Which of today's artists will get into Rock and Roll HOF?

xpost

Joe Walsh (solo)
Blue Oyster Cult
Dave Mason (solo)
Seals & Crofts
America
Doobie Brothers
3 Dog Night

Run DMC & PE, absolutely. (LL maybe)

My guess is that the criteria in that respect is whether they made an impact on the rock charts. Travis Tritt, no. Garth Brooks - maybe. (Though doubtful because he's worse than Billy Joel.)

you seriously think jann wenner's a big gbv fan?

Probably not, but I doubt he'll be running it in 20 years. Hopefully it will be someone a bit younger...

Why? I'm sure they couldn't give less of a fuck about it themselves....and nor should they. It's meaningless.

I think it's inevitable that Alanis, DMB, RHCP, STP, Green Day, etc. will be held in the same regard as the most of us hold 70's-80's rock now (which is, it's all pretty much revered or at least tolerated with a smirk--even the 2nd-3rd tier stuff like America, Guess Who).

Console yourself knowing that those people are whistleheaded sheep and that YOU KNOW BETTER!

Radiohead is like the Talking Heads, "edgy" for the Hall of Fame, critically respected...they're in.

Teenage Fanclub? tee hee!

for some reason, I read this as whiffleheaded sheep (a la whiffle balls)

"I don't want to see Eric Clapton's stuffed baby!!!"

I said I was pissed off, not that Fripp or any other Crims should be. I've never been very far above the fray, as it were.

I think they deserve it. It would be nice to see them get the recognition they deserve. It pisses me off because of WHY I think they're not in -- Fripp's insistence on calling bullshit on the corruption of the music industry, esp. since his re-un-retirement in the early 90s, following the "period of Endless Grief" legal fight with E.G. Records. He refuses to accept standard industry practices, especially accounting practices, and is very patient, methodical and intractable dealing with major labels*. Anyway, my guess is that part of the industry's payback is "No HoF for YOU."

*This certainly makes him come across as a dick and a martyr. He's infuriating as only the truly principled can be.

Except for the fact that Seymour Stein is one of the men behind the HOF, and all of the Talking Heads LPs were on his label. Didn't Stein himself get inducted into the hall this year or last?

Alex: The Stooges are not in.

Yet the Pretenders are. Yeah, that makes sense.

And don't give me that "...but they didn't sell any records!" nonsense. The Velvet Underground didn't sell shit either and they're in.

R.E.M.
Beck
Pearl Jam
Nirvana
NIN
Sonic Youth
Beasties
Metallica
Radiohead
Green Day (with one more 'serious' album)
Pumpkins
Phish

... are all in. I can't think of any other 90s bands that were as big, though, besides RHCP and bands like Soundgarden, Bush, Live, etc., which I can't imagine will make the cut.

As for bands that are 'big' today not on the above list--i.e., bands who are more in the '00s--

White Stripes
Outkast
The Strokes
Wilco

are in. Assuming the whole place doesn't totally change and let in bands besides Outkast that don't use guitars.

Have a good shot:
Beck (a Rolling Stone darling)
White Stripes/future Jack White projects (see above)
Pearl Jam (may have fucked up their popularity too badly to get in)
Pixies
Eminem
Red Hot Chilli Peppers
Outkast

Don't see it:
Smashing Pumpkins (maybe after Yes gets inducted)
Sonic Youth
Radiohead

No chance in hell:
Pavement
Nine Inch Nails
Oasis
uh... Hasil Adkins

I really don't like at least half these people but the trivial, analytical aspect forces me to weigh in

Didn't Corgan induct Pink Floyd? They're totally in. Yet another meaningless band for a meaninless institution. HUMBUG!

http://www.a-cappella.com/tbimages/45075.md.jpg

!!!

Missy Elliott/Timbaland?

R.E.M. is totally there.

I also think Radiohead, the Pixies, Metallica, Dave Matthews band, Guns N Roses, Green Day, Nine Inch Nails, Beck and Sonic Youth have a good shot.

Run DMC, LL Cool J, and Public Enemy will either make it in, or they'll start a hip hop hall of fame.

I don't see Teenage Fanclub,m the White Stripes, the Strokes or Coldplay making it.

The Stranglers
Siouxsie & the Banshees
Motorhead
Killing Joke
Julian Cope/the Teardrop Explodes
Dead Kennedys
Black Flag
Throbbing Gristle
the Misfits
the Pop Group
Cop Shoot Cop
Pussy Galore
Swans

The thinnest of possible chances:
Buzzcocks
the Damned
Joy Division
Devo
B-52s

Even though I am not at all into hip-hop, I hope they will also be able to include hip-hop (and electronica), as hip-hop and electronica are both clearly part of the bigger and broader history of rock'n'roll.

Hahahhaha...OTM.

They've swiftly become my nephew's favorite band (.........and he's only eleven).

Anyway, REM, Metallica, Madonna, Run DMC and Public Enemy are the sure-thing locks from the 1980s. 1990s, you've got Nirvana, Pearl Jam, Radiohead. After that it gets a little fuzzy.

-- Keith C (kcraw91...), April 9th, 2005.

OTFM \m/

Actually, I bet he'll get in as a "non-performer," which would be hilarious. "Yeah he was that guy who produced Joshua Tree, so we should put him in."