RESULTS (of the very nebulously defined) 110 ELECTRONIC DANCE TRACKS of the 00s

http://i.imgur.com/l95Ez.jpg
1. Lindstrom - I Feel Space (775 points, 27 votes, 2 first place votes)
Year: 2005
Youtube: http://youtu.be/i7_edU9T2Ho

http://thatsglitchy.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/03/sad-ohioans.jpg

Good work! My number 1. You can blame me. It gets me every time.

well...ok

I had fun doing this. Hope you enjoyed it and found something worthwhile in here. Also sorry if I chose weird hours to publish the winners, I've been having a busy month. Here's the full list of results:

https://docs.google.com/spreadsheet/pub?key=0ArHM5vPIjnrqdHFRUmQzdGtSOVBtcml1Y1RhZGFSVmc&output=html

If Tessio had won the poll we would have had Luomo at both ends. Think about it.

i like both, i keep the Janet 12" next to R&B Drunkie in the box. i have been playing the Janet much more often recently.
― dan138zig (Durrr Durrr Durrrrrr)

haha that's soo not my quote.

anticlimactic #1 in my eyes but can't argue with that.

The three versions of "Blind" had ~688 points if added together, which would have secured it #3; the two versions of "Flowers" had ~375, bumping it up to #17.

Wouldn't have guessed most of this top 10; can't complain and I've already discovered some pretty big blind spots. Thanks so much, Moka/TLG!

For a while Jurgen Paape had the top spot. I think most of the voters got confident about it placing at the top and it got affected by it. Noone gave it a 1st place vote and from what I recall half of the ballots that had the song gave it less than 20 points.

I'll do heresy against these results but I've never really understood the appeal of 'I Feel Space'. I don't see it working on a dancefloor (or at least it failed miserably that one time I heard it on a club) and it's not layered enough to be 'trip' music. I love Lindstrom and I think the track is ok but I would never rate it top 10 of the 00s.

My number one, too. Did I miss it, or did Dexter not place?

(also, looking back at my ballot, due to a c+p error I think I voted for "Poney pt 1" twice, heh)

xp Dexter's #21.

eww

Definitely heard it working at Fabric back in the day, fwiw.

xp thanks, totally missed that!

I don't think I know the Juan Maclean track, either. Surprised to find two things in the top ten that I don't know!

Anyhoo, speaking as a casual observer I think this might be one of my favorite polls on ILM, results-wise. There were lots of pleasant surprises throughout, a couple of things I overlooked and which I've kept repeating all week, the top 10 wasn't all that predictable and overall I didn't really hate any of the songs that made it.

Oh yeah, there were some ballots that had double-votes and song that were not on the noms list. I didn't count those. (Which means I did count the higher vote and removed the lower double).

I really hate the lyrics/vocals of tessio. I mean, the vocal production or w/e soundsamazing of course, but the words are so terrible.

i'm trying to write a "most overhyped record of year" thing about this for my neglected blog, but i barely even understand why people are hyping this in the first place, which is making it really hard to explain how it's been over-hyped.
OK "i feel space" is fine (if you missed out on faze action and yellow sox and the rest of the great lost first and second wave of space-disco on nuphonic and u-star and versatile and discfunction and repap in the first place) but this album ... GAH ... it really IS fila brazilia all over again!

― vahid (vahid), Thursday, 5 January 2006 10:34 PM (6 years ago)

BTW in one month it is the TENTH ANNIVERSARY of the release of faze action's "in the trees", dig it out if you need to (although i've always had it on hand for the TEN YEARS) and it'll take your head off.
that single is ETERNAL and PERFECT like the first NEU album or like "in the light of the miracle". we'll see if people remember lindstrom a year from now.

also, while you are at it, dig out yellow sox "flim flam", another space disco track from ten years ago that ruins all nu-nu-space-disco pretenders.

― vahid (vahid), Thursday, 5 January 2006 10:40 PM (6 years ago)

The three versions of "Blind" had ~688 points if added together, which would have secured it #3; the two versions of "Flowers" had ~375, bumping it up to #17.

I don't believe that anyone intentionally voted for the OG "Flowers" - it wasn't even released as a single. Could this have been a mistake of someone accidentally nominating the original and then people accidentally voting for it?

we'll see if people remember lindstrom a year from now.

as usual this is always the silliest prediction to make.

how is a Janet Jackson edit a landmark 00s dance track lol

7 and 8 are otm. Aeroplane are total hacks.

how is a Janet Jackson edit a landmark 00s dance track lol

― check my slipknot shred on youtube (blank), Wednesday, 29 August 2012 6:29 AM (1 minute ago) Bookmark Flag Post Permalink

Given the rise of edits culture in the second half of the 00s this actually makes perfect sense to me.

I don't believe that anyone intentionally voted for the OG "Flowers" - it wasn't even released as a single. Could this have been a mistake of someone accidentally nominating the original and then people accidentally voting for it?

― Tim F, Wednesday, 29 August 2012 6:28 AM (6 minutes ago)

Guilty as charged - turns out the version I know / thought was the original is, in fact, an edit of the Sunship mix - thank poorly labelled bargain-bin garage/2-step cassettes/CDs and Slsk for me being under this impression for over a decade. I actually can't seem to find the original "Flowers" to see what it sounds like - the version on both the SFA album and the single is the Sunship remix.

yeah I assumed it was the sunship rmx as well

xp interesting point

yeah but i still think faze action and yellow sox are better than windstorm

lindstrom

it would not have been a silly thing to say if people had forgotten about lindstrom tim

Yeah ok I'm definitely down with R&B junkie being the highest ranked edit here, now that I think of it in that way.

late great otm re windbagstrom

it would not have been a silly thing to say if people had forgotten about lindstrom tim

― the late great, Wednesday, 29 August 2012 6:47 AM (39 minutes ago) Bookmark Flag Post Permalink

Even though I can agree with "In The Trees" being better, like anyone was ever going to forget the most "overhyped record of the year".

I feel the same about "Hyph Mngo" (vis a vis, oh, say, DJ Abstract's "Touch") but I still expect it to top lots of retrospective "dance tunes of 2009" lists in the future.

i am not sure i know that track though the name rings a bell, I think maybe i heard oneman or fourtet play it

stfu

OK, this has been a very fun (and very very ILM) list, and the Spotify playlist has lightened my days immensely.

Thanks for compiling and posting, Moka!

I feel bad now that I didn't vote, but I feel quite happy and comfortable with that number one.

i made a youtube playlist, if anyone doesn't have spotify: http://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PL5D929515B2E7016D&feature=mh_lolz

Great rollout Moka.

Surprised to see how many I know. Must have been keeping up better than I thought.

Do we get to see individual ballots at any point?

can't believe happy house was so high, really just doesn't even register for me.

Really, I wouldn't have been surprised if it was (I shouldn't have bought a british laptop cause now I have no idea where the number symbol is on this keyboard) 1.

Wow, I'm really not hugely that familiar with a lot of the top ten.

Lol, my number one was 331 with a bullet. :D

Can we have a complete rundown yet please?

Oh I see - it was posted above. My bad. My number 1 was 356

Were any of those MFA votes (including the first place vote) supposed to be for the remix? Not sure I've ever heard the original, guess it could also be really good?

Agreed that all of the Flowers votes were surely for the remix, though.

Is it okay to post our ballots then? Here was mine. I take it "Body Rock" comes under the banner of verboeten non-house/techno tracks which was why I seemed to be the only person who voted for it.

DOG LATIN'S BALLOT
1 andy c & shimon body rock
2 blawan getting me down
3 daft punk digital love
4 girl unit wut
5 friendly fires paris (aeroplane mix)
6 kingdom mind reader
7 tensnake coma cat
8 todd terje inspector norse
9 laurent garnier sound of the big babou
10 burial archangel
11 autofire succotash wish
12 fischerspooner emerge
13 mosca bax
14 lcd soundsystem losing my edge
15 justice vs simian we are your friends
16 ame rej
17 royksopp what else is there (trentemoller mix)
18 2000f & j kamata you don't know what love is
19 mylo drop the pressure (rex the dog mix)
20 james blake cmyk
21 sebastian tellier la ritournelle
22 tucillo disco en paradiso
23 ricardo villalobos fizheuer zieheuer
24 frankie valli beggin' (pilooski edit)
25 joy orbison hyph mngo
26 kelley polar here in the night
27 crazy cousinz inflation
28 extrawelt zu fuss
29 luomo tessio (vocalcity version)
30 luke vibert i love acid
31 runaway brooklyn club jam
32 the knife heartbeats (rex the dog remix)
33 X-press 2 lazy
34 actress hubble
35 boards of canada in a beautiful place out in the country
36 nathan fake the sky was pink (holden remix)
37 robag wruhme thora vukk
38 royksopp poor leno
39 adult. hand to phone
40 cortney tidwell don't let stars keep us tangled up (ewan pearson‚äôs objects in space remix)
41 daft punk something about us
42 darkastar aidy's girl is a computer
43 dj mujava township funk
44 fuzzy logik feat. egypt in the morning
45 golden boy with miss kittin rippin kittin
46 justice dance
47 teengirl fantasy cheaters (john talabot classic vocal refix)
48 rustie ultra thizz
49 major lazer pon de floor
50 the other people place sunrays

woops, sorry about not separating artists/tracks

I'm surprised that no one else besides me voted for Ellen Allien's "Sehnsucht"! To me that tune is massive, clearly better than that Ellen Allien & Apparat tune that placed (which is not bad itself). Was there no ILM buzz about that tune? I remember when I played Berlinette for the first time, and "Sehnsucht" came on, I was like "holy shit, this is epic!". Even though the rest of the album is good too, it never quite reaches the same heights.

my number 1 came 291st :( who else voted for 'quetzal'?

xpost Goes to show that with dance music very often the consensus is that there's little consensus - whether a track lifts you or not is often entirely down to subjectivity and setting.

Oh yeah, here's my ballot:

1. Eric Prydz - Call on Me
2. All Saints - Chick Fit (Kissy Sell Out's Excellent Adventure Remix)
3. Acid Washed feat. Barbara Panther - Snake
4. Ellen Allien - Sehnsucht
5. Etienne Jaumet - For Falling Asleep
6. Sydenham & Ferrer - Sandcastles
7. Jahcoozi - BLN
8. Αλλού - Γυμνή Φωτογραφία
9. Mico - Signal Found
10. Jürgen Paape - So Weit Wie Noch Nie
11. Op:l Bastards - Scorpius
12. The Chemical Brothers feat. Q-Tip - Galvanize
13. Srkkpjt - Klb
14. Norma Jean Bell - Nobody
15. Ada - Maps (Michael Mayer & Tobias Thomas Mix)
16. Dan Electro - Down Is the Power
17. Barbara Panther - Unchained
18. Chymera - Valerian (Orlando Voorn Mix)
19. DJ Sprinkles - Sisters, I Don't Know What This World Is Coming To
20. Mylo vs. Miami Sound Machine - Doctor Pressure
21. S.I. Futures - I Like That (Brand New)
22. Steffi feat. Virginia - Yours
23. Grace Jones - I've Seen That Face Before (Libertango) (DJ Hell Vienna Mix)
24. Drexciya - Soul of the Sea
25. Burnt Friedman - Das Wesen aus der Milchstrasse
26. Two Lone Swordsmen - Solo Strike
27. Sydenham & Ferrer - Sandcastles (Afterlife Mix)
28. The Modernist - Kangmei Pt. 1 & 2
29. Nina Simone - See-Line Woman (Masters at Work Remix)
30. Steve Bug - Electric Blue
31. Acid Washed - General Motors, Detroit, America
32. Masters at Work - Backfired
33. San Proper & Steven de Peven - Hupsers & Kletsers for Life (Original)
34. Crazy Cousinz - Bongo Jam
35. Takkyu Ishino - Creatures of the Night
36. Ada - At the Gate
37. DJ Mujava - Township Funk
38. Benny Benassi - Satisfaction
39. Laurent Garnier - Greed (Part 1+2)
40. Hell - Control
41. Robert Lippok & Barbara Morgenstern - Kaitusburi
42. Readymade - Bold
43. Gudrun Gut - Monika in Polen
44. Chateau Flight- Prism
45. Kami-Sakunobe House Explosion - B2B
46. Donae'o - African Warrior
47. Dub Trees - Butterfly Trilogy
48. Shifted Phases - Lonely Journey of the Comet Bopp
49. Barbara Morgenstern - 37 Degrees
50. Lumukanda - Electric Deluxe

The biggest surprise for me was that "Sandcastles" didn't place, I thought that one was locked for the top 100.

How surprising.

xpost

~sarcasm~?

Well i thought if ILM had come to any conclusion it's that consensus is arbitrary at best and that we're all different.