i am glad this reunion is over. the gimmick of gbv was honestly starting to make me like them less and i don't want to like them less.
i hope everyone's health is ok.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2Cl-grAJlt8#t=165

"Asked for a more detailed reason why the group is disbanding, Mr. Pollard responded through his manager in an email.
“I feel we’ve done some great work with these albums,” he wrote, “it wasn’t just a reunion to cash in. But it’s gone as far as it was going to go and to go beyond this point, to any degree or any length would be just going through the motions. It’s time to wrap it up with this particular entity.”

hmm
sounds like something else happened but ok

He's way more wasted there than any of the three times I've seen them play.

maybe they gave him an ultimatum about excessive drinking and/or recording

lol. I for one welcome this breakup since it will give me a much needed chance to catch up on their recorded oeuvre subsequent to Earthquake Glue.

i've seen pollard plastered beyond the possibilities of mathematics numerous times, but that stone pony footage is pretty fucking depressing.

i can't even watch it

ugh that is fucking horrible

Wow I thought that Replacements reunion clip was bad...

But yeah looks like he's moved on from slugging Budweiser to Jack Daniels which packs a little different punch.

Ha, I was just thinking Bob P should join up with Tommy and Paul in some kind of bizarre supergroup.

?? The Replacements were pretty pro the other night

Actually wish I were going to see the 'Mats tonight but I am under the weather.

What clips I saw/heard of the big Replacements show in St. Paul last week were pretty great. Was reminded of when Fogerty started playing CCR songs again.

stone pony footage reminds me that i saw them plenty in 90s and 00s, and don't need to be bummed that they never came to the uk in this incarnation, because that is some awful garbage.

The albums weren't very good either

Looks like it's tequila he's swigging from. Fuck's sake. When did he switch to that from beer?

Last time I saw GBV play in London - must have been 2003? - he was swigging from a JD bottle

xp i liked a couple of them, and the others had good moments, which is pretty much how i felt about all gbv post-earthquake drills

he did seem to gt extra drunk in london. he never got that nasty wasted tho.

Tequila since at least 2010. He passed it around during the Maxwell's show.

sooooooooo saaaaaaaaad
what has become of this supercreative person?!

which is pretty much how i felt about all gbv post-earthquake drills

They did an outdoor show in St Paul at a street fest about 10yrs ago before another hiatus, this was last gasp of the Billiard lineup, pretty bad, that one younger bass player dude who drove the pickup truck in that one gbv video kept asking for coke onstage

haha okay the drills album, the divorce album with chasing heather crazy xp