Pitchfork Reviews Reviews

Maybe we need a "Pitchfork Reviews Reviews Reviews" thread for reviews of Pitchfork Reviews Reviews.

smh

hmm this one kinda sounds like mid-period radiohead.

yeah but does it remotely scan with that review

i thought the review fair, and unlike most p4k reviews, an 'actually readable and intelligent piece of writing'

final gambits: photoshop handsome which is a rly pretty pop song

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=a5h2LRvBQ5Q

and 'nasa is on your side' which is like a coldplay song gone right

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4d5PKHhRhkg

yeah i mean i don't want to say "pfork guy offtm" based on two songs (one being a live youtube) but they are less annoying than i imagined so

re: last two tracks, you'll notice they're both very catchy and contain no baffling time-sig changes, confusing melodies or electro wankery

i.e. they're much more about songcraft than about all the extraneous shit that Mr Cohen seems to think EE are about

wish the guy's voice wasn't completely unlistenable

the first of those two isn't great--it's still choppy and i honestly don't understand why they're choosing some of those keyb sounds. the ballad is kinda pretty but his voice does suffer there.

i could give these guys a review in the high 5s.

and w/that i will turn this thread back over to people who want to discuss an inane personal blog site.

That guy is a terrible, terrible singer, about as bad as any I've heard.

i was gonna say that this wasn't apocalyptically bad or anything but the singing in the chorus is just absurd

Can you guys take this shit to another thread ffs?

a few minutes later i accidentally bump into kelly osbourne as we are going up the stairs to the roof and instinctively say “hi my name is david and i write a music blog, could i ask you two questions please?” and she says “okay hurry” and i think really hard for a half a second about what i want to ask her and say “okay what is your favorite black sabbath record?” because ozzy osbourne is her father and was the lead singer of black sabbath, and she looks puzzled and says “i guess all of them? no! no! sabbath bloody sabbath!” and i say “okay and when do you listen to black sabbath? like at what occasion, for example at the gym or when you are relaxing or like any other occasion like that?” and she says “like every day!! i hear it on the answering machine whenever i call the house, or whenever they put me on hold!”

and she looks like she is considering something for a second and says “it’s weird cuz he’s my dad right?”

Thought this was an amusing anecdote in this week's biggest PRR post.

there are so many things i want to say but i'm basically a nice guy

I'M NOT

go on

GIS for "strained laughter" didn't work out tbh

so the Pitchfork threads don't become PRR threads

― markers, Friday, July 23, 2010 4:22 PM (1 month ago) Bookmark

Can you guys take this shit to another thread ffs?

― ilxor has truly been got at and become an ILXor (ilxor), Wednesday, September 15, 2010 3:54 PM (9 minutes ago) Bookmark

<2 months for PRR thread to turn into just another pitchfork thread ;_;

2 posts

the profound comedy of messageboards

so the Pitchfork threads don't become PRR threads
― markers, Friday, July 23, 2010 4:22 PM (1 month ago) Bookmark

Can you guys take this shit to another thread ffs?
― ilxor has truly been got at and become an ILXor (ilxor), Wednesday, September 15, 2010 3:54 PM (9 minutes ago) Bookmark

he doesn't mention that there are two very pretty ambient electro workouts, but then he wouldn't - he hasn't heard the album

― acoleuthic, Wednesday, September 15, 2010 11:14 AM (51 minutes ago) Bookmark Suggest Ban Permalink

dying @ this

T/S: that dog or the Kelly Osbourne anecdote

"if ONLY he knew there were TWO ambient electro workouts--he would NEVER HAVE WRITTEN what he did"

Maybe they should've put a sticker on the case

good thread!

“okay what is your favorite black sabbath record?” because ozzy osbourne is her father and was the lead singer of black sabbath

can't understand why people think this guy could maybe do with reigning it in a tad

Is "reigning it in a tad" slang for cutting his own hands off?

that was Tony Iommi iirc

to ask the finest writer of my generation to self-edit is perverse~

I would endorse this site if every article ended with a paragraph about how badly the interviewee beat him up

PRR weighs in on the Everything Everything review:

Cohen also writes, “…the self-absorbed musical equivalent of having 12 browsers open at the same time…” and having 12 browsers open at the same time would be like having Firefox and Chrome and Safari and Internet Explorer and Netscape Navigator and Opera and 6 other browser programs open simultaneously, and i don’t even know if there are 6 other browsers so i think what he means is either 12 browser tabs or 12 browser windows open, because probably not even the most dedicated tech writer would ever have 12 browsers open simultaneously because what would even be the point of that? they have tabs now

<3

because probably not even the most dedicated tech writer would ever have 12 browsers open simultaneously because what would even be the point of that? they have tabs now

how can you not enjoy this dude, i ask you

very fucking easily

what the world was missing was a cross between fred figglehorn and a self-deprecating ryan schreiber

that ian cohen guy, who wrote the everything everything review, also wrote a particularly smug review of the latest blonde redhead album where he all but dismisses the band's career as a product of new york chic and nothing more, and makes gross assumptions about the band's motives for releasing a quiet record.

u mad

Ian Cohen can only handle four browsers at most.

really possible that ian cohen is not all that as a reviewer, and this everything everything band is not very good either.

the first few lines of that BR review didn't look too persuasive to me either, but i haven't heard the record, so

wahts pitchfork

wrote a particularly smug review of the latest blonde redhead album where he all but dismisses the band's career as a product of new york chic and nothing more

they're kinda mediocre compared to DNA - whose song title they appropriated for their band name - but they're not awful, and i have no problem with other people liking them, even though their career is kinda a product of NY chic

i'm happy to concede that as one possible outlook, but really BH have been around for many years now and have done a lot of things with their sound. seems each time you read about them somebody's having a go at their roots, which by now have more than been transcended.

seems each time you read about them somebody's having a go at their roots

geddit

roots -- like hair