Joy Division: Classic Or Dud?

ugh to that guy saying "they had no fucking choice" but to be on stage - annoying nonsense stance

-- J0hn D., Friday, 25 April 2008 02:30 (4 days ago) Bookmark Link

'that guy'?!

Every other band is on stage because they wanted to be rock stars this lot were on stage because they had no...fucking...choice.

I love this quote actually, it's pure Wilson genius. It's not true of course (at the very least I'm sure Hooky always wanted to be a rock star) but it gives a great idea of why we love(d) them so much. We felt that WAS the reason they were onstage.

Oh, I sound like a teenager.

DANCE DANCE DANCE TO THE RADIO

Just been to see the film. Good stuff although I doubt there's anything new for most people here. Lots of good things, reminded me why Dead Souls is my current favourite JD track, Barney, Hook and Morris are all on top form, and it's clear that Anik has aged better than them, some nice footage of Hannett. A few bits, like the hypnosis tape Barney and Curtis did- seemed rather pointless or over laboured, but all in all pretty enjoyable.

I thought the hypnotic regression thing was astonishing. I loved how Barney just casually dropped the "I was reading a book on hypnotic regression therapy at the time"...

I just thought it was a bit silly.
Also, as my friend pointed out, whatever happened to therapist/patient confidentiality?

At the end of the film a guy was having a row with some young hipster dudes who had been rustling sweet wrappers and popping cans occasionally (really no big deal and as we were at an 'arts cinema' much less than you average multiplex showing) and after a bit of verbal argy-bargy a cinema fellow turns up and the aggrieved party is shouting, virtually in tears "I saw them in Manchester when I was 18 and so this film means much more to me than it did to them...". Which is not something you hear at the end of most movies.

xpost
I like how it shows Barney's mad scientist/nerd side.

I've got the DVD of the documentary now and I'm trying to watch it but it's really way too intense for me. I have to stop it after every so often because I feel like I'm tripping on acid. Anyway, that bit where Bernard slags off the likes of "You're No Good For Me" as dreadful made me LOLS.

i managed to miss this at the cinema, which i'm gutted about. it was on for about a week; that was it. i need to get the DVD, but ... it won't be the same as the big-screen experience. tits.

http://www.toggle.co.nz/catalogues_other/DAR0015_20084813125.jpg

Region 2 DVD not out in the UK until the end of August? Why do they still do this? I've ordered a region one one from the states, cheaper anyway. The R2 one has a better cover though.
http://ecx.images-amazon.com/images/I/41cxrP7hAhL._SL500_AA240_.jpg

Is this the director's cut with happy end?

Yeah I got the doc. I tried to watch the doc. It taxed my brain. I had other things on my mind. I couldn't quite make it through all of it. Sensory overload.

i've realised i go through a heavy JD phase about once a year, then don't listen to them for most of the rest of the time (even though i'd still say they're my "favourite band" -- or at least did when my nine-year-old nephew asked who my favourite band was, and i really can't think of a more honest answer, especially if the set "joy division" is allowed to include "the new order stuff i love, which admittedly is most of it, substantial parts of the last two albums aside"). hopefully this year's phase will coincide with the release of the DVD :)

i just watched the doc. not staggering amounts of new information but it's always nice hearing it from the horses' mouths so to speak. actually hearing from bernard for once was an unexpected pleasure (no pun intended) and steven morris continues to be my favourite member..

Cooking from a stovetop
Waiting on the brine...

Stir stir stir
To the radio.

Why is joy division getting so much attention over here lately!? IAN CURTIS SUCKED COCK FOR CAB FARE.

So was Ian into the occult? I've heard conflicting statements from two members of New Order. Ian sure seemed like the kind of guy who owned a copy of "Nazism and the Occult" or something.

I don't remember reading anything about him being particularly into the occult, no, and I've read quite a bit about him/JD.

Soooooooo good:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7Mm6ycEz2A8

http://www.insound.com/Derek_Erdman_Three_Quarters_of_Joy_Division_Win_Big_at_OTB_Art+Print/productmain/p/INS62377/

http://i45.tinypic.com/bipatu.png

Ok, so instead of clogging up the board with yet another Joy Division thread, I thought I'd just add to this one.

Making a comp for someone who doesnt know a lot about The Joy Divisions - even though they've had fillums made about them and everything.

Having a bit of trouble fitting it all onto an 80 minute cd though.

Tracklisting:

1. Warsaw
2. No Love Lost
3. Digital (Les Bains Douches live versh)
4. Disorder
5. Day Of The Lords
6. Incubation
7. Transmission
8. Insight
9. Shadow Play
10. She's Lost Control (12" 'dancier' versh)
11. Dead Souls
12. Interzone
13. New Dawn Fades
14. Atmosphere
15. These Days
16. Atrocity Exhibition (Les Bains Douches live versh)
17. Isolation
18. Means To An End
19. Heart And Soul
20. Twenty Four Hours
21. Eternal
22. Decades
23. Love Will Tear Us Apart (Permanent mix)

Probably need to take 3 songs off this to make it fit on a cd. Buggered if I can decide which ones though. What says you, ilx?

Would still make sense if you cut the three earliest tracks and started with "Disorder."

...while at the other end of things, you prob don't need the entire side 2 of Closer to make the point.

Want to keep the first two tracks at least for their punky immediacy....the comp is for a young chap who could be put off initially by the doomy baritone and sparse first album production.

Have taken off the live version of 'Digital', 'Interzone' and 'Heart and Soul'.

Still need to lose one longish track.

Down to 'The Eternal' and 'Decades'.

I love em both. They go together!

Which one should I chuck?

"The Eternal"

Have taken off ... 'Heart and Soul'.

WHAT

NO

who could be put off initially by the doomy baritone and sparse first album production

actual lols @ this

ahahaha that steel drum cover is AWESOME

better than the original?

Dud. I mean, classic.

Saw this on someone's tumblr. Don't know if it's a photoshop or not, but it looks real. And, if that's the case, WTF MAN?

http://i56.tinypic.com/f4rbxw.jpg

Actually, I take that back. The edge on the near side kind of betrays its photoshoppedness.

she's lost control...of her joint banking account and visiting rights

looks like a photoshop phriday kind of thing

A bunch of my mates went to that "Peter Hook and friends" thing last night and there was varius "well it was good... but it was like a good cover band". Im like, WTF did you think it was going to be, jesus.

a bad cover band.

Hahha exactly. Apparently they played this 20 min self indulgent wank video before they came on that was all random new order clips and really poorly made? The audience all started to shout abuse, haha.

It's anti-performance theory. Hook's a secret academic.

can someone tell me what's considered the canonical/best joy division biography?

i quite liked mick middles biography on ian curtis called "torn apart". but obviously it centers on the singer. it is an easy and still rather rewarding read.

ty alex, i'll look into it now!

yesterday I turned on the radio and there was some post-punk rock stuff and I got all Man Yells At Clouds in my mind about "fuckin young kids from Brooklyn starting bands, is that all you know how to do is bite Joy Division" and then the singer came in and he was like "Iiiiiii'm living in the ice age" and I was like "oh ahem lol"

hahaha

the one by his widow is decent, markers. though you will finish it and think she's boring and he was a cunt.

I want to listen to that radio station.

WXYC Chapel Hill - probably has an internet stream & is frankly awesome every day

"the one by his widow is decent, markers. though you will finish it and think she's boring and he was a cunt."
it gives a different perspective that's true but it does not shed a lot of light on the music. i don't even remember if she liked it.

Mickey, Mickey will tear us apart. Again.

http://a2.sphotos.ak.fbcdn.net/hphotos-ak-ash4/316843_2193118826704_1209155925_31961468_2136553259_n.jpg