Animal Collective Sung Tongs POLL

leaf house!

this album has def highlights. i think for a long time i wouldve said leaf house which kindof blew me away 1st time i heard it.

bbc session of good lovin outside is cool, bob drake-ish

my favorite animal collective disc, by some distance. i don't get the love for the herky-jerky who could win a rabbit, but other acid-fried songs on the disc -- e.g., college and winter's love -- are beautiful.

Can we have an Animal Collective thread without people being arseholes about them? No matter what you think of Merriweather Post Pavilion, this one should be given a shot as it's a very different record and a very brilliant record at that. Also, haters, you don't see me turning up on threads about whatever shitty music you like just to tell you it sucks. You should shut up.

I'm voting We Tigers.

illchay udeday

Is this the Animal Collective album with all the cat noises?

meow
kitties
meow
kitties

Only tracks I'm not really feeling are the last two ones "Good Lovin Outside/Whaddit I Done". This album could benefit from losing them entirely or canning them as b-sides or something. I'm sure the band also thought they were the weakest ones in here and decided to keep them as tails. 'Mouth wooed her' would be a much better closer.

Leaf House and We Tigers were the ones that caught my attention on first listen. At the time of the release I hadn't heard anything quite like it before.

Also 'Visiting Friends' is unnecesarily long, it could benefit from keeping the elements tighter and reducing the play time from 13 to 5 or 6.

was really into this album when it came out, it was a perfect fall album, but I don't remember it that well now. was tempted to vote for "college" but voted for "kids on holiday"

HOLIDAYHOLIDAYHOLIDAYHOLIDAY
HOLIDAYHOLIDAYHOLIDAYHOLIDAY

i thought that was HARE! HARE! HARE!

kids on holiday, but mostly because i remember the live versions i witnessed being so amazing that i loved the album version even more. leaf house would've been next.

xp i think thats the point

kids on holiday, but mostly because i remember the live versions i witnessed being so amazing that i loved the album version even more. leaf house would've been next.

totally 100% otm, voted "kids on holiday"

Whenever I want to put a track from this album on a comp for someone who's never heard it, I can never choose one. It's surprisingly diverse despite the sound pallette being fairly consistent, so I can never decide on what is the quintessential Sung Tongs track. The closest I can think of is We Tigers.

totally disagree about visiting friends, think it only works because of its length. agree that album would be stronger with last two songs excised.

hung dongs

(sry)

relistening to this, there's so much great layering of guitar parts on this record. the last 1.40 or so of mouth wooed her is some blissful, melt-into-a-puddle stuff. love visiting friends&leaf house a lot too.

the middle of winters love where someone goes to town strumming E EEE E-E-E reminds me a little of

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_Wz7K-Kry8k

so it gets a vote.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=L-Hmu3mOX4o

Automatic thread bump. This poll is closing tomorrow.

I'd have contented that Who Could Win A Rabbit was the unimpeachable best song, but I voted for Visiting Friends because 1) I've grown to love the immersive hypnotic quality of it, 2) My tastes for whiny vocals is not what it used to be, 3) I suspect Rabbit going to win anyways.

really i wouldv thought leaf house and we tigers would be the top two in idk what order, i voted mouth wooed her bc it is secretly the best

*Contended (xpost), that is, contended years ago.

this album has def highlights. i think for a long time i wouldve said leaf house which kindof blew me away 1st time i heard it.

― plax (ico), Sunday, December 19, 2010 7:58 PM (6 days ago) Bookmark

^^^^^

this house is sad ;_;

The one that sounds like Brian Wilson if he could never sing or write a melody

^^ anco h8er

could never ZING or write a LOLody, more like

i think leaf house, but we tigers and who could win a rabbit both good. tho "college" is maybe the funniest AC song? I can't think of any others that even approach sarcasm/irony (tho perhaps AC is not even trying to be ironic here)

surprised by the win a rabbit love, it kindof shows off a lot of the things ppl hate about anco now right?

yeah but it sounded good in 2004 and it still sounds good now if yr not 'lashing

lashing?

back-

Automatic thread bump. This poll's results are now in.

We Tigers is too low.

ftr i love good lovin outside. plax was highly otm upthread, this record does some top notch bob drake channeling

I think I mixed up Visiting Friends for Winter's Love, actually.

who were the other mouth wooed hers

so was it the crayon commercial that ruined "sweet road" or ?

10 years in June.

Bloody eck.

The secret truth is that this album is not as good as Here Comes the Indian. Few things are, though.

People upthread complaining about the last two songs are otm.

Never could get my head around HCTI.

Echoing the Leaf House discovery mentioned upthread. Sounded to me like Inuit prog.

We Tigers is one of the highlights on this one for me. Shame it did so bad in this poll.

Yeah, We Tigers is the quintessential pre-MWPP AC song.

People claiming to dig this band's music are all part of some elaborate hoax, right? Like, an ongoing "Punk'd" sort of thing...?

so many songs from the sung tongs era were never recorded in the studio... rediscovering this gem today

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uIn2oVFsXd4

Funny, the album performed live thing...
On one hand it seems unlike them but I remember when HCTI came out they did a show where they played it front to back. Missed that one tho :(

Meeting of the Waters is kinda a new AC acoustic record.

Which one of these tracks sucks the least? Oh right. None of them.

― Lightning Is For Babies (Johnny Fever), Sunday, December 19, 2010 9:23 AM (six years ago) Bookmark Flag Post Permalink

Amen!

do you have some sort of notification set up every time someone posts about this band so you can remind everyone you don't like them?

I'd definitely go and see them doing this album

Last acoustic I think was the Other Music one, which I'm sure you know from the great boot

― Priory, Thursday, November 30, 2017 2:58 PM (yesterday) Bookmark Flag Post Permalink

yeah that recording is amazing, a few songs only performed once at that show, also their cover of "On a Plain" has always stuck with me.

Can't wait to see PB play an acoustic guitar again

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jh3o73dDuHc

xxxpost:

I usually find clicking on "ILM Answers" does the trick.

Why would you post in threads for bands you dislike

*regularly

In the case of Animal Collective, the praise they get from people who otherwise like some great stuff absolutely confounds me. This album, for example, codes to me as whiny American vocals fronting the sort of self-consciously inept crud that often mistakenly gets branded as "psychedelic" ...

Absolutely nothing at all about this band feels natural.

ok well you're not going to get anywhere or change anyone's mind reiterating that same exact sentiment every time an AC thread gets bumped. i really don't understand why you do it, it's just irritating and obnoxious and a complete of waste of time for everyone

"irritating and obnoxious and a complete of waste of time for everyone" would be a good capsule review for the band in general, IMO... unless you can helpfully point me to something worthwhile about this band or explain what on Earth you see in 'em.

Fuck off

lol @ this performance of "Mouth Wooed Her" at 18:46

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=R5-ovtyXp9A

Starting to sink in imagining what that room is going to be like tomorrow when everyone sings "College" together

Fuck that was amazing. Stood up front through a shitty Alex G set but was worth it. They get up on stage, sitting in folding chairs, two acoustics for each of them & a single floor tom, Avey just grins and whispers "sunngggg tongggss" crowd goes apeshit. crowd sang every word of the record. one of the best shows i've ever been to. also they fucking played COVERED IN FROGS going into Winter's Love. and closed with Prospect Hummer. it was just fucking great.

for posterity, a nice audience video of the whole set. i've seen the multi-camera p4k stream, some fans recorded it bc p4k isn't going to put the whole thing up, all of those are unlisted atm but i'll post if i find one i can embed, it's a nice video

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yWrSscnBFdA

Leaf House
Who Could Win a Rabbit
The Softest Voice
Covered in Frogs
Winters Love
Kids on Holiday
Sweet Road
Visiting Friends
College
We Tigers
Mouth Wooed Her
Good Lovin' Outside
Whaddit I Done
Prospect Hummer

Any sign they’ll return to this sound when/if they record a new album? Would be great.

Someone talked to PB after the show and he said they're considering touring Sung Tongs (!)

Avey Tare's solo record this year + the Meeting of the Waters EP were acoustic based, he definitely seems headed in that direction, and even though PB's new EP is supposed to sound like deep house/techno, his willingness to play this Sung Tongs set and potentially tour it are encouraging re: the next AC record. really hope it happens too - they've been stuck in sampler land for too long (although I loved the Painting With album and the shows for it even more).

Wow! Haven’t gone through the whole thing but what a great concert and crowd! Didn’t realize how sing-along the album actually is but when you have a full crowd doing the vocal oooohs and aaahs and whathaveyou it sounds gorgeous and seems like real fun to sing along to. I’m jealous.

even though it was ostensibly a birthday party for p4k (was smoking outside early in the night and someone asked me if i worked for p4k or was here for 'that animal band'), the crowd was easily 90% hardcore AC fans. like, you can hear the crowd freak out when Avey starts singing "Covered in Frogs," an obscure never-recorded Sung Tongs era castoff (and my favorite song of that era). and then losing it again at the end when they started "Prospect Hummer," everyone singing "whoaaa whoaaa whoaa whoaa whoaaaas." A thousand people singing every word of the record, and then falling into solemn silence during "The Softest Voice" and "Visiting Friends," the latter of which was just out of this world- I closed my eyes for most of it but I looked around at one point and saw many people openly weeping. a guy proposed to his girlfriend during "Winters Love." you get that many people in the room so excited & completely in tune with the artist, it was truly magical.

here's an unlisted rip of the multi-camera p4k stream- do yourself a favor and watch "Visiting Friends"

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EeU-ZBGLVyY

ha, Moka you should check out "Mouth Wooed Her" from the p4k stream- you can see people doing the staggered claps in the second half of the song. like, not only were people singing every word, they were mimicking the sound effects and overdubs on the record

Ah We Tigers sounds so fun! They should do that one in every live performance. If the crowd follows it’s crazy stupid fun. Makes me want to see a performance with one of those student choirs that are all over youtube..z like this Crystal Castles - Untrust Us cover: https://youtu.be/g7a2u9v0V0c

Oh I just got to ‘mouth wooed her’ I’m going to cry tears of envy.

https://youtu.be/auL2dU5U-4s

here's a great winters love student choir performance

I revisited this record for the first time in *years* yesterday... some excellent tracks (Winters Love, Leaf House, Softest Voice) and i liked the 12 minute song more than i remember. But everything after College is kinda... unlistenable??

Perhaps it's something i just need to listen to more until it clicks but all i could think was, like, how stoned was Pitchfork back in 2004 to think this was good enough to be an 8.9?? (if i remember the score correctly). Do people actually think Whaddit I Done is good?

and like, I LOVE those tracks I mentioned earlier. So i want to love this. but the second half is a mess!

it's funny how Who Could Be A Rabbit? sounds so dated. I like it, but it's very mid-2000. I think as a teenager i wished it was less weird, now i think it sounds so overtly pop!

Love this album.

Drop off on the last three tracks is real, but also I wouldn't say they're horrible. I always listened to those almost as soundscapes because the songwriting chops aren't on full display, a flip side to visiting friends that is not intentionally trying to be visiting friends. Maybe it's too forgiving a perspective but it works for me!

Softest voice to visiting friends is exactly what I want AnCo to be always. they're at their best at their most melancholy (see: Banshee Beat, Cuckoo Cuckoo, No More Running, man-of-oil EP)

I quite like Whaddit I Done

We Tigers was robbed in this poll

We Tigers is my authentic teenager choice and also my closeted 28yo choice which I will never tell anyone about.

visiting friends and the softest voice are the true victims. Glad kids on holiday got respect at least