Rolling Teenpop 2006 Thread

Message Bookmarked
Bookmark Removed
Not all messages are displayed: show all messages (1918 of them)
Okay, now I'm fixated on this. Here's the lesbian import KT Tunstall cover.

http://images.amazon.com/images/P/B0007A0GD4.01._AA240_SCLZZZZZZZ_.jpg

Je4nn3 ƒur¥ (Je4nne Fury), Thursday, 16 February 2006 18:20 (eighteen years ago) link

I think it'd be cool if Pink didn't spend the majority of her video lampooning half-naked female icons half-naked, and fleshed out her basic platitudes (though that's ALWAYS been a problem with her), but I'm glad she's asking for something that's pretty reasonable rather than talking about raping and killing her dad or something. "My Vietnam" was more than enough "forbidden."

Zwan (miccio), Thursday, 16 February 2006 18:27 (eighteen years ago) link

Really, the only thing that makes her not Britney Spears is that she says she's not Britney Spears. Weird clothes, weird collaborators, genre futzing, claims of empowerment and pain, all B.S. territory.

Zwan (miccio), Thursday, 16 February 2006 18:31 (eighteen years ago) link

That said, Britney didn't really highlight these qualities until after Pink's big album.

Zwan (miccio), Thursday, 16 February 2006 18:40 (eighteen years ago) link

Are you for real?? Little Miss NYLA is a poster child for naivete. She's a *kid*. Pink's got much more know-how about her. Plus balls, a sense of humor, and sure-fire ability to rock.

Je4nn3 ƒur¥ (Je4nne Fury), Thursday, 16 February 2006 18:42 (eighteen years ago) link

Wm Bl Swygart: That Website wants me to do something I don'y do for no Website: download software. So could you give a description of the vid?

Frank Kogan (Frank Kogan), Thursday, 16 February 2006 18:56 (eighteen years ago) link

Pink's got much more know-how about her.

That's gotta be a pretty relative scale. And Pink sure acts like a *kid* with her license plate reading No. 1 Superstar and her comparing her life to Vietnam because her mom's going to change her last name and her family won't pretend they're all really happy. I didn't hear Try This, though.

Zwan (miccio), Thursday, 16 February 2006 19:02 (eighteen years ago) link

She's a *14-year-old*.

Fr Kog: links at the bottom of this page should prove more amenable.

William Bloody Swygart (mrswygart), Thursday, 16 February 2006 19:12 (eighteen years ago) link

Delays "Valentine": I like it. A guitar band that's playing what basically sounds like Hi-NRG Eurodancepop. The bass player is doing a subdued Moroder. The chorus kind of loses the feel, though: too arty in the chord selection, making the sound diffuse.

How is this sort of thing perceived in Britain? As just more indie poprock, or is the Hi-NRG dance sound recognized?

Frank Kogan (Frank Kogan), Thursday, 16 February 2006 20:58 (eighteen years ago) link

My neighborhood branch of the public library just started carrying CDs; mainly country and pop, some Latino, no hip-hop. I checked out recent ones by Jo Dee Messina, Bobby Pinson, Ryan Cabrera, Kaiser Chiefs, expecting to like them in about that order, instead liking 'em in about the reverse. Messina: strong-voice country broad from Boston; two great singles, then a bunch of what would otherwise be blah if her voice weren't grating ("grating" becomes "caustic" and "powerful" when the songs are good). Pinson: a guitar growling deep in the rhythm, husky voice in with the guitar growl but doesn't surmount it; what might be interesting lyrics about being shaped by hardship and failure, but I'm skeptical as to whether I'll really find the words interesting when I give them a chance, and I might not give them a good chance before the due date. Actually, I feel that they're trying to bully me into a view of what makes up life. But maybe the fact that they're bugging me means there's something to them. Ryan Cabrera: See below. Kaiser Chiefs: first few lines of the first track immediately cracked me up; I'll say why below. Remind me of the Buzzcocks, humor mixed with rue, harmonies buzzing pleasingly, the most "poppy" (if not officially pop) melodies of the bunch. Most of the good songs come right at the start, and these guys, like the Buzzcocks, start to sound samey if you hear more than a few in a row. And they're not as good as the Buzzcocks, and they're emotionally timid, but certainly fun.

(Yeah, I know

Now, I won't pretend that Messina or Pinson are teenpop, but I bet lots o' Brit teens and teeny-weenies go for the Kaiser Chiefs. My impression is that their official category is "indie" (though they're major label).

Frank Kogan (Frank Kogan), Thursday, 16 February 2006 21:20 (eighteen years ago) link

The "Yeah, I know" line was meant to go: "Yeah, I know that the album is probably about timidity, but that's no excuse."

Frank Kogan (Frank Kogan), Thursday, 16 February 2006 21:22 (eighteen years ago) link

My London penpal Sarah Manvel emailed me a strong opinion about the Kaiser Chiefs, but I forget if she loved them or hated them.

Frank Kogan (Frank Kogan), Thursday, 16 February 2006 21:26 (eighteen years ago) link

Oh, I guess her opinion isn't that strong. She "likes" them. (But this is in comparison to a whole lot of other equally huge bands whom she considered just awful.)

Frank Kogan (Frank Kogan), Thursday, 16 February 2006 21:36 (eighteen years ago) link

"Stupid Girl" sounds more like something from Pink's first album than anything since "Get The Party Started", and perhaps even more than that in terms of the vocal. I wonder to what extent she's happy with that and to what extent it's a forced manoeuvre (and I say that as someone who loved Can't Take Me Home).

Tim Finney (Tim Finney), Thursday, 16 February 2006 22:04 (eighteen years ago) link

The "Valentine" song struck me as one of those songs where it sounds like it's going somewhere exciting and then doesn't. They're definitely using guitars in interesting ways but the song seemed too unfocused. Maybe I need to listen to it again.

Eppy (Eppy), Thursday, 16 February 2006 22:07 (eighteen years ago) link

Yeah, I wish they'd stuck with the verse and not even had a chorus, seen if they could have pushed somewhere through maniacal sweetness and repetition. But it's something interesting.

Frank Kogan (Frank Kogan), Thursday, 16 February 2006 22:11 (eighteen years ago) link

> Remind me of the Buzzcocks<

Interestingly, I was just listening to the NEW Buzzcocks album *flat pack philosophy* today, and what's clear to me is that Pete Shelley's voice just doesn't hold up; he seemingly can't get it high or nasal or swishy enough to convey his old sweetness and manic excitement anymore. which might not be that big a surprise, except that i actually liked the buzzcocks's *modern* album in 1999 (or at least i did at the time; maybe if i pulled it out now, i wouldn't be so impressed.) band still sounds like they might be fairly tuneful, if not nearly as energetic as they once were. without shelley's voice, though, it just doesn't matter. i gave up after five or six songs.

xhuxk, Thursday, 16 February 2006 23:24 (eighteen years ago) link

Ryan Cabrera You Stand Watching: He's got a beautiful voice, would have done the soft-soul heartbreak of "Gone" better than Justin, would have done the mournfully chilly "To the Moon and Back" almost as well as Darren. I wish he would do songs like that, since there's nothing on here like those, and teen wail might not be his strong suit. "Sensitivity" is, but since the sensitivity is there in his voice anyway, the material is better off not playing it up. This album sounds somewhat anonymous, which I don't consider a flaw necessarily, but only four tracks have reached me so far ("From the Start," "Last Night," "Fall Baby Fall," and especially "Hit Me With Your Light"); since he's not blasting you or nailing you, I may get to feel more here after further listens. The lyrics are vague and generic romance stuff ("Love is it enough/I'll be your shelter when the weather is rough... It's not a fantasy, you can have everything, you can be loved"), which doesn't cripple the music but doesn't draw you in, either. He's not nearly as articulate about what it is to offer love than his ex–better half is at what it feels like to receive it; but then, that's hard to match, since "Pieces of Me" is maybe the sweetest, most charming song ever about what it feels like to be truly and thoroughly loved: "I am moody, messy, I get restless/And it's senseless/How you never seem to care/When I'm angry you listen/Make me happy it's your mission/And you won't stop till I'm there." That has meter and rhyme without losing the sense of someone just conversing; if you think something like that is easy to write, you try it. Of course, I don't know how many of those words are Simpson's and how many are Shanks' or DioGuardi's, and since I don't keep tabs on the teen tabs I don't know if she and Cabrera were yet an item when that song was written; even if they were, the song doesn't have to be referring to him or to anyone, it's a song after all. But I might as well imagine that it does, and that the guy's a sweetheart. Notice how this post ends up about Ashlee; you really didn't imagine it wouldn't, did you? (But a final thought about Ryan's music. He plays acoustic guitar, inserts Spanish touches, and this inspires me to think that maybe he should go to Mexico or Spain and find some swoony extravagant melodies to hang his handsome voice on.)

Frank Kogan (Frank Kogan), Thursday, 16 February 2006 23:36 (eighteen years ago) link

Do you think if he changed his production style to be more soul-inflected it might go a long way? (Or is he already kinda soul-inflected? It's been a while since I heard any Cabrera.)

Eppy (Eppy), Thursday, 16 February 2006 23:45 (eighteen years ago) link

Oh yeah, and what made me laugh out loud when I started the Kaiser Chiefs album:

I've got to get this message to the press
That every day I love you less and less

It was refreshing after all that country be-a-tough-babe/this-is what-makes-a-man bullshit, and all that earnest romance.

xpost

Well, he's basically using a rock beat on this album, in keeping with contemporary teenpop, though he's not particularly trying to rock out. But that I heard Justin and Darren when I heard him might indicate that MJ-type soul could work.

Frank Kogan (Frank Kogan), Thursday, 16 February 2006 23:51 (eighteen years ago) link

i dont know how i feel about jack johnson, can we talk about him--he has a great smooth voice, and he has a sweet, gentle, genorus subtlety, and i kind of like his kids stuff for the curious george soundtrack, (way pre teen) but has anyone heard anything else, does his connections to john mayer make anyone nervous

anthony easton (anthony), Friday, 17 February 2006 00:30 (eighteen years ago) link

*Aquamarine* soundtrack (not sure what the music's about), on first listen anyway, starts slow and way too mellow, with too many David Gray Jack Johnson Jason Mraz John Mayer type boys we never heard of before (well, two of em anyway) getting sensitive and too many girls doing the same (including Sara Paxton, which is disappointing after she was so boppy on last year's geat *Darcy's Wild Life* soundtrack), but things start to pick up a little for Emma Roberts's version of Weezer's "Island in the Sun" (not bad, though her "hip hip"s sound totally limp) and pick up for real for a three song stretch that starts with Courtney Jaye whoever she is misbehaving and ends with Mandy Moore who is almost an oldtimer by now covering Blondie and peaks, in great Hope Partlow Samantha Jo tradition with another GREAT summer song, "Summertime Guys" by longtime Disney pop C-lister Nikki Cleary, which has a killer rumbling bounce of a beat I can't put my finger on - not quite Bow Wow Wow, not quite Bo Diddley, but pretty close taxonomincally: early Sweet, maybe? I dunno, something like that. Album ends with the Stellastarr* dimwit doing his dumb but (very slightly) endearing imitation of Bowie after Bowie couldn't sing in his high register anymore (i,e, after Bowie started to suck), and he's no Andrew Eldritch let me tell you, then with a slimy piece of industrial bubblegum leachery called "I Like The Way" by the Bodyrockers which I predict some silly teenage girls will find sexy.

xhuxk, Friday, 17 February 2006 14:42 (eighteen years ago) link

Chuck is totally OTM about that new Buzzcocks album. I had to check the liner notes to see if Shelley was still in the band!

Matthew C Perpetua (inca), Friday, 17 February 2006 14:44 (eighteen years ago) link

>(not sure what the music's about), <

actually this might be true but I meant I'm not sure what the MOVIE'S about (though I'm guessing it might concern going to the beach. Matter of fact, one of the 3 girls on the CD cover is a mermaid.) xp

xhuxk, Friday, 17 February 2006 14:45 (eighteen years ago) link

"Summertime Guys" written by Jeffrey W Coplan (who also produced it), Nikki Cleary, and Robert Ellis Orrall, the last of whom sort of existed on the commercial country/late-Creem powerpop cusp once upon a time and had a #32 Carlene Carter duet pop hit in 1983 with "I Couldn't Say No," and bigger country hits later than that I believe.

xhuxk, Friday, 17 February 2006 14:49 (eighteen years ago) link

Aquamarine trailer up via Apple - starring Emma Roberts and JoJo and someone else as a mermaid.

Abby (abby mcdonald), Friday, 17 February 2006 16:44 (eighteen years ago) link

I am not the kind of person to say this, but the mermaid is creepily sexualized. Buh.

Eppy (Eppy), Friday, 17 February 2006 16:56 (eighteen years ago) link

I have been listening to the new Goldfrapp album and comparing it in my head to Madonna and Kylie and current British girlpop and it strikes me as actually trying to be teenpop for grownups, which is maybe why it's not that appealing to me. Ditto for the Madonna album. Maybe I should take this to the dance being too gay for American thread or something.

Eppy (Eppy), Friday, 17 February 2006 16:58 (eighteen years ago) link

One more thing on Cabrera (alb due back at the library tomorrow): Erlewine at allmusic thinks Cabrera was aiming this album as much at the Matchbox 20/Third Eye Blind crowd as at the teens, which makes sense - I mean, makes sense as an analysis, not as an artistic strategy. The singles from the album - "Photo" and "Shine On" - are far worse than the ones from his last; "Shine On" has some merit as a song but he overdoes the "passion" in his voice and it's irritating. I really wish he'd follow Michael Jackson (or even Timberlake) rather than the white AC balladeers, since they seem to know how to let the music deliver the passion without their having to push anguish forward out of the throat.

Frank Kogan (Frank Kogan), Saturday, 18 February 2006 06:48 (eighteen years ago) link

"They" being Jackson and Timberlake, not the white balladeers.

Frank Kogan (Frank Kogan), Saturday, 18 February 2006 06:51 (eighteen years ago) link

Pop World Cup team talk by USA manager Alex M:

Smoosh - "Rad": It is a well-known scientific FACT that a key ingredient of Great Pop is YOUTH. Smoosh back this up nicely. They are sisters Asya, 13, and Chloe, 11, and on 'Rad' Asya raps charmingly about how you should be a little happier and if you want to play then GO PLAY over insanely melodic electric piano. I am sure all Poptimists will take Smoosh to their hearts with no further prompting, but should you need further convincing here are some TEAM ANECDOTES: 1) While recording their album, relations between Chloe and the band's producer got so fractious that she had to be locked out of the studio, whereupon she scrawled "DO U WANT A FIGHT!" on a piece of paper and pressed it to the window; 2) They were once told by an over-excitable interviewer that they could be "as big as Led Zeppelin", to which they replied, "Is that big?"; 3) When I went to see them at Cargo a couple of months ago I got to the venue early to find them playing tag amidst all the bemused punters. CUTE!

Frank Kogan (Frank Kogan), Saturday, 18 February 2006 07:08 (eighteen years ago) link

>getting sensitive and too many girls doing the same (including Sara Paxton, which is disappointing after she was so boppy on last year's geat *Darcy's Wild Life* soundtrack)<

actually her Aquamarine song "Connected" is not bad, and not really all that sensitive, and even slightly boppy, though I'm not sure what I think of its self-help lyrics about soulmates.

My fave song so far (and by far) on the *High School Musical* OST is "Bop To The Top," which reminds me of early Conga/Dr Beat-era Miami Sound Machine almost. (Or really, I guess, of MSM a little later, when Gloria was doing that 1-2-3 song.) More on this soon I'm sure.

xhuxk, Saturday, 18 February 2006 14:32 (eighteen years ago) link

"I Can't Take My Eyes Off of You" is another good MSM-style bubblesalsa track. (That one's performed by Troy, Gabrielle, Ryan, and Sharpay; "Bop to the Top" by just Ryan and Sharpay.)

xhuxk, Saturday, 18 February 2006 14:55 (eighteen years ago) link

Lindsay Lohan, wafer or waif?... Is that Courtney Love on the cover of Seventeen?... Angelina of the morning sickness... Us Weekly reports that someone said something in the January Vanity Fair.

Frank Kogan (Frank Kogan), Sunday, 19 February 2006 04:48 (eighteen years ago) link

Today's haul from the library:

Chip Taylor and Carrie Rodriguez Red Dog Tracks, Brad Paisley Time Well Wasted, Sara Evans Real Fine Place, Aly & AJ Into the Rush. I'm looking forward to listening to them - I'm especially eager to hear Red Dog Tracks, since I've never heard Uncle Chip's actual singing voice.

Frank Kogan (Frank Kogan), Sunday, 19 February 2006 05:00 (eighteen years ago) link

And now Launch is playing Mariah's "All I Want for Christmas Is You"; the song achieves something I didn't think Mariah could pull off: a Ronettes-Crystals sound while Mariah still gets to be her vocal-trapeze-artist self. (I miss that Mariah. The new Mariah seems chastened and subdued in comparison.)

My favorite Mariah is the early Mariah, "Somebody," "Can't Let Go," "Make It Happen" era. After that she helped pioneer a bury-your-voice-in-the-r&b-mix style, which I'm not against in principle (is one of the things that helped her also to pioneer the thug'n'hug mating of hip-hop guys and r&b chicks, which I usually don't love but have nothing against in principle), but it knocked down her exuberance, and "We Belong Together" is far more conversational and less melismatic in its approach - again, I've got nothing against the principle, but all of these things toned down her natural exuberance, which may be the conditions of her staying acceptable to r&b but is too bad.

Anyway, I just heard "Stay the Night," one of the album tracks from Mimi. Reminds me a LOT of Teena Marie, which from me is a high compliment: the rhythm has more or a '00s push and counterfunk than Teena's had back in her prime, and Mariah works the voice well against the rhythm. I'll wait to say more when I listen more. It isn't in what's necessarily my favorite of Teena's various styles - kind of jazzy, Riperton fly the breeze - but the voice does move.

("We Belong Together" isn't bad; it never really sticks for me, though, despite its having living atop the charts for months and months in mid '05.)

Frank Kogan (Frank Kogan), Sunday, 19 February 2006 13:56 (eighteen years ago) link

"having lived," that is.

Frank Kogan (Frank Kogan), Sunday, 19 February 2006 13:58 (eighteen years ago) link

I think I've said before that I reckon the absolute apotheosis of that bury-your-voice-in-the-r&b-mix style of Mariah's is the "Funkin' 4 Jamaica" "cover" she did with Mystikal. In the video clip they had three Mariahs singing her bits into a microphone, and the visual seemed really apt - it was like an ode to backing singer perfection.

Tim Finney (Tim Finney), Sunday, 19 February 2006 14:01 (eighteen years ago) link

from country thread:

--at least one song from the *high school musical* OST, "breaking free", sounds as much like a pop-country power ballad to me as a teen-pop power ballad (isn't that one of the big download hits? i think so, since it's one of two tracks with a "karaoke instrumental" version at the end of the CD. and come to think of it, the instumental - which i I kind of like; when I first heard it, it was in my random CD changer, and I guessed it was by either tea leaf green or the tossers! -- sounds somewhat rural or pastoral or whatever as well.) the non-karaoke rendition is said to be sung by leading man troy + leading lady gabrielle.

xhuxk, Monday, 20 February 2006 14:58 (eighteen years ago) link

Frank, yes-exactly-totally-110% on the Mariah r&b muddled-voice conundrum. Woman needs to *sing*, go for the 90s stuff, etc.

Je4nn3 ƒur¥ (Je4nne Fury), Monday, 20 February 2006 15:26 (eighteen years ago) link

yeah, people who think mariah has improved over the years are nuts. (i assume her recent respectability in hip-hop circles has as much to do with her biography as her music -- i.e, people were rooting for a comeback. to my ears she's become duller in direct proportion to getting more hip-hop. i'd like to hear the song frank compares to teena marie, though.)

despite tracks i mentioned above, i should note that i'm pretty sure *high school musical* isn't a very good CD. most of it, i'd classify as "lame show tunes." i'm guessing the music is closer to *rent* (which i've never heard) than to *fame* or *grease.* and i'd rather hear almost any Radio Disney star than the singers on this thing. A couple okay tracks, though.

xhuxk, Monday, 20 February 2006 16:22 (eighteen years ago) link

(there is also some little-bow-wow (maybe aaron carter)-level grab-and-go kiddie-hop b-ball r&b on it, too, which tracks are okay I guess. and the tracks i do like -- the two latin-ish ones and maybe the one country-ish one, which is probably not all that country -- suggest that the singers might actually be okay if given palatable material. (the most and maybe only country thing about "breaking free" might be gabrielle aka vanessa anne hudgens's vocal inflections as her intensity picks up. i'm guessing if anybody on here has a future, it's her.) (another not-bad track, i just decided, is "we're all in this together," which starts off as a show-tuney mess of sap but winds up with cool chant-a-long sections ["wildcats! everywhere! wave your hands up in the air"] then a cool pep-rally whistle break [to do step routines or drum line bits too] that have some real energy in them. actually, i'm realizing who that song reminds me of is long-lost early '90s teen-poppers The Party, of "In My Dreams" fame, and as a matter of fact the *High School Musical* cast, crossing all racial and gender boundaries known to affluent exurbia, also kinda LOOKS like The Party.)

xhuxk, Monday, 20 February 2006 16:48 (eighteen years ago) link

Cheyenne Kimball, "One Original Thing," opening *Aquamarine*: Better than I suggested above. "1 Thing" by way of Kelly C. pop-rock, with a drum break in the middle blatantly swiped from *Dookie* ("Longview," I think?) overlaid with a nifty synth line. Followed by Nikki Flores in "Strike" imitating Aaliyah oops I mean Beyonce over quasi-middle eastern undulations and quasi-Timbaland (or somebody) incidental whoops and geegaws. Cool.

xhuxk, Monday, 20 February 2006 17:48 (eighteen years ago) link

i'd rather hear almost any Radio Disney star than the singers on this thing

Might be why B5's version of "Getcha Head in the Game" seems to be more popular than Troy and whoever's version (as well as "Breaking Free") on Radio Disney. I thought this might be an interesting phenomenon in the Disney to Top 40 tradition, but it seems to be a downloading fluke.

nameom (nameom), Monday, 20 February 2006 18:02 (eighteen years ago) link

Track 7 on *Aquamarine*, "Time For Me To Fly" by the Jonas Brothers, takes its beat from Katrina and the Waves. And its title from REO Speedwagon, even more blatantly than Toby Keith did in "Time For Me To Ride". Also, the Jonas Brothers (apparently named Nicholas Jonas, Joseph Jonas, Kevin Jonas II, and maybe Kevin Jonas Sr and PJ Bianco, or at least that's who all wrote it) sing like girls, and I kind of like it, way more than boy wimps Teddy Geiger and Teitur earlier on the album. (The latter. whoever he is, tells some girl that she is either going to be his friend and his lover, or neither. Nikki Cleary should kick his butt.)

xhuxk, Monday, 20 February 2006 18:24 (eighteen years ago) link

And Courtney Jaye "Can't Behave" sounds like classic early '70s bubblegum, White Plains or Vanity Fare or Flying Machine or Edison Lighthouse or somebody, but with a girl singing.

xhuxk, Monday, 20 February 2006 18:31 (eighteen years ago) link

I am now listening to the Delays album. It's rather good in an over-reaching 80's-synth hopeless romantic poetry (with a bit of a dash of the Modern British Boys With Guitars) kind of way. The singer's not Morten Harket, which is points away, and it's not exactly The Definite Article, but they've rather defied the odds and appear to have blossomed into something really interesting.

Whether that fits on this thread or not I don't really know, but I just thought I'd let you know. 'Valentine' is one of the best things on the album, but its ambition is definitely matched elsewhere.

William Bloody Swygart (mrswygart), Monday, 20 February 2006 18:43 (eighteen years ago) link

I need to correct something I wrote above: It was in the February Vanity Fair that somebody said something, not the January. I'm sorry for the inconvenience I may have caused.

Frank Kogan (Frank Kogan), Monday, 20 February 2006 20:52 (eighteen years ago) link

So I bought The Secret Life of the Veronicas and on first listen, I don't quite understand the giant orgasm people are having over them. The pop hooks are there in spades, the production is excellent, and they can sing. But I couldn't remember any of the songs after I was done listening (which, to me, usually means there's some forced activity going on and/or I need to enjoy the silence for a while, so to speak). I'll give it a day and go back to it. But it didn't have the same instantaneous "omg" effect as say, "Since U Been Gone" (I'm worried that that kicked the bar too high) or even "You Oughta Know" (which isn't exactly pop, I know).

Je4nn3 ƒur¥ (Je4nne Fury), Monday, 20 February 2006 23:13 (eighteen years ago) link

Very strange Simon Reynolds piece here. (It's probably been talked to death on the Simon Reynolds c or d thread already, but I gave up on that one several years ago.) He's focusing on the UK, which may be a reason for his claim that there's almost no conversation between black and white, but the U.S. music that charted in the U.K. was inundated in conversation between black and white: How is Mariah Carey not a conversation between black and white (gospel and r&b so intermixed with show and opera that there's no way to distentangle them)? Not to mention all grime and most Southern hip-hop, which have adopted the musical vocabulary of central and eastern European romanticism. Not to mention "Hollaback Girl" (or was that not a U.K. hit?). Not to mention Kelly Clarkson, who's applying the Mariah intermixture to goth (speaking of the musical vocabulary of central and eastern European romanticism), and if you listen to "Addicted" (one of her gothier tracks), there're some fascinating skitter beats that are dance- and club-derived. Oh yeah, and 2005 was the year that Lil Wayne rapped to an Iron Maiden song. I think with Reynolds you have to take what he says and say to yourself, "OK, what was really on his mind?" Perhaps that groups like Coldplay and Kaiser Chiefs aren't taking in what is going on in grime and hip-hop, and grime and hip-hop aren't incorporating Coldplay and the Kaiser Chiefs? (Actually, I've barely heard Coldplay, so maybe this isn't so.) The generalization he might be shooter for could be, "There don't seem to be any new styles of conversation between black and white that aren't mere extensions of the ongoing conversation between black and white." But even then, what Kelly Clarkson is doing seems new. Some of you with a more thorough knowledge of goth might want to weigh in on this, but Kelly Clarkson's melisma and call-and-response stylizations seem more from black gospel and r&b than are the vocal styles you get from Amy Lee (Evanescence), Annette van Giersbergen (The Gathering), or Cristina Scabbia (Lacuna Coil).

(I don't suppose this is the thread to discuss it, but I can't fathom why Reynolds would say, "Because its internal socio-cultural dynamics force it to keep on generating freshness, black music has never really needed to borrow from white music." History of 20th century to thread? (But not this thread.))

Frank Kogan (Frank Kogan), Monday, 20 February 2006 23:42 (eighteen years ago) link


You must be logged in to post. Please either login here, or if you are not registered, you may register here.