Grant Morrison S/D

http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/thumb/0/08/Newadventuresofhitler.jpg/180px-Newadventuresofhitler.jpg

The controversy around it was half the fun. It's always great watching po-faced twunts get excited about things.

Nice to know there are plenty of other people out there who keep reading some of these damn series despite the lack of rewards.

(This post will be deleted at some point this weekend by the way).

Does this guy have any kind of game in comic collector circles? I ask because while tidying up the attic last week, I found a copy of "near myths", a brit comic anthology zine from the late '70's. As well as an episode of Bryan Talbot's "Luther Arkwright", it contains an episode of Morrison's "Gideon Stargrave". I believe Morrison resurrected the character in recent years. It is really, really bad. But kind of entertainingly so.

Should I haul it up on ebay, or just stick it back on the shelf, dear ILC-ers?

OH YEAH

perhaps you may even get offers from ILComickers

Oh man!

I have just discovered that they retconned out of existence the big twist from GM's New X-Men.

Which one... the everybody-will-be-mutants one? Or another one?

I thought they'd retconned the lot. Presumably because it left a bunch of X geeks and casual readers who'd just seen the movie all going "WTF? We don't want actual ideas in our comics."

Most of them. Although they retconned Xorn within, like, days after GM's run ended. Evidently they didn't understand the entire concept.

"The Filth is good as a collection of ideas and reads better the second time through. It's part of Grant's "feel sorry for my dead cat" genre."

Can anyone explain this to me?

Which bit?

The Filth is good as a collection of ideas - it's certainly a collection of ideas, and I really like the ideas in the collection.

reads better the second time through - this is self-explanatory, though I haven't given it the second read.

It's part of Grant's "feel sorry for my dead cat" genre." - as seen in Animal Man, he's not above using the projection that humans place on lower lifeforms to get an emotional response, as part of the effect he's trying to generate with his stories.

I actually think that The Filth's insistence that sympathy for non-humans is an essential aspect of humanity is pretty interesting. It's Feely's love for his cat that keeps him from returning to his old life. It's certainly heavy-handed, and something GM's perhaps done a little too much (both in Animal Man, and at least once in The Invisibles), but it is a pretty effective near-universal experience to tap into.

Also, yes, The Filth is certainly better second time through.

...he's not above using the projection that humans place on lower lifeforms to get an emotional response...

-- Andrew Farrell

Perhaps it's exactly as cynical as you suggest, but based on Animal Man, The Filth, We3, Seaguy, I get the impression that the issue is a bit more personal for Mr. Morrison. I.e., he's not coldly exploiting a projection so much as sympathetically exploring the emotional consequences of loss -- using personal experience as a tool. Loved The Filth the first time through, and no more (no less) the second.

Servoret posts from way upthread are so damn great.

Maybe it's not a big issue in The Filth, but I thought Animal Man and WE3 made it clear Morrison cares about animals and animal rights as such, so it's not always just about projection. WE3 is all about not seeing animals as mere intruments to satisfy human needs.

wHAT tUOMAS AND sUGGEST bAN pERMALINK SAID. Sorry, typed without looking with caps lock on.

question - somewhere in volume two of the invisibles, they all draw straws to decide what their role in the group is in terms of elemental symbolism. sadly this comes across as an excuse for the artists to start drawing ragged robin in leather, but the idea is still sort of interesting: does anyone know where morrison got it from?

Maybe he just came up with it himself? The idea of switching roles/responsibilities from time to time to avoid internal hierarchies from developing is quite common in anarchist-oriented grassroot politics, something which Morrison no doubt is familiar with. And combining that with elemental symbolism seems like a typically Morrisonian idea.

hey tuomas is back!

i heard a thing on npr the other day about how during harold washington's (1st black mayor of chicago) campaign, racist supporters of his opponent would sometimes wear blank white badges.

didnt read the thread but marvel boy is his best thing

Has anyone ever checked out that Invisibles' guidebook "Anarchy For The Masses?"