WHAT A DRAG IT IS GETTING POLLED – ILM Artist Poll #16 – The Rolling Stones (Extended deadline: April 1st)

could you ask for a better 'selective discography'?

The Rolling Stones: Let It Bleed, Sticky Fingers, Exile on Main St., Goats Head Soup, Emotional Rescue, Stripped
Joe Cocker: Mad Dogs and Englishmen
George Harrison: All Things Must Pass
John Lennon: Some Time in New York City, Walls and Bridges, Rock 'n' Roll
Keith Richards: Talk Is Cheap, Live at the Hollywood Palladium
Ringo Starr: Ringo, Goodnight Vienna
Ronnie Wood: 1234, Gimme Some Neck, Mahoney's Last Stand
B.B. King: B. B. King in London
Barbra Streisand: Barbra Joan Streisand
Carly Simon: No Secrets, Hotcakes
Chuck Berry: Hail! Hail! Rock 'n' Roll
Delaney, Bonnie & Friends: On Tour with Eric Clapton
Donovan: Cosmic Wheels
Dr. John: The Sun, Moon & Herbs
Eric Clapton: Eric Clapton
Faces: Long Player
Harry Nilsson: Nilsson Schmilsson, Son of Schmilsson, Pussy Cats, Duit on Mon Dei
Warren Zevon: Warren Zevon
Humble Pie: Rock On
Joe Ely: Lord of the Highway
John Hiatt: Beneath This Gruff Exterior
Kate & Anna McGarrigle: Kate & Anna McGarrigle
Keith Moon: Two Sides of the Moon
Leo Sayer: Endless Flight
Lynyrd Skynyrd: Second Helping
John Lennon and Paul McCartney: A Toot and a Snore in '74
John Lennon: Whatever Gets You thru the Night
Marvin Gaye: Let's Get It On (deluxe edition)
Sheryl Crow: The Globe Sessions
Yoko Ono: Fly
Jim Carroll: Catholic Boy

"midnight rambler" guitar solo is BADASS, but whoever's in charge of video editing here needs to be taken out back behind the shed and instructed in the proper way to be

Jim Carroll: Catholic Boy

you could not ask for a better "selective selective discography"

but HOLY FUCK, bow down, etc.

agreed about the video editing. they do it a couple of times during key awesome jamouts and it's like raaagggh wtf are you doing

Doesn't Start Me Up automatically place on the most hated list? I was in high school when it came out. It was a defining song - if you loved it, you couldn't be a real Stones fan. For years we laughed when the DJ said he was going to play some classic Stones and put on Start Me Up. Too plastic and shiny. The riff was an cheap high when we knew they were capable of Brown Sugar. And the lyrics. After absorbing the murk of Live With Me, Shattered and Stray Cat Blues, Start Me Up just seemed like a joke. Guess I better send in my hated songs ballot.

i was 14 & jr. high, thus not properly schooled in the ways of the HS world. i dug "start me up" and still feel a faded echo of the initial attraction, despite the shinyness, despite years of hideous flogging abuse by bill gates and his corpse buddies.

plus VG otm, that hyde park "bitch" fucking RIPS

<3<3<3 "brown CHOOGAH"

mick fucking taylor, ftr

that may be the best version of "brown sugar" i've ever heard

"Dead Flowers" was high on my ballot. Overall, Sticky Fingers is my least favourite of the Hopkins/Taylor four-album run, but it produced two of my top five. (The other being the most obvious one.)

Will rep for Sister Morphine and Moonlight Mile

Sticky Fingers is not among my favorites but Brown Sugar and Moonlight Mile are the biggest songs ever

Contenderizer had a good post last night on the comedy-poll thread delineating the difference between Taxi Driver and Tarantino's films in terms of comedy and tone. (I was being a little disingenuous when I asked where the line should be drawn; I think I was trying to force someone to articulate clearly the difference.) I'd draw the same distinction between "Far Away Eyes" and "Dead Flowers." "Far Away Eyes" is just straight laughs for me--it's a nice song, and I like it, but its appeal begins and ends with the broad parody. Jagger slips into the same voice on "Dead Flowers" (less broad, which is one advantage), but I consider it a much darker, more vivid song. Even though I know that "I'll be in my basement room/with a needle and a spoon/and another girl to the pain away" is, in itself, a bit of a caricature of the Rolling Stones' image circa 1971, the line, and the whole song, actually does encapsulate why they seemed so mysterious and grown-up to me when I discovered them around that time.

Agreed. Jagger's injection of humor into "Dead Flowers" makes it more moving

Jagger may have been taking the piss out of Gram Parsons a bit, too; supposedly, he was acutely jealous of Parsons' friendship with Keith.

The "so I ran 20 red lights in your honor, thank you Jesus, thank you Lord" line makes me laugh every time

Unexpectedly fallen in love with ... Dance (pt I) from Emotional Rescue

KEEF
WHATCHOO
WHATCHOO DOIN

Was listening to Sticky Fingers in the car on the way into work this morning - 'Dead Flowers' really is a perfect singing at the top of your lungs song.

also vv easy and fun to play

Made a couple of last minute changes and sent my ballot. The deed is done!

"Unexpectedly fallen in love with ... Dance (pt I) from Emotional Rescue"

Try listening to Led Zep's "Trampled Under Foot" while watching an episode of Welcome Back Kotter. Same thing! (Guess what song made my most hated list?)

Yeah, Trampled Underfoot was exactly what I was thinking. There are a few other yacht rock type influences buried in there too though, it's a smoother listen than Zep.

Dance has an awesome groove but a) the vocals sound like they were recorded via a sewer drain across the street from the studio and b) Kieth's voice is a little, 'yeesh'.

It's not quite right. But almost great.

The vocals are awesome! I love that kind of slurry shoutalong. I cannot imagine hearing it in a club though - was supposedly a big dance hit at the time.

could you ask for a better 'selective discography'?
...
Keith Richards: Talk Is Cheap

Love this record so much. I still say it's by far the best Stones record of the 80s. The caliber of guest musicians is ridiculous: Bobby Keys, sure, but also Mick Taylor...and Johnnie Johnson! Maceo Parker! Bootsy Collins! Sarah Dash!

i love "dead flowers" and am starting to feel like a bozo for leaving it off my ballot. i couldn't get it out of my head as i fell asleep last night, and VG otm: it's one of the best "sing along at the top of your lungs" songs ever, fake haccent and all. i mean, i'm sure it'll do just fine w/o my vote cuz you people seem p sharp, but i'm nevertheless experiencing a twinge of voter's regret.

need to hear talk is cheap, i guess. never have.

Jagger slips into the same voice on "Dead Flowers" (less broad, which is one advantage), but I consider it a much darker, more vivid song. Even though I know that "I'll be in my basement room/with a needle and a spoon/and another girl to the pain away" is, in itself, a bit of a caricature of the Rolling Stones' image circa 1971, the line, and the whole song, actually does encapsulate why they seemed so mysterious and grown-up to me when I discovered them around that time.

just gonna come out and say it - this will be my #1 and is really the only ballot entry I'm certain of. I like to envision it as a song Jagger is singing to his future self.

Did you ever see the Texas Chainsaw Massacre? Horrible isn't it? ... oh no, don't saw off me leg, don't saw off me arm

This is awesome!

It's only been mentioned once so far, but for me this stands alongside "I Am Waiting" as their prettiest song ever:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bkm1efUhGJ4

The lyrics, not so much LOL

one of the their best but pretty is a wrong word.

xxpost Tarfumes otm: Talk is Cheap is great! Love it. Took me a while to get used to Keith's singing just bc the sound is still kinda Stones and you're waiting for Mick, but once you get over that, damn it's good stuff.

re "backstreet girl": a sad & bitter little song, but undeniably lovely

was there a single from Talk is Cheap? i think i remember liking it when it came out.

Take It So Hard was the single

xp At the time, I preferred Keith's singing to Mick's. But that was mainly because Mick had just put out those two crappy solo records ("Let's Work" was on MTV far more frequently than it had any right to be, which is to say, more than once), and the way he sang "competition" in "Winning Ugly" made me think, that guy there, if he doesn't stop it, man...

I hadn't even thought about the lyrics--the music is so perfect for me, I don't think I've ever given them a thought.

the way he sang "competition" in "Winning Ugly" made me think, that guy there, if he doesn't stop it, man...

haha we won't agree will we?

I kinda wish Keith had done an earlier solo album, because his voice was so much brighter...by the time Talk is Cheap came around he's sounding a little more ragged than I'd like.

but I still love him.

xp I actually like that song now, but some of Jagger's 80s vocal quirks make me cringe.

Where's the Hyde Park "Bitch" youtube?

scroll up; it's the whole show

"bitch" is the 2nd to last song

stick around for "brown sugar" though, it's amazing

Yeah, I must be an idiot but I keep looking through the thread and not seeing it? I see the Marquee Club one, but not Hyde Park

oh, that vid is sometimes titled "marquee club/hyde park", not sure why

yeah it's Marquee Club, that's the link above.

Hyde Park is a totally different show, it was outdoors iirc?

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uYPFrUzp87w