guitar as a pop/R&B instrument (not a "rock" instrument, not a country instrument)

sometimes it works, though, cf Miguel's many TV appearances where a goofy-face-making guitarist adds something musically worthwhile to "Adorn" (which has no guitar on the studio version)

Marv Tarplin to thread.

True, I guess I didn't mean to imply a blanket dismissal of that practice. Sometimes it's interesting/good/great.

xp

sometimes it works, though, cf Miguel's many TV appearances where a goofy-face-making guitarist adds something musically worthwhile to "Adorn" (which has no guitar on the studio version)

― some dude, Friday, January 4, 2013 2:27 PM (3 hours ago

Ha. When I saw Miguel live, I decided after a bit to try not to look at the guitarist as his goofy, straining guitar hero faces and his retro 80s look were bugging me (but yea, he sounded ok and sometimes good)

lol it should be noted that live performances of "Adorn" omit the synth chords that outline the harmony in the studio version and thus it's up to mr. goofus to do so.

This is OTM. Every "pop" act (and most hip hop acts) I've seen perform on TV (SNL, some talk show, whatever) has the requisite pseudo-Hendrix guitarist in their band, usually stepping forward for three or four seconds of high-gain whammy bar wankery.

― Tarfumes The Escape Goat, Friday, January 4, 2013 6:25 AM (5 hours ago)

When I saw Ke$ha a few weeks ago, she wore a guitar (les paul standard?) as a prop for a couple songs. I don't believe it was plugged in (possibly remotely?) but she was not really playing it much either so idk.

guitars are just signifiers of rock at this point, technique/style is kind of irrelevant

yeah i mean Lil Wayne has been "playing guitar" on stage for like 6 years now and hasn't demonstrated any really desire to learn how to be any good at it

http://cormacheron.files.wordpress.com/2008/09/madonna-guitar.jpg

it was kind of charming when Madonna decided to learn guitar, and went on Letterman a month later and played "Don't Tell Me" with her guitar teacher

I saw it. Wasn't that her big rapprochement with Letterman?

most of the press for d'angelo's return to live performance this year spent time on the "now he plays guitar" angle. of course he's an outlier because he's still relevant while being able to ignore current pop trends, and is like the last remaining symbol of classicist r&b chops, but still.

i think that was more that he was always seen as a keyboard guy, and spoke openly about how he'd spent some of his time out of the spotlight mastering guitar and re-emerged with guitar skills fully formed

Voodoo has a few songs that say ALL INSTRUMENTS BY D'ANGELO when at least three other people are credited with drums-guitar-bass.

i think that was more that he was always seen as a keyboard guy, and spoke openly about how he'd spent some of his time out of the spotlight mastering guitar and re-emerged with guitar skills fully formed

yeah exactly

the voodoo credits are weird for sure. like, on the songs that ?uestlove isn't credited with drums ('the line', 'the root'), did d'angelo program the drums using samples of ?uestlove's drums from other songs? it's possible.

prob more likely sloppy crediting than that. also didn't ?uest supposedly take a bunch of dilla beats and re-play them live for that album? don't think the credits reflect that either.

yesss, found the track-by-track breakdown that ?uestlove did back in the day on okayplayer: http://web.archive.org/web/19991114212019/http://www.okayplayer.com/reviews.htm

basically it goes to show that you can't trust the credits.

xp

there are def some songs on voodoo where the drums sound programmed rather than live

Stevie Wonder also did ALL INSTRUMENTS BY when he plays "just" keybs, drums, and harmonics (obv okay on "Higher Ground").

"he's still relevant while being able to ignore current pop trends, and is like the last remaining symbol of classicist r&b chops, but still."

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YpXWgLcQPMc

good call

feel pretty stupid forgetting him

stevie played almost everything on his eivets rednow instrumental album. not, like, the string and horn sections though.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8bhDn6i7bdE

Stevie Wonder also did ALL INSTRUMENTS BY when he plays "just" keybs, drums, and harmonics (obv okay on "Higher Ground").

― the little prince of inane false binary hype (Alfred, Lord Sotosyn), Friday, January 4, 2013 12:31 PM Bookmark Flag Post Permalink

Those are the only instruments on "Higher Ground" tho. Synth bass + clavinets.

that's what he was saying, it's a truthful statement on that song, but not the ones w/ horn sections

legit credits on "Living For the City" too.

oh ok, i gotcha

van halen on beat it = how I figure a lot of producers think of guitar in pop/hip hop songs. it is the easiest, most direct way of satisfying the "rock" ingredient in a pop song recipe. imo learning how to "cross over" is the first chapter in making popular music now, as opposed to, say, anything other than the first chapter, as it might have been prior to MJ (or prince)

― Dominique, Thursday, January 3, 2013 11:51 PM (Yesterday) Bookmark Flag Post Permalink

This is OTM. Every "pop" act (and most hip hop acts) I've seen perform on TV (SNL, some talk show, whatever) has the requisite pseudo-Hendrix guitarist in their band, usually stepping forward for three or four seconds of high-gain whammy bar wankery.

― Tarfumes The Escape Goat, Friday, 4 January 2013 14:25 (7 hours ago) Permalink

This is pretty much exaclty what I meant by "guitarness"

yeah i mean Lil Wayne has been "playing guitar" on stage for like 6 years now

he's still doing it????

yeah at least Madonna has mastered a punkish rhythm guitar amateurishness.

I have old demos of Madonna's NYC days in the 80s. She always had that amateurishness of her guitar playing. She was smart to have a more talented guitarist beside her.

prob more likely sloppy crediting than that. also didn't ?uest supposedly take a bunch of dilla beats and re-play them live for that album? don't think the credits reflect that either.

― some dude, Friday, January 4, 2013 12:28 PM (5 hours ago) Bookmark Flag Post Permalink

This would explain why the "drums" don't sound like drums on that album. I hope the Dilla estate got some money for that one.