A Foreign Language Vocabulary Thread: In Which We Look For Things That Have A Different, Non-Cognate Name in English/French/Spanish/German.

re: boy, i looked up 'cowboy' and couldn't find one for german, which seems odd.

Old Shatterhand?

Cowboy is Cowboy in German.

Hut is German for hat. Pizza Hut chose not to change its name when they expanded into Germany, so it's known there as Pizza Hat.

'Boy' looks good. thanks, ShariVari. iirc, Danish, Swedish and Norwegian all have a different word for this. Is "child" related to "Kind"? If not, then that also should work.

Thanks to everybody else as well- I was afraid this thread would end up a barren Bergmanesque howl into the void on a dreary winter Sunday aka What You Talkin Bout, Willis? but it has shaped up pretty nicely. Now back to my errands.

oh 'nightmare' seemed close except for the mar part of 'cauchemar'

The OED is undecided as to whether "child" is related to "Kind":

from root *kilþ- , whence also Gothic kilþei womb, inkilþô pregnant woman. Not found elsewhere: in the other West Germanic languages its place is taken by kind.

As the form of Old High German, Old Saxon, Old Frisian kind is not satisfactorily explained from the root ken- (Aryan gen-) ‘beget, bear’, and is, for Low German at least, quite irregular, Prof. Sievers suggests the possibility that kind is a perversion of cild, kilþ-, by assimilation to the derivatives of root ken-, which may have spread from Old High German to Old Saxon and Frisian.

Also pied wagtails are great. (Sorry, I only really came in here to suggest "butterfly", but no need, as it was example #2)

if there are related terms that are cognates, you're not finished yet.

pow!
es: pum
de: zack
fr: bang
it: prigioniero di guerra ????

Not quite sure what you mean, fh, that this thread does not meet academic standards and will be rejected by a journal? Please elucidate.

The butterfly page that was linked is great, especially the "ladybug" digression. One more thing about that is the Portuguese word "borboleta" also means "turnstile," in Portugal at least.

Pow! reminds me to list:
En: Ready, Set, Go!
Es: Preparados, Listos, Ya!
De: Achtung, Fertig, Los!
Fr: A vos marques! Prêts? Partez!

Back to boy:
Swedish: pojke
Norwegian: gutt
Danish :dreng

Oh, the Swedish is like the Finnish, "poika".

(As featured in chapter 1 of "Teach Yourself Finnish", the only chapter I made it through.)

Not quite sure what you mean, fh, that this thread does not meet academic standards and will be rejected by a journal? Please elucidate.

you're starting with an english word and then trying to find non-cognates of it from other languages based on the meaning of the english word. but cognates don't necessarily have the same meaning... they have the same origin.

Fr: A vos marques! Prêts? Partez!

Isn't the first part of this "on your marks", though? Which is an often used English alternative, and surely cognate?

fh, isn't that the point? Trying to find phrases where the expressions that transmit the same meaning are non-cognates in multiple languages? I'm not sure what your problem is with the idea.

I thought fh meant something like your example, emil.y, where another word or phrase exists like "on your marks," but I guess not. Truth be told I didn't remember or know the French expression and had to look it up, I guess it doesn't quite work.

Not starting with the English word, fh, starting with the idea that there is a thing that is a *Shark* which has names in four (or more) languages that are not etymologically related. Don't want to get into any philosophical discussion of Signifying Intentional Zombies or "What is it like to be a bat?" or 'Der Schnee ist weiß' if and only if snow is white.

Oh, the Swedish is like the Finnish, "poika".
This happens a lot in Swedish, I think Finnish is an official language in Sweden. Just looked up "butterfly" in a Swedish dictionary and got "fjäril" which I guess is from Finnish but it turns out they also have "sommarfågel."

Well, take the French garcon. It does have a German cognate, Recke, which means warrior. An English one as well... wretch. So... it's not a non-cognate with German, or English. See what I'm saying?

I should come clean and say my ultimate goal is to not let another interesting linguistics thread disappear.

OK, here is the thing that prompted the creation of this thread, long in gestation, this weekend. I still keep wondering whether I am missing something, if I have formulated the problem correctly or if it really works. Or if it really works, is it anti-climactic, so what?. So, my theory, which is mine is that there is a certain chess piece, which moves diagonally on one specified shade of light or dark throughout the entire game which is called

En: the bishop
Fr: le fou
De: der Läufer
Es: el alfil

The bishop, the fool, the runner, and (from the Persian) the elephant rider(!?).

fh, I kind of thought that's what you meant but I guess is should have specified, and I think it is fair to specify, that is OK if a cognate exists, as long as it is not a common word for the exact same thing.

OK, alfil is just an elephant.

But still.

(It's that "the" "the" thing that happens when Spanish and Arabic mix)

It's a different thing then the rest, it is not a name of an animal, like tipsy mothra mentioned, which makes it that much more amazing that it didn't get more standardized.

Your move, ILX.

Shark is actually pretty disparate... German and Icelandic words for shark are cognates (Haifisch and hákarl), but I can't chase down much else!

you really gonna make me google "non-cognate" on a sunday afternoon?

― scott seward, Sunday, February 24, 2013 2:40 PM (34 minutes ago) Bookmark Flag Post Permalink

little-known original line in the Rascals' "Groovin'".

― Tarfumes The Escape Goat, Sunday, February 24, 2013 3:16 PM (4 hours ago)

Songs this thread is making me think of
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4zgB1Jfpjdw

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qYk1iVEezAg

^ YES

Holy Haifisch, Fledermausmensch, I never knew this version existed:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NcnEur8lrXc

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_QXJ3OXWaOY
(You've got to wait through some Broadway ad)

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Kpe_KHDEfgw
DO U SEE?

I thought this would work:

English: hedgehog
French: hérisson
Italian: riccio
German: igel

But no. Looking at the Spanish (erizo) made me realise I'd overlooked the connection between hérisson and riccio.

Still interesting, though.

hedgehogs are excellent

the near-misses like hedgehog and squirrel are still awesome.

"computer" in icelandic is "tölva" which apparently comes from the Old Norse word for their compass-like unit, talwôn.

Another miss here, but three distinct strands of naming.

English: buttercup
German: Butterblume

French: bouton d'or
Spanish: botón de oro

Italian: ranuncolo

Probably not worth posting any more of the three-stranders, as there will be shedloads out there.

Speaking of which (and this is via google translate, so I'm aware there may be synonymous cognates that just haven't come up)...

English: shed
French: hangar (not counting as a similar cognate because hangars are pretty different to sheds, right? Or is this cheating?)
German: Schuppen
Spanish: cobertizo
Italian: capannone

Are there any resources in English that let you trace foreign etymology, like etymonline?

Dunno. I hope fh can help us.

What about this kind of thing:
En: the honeysuckle
Es: la madreselva
Fr: le chèvrefeuille
De: das Geißblatt

So here we have the Spanish being the wonderful "mother (of the) jungle" and both the German and the French meaning "goat leaf," with the constituent parts for "goat" and "leaf" being unrelated.

The word for it in Czech is pretty cool:
http://www.omniglot.com/blog/?p=3363

Welsh too, on that same page.

Wiktionary is pretty good for English web sites with foreign etymologies, emily.

Shed has some hidden cognates... Italian capannone = Spanish cabana, and Spanish cobertizo = English cover, for example. Badger is another where they look quite disparate but turn to be all pretty much from the same origin!

(not counting as a similar cognate because hangars are pretty different to sheds, right? Or is this cheating?)

That's a pretty deep question, and it's why I was harping on the fact that cognates have similar origins, not meanings. If you start with an English word like shed, you've got to also consider similar English words such as hut, hide, cover, blind, lean-to, shelter, even stuff like gazebo or house.

But not for this game, surely? Those are far too wide. It's not about "does this word have a cognate in English/French/Spanish/German?" but "does this thing have an expression that is a cognate in English/French/Spanish/German?" The reason why I was unsure about hangar is that you can make a case that a hangar is synonymous with shed (it's just a big one), whereas something like "cover" is not synonymous. Metonymy, meronymy, etc etc, those things change language and give us interesting branches. Just because 'chevalier' is from the same root as 'cheval', it doesn't mean we discount 'horse'.

Wait, the second question isn't even phrased right, I don't think. How about "Does this thing have a pan-language consistent cognate from whence it draws its name?"

i think its funny that almost every language - european language - uses a variation of maiz for the word corn except english. even the dutch and german is from maiz and the word corn comes from germany (word for seed).

not funny ha ha, but i'd never really thought about it.

Yeah I think there are metaphysical problems there of what is a room

English: pillow
German: Kissen
French: oreiller
Spanish: almohada
Italian: cuscino
Portuguese: travesseiro
Welsh: gobennydd

― Alba, Friday, July 14, 2017 5:51 AM (three years ago) bookmarkflaglink

this one occurred to me today.

although "guanciale" might have been a better, if slightly awkward, choice for the italian — since both "Kissen" and "cuscino" seem to come via old french "coussin"

This thread inspired me (in part) to name a set of songs i recorded after HEDGEHOGS in 7 different languages. Thank you to emil.y for the hedgehog inspo and all thread contributors for non-cognate inspo <3

https://on.soundcloud.com/xW2Xp

English/French/Spanish/Language Makes No Sense

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=shorts

Listening to the hedgehog songs now - they're great, LL!

Thanks for listening!! 💕 I’m proud of these, hence the proper names.