d'angelo - voodoo - classic or dud?

love ?uestlove's homage to "I Wonder U" on that

nick i think it's nice you're starting a record club at an old-folks home, but really i think the time limit is unnecessary, what else are these people gonna do with their day

It's been pointed out to me that Send It On's the one with the mournful horns, so that's staying.

i am frankly not a fan of devil's pie in context of this album

How come?

feels awkward and rockish-y to me; always has

who wrote em?

― thomp ynchon (some dude), Monday, January 7, 2013 10:32 AM (14 minutes ago) Bookmark

jason king... which made it extra funny when people were trying to slander him for that r&b thing

also never a big fan of untitled, historical importance be damned

i mean some of it is of course redundant if you know the history/mythology of the album but there's still some really good technical stuff (a lot about the timing of the drums and the bass) plus some interesting historical connections made

for christ's sake, forks

I Love Africa but if time is a concern it makes sense to x it.

time being a concern is at odds with the very ethos of this album, so it doesn't even make sense to me to discuss it

Yeah, Voodoo kind of bends time.

I don't know. The mumbled lyrics in Devil's Pie are all "gotta get up, get outta bed, get some coffee, and go to work. I don't have time to kiss you there."

xpost

Read what ?uestlove has to say about working with D'Angelo here. Crazy shit.

http://pitchfork.com/features/5-10-15-20/8474-5-10-15-20-uestlove/

what the fuck could possess a human being to be hating on "devil's pie" and/or "untitled"

then there's this, which i remember reading years ago but was apparently written before voodoo came out:

http://web.archive.org/web/19991114212019/http://www.okayplayer.com/reviews.htm

at the time ?uest says that meth & red's verses had been taken off in favor of q-tip's original one, that lauryn was still going to be on "feel like makin' love" (also says that dilla was producing it, but it sounds like the regular band to me), and mentions a bunch of interludes that didn't make the cut.

not hating on either one; calling them the weakest tracks on a top ten all time album and thematically a little off

I made people turn up early, and played the whole thing. (I was gonna skip Greatdayindamornin but that was when the takeaway arrived, so it soundtracked the unpacking and eating of Lebanese food.)

http://devonrecordclub.wordpress.com/2013/01/09/dangelo-voodoo-round-44-nicks-choice/

questo sez

"If this record is not turned in by February, then something is extremely wrong. Because we worked to the bone in the entire month of January just to tighten up all the loose ends."

kept his dealers away?

Total dud.

Tuneless, meandering jams that I'm sure were a blast to witness in person. Tedious in all other instances.

I drank the Kool Aid with this album. But fuck that. Just sold my original vinyl copy (played maybe thrice) for $50 the other day (dude was in the record store and was like, "Name your price!" when he saw it — in retrospect, I should've aimed higher).

Love how Maxwell has released not one, but two, albums that are better in every aspect since Voodoo came out.

(yes, I went there)

smh

wow, Austin went there

kept his dealers away?

― the little prince of inane false binary hype (Alfred, Lord Sotosyn), Sunday, January 27, 2013 5:22 PM (4 hours ago) Bookmark

d'angelo's problem isn't drugs

smh

I know. I should've gone for at least 75.

well, not his only problem.

bummed i missed out on the voodoo vinyl reissue. ;_;

maybe not right now. but he has been in rehab twice for coke, booze, etc. xp

I thought his problems were drugs related to his problems with the perfectly cut image he'd created....?

xxpost

i mean the image thing i'm sure fucked with his head but i'm sure it's not like a Walk Hard "oh i hate how people want to see my six pack! ::picks up bottle::" scenario

i go through periods of being very "fuck this dude" like Austin tbh

i go through periods of being very "fuck this dude" like Austin tbh

Well, to be democratic about this, it's not entirely his fault that I never have liked him.

But it is his fault that he can't write a song to save his life.

I thought his problems were drugs related to his problems with the perfectly cut image he'd created....?

xxpost

― the little prince of inane false binary hype (Alfred, Lord Sotosyn), Sunday, January 27, 2013 9:32 PM (9 minutes ago) Bookmark

i think his problems now are all creative

weren't you the same guy who hated that Mystikal record? your crazy opinions are inspiring

(except i too think Maxwell, especially BLACKsummer'snight, is waaaaaaaaaay overlooked, so uh you got me there)

xp

i mean the image thing i'm sure fucked with his head but i'm sure it's not like a Walk Hard "oh i hate how people want to see my six pack! ::picks up bottle::" scenario

I'm just quoting the PR, which like most PR has to find a psychological origin for indulgences.

(except i too think Maxwell, especially BLACKsummer'snight, is waaaaaaaaaay overlooked, so uh you got me there)

xp

― berner herzog (fadanuf4erybody), Sunday, January 27, 2013 7:46 PM (2 minutes ago) Bookmark Flag Post Permalink

Not overlooked on ILM. There is much love for Maxwell here.

Heard the reason behind that Blige tour was to test the water in a safe way, since she is post rehab, too, and keeps things clean.

i think his problems now are all creative

not from what i've heard from people who have been on tour with him, but whatever. none of us really know what's going on, i just hope he puts his record out and doesn't self-destruct doing it.

either/or love for artists confuses the hell out of me. who's forcing that dichotomy?

HEAR THAT, HELEN? It's the Mystikal - "Hit Me" thread

I think his problem more than anything is the pressure to live up to the genius of Voodoo.

he can't write a song to save his life.

― Austin, Sunday, January 27, 2013 6:40 PM Bookmark

This is the single wrongest thing ever written on ILM, even the Hongro oeuvre.

Agree xp

Pick any Maxwell song from Now or BLACKsummersnight and it's a more well-written overall song than anything D'Angelo has ever done.

And then, Maxwell has two other albums.

I'm just trying to level the playing field by saying: look what this guy has done and what D'Angelo hasn't.

And my crazy opinions can only be blamed on not listening to the radio enough.

(joking)

your false dichotomy game is outrageous

I'm gonna go ahead and assume that - joking - refers to everything you've written in this thread.

xp

^^^D'Angelo fanboys.

Slash apologists.

Max has done two near masterpieces/near sold out world tours and your boy has done a few shows that got lukewarm reception, if that.

For posterity, here's actual new Max material:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=T1OvxV3HFho

at least you're doing some service to this thread now

^^^The Rev just got converted, ya'll!!!