Can someone tell Batman why not?!?

in dude's defense, grant morrison is also bonkers.

sure, but Morrison's stories tend to be crazy in the sense of "I can't believe he just did that", not in the sense of "what the fuck does this mean"

eh I dunno some of his stuff can be pretty oblique, especially if you aren't paying close attention to seemingly minor details. otoh the clerk's comment just seems wrong

maybe Morrison is in control of his madness, where Adams is not

Morrison does a lot of big picture crazy where all the details really only make sense if you look at the whole storyline (and have a deep understanding of kabbalah).

Adams is just nutso

the only Morrison thing I've read that I thought didn't make sense no matter how many times I read it was Mr Miracle and that was only because it relied heavily on assumed knowledge outside of the book; even Shining Knight had a massive "A-HA!" moment that made the first two issues intelligible in retrospect

well there's the thing where Morrison's sentences all seem to be related to each other, for starters
― a variable (sic) "League of Nations" (DJP), Wednesday, July 20, 2011

TBF, that is hardly a consistently accurate assumption

lol being a Kirby nerd I had no problems with Mr. Miracle

The main criterion one should have of a solicitation is "Does it make me wish to read the book in question?" This one, in all its jolly oddness ("...BY MAN OR HERO."; "...BRING TIME TO A STANDSTILL.") most certainly does.

I think what's drawing the most attention is the lack of any exclamation marks, thus rendering all its absurdity po-faced. Absurdity is always better sans hyperbole - who knows what awaits?

Adams has been a mentalist very occasionally making terrible, unreadable comics for thirty years now (until Odyssey, which is either terrible and compulsively readable, or amazing and unreadable) - clerk otm

TIME... ITSELF!

http://i.newsarama.com/images/bmody_v2_cv2_r1_02.jpg

It's BEAUTIFUL.

What the hell? The head cages made of tusks - how are they attached? And why?

Can't guess how, but as to why I'm postulating those are like the lampshade things vets put on pets so they don't lick/bite a healing wound or surgical scar etc.

So that they can't attack the rider or people standing nearby when stationary, I think

Has anyone ever addressed the unlikely coincidence that Bruce Wayne & Boy Wonder share the same initials? If not, I have a pitch for THE summer event of 2013!

Batman: Odyssey is the only Batman book I ever want to read

^

just read this whole thread, i am dying

it's a tragedy if this was canceled

it's still running; they started a volume 2

need to sit down and reread all of these

gonna do a first readthru finally in about five minutes

oh my god every page is immensely impossible and utterly insane
this is kind of magic

I liked Ra's moping around like Charlie Brown. "Sigh..."

i was drowsy when i read this and i fell asleep and when i woke up everything i heard or read sounded like gibberish to me

i was drowsy when i read this and i fell asleep and when i woke up everything i heard or read sounded like gibberish to me

So Batman: Odyssey was the only sane thing in an insane world? Awesome.

Might as well post this here because it's a goddamn Batman book by any other name -- but omg, Holy Terror is so insane and bad. Miller didn't even try to make it good, he just had to get the loathing down on paper as quickly as possible.

explains why he spent eight years working on it

oh what an octopus of a thing

he did a fantastic job of making it look like he spent three weeks working on it

Margaret Atwood on Batman http://www.beamsandstruts.com/bits-a-pieces/item/653-atwood-on-batman

real insightful there

jesus fuck, adams is digging a lot deeper than atwood there.

bought v2 #1 today because of this thread. jesus. <3 neal adams

When is Odyssey going to be collected? I hate buying floppies but want to support this madness.

Volume 1 should be available by now.

Holly crap! Odyssey just keeps getting better. If this isn't hailed as a classic when it's through I weep for humanity.

coming in September:

BATMAN: ODYSSEY HC
Writer: Neal Adams
Artists: Neal Adams, Josh Adams, Michael Golden, Kevin Nowlan, Bill Sienkiewicz, Scott Williams and Paul Neary
Collects: BATMAN: ODYSSEY VOL. 1 #1-6 and VOL. 2 #1-7
$29.99 US, 368 pg

I am so there.

All that crazy for only thirty bones? THAT'S A LOT OF CRAZY.

It'll do until we get the ABSOLUTE LUNACY EDITION

this is full of double pp spreads y/n? will be unreadable in DC's glue-bound, no-gutter-space binding if so

hmm. Hadn't thought of that.

It'll probably do until the IDW artist edition.

Bill Sienkiewicz,

wait waht

He's been inking most of the second volume. You can tell.

So does that mean we're on the other side of the mirror here? Didn't Bill S. start out very much in the vein of Adams (along with half the other artists who started out in the 70s).

WE'VE CROSSED THE STREAMS.

adams even drew a cartoon for the comics journal basically accusing sienkiewicz of copying his old batman comics for moon knight

but then adams has often surrounded himself w. 'school of adams' associates and fellow travellers - for example, the DC artist mike nasser/netzer was a straight adams copyist who went on to do an awful lot of 'ghosting' for adams on shit like ms mystic and skateman. almost everything adams has signed his name to since the late seventies - and possibly earlier - has been the work of 'diverse hands', inc colouring, inking, layouts, etc.

it is incredible, tho, what has happened to bill sienkiewicz's career - did he lose interest, heart, credibility, compulsion?

I get the feeling he never wanted the ultra-high profile he was getting. He also stepped away into commercial art for a while.

I know there was a documentary done a few years ago about him but I never saw it.

He always did commercial art on the side AFAIK, another aspect of following Adams – his turn to inking schlock in the 90s seemed to me to be entirely of a piece with that, something he could churn out quickly for money, except without dealing with revisions from ad house art directors.

I’ve also always taken as significant that he abandoned storytelling in comics completely* two episodes into A River In Egypt – he was starting his third self-written story ever, what was meant to be a second major work, and it immediately revealed itself to be about the same topic as his previous two stories (ie ǝsnqɐ pʃıɥɔ). It looked to me like he’d realised this was the main theme that was going to come out every time he wrote, and he made either a deliberate or visceral reaction to walk away, for understandable reasons.

*As far as I know, the only pages of comics he’s done himself since then were for the Endless Somethingorother hardcover – and there, he turned in 20-some paintings for a 12-page story (or whatever), including multiple takes at various ones, and not matching the script - such that Gaiman ended up picking the ones he liked the look of best, choosing an order for them to go in, and rewriting a new story over the top.

Also he started advocating for earth expansion theory