ILX Book Club - Jennifer Egan: A Visit from the Goon Squad

i think 'the keep' breaks down worse than this one tbh but its a lot more fun

i still need to read that

xp

very last part of good squad was very much in the "why non-sf writers shouldn't do future projection" mold. (most of them shouldn't do it, either, tbh.) otoh i can't name too many sf books that punched me in the gut as hard as the best parts of this book.

very last part of good squad was very much in the "why non-sf writers shouldn't do future projection" mold

or MFAs.

i dont think egan is an mfa, actually

can we just say she is?

motherfuckin' author

haha

can we just say she is?

no, that would be lying

i think if we want to make up something about how all mfas are bad at the very least we should be talking about people who are actually mfas

like i mentioned on the "what are you reading" thread that i recently plowed through the three william gibson '90s books and while he got a lot "wrong" and a lot of the rest was obviously blown out of proportion for satirical/narrative effect, his "now" feels a lot more like our actual now than i think egan's future is gonna actually look/feel like when we get there. but gibson's characters are mostly ciphers/plot-drivers, whereas i was actually relieved to see in good squad that rhea (despite a lot of obvious bumps) was doing okay as an adult. all of which just means i guess that i think egan's real gift is for character and sometimes that got away from her with all the hoop-jumping and special effects, though in the abstract i think she should be applauded for trying to bring that gift to all the metafictional hoohah.

all of which makes it sound like i enjoyed this book a lot less than i did, but i actually really, really enjoyed it.

i think egan's real gift is for character

definitely

i think why i was so dazzled by goon squad immediately after i read it, even though on reflection i like look at me and the keep more, is that it's virtuosic in its tour of characters and it seems like egan sympathizes with them all.

Lamp said something about this upthread i think; he was otm

i think the best part of the novel is how compassionate it is, & how much she seemed to want to give all her characters the benefit of the doubt, to do them justice. & that made me eager to spend time in their company, to know them & to empathize w/ them.

― Lamp, Sunday, May 8, 2011 5:29 AM (11 hours ago) Bookmark

I didn't enjoy it much but it was too vaporous to despise. My favorite section remains the one set in Italy; its tone is subtler than the rest of the novel.

i'll kill u

lol

tbh i was kinda afraid of voicing any reservations about this book in front of horseshoe

haha i'm sorry! the days of the ilx book club on this book were hard for me but it was good experience to try to respond to pinefox's criticisms in my head. really welcome what all the smart people have to say about how they hate my beloved book.

hahaha never read this thread, pinefox is hilarious

pinefox on some definite anthropologist-from-mars steez in this thread

― thomp, Tuesday, May 3, 2011

"this thread"

j/k pinefox i luv u boo

I'd like to go to a party with horseshoe and change her experience - and mine - of what people talk about at parties.

I don't see what grounds Max has for saying Egan is a talented stylist. I think 'stylist' etc was already discussed in this long fractious thread. I think some of us think she seems stylistically pretty flat.

Max is very lucky to be 25 years younger than Egan. Let's hope he makes the most of that incredible boon! (I'm serious - there is nothing much more valuable than youth.)

I don't know Warlock but I can confirm that I have never finished THE WARLOCK OF FIRETOP MOUNTAIN.

I'm actually only 23 years younger than Egan.

Oh no !!!

Oh no !!!

Now that REALLY shouldn't have posted twice.

hey horseshoe, have you listened to this?

http://www.kcrw.com/etc/programs/bw/bw061221jennifer_egan

<3 for "stephen king's salem's lot...a book that i love"

listening right now, thanks strongo! everything she's ever said about fiction is totally <3 ime

not fair for her to be so talented and so pretty btw

when i went to look up her age i figured she was gonna be like 30something, not 50

she lives near me btw

I don't like her as a writer

never read anything she wrote though

i don't like YOU as a writer

that's untrue tbh

she's just one of those contemporary writers who has won a prize so I lump her in w/ people like franzen or zadie smith or whatever, whose work I'm familiar w/ and think will not last in any meaningful way, probably shouldn't though

it's so weird that that happened btw...i guess she was on the fast track (i get the sense she's literarily *connected* maybe) but when i was first reading look at me it felt like this undiscovered gem that if any literary tastemakers ran across it they would probably dismiss as chicklit.

of course she was getting published in the new yorker so i was wrong, i guess

now that I am talking about books on a thread big ups to aero for recc'ing the rodoreda

I am actually a really easy reader once I actually read something though and like p much everything so when I read this I probably won't hate her

also, a lot of other good interviews on that show, hs, if yr not familiar. especially the robert stone ones.

jokes.

my hatred of robert stone is so kneejerk and reflects very poorly on me. it's basically the same as if someone dismissed egan as chicklit.

well he is very dudelit

marlboro man lit

god i know, right? i imagine he has a whiskey-roughened voice.

haha he actually kinda sounds like a kindly grandpa

but one thing i've learned listening to bookworm over the years is that insufferable writers tend to sound exactly like you'd think they would