Bands you keep trying to like but can't get into

Another one: Meshuggah. Try as I might, I cannot make fandom happen.

Welch-era Mac is definitely the way in

no, it's not. That's just something people say to make themselves feel better about owning Welch-era records.

i enjoy them a lot

Shakey, do you know the song "Hypnotized?"

hmm yeah this is pretty good

B bbbb

B bbbb

Whoops.

otm

B bbbb

Grim Reapah!!!

Welch-era Mac is definitely the way in

Yes! Future Games is probably my favorite Mac record. Danny Kirwan is super-underrated.

I'm going to try the Smiths again pretty soon. So far, all I've got for them is the title track from The Queen Is Dead.

― cloacachella (how's life), Sunday, January 27, 2013 8:37 AM (2 weeks ago) Bookmark Flag Post Permalink

Loading The Sound of the Smiths onto my iTunes for listening on the commute tomorrow morning, courtesy the local public library. Here we go again, I guess.

i'm kinda with shakey on FM but i should probably give them another shot. i do dig 'go your own way.'

Still don't get the welch-era love on this board. I mean, those records are nice I guess.

you're nice i guess....NOT

(j.k. you are probably a very nice person but bare trees rules dude)

"Sunny side of heaven" is cool. I'll try it again some day.

John Cale

Simon and Garfunkel....I give up--that shit is too twee for my taste

There's always a sense of trepidation when I'm about to listen to music by reprehensible people that I might like it, but every time it's been pretty disappointing (and also very relieving!)

This doesn't work with food, though.

The Fall, The Smiths, The Clash, also John Cale as mentioned above

Although I was really into the record he did with Terry Riley for a while

second Marnie Stern, Meshuggah also. And Hella. And Mick Barr, and all that tech guitar stuff.

John Zorn

Talk Talk

re: hella, maybe try playing it at 3/4 or 1/2 speed?

^^^great endorsement

2/3 speed, sheesh

Although I was really into the record he did with Terry Riley for a while

yeah, church of anthrax is great, velvets are great, I love some of the albums he produced, but I just don't get what people see in his solo recs. and on paper they seem like exactly the sort of thing I would like.

i'm going to try the Smiths again pretty soon. So far, all I've got for them is the title track from The Queen Is Dead.

― cloacachella (how's life), Sunday, January 27, 2013 8:37 AM (2 weeks ago) Bookmark Flag Post Permalink

Loading The Sound of the Smiths onto my iTunes for listening on the commute tomorrow morning, courtesy the local public library. Here we go again, I guess.

― how's life, Monday, February 11, 2013 6:47 PM (3 hours ago) Bookmark Flag Post Permalink

best way into the smiths is louder than bombs

it took me a long time to get into the smiths (louder than bombs was my first cd by them, and it didn't do the trick for me, so i understand).

gateway for me was looking up 1984/85 live performances on youtube and just being overwhelmed by the presence of morrissey

like this performance of still ill: youtuuuuuuube

2013 will be the year that I completely give up my indie guilt

or actually, this one from 1983 features taller hair aka is better: youtuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuube

the smiths are so divisive that I can't imagine feeling guilty for not liking them. I love them but it's easy to see how people would be put off by morrissey.

XTC and Dinosaur Jr, chiefly.

― Z S, Monday, July 9, 2007 3:44 PM (5 years ago)

5-year update:

i'm a pretty big fan of dino jr now (to the extent of volunteering to run the dinosaur jr tracks poll when it arrives sometime in 2042), xtc i've come to terms with. i really like about half of drums & wires and black sea, and some of english settlement. i feel like i understand where they're coming from a lot better now, even if i'm not a megafan.

i will return with another update in 2018

no one should feel guilty for not liking anyone. and yeah, they're pretty divisive i guess. the thing is, morrissey used to actively annoy me. just his voice, his way of picking a single key pitch for each phrase and running around and over and under it, always returning to it. seemed really amateurish and gimmicky. now i love it. that's his thing. now it sounds amateurish (in an endearing way) and unique and distinctive.

xposts i mean check out 1:35 into this:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ouRD7yuGOFc

how can you not appreciate the impact on someone's life like that

this thread was the inspiration behind my overrated bands thread

it is a good thread, but i thought it capable of improvement, as has been shown

dude writes hilarious lyrics. and genuinely affecting lyrics. i'll forgive him for anything for "is it really so strange?" and "this night has opened my eyes"

ok, worst persuasive argument ever (i blame the whiskey). but for some reason seeing the visuals and the context helps me to appreciate some kinds of music. i need to see the tall hair, the flowers flying everywhere, adoring boys, johnny maher floppy hair, little glances between band members, the vibe of the room, the sense of a "moment", cheesy at that is, and suddenly listening to the smiths isn't just some fingerpicking and morrissey flitting around a key pitch, but something more lasting and important that i can sense every time i listen to them

no one should feel guilty for not liking anyone.

maybe not guilty, but if you keep trying to like something and you can't get into it then there must be something that's making you feel like you should be into that artist. maybe not guilt but the feeling that you're missing out or that you want to understand what other people hear in the music.

for some artists I like, if somebody says for example "I hate the smiths" I just think well yeah, they're not for everyone, nbd. but if someone says "the beatles suck" I think that they're trolling or they're an idiot who doesn't know anything about music.

I don't know, maybe it's just me. have we ever done a thread on litmus test artists? there are artists I love but I don't care if other people like them or not, but then there are artists that are like a litmus test and if you think they suck I know I can't trust anything else you say. anyone else feel this way sometimes?

and I guess I started thinking about this because a lot of the artists mentioned in this thread seem like they fall into that category where nobody would blame you if you don't get it. it seems like even the most die hard scott walker fans would realize that his voice is pretty over the top for example. so I wonder where this desire to keep trying to like them comes from.

like this performance of still ill: youtuuuuuuube

― Z S, Monday, February 11, 2013 10:45 PM Bookmark Flag Post Permalink

this is a perfect example of why I can't get into them -- starts out very promising, cool bass and guitar parts, but then morrissey comes in with his awful, meandery non-melody. I almost can't tell smith songs apart because of his singing.

but for some reason seeing the visuals and the context helps me to appreciate some kinds of music

this has happened to me a lot. the visual side is definitely the easiest way to get a feeling of the music's social and historical context in a visceral way.

I can't imagine trying to get into morrissey after the age of 16

Tbh, I like the Smiths (less than I used to) but I don't always know what to make of Morrissey's performances in those early live clips. Hurting 2, if you really want to give the Smiths a try, you might want to start with later material. I think Morrissey's vocals are a little more musical. If you've already heard The Queen Is Dead and don't like it, though, it might not be worth it to keep trying.

xpost

I'd probably say 20 but yeah.

captain beefheart but i think i'm getting really close to getting into them

why do you feel like you need to be into beefheart? what similar stuff do you like?

this is maybe my favorite song ever

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xfdtB_4aCDo