david foster wallace: classic or dud

BEE is a troll

BEE sounds so painfully just not very smart in those tweets. I mean those zings pretty much SUCK.

I mean you are a PROFESSIONAL WRITER, dude, and you can't even come up with anything better to sling than poorly expressed cliches

BEE sounds so painfully just not very smart in those tweets. I mean those zings pretty much SUCK.

according to prof. whiney they don't suck...because they are zings

but yeah OTM. dude has no insight or critique, just take shots at the more successful dead guy. what a hack

as for the dt max excerpt, yeah, something rings false and hollow about it, like the dude is just trying to write the All American Story instead of DFW's story.

I h8 BEE

I don't really like DFW but BEE writes stuff for stunted americans imo

(I haven't read any tho)

I'm a bigger fan of Ellis (at least if we quantify it in terms of #s of books read) than Wallace, and/but I'm curious about the "more successful" thing. Has Infinite Jest (cause let's be honest it towers over everything else DFW released, in terms of public awareness beyond lit circles) really outsold the combo of Less Than Zero and American Psycho? I mean, if we're talking about generating-income-from-one's-writing, I think Ellis wins; he's never had to take a teaching job, has probably spent a significant portion of the last few decades living off royalties from adapted screenplays, etc. Of course, if "more successful" takes into account critical love and lit-circle sainthood, then yeah, DFW stomps him into the dirt.

I mean you are a PROFESSIONAL WRITER, dude, and you can't even come up with anything better to sling than poorly expressed cliches

― look at this quarterstaff (Hurting 2), Thursday, September 6, 2012 11:42 AM (53 minutes ago) Bookmark

yeah there have been so many pointed and stinging critiques of the guy's writing at this point that just repeating the word "pretentious" is so toothless

xxpost

Not unlike John Grisham's ribald space operas for stunted Americans. At least that's what I assume he writes, based solely on having seen one of his books misshelved in the erotic sci-fi section that one time.

btw the thing I like most about dfw is this part of some article I read once where a fawning interviewer is just so crushed, just seemingly almost in tears because he walks into a room to interview dfw and the dude is sitting on a couch eating kfc and watching the x files

it reminded me of that time when jodorowsky actually cried because he wanted pink floyd to score dune and he revered them so much and when he walked into a room they were dudes just sitting around eating fish and chips

and the old "people just like him to feel smart" canard -- you can just as easily throw that at ANY literary author, hell, at the entire idea of "literary authors."

he walks into a room to interview dfw and the dude is sitting on a couch eating kfc and watching the x files

this = a reason for love

To turn the end of Wallace's Updike review into a posthumous BEE zing, Erect or flaccid, Ben Turnbull's BEE's unhappiness is obvious right from the book's first page first tweet. But it never once occurs to him that the reason he's so unhappy is that he's an asshole.

Love that review.

We are paying attention to the opinions of Brett Easton Ellis now?! When did this misfortune befall?

Here's the opening of Dale Peck's Infinite Jest review:

http://www.lrb.co.uk/v18/n14/dale-peck/well-duh

The US literary world can be divided into two camps: those who think Thomas Pynchon is a very clever guy, and those who also think he’s a great writer.

Dale Peck is an idiot, though

Peck knows what he wants and he wants recognizable human characters, which is a legitimate desire. His ability to recognize human characters seems to be limited by how closely they resemble people or fictional characters already familiar to him. This makes him not an idiot, but not an ideal reviewer of books like Infinite Jest.

dale peck, internet nobody

the myth of foster wallace is p gross to me but ellis is just bringing nothing in those zings

I haven't read Infinite Jest but that review and all the things it resents makes me wanna read it more

the myth of foster wallace is p gross to me but ellis is just bringing nothing in those zings

agreed.

I haven't read Infinite Jest but that review and all the things it resents makes me wanna read it more

300 pages of it are really good and the rest is good for arguing with people about

I think back wistfully to a time when I enjoyed DFW and never saw/heard anyone talking about him outside of, like, newsgroups.

(Eternal thanks to erstwhile(?) ILXor D. Wolk for introducing me to the dude via his review of Supposedly Fun Thing... in CMJ.)

ellis has been like this all his life: 'american psycho' is basically one long troll of whoever's reading it.

judging from the first few paragraphs of that review dale peck is even dumber than that 'reader's manifesto' guy.

but b r myers is pretty cool and often right

I read a BEE book once and all I can remember is something something colombian foot soldiers

no wait that was jay mcierneyerrerer

sorry BEE I didn't mean to tarnish you by association

I almost took a McInerney book out of the library the other day but then I flipped it open to a random page and read a sentence and was permanently cured of the impulse to ever read anything of his ever again.

McInerney's pretty good at wine writing and Ellis is pretty good at tweeting.

Wallace is pretty good at jamming and Baker is pretty great at thinking as dramatic action.

pretty sure Ellis has never had a website like this dedicated to one of his novels, same goes for Dale Peck

http://infiniteatlas.com/

pretty sure Ellis has never had a website like this dedicated to one of his novels, same goes for Dale Peck

Degree of obsessive fan devotion is a 100% reliable sign of quality. See: the Grateful Dead, Amanda Palmer, Star Wars.

i'm just saying the guy has made a significant cultural impact.

Degree of obsessive fan devotion is a 100% reliable sign of quality.

Agree 100%, problem is, I think BEE wishes he had the impact DFW does

Um, Less Than Zero and American Psycho didn't have a cultural impact?

In May 2011, Peck's criticism of Jewish-American literature in which he claimed "(I)f I have to read another book about the Holocaust, I’ll kill a Jew myself" prompted a public outcry. His editors later removed the statement from his article.

they do a little bit, sure! not nearly the impact that DFW does--those tweets BEE made reek of desperation

and anyone who shits on the dead like that does not deserve to be taken seriously

ellis is soooo jelly of dfw's cult

I do not knwo who he is and I am not going to google it

bee is gross and sad. still like lunar park.

Um, Less Than Zero and American Psycho didn't have a cultural impact?

as literature they're toilet paper, plenty of crappy literature has had some impact just by virtue of being widely read. I haven't read IJ & probably never will but I like DFW's short work, he's capable of thinking a problem through. BEE wouldn't know what to do with an idea if one ever occurred to him.

wait ppl think Ellis is anything other than decent trash to read on airplanes?

Next poll: chuck palinuknuk vs David Mitchell

i didn't realise we had a whole other thread on this already, this happens when i take a day off ilx