nomination and discussion thread for possible top 100 electronic dance tracks of the 00s

the juan maclean - tito's way (reverso 68 mix)
justus kohncke - elan
rubies - i feel electric (max essa remix)
siobhan donnaghy - don't give it up(c2 remix)
alter ego - gary (c2 remix)
my my - swiss on rye
dj hell - je regrette everything (superpitcher mix)

search function

yeah, i know. no hits, no mainstream visibility. still surprised, cuz this stuff seems very accessible to me.

should also be noted that dude is sort of a recluse and doesn't exactly jump at the opportunity to work with anyone.

search function

― the late great, Thursday, 26 April 2012 19:20 (1 hour ago) Bookmark Flag Post Permalink

i ctrl/f'd. sincere apologies if i replicated something, 'tis a big thread.

what did i replicate anyway?

oh whoops my bad it was tiga's remix of gary posted upthread!

:-(

i knew it! apology accepted ;)

feel for you compiling this all btw.

eh i think EDB's going to do that for me

;-)

Heh, I'm definitely willing to, though. And I'll do my best to sort out "questionable" nominations.

Well, we're at 1053 now, though there's dozens of duplicates and "questionable" nominations that need to be taken out.

Having compiled all the nominations, let me say that for all the hand-wringing about house/pop distinction, over-nominating stuff (i.e. adding every track you kind of enjoyed) has made the nomination list way more arbitrary than any fever rays track ever could. Granted, I'm still questionable about LCD soundsystem (surely something like yeah (pretentious mix) would be elegible?)

I added everything to a google spreadsheet that's here

I think the most effective thing to do is have a sort of "flag nomination" system, where if you see something you don't want on, flag it, and it will go to an external review board (i.e. we'll debate it here for 2 days to no conclusion).

EDB you're thinking the same way i am - just scanning the list i see way more random house/techno choices than questionable pop or indie choices

one thing we could do is have everybody nominate 50 tracks they think should make the cut (w/o sorting into a ballot) and then chop out everything that doesn't get any votes

then do a full ballot

thanks again EDB

Good work EDB. There's quite a lot of duplicate entries there, and it's quite amusing that Matt DC's nom is listed with his comment:
Mylo - Drop The Pressure (I don't even want to vote for this but the idea of the Gloria Estefan bootleg being nominated and not the original is horrible)

one thing we could do is have everybody nominate 50 tracks they think should make the cut (w/o sorting into a ballot) and then chop out everything that doesn't get any votes

I've got nothing against that, but I think it will lead to far fewer tracks being eliminated than you suspect.

late great what do you hope to accomplish w/ this???

accomplish w/ pruning down the list?

i don't know - just making it easier to work with the spreadsheet, not overwhelming voter?

just throwing it out there, not really pushing the idea, i think it will lead to far fewer tracks being eliminated than you suspect is correct

does that mark the end of nominations then? even just scanning it there's so many glaring omissions. the ambition deserves some kudos and no doubt the heart's in the right place but jeez... i'm obv still compelled to vote mind.

i thought the point was to cross-reference with that fabuloso best djs list

A further elimination process seems like overkill but I think anyone who wants to nominate more stuff should honestly ask themselves "will this actually make my top 50"?

At this point I doubt that anyone will be obsessively checking everything they haven't heard out of the 1000+ noms so there seems to be little point in expanding the field.

i agree, referring specifically to a couple of personal favourites (have been hovering around this thing aprehensively and jumped in quite late tbh). if that's it tho, then i'm fine with it. p much all my big favourites are there.

accomplish w/ pruning down the list?

no like just in general, with this poll? like do you want something thats quasi-canonical or just a collective 'desert island' mix or do you want some kind of aesthetic soi for ilm

why does anyone do lists?

to make sense of things, to bring order, to commemorate

i don't have any agenda, durr durr durr brought up the idea and i thought it might be fun?

i see a lot of poll threads on ILM and i never click on them because i basically don't give a shit about what they're polling about, thought i'd step in and facilitate this one because i have a lot of past dance-thread sins to make up for. also because i always looked at those threads on new answers and thought "we should do a dance one".

i always thought about doing separate house and techno ones but always figured it'd be hard to draw the line and everyone would get super-frustrated, sort of smh that we're doing a much more inclusive poll and people are still arguing about it

to answer your questions

1) i don't think there's enough critical distance to do something canonical on 00s dance music. it's hard enough coming up w/ a disco canon let alone 00s dance.

2) i am pretty certain that the results are not going to look like 50 tracks i'd want to take to a desert island w/ me ... i'll feel lucky if five of my picks make the top fifty let alone ten

3) not sure what an aesthetic soi is, is that like a soi disant critical theorist of the hardcore continuum?

I think the most effective thing to do is have a sort of "flag nomination" system, where if you see something you don't want on, flag it, and it will go to an external review board (i.e. we'll debate it here for 2 days to no conclusion).

I see that my two Barbara Morgenstern noms were flagged as "pop?". If you really must, you can delete "Gute Nacht", as it is kind of a synth poppy (though everything in it is still electronic beside the vocals), but "37°" is a pure instrumental electronic tune with no singing.

I see two Knife songs have been flagged as "popish". I'm pretty sure they're Lutheran.

No good can come of whittling down the nominations. If you can go through to flag things you want to get rid of, or things you want to keep, you can put a ballot together. Just let people vote and call them a feeb if you don't like their list afterwards.

Also: DL nominated Röyksopp's "Eple", but it isn't in the nomination spreadsheet.

Horsepower Productions - Gorgon Sound

Just let people vote and call them a feeb if you don't like their list afterwards.

always curious about this urge some people have to stroke chin and say "Venetian Snares is electronic music and you could dance to it if you wanted to hmmmm??? do you see?????" tho

like a common reading of the parameters wdn't generate enough options to vote for.

"actually i think Mike Leigh's Naked is the best horror film i've ever seen" *pushes glasses up nose*

That's true, though i suspect more stuff will be flagged as "pop" than flagged as anything else.

Clearly anyone who votes for Venetian Snares should be forced to submit a YouTube clip of them dancing to it or have their ballot considered void.

the impulse is equally bizarre was my point

Good to see Slowhouse - 03 A1 up there, what a tune.

Is it too late to add:

Ada - The Red Shoes

I noticed a lot of tracks in the spreadsheet, but not this one, which is the one I've seen get the biggest reactions on the dancefloor.

Disagree w tim about all the above (Ben has def become a better dj for a start)

Not sure that post was supposed to go there, was half written post in my phone...

I want to see a youtube clip of NV dancing to Mike Leigh's Naked

nobody wants to see that, let's be honest

Yeah, if your nominations are missing, just put them in, or mention it here (but again, if you have no intention of voting for it, probably no point of having it there).

While I think submitting 50 track list first solves a lot of problems, I doubt people are willing to submit a list, and then submit another one.

lol@venetian snares

that Slowhouse record is good, forgot about that, tho i can never remember which track is which

Just let people vote and spare the endless handwringing.

Like when magazines or websites do these sorts of lists people are basically free to vote for anything with no nominations process and those turn out alright*, the number of nominations is a red herring.

*Okay they are often lame but not as a result of having too many options to vote for.

Yeah, at this point the nomination system is kind of... well, pointless (other than giving a convenient advice list to refresh people's memories).

but yeah, OTM.

And why did someone 0_o my Poison Dart/Skeng noms? The former is definitely top 50 material.

I see two Knife songs have been flagged as "popish". I'm pretty sure they're Lutheran.

ba dum TSSSSSSSSS ;-)

poison dart / skeng is post-dancehall NOM DENIED

spare the endless handwringing

b-b-but if we did this there would be no ILX

lol wth how does venetian snares not count