does anyone still like Belle and Sebastian?

The 50 Best Scottish Bands Of All Time (as voted for by the public) are as follows:

Belle & Sebastian
Travis
Idlewild
Wet Wet Wet
Sensational Alex Harvey Band
Simple Minds
Teenage Fanclub
Bay City Rollers
Primal Scream
The Proclaimers
Texas
Mull historical society
Big country
Snow Patrol
Franz Ferdinand
Bis
Deacon Blue
Fish
Jesus and Mary Chain
Mogwai
Runrig
Trash Can Sinatras
Del Amitri
Orange Juice
Nazareth
Beta Band
Biffy Clyro
Altered Images
Aztec Camera
Eddi Reader
Goodbye Mr Mackenzie
Fire Engines
Delgados
Arab strap
Vaselines
Associates
The Pastels
Eurythmics
Aereogramme
Blue Nile
Boards of Canada
Rezillos
Incredible string band
Cocteau twins
Dogs Die in Hot Cars
Spare Snare
Average White Band
Lulu
Skids
Shamen

Aereogramme

lol 2004

I'd still consider voting Aereogramme now.

Where was that from, anyway?

The List/King Tuts' Wah Wah Club/Orange joint promotion, 2005.

I dunno, who are meant to "canonically" be the best Scottish band ever then? Because, Sensational Alex Harvey Band aside, I probably _would_ vote for B&S.

Er, dunno. Just not B&S, that's all ;)

Actually, Yatsura were great as well. I'll vote for them. They would have been better if they were from Camden though.

well it's clearly spare snare

I still love everything prior to that last album which I hate.

This is straight up madness, as The Life Pursuit was pretty much the only thing by B&S worth hearing since If You're Feeling Sinister.

The Life Pursuit was pretty much the only thing by B&S worth hearing since If You're Feeling Sinister.

you just aren't down with that orchestral pop, THATs the true madness. it's beautiful, imo

The blurb was from the HMV website, folks.

Often referred to as the 'greatest Scottish band ever',

You could remove the word "Scottish" from there and you'd get no argument from me.

wit & sebastian

it just strikes me as kind of ummmmmm that a band as derivative as Belle & Sebastian would be championed as the best specimen of anything

is there anyone ever who didnt like If You're Feeling Sinister?

yes kevin, there are many people in this world who don't like that album

Probably most people, if you could play it for every person in the world.

that's a good point

That list of the best Scottish band upthread is a peyle of shyte, fer fooks sake. No BMX Bandits, no cred.

surely most people would like the eps more than sinister

or the life pursuit

Actually, I've found the best B&S album to play to someone whose never heard them is Dear Catastrophe Waitress.

That's because Dear Catastrophe Waitress is easily their very best album. (ducks & runs..)

This is straight up madness, as The Life Pursuit was pretty much the only thing by B&S worth hearing since If You're Feeling Sinister.

― Johnny Fever,

you are deaf

^^^ werd

whenever i'm in a record shop in glasgow and they're playing some unspeakable shite over the sound system, it always turns out to be belle and sebastian

I saw a review this morning, seemed to suggest that the christmas session was an extra on CD2..

Oh, I see what they've done...

The Belfast show was a christmas gig.

Their b-sides and EP collections feature their best work. Hooking up with Trevor Horn was a bad idea in the long run, but where else would they have taken their sound? Oh well, still have the early music.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jJbIqiBNQX0

Such a great live band. The audience is getting older and surlier though. Someone threw spitballs at me for standing & dancing when they played at a seated concert hall in Toronto last year :(

the youtube that I posted is strangely amazing btw

I can't stop watching it