Don't go for second best, baby. Put your ILM ARTIST POLL #31: MADONNA to the test.

hang on have we done the remixes results yet?!

1. Open Your Heart
2. Burning Up
3. Live To Tell
4. Angel
5. Lucky Star
6. Deeper and Deeper
7. Hung Up
8. Bad Girl
9. Words
10. Love Tried To Welcome Me
11. Vogue
12. Till Death Do Us Part
13. Take a Bow
14. Sky Fits Heaevn
15. Thief of Hearts
16. Keep It Together
17. Crazy For You
18. Like a Prayer
19. Gambler
20. Don't Tell Me

Nice. "Open Your Heart" was my #2, too. Best "sugar" Madonna by leagues.

Did I miss the remix rollout?

My ballot:

Burning Up - 40
Lucky Star - 36
White Heat - 33
Into The Groove - 30
Justify My Love -28
Live To Tell - 26
Skin - 25
Frozen - 24
Dress You Up - 23
Open Your Heart - 22
La Isla Bonita - 21
Angel - 20
Holiday - 19
Human Nature - 18
Crazy For You - 17
Papa Don't Preach - 16
Express Yourself - 15
The Power Of Good-Bye - 14
Where's The Party - 13
What It Feels Like For A Girl - 12

(included a note "fear my wasted vote for Skin", lol)

ALBUMS:

True Blue - 10
Madonna - 8
Ray of Light - 6
American Life - 4
Bedtime Stories - 2

VIDEOS:

What It Feels Like For A Girl - 10
Open Your Heart - 8
Borderline - 6
Bedtime Story - 4
Frozen - 2

hang on have we done the remixes results yet?!

We haven't. I ran out of time this weekend and didn't pull together any results yet. They're forthcoming (perhaps tomorrow?).

Into the Groove
Vogue
Like a Prayer
Express Yourself
Lucky Star
Hung Up
Beautiful Stranger
Open Your Heart
Music
Like a Virgin
Don't Tell Me
Cherish
Impressive Instant
Deeper and Deeper
Material Girl
Papa Don't Preach
Burning Up
La Isla Bonita
Holiday
Over and Over

1. "Beautiful Stranger" (40)
2. "Holiday" (36)
3. "Open Your Heart" (33)
4. "Ray of Light" (30)
5. "Shoo-Bee-Doo" (28)
________________________________

"Bad Girl" (19)
"Borderline" (19)
"Crazy for You" (19)
"Don't Tell Me" (19)
"Dress You Up" (19--somewhere on this thread I say I didn't vote for it, duh)
"Give Me All Your Luvin'"
"Hung Up" (19)
"Into the Groove" (19)
"Live to Tell" (19)
"Miles Away" (19)
"Oh Father" (19)
"This Used to Be My Playground" (19)
"Vogue" (19)
"What It Feels Like for a Girl" (19)
"Who's That Girl" (19)

Deee-Lite. Now there's an early '90s sound I find tiresome.

one of the best polls and poll threads i can recall. thanks jf. happy enough with the top 2.

my ballots:

1. live to tell - 40
2. lucky star - 36
3. open your heart - 33
4. bad girl - 30
5. papa don't preach - 28
6. physical attraction - 26
7. into the groove - 25
8. borderline - 24
9. crazy for you - 23
10. justify my love - 22
11. get together - 21
12. dress you up - 20
13. deeper and deeper - 19
14. la isla bonita - 18
15. like a prayer - 17
16. bedtime story - 16
17. vogue - 15
18. burning up - 14
19. secret - 13
20. sorry - 12

remixes

1. la isla bonita (the revenge rework)
2. sorry (man with guitar edit)
3. what it feels like for a girl (above & beyond remix)
4. get together (james holden remix)
5. erotica (masters at work mix)

1. Like a Prayer
2. Hung Up
3. Open Your Heart
4. Dress You Up
5. Into the Groove
6. Dear Jessie
7. Lucky Star
8. Papa Don't Preach
9. Sorry
10. I Love New York
11. Holiday
12. Angel
13. Oh Father
14. Like a Virgin
15. Till Death Do Us Part
16. Material Girl
17. Borderline
18. What It Feels Like For A Girl
19. Ray of Light
20. Take a Bow

1. Like a Prayer
2. Confessions on the Dancefloor
3. Like a Virgin
4. True Blue
5. Erotica

Thanks Johnny. Perfect poll. My ballot:

1. Live to Tell (5)
2. Hung Up (SDP Extended Vocal) (14)
3. Borderline (4)
4. Justify My Love (15)
5. Into the Groove (1)
6. Bedtime Story (Orbital Mix) (38)
7. Oh Father (21)
8. Ray of Light (12)
9. Beautiful Stranger (20)
10. Deeper and Deeper (3)
11. Jump (DNP)
12. Like a Prayer (6)
13. Lucky Star (7)
14. Words (50)
15. Crazy For You (11)
16. Bad Girl (22)
17. Sorry (DNP)
18. Open Your Heart (2)
19. Burning Up (8)
20. Music (32)

If you're posting ballots and voted for remixes, edit your posts. I haven't rolled that subpoll out yet.

This has been my favorite poll to lurk on. Just getting into the first few records, and really digging the Madonna I wasn't previously familiar with (except for that last song on True Blue, which doesn't feel like it should occupy the same space as the brilliant "Live To Tell").

oops at revealing my remixes ballot, thought it was a dead rubber.

songs I really wanted to make space on my ballot for but cut at the last minute:

Secret
Impressive Instant
Borderline
Physical Attraction
Papa Don't Preach
Nothing Fails
Love Profusion
Sky Fits Heaven

1. Deeper and Deeper
2. Bad Girl
3. Into The Groove
4. Love Tried to Welcome Me
5. Waiting
6. Secret Garden
7. Like a Prayer
8. Crazy For You
9. Vogue
10. Open Your Heart
11. Take a Bow
12. Burning Up
13. Get Together
14. Secret
15. Gambler
16. Holiday
17. Hung Up
18. Papa Don't Preach
19. Keep It Together
20. Justify My Love

slightly strategic placing of my fav deep cuts at the top under my eternal top 3, but they'd all be top 15 at least anyway

Deeper And Deeper (40)
Into The Groove (36)
Justify My Love (33)
Vogue (30)
Secret (28)
Hung Up (26)
Like A Prayer (25)
White Heat (24)
Waiting (23)
Like A Virgin (22)

Sorry (21)
Lucky Star (20)
Causing A Commotion (19)
Secret Garden (18)
Erotica (17)
Think Of Me (16)
He's A Man (15)
La Isla Bonita (14)
Nothing Really Matters (13)
Gone (12)
_________

Erotica (10)
Bedtime Stories (8)
Madonna (6)
Confessions On A Dancefloor (4)
I'm Breathless (2)

thought it was a dead rubber.

It may be. I don't know if there was enough consensus behind anything to bother with a top 10, but in case there was, I'd hate to have it spoiled.

oh wait Papa Don't Preach made it, lol

I'm surprised Sorry didn't make it.

I'm not; that song bricked hardcore here

http://students.cis.uab.edu/rwienke/sorry2.jpg

can we talk for a second though about how cuckoo "Impressive Instant" is

JF, is there a single imgur page where we can see all the images in one place by any chance?

dumb question - when were the remix results rolled out? I think I missed that part of the countdown

earlier today, someone was talking about how "burning up" sounds less like a come-on to a guy and more like a come-on to the universe. "open your heart" does the opposite for me. "i've had to work much harder than this for something i want, don't try to resist me" sounds like madonna's career objectives on paper, but on record it sounds like the most beautifully relentless/desperate/confident love song ever made. and if the "one is such a lonely number" bridge hook doesn't melt the guy completely and win him over for life, the "aaah aaah aaah aaah" that follows will surely do the trick.

can we talk for a second though about how cuckoo "Impressive Instant" is

cuckoo, like a bird on the wingy wingy wingy

thank you Fever. new madonna fan itt.

xpost YES to lex's question, I'm dying to see an image thread

"open your heart" is the perfect pre-date song

and huge kudos to JF, this was a really really fun poll.

Sorry was a great great song

1. Vogue - 40
2. Open Your Heart - 36
3. Thief of Hearts - 33
4. Erotica - 30
5. I'll Remember - 28
6. Like a Prayer - 26
7. Bad Girl - 25
8. Human Nature - 24
9. Live To Tell - 23
10. Lucky Star - 22
11. Inside of Me - 21
12. Fever - 20
13. Deeper and Deeper - 19
14. Express Yourself - 18
15. Into The Groove - 17
16. Jump - 16
17. Nothing Really Matters - 15
18. Get Together - 14
19. What It Feels Like For a Girl - 13
20. I'm Addicted - 12

Albums
1. Erotica
2. Bedtime Stories
3. I'm Breathless
4. Confessions on a Dance Floor
5. True Blue

Videos
1. Express Yourself
2. Bad Girl
3. What It Feels Like For a Girl
4. Hung Up
5. Nothing Really Matters

i REALLY LOVE the idea that there are still people only just getting into madonna, and that we are helping them in some small way

also a bit jealous of the fucking treasure trove awaiting you all

Subj: madonna poll ballot - how's life
1. Papa Don't Preach

2. Borderline

3. Cherish

4. Burning Up

5. Human Nature

6. Dress You Up

7. Bad Girl

8. Deeper and Deeper

9. La Isla Bonita

10. What It Feels Like For a Girl

11. Who's That Girl

12. Erotica

13. Frozen

14. Lucky Star

15. Holiday

16. Like a Prayer

17. Everybody

18. Into the Groove

19. Bedtime Story

20. Like a Virgin

Albums

1. Madonna

2. Bedtime Stories

3. Like a Virgin

4. Erotica

5. Ray of Light

JF, is there a single imgur page where we can see all the images in one place by any chance?

http://imgur.com/a/oMZkq

I don't want to sideswipe other, slower polls but the pacing of this one made it so much more fun.

"open your heart" does the opposite for me. "i've had to work much harder than this for something i want, don't try to resist me" sounds like madonna's career objectives on paper, but on record it sounds like the most beautifully relentless/desperate/confident love song e

You've answered the question of why this song is so difficult to karaoke.

when were the remix results rolled out?

They haven't been. Depending on what adding up the results looks like tonight, they'll appear tomorrow.

Also, given the surprisingly small pool of deep cuts vs. the overwhelming abundance of obvious contenders, placement in this poll in particular meant so much more than usual.

xpost oh hooray! I was afraid I'd miss the whole shebang

thx johnny

that might now be my favourite page on the whole of the internet

this whole thing has been incredible thank you so much JF

I don't want to sideswipe other, slower polls but the pacing of this one made it so much more fun

Partly due to nature of artist, partly due to quality of posters tbh - feels like most of our top music writers are heads

said this yesterday but, man, watching the "Open The Heart" video again I'm struck by what a beautifully wrought collection of images it is.

hey johnny when were the remix results rolled out i don't remember the remix results rolling out where are they huh where are the remix results

where's the party

lol

btw "Into the Groove" is such a beast of a song, so perfect in so many ways

1. holiday
2. open your heart
3. like a prayer
4. deeper and deeper
5. burning up
6. the power of good-bye
7. into the groove
8. rain
9. live to tell
10. ray of light
11. act of contrition
12. like a virgin
13. thief of hearts
14. what it feels like for a girl
15. don't tell me
16. dear jessie
17. jimmy jimmy
18. vogue
19. hung up
20. till death do us part