Lament

Message Bookmarked
Bookmark Removed
I lament the real cut and thrust of a footy forum.

We all seem to be a bit sterile and very, very conservative with our comments and observations.

In a way, I kind of miss the old ABC Footy Forum, where we sometimes travelled down memory lane but always got a laugh from the comments of others.

At the moment it's a bit like we're afraid to offend someone or other. And aren't we ever so polite when Coll/Ess/Eagles or whoever beat our team on Sat arvo.

Come on everyone, let loose. Let's hear your opinion on who the best player or team is that you've ever seen.

Perhaps the reason we like to have a dig at jase is because he wears his heart on his sleeve and his foot in his mouth, but he seems to ride the bumps and comes back for more.

Let's all be a bit like jase and get more involved.

Pleads his case for more banter. Judd for the alternate Brownlow

Westener (Westener), Tuesday, 17 May 2005 13:24 (nineteen years ago) link

Westy. If you want ferals you can get them on Saintsational or BigFooty. Nothing wrong with a bit of Nettiquette old chap.

*sotto vocce* fargen Western Australian tossas fargen frontrunning pretender AFL susbsided suckhole wanker wannabees.. Oops! Is this thing still on??

Cats for the flag get stuffed!!

regards,

REB

Rik E Boy (Rik E Boy), Tuesday, 17 May 2005 21:00 (nineteen years ago) link

Let's all be a bit like jase and get more involved.

Jase only gets involved when his team has had a win.

Let's hear your opinion on who the best player or team is that you've ever seen.

Best player seen? Gary Ablett snr.
Best team? Essendon 2000.

chrisso (chrisso), Tuesday, 17 May 2005 22:13 (nineteen years ago) link

Best players: Doull, Jessa, Blight, Ablett, Carey, Hird, Matthews, Royce Hart

Best team: North 1977

Re the ferals: Who needs them? Haters may be noisy but after the novelty wears off they quickly become as boring as batshit (look at waboy or shortkeeper or ccc from the old ABC). I'm with REB on this. Especially when there's only about ten of us altogether.

Fred Nerk (Fred Nerk), Wednesday, 18 May 2005 01:30 (nineteen years ago) link

Benno's Best players of the last decade or so - King Carey, Paul Kelly, Glen Archer, Plugger for being round and unstoppable. Voss, Bucks, Hird, Riccuto. Guys who put their body on the line week in week out.

Best team? Lions 2001-2004 (minus the GF) by a long shot.

Best coach? Lethal.
Worst Coach? Spud, Coaster Laidley (half a coach), Tony Shaw
Best looking jumpers - Collingwood.
Worst looking jumpers - the red abomination Port played in the heritage round, and Freo's green jumper from early seasons.

Most overrated players - Fat Lance, Shane Woewodin, Nick Davis, Jude Bolton, Michael O'Loughlin.
Most underrated players - Glen Archer, Jimmy Clement, Luke Power, Brad Johnson, Luke Darcy

Things I would change if AFL Commissioner - ALL clubs have distinctively different clash strips. Collingwood have black and white at home, have white or green or something else away. Richmond have yellow strip, silver clash jumper etc
- Holding the ball - reward the bloke trying to win the footy
- Ruckman catching the ball and getting tackled instantly - reward the ruckman for his good work or fortune.


Bennö (Bennö), Wednesday, 18 May 2005 05:23 (nineteen years ago) link

ps - Most entertaining footballer - RIIIIIICCCCHHHHHOOOOO! On fire, he is the ultimate entertainer. When not on fire, he is the ultimate comedy act...

Bennö (Bennö), Wednesday, 18 May 2005 05:26 (nineteen years ago) link

Lucy's Favourite All time player - John 'Woosha' Worsfold.
With Benno on this - Voss, Hird, Riccuto. Guys who put their body on the line week in week out.

Best team? Lions 2001-2004 (minus the GF) by a long shot. Tick, Tick

Best coach? Lethal.
Worst Coach? Laidley
Best looking jumpers - Brisbane Lions, Maroon Blue and Gold with a bloody big Lion!
Worst looking jumpers - the red abomination Port played in the heritage round, and Freo's green jumper from early seasons and the Eagles Cross your heart Bra version.

Most overrated players - Fat Lance, Shane Woewodin, Nick Davis, Jude Bolton, Michael O'Loughlin.
Most underrated players - Glen Archer, Jimmy Clement, Luke Power, Brad Johnson, Luke Darcy

Things I would change if AFL Commissioner - ALL clubs have distinctively different clash strips. Lions will be unveiling their new alternate strip this year it looks great and quite distinctive. It also has a bloody big Lion on it!

No Salary Cap Consessions for any team or a Concession for every team who has a %of out of state players.

Football Clubs that value their members above corporate hangerson.

Most entertaining footballer - Darryl White in full flight

Lucy Lion (Lucy Lion), Wednesday, 18 May 2005 08:12 (nineteen years ago) link

Westy. If you want ferals you can get them on Saintsational or BigFooty

Nah REB, ferals of the BigFooty type not welcome. How many threads of "Which player has the best bum" or "Which team practices square dancing before da game", can a koala bear? They can stay where they are.

But good footy talk and discussion is what I crave. Some outrageous opinions that we can pile the carp on are most welcome.

Bloody love it.

Westener (Westener), Wednesday, 18 May 2005 12:30 (nineteen years ago) link

Now to the task in hand seeing as though I started it.

Best ever seen - Polly Farmer by two country miles - and not because he is a Groper, just the best. Big wraps for Plugger, Hird, Voss,Ablett, Lethal and Dean Kemp.

Best team - would like it to be Eagles early 90's but must concede and nominate Brisbane for last few years.

Entertainers would have to include the Krakouers, Crackers and a huge laugh from Wacko Jacko.

Most overrated - Nick Stevens, Anthony Banik and Richard Lounder. John Hutton figures in there somewhere.

Biggest mistake - Dockers taking Chris Groom over Andy McLeod

Biggest blight on the game today - 1. Ch 9 and the perception that by endless replays of an incident it can influence a decision.
2. Umpiring standards at an all time low in spite of an all time record number of people officiating. The days when an umpire learnt his craft umpiring in the bush and then through the grades are gone and now we have umpires of a young age with limited experience making the Michael Avon type decisions from last week. Their lack of consistency is appalling.

What I would change if an AFL Commissioner - The AFL CEO!!!

Westener (Westener), Wednesday, 18 May 2005 12:53 (nineteen years ago) link

Best Teams I've witnessed ... Hawkas 1983-1991 (missed playing in only one Grand Final) ... followed by the Lions who are the best team of the present day

Best Players I've witnessed ... Lethal, Carey, Ablett
Best recent Player .... Voss, Judd, Hird
Best Coaches ... Alan Jeans / Lethal / Sheeds

Things I would change if AFL Commissioner ... only one field umpire (make them earn their money and we would see some consistency across the park for a change).

Current ...
Best Acting Team ... Essendon
Overated Team ... Richmond (they're talking finals after just 8 rds ... they mustn't remember what happened to them in 2003)
Played above themselves for a few years and are now showing true form ... Collingwood
Worst overall performance ... AFL CEO / Umpires
Funniest player - Richo
Best Disguisers of a throw - Adelaide / Essendon / Port

Hawka (hawka), Wednesday, 18 May 2005 12:53 (nineteen years ago) link

Best Team: Brisbane 2001-2004
Best Player: Gary's dad
Most overrated: Nathan Buckley
Most underrated: Darren Milburn (Archer? He is universally admired I would have thought)
Best Jumper: Cats
Worst Jumper: Brisbane Bears, Hawthorn's 'triangles' pre-season get up.
Best Coach: Malthouse
Worst Coach: Don Scott (South Adelaide SANFL. Lost first six matches and went back to Victoria with his tail between his legs). Worst AFL? Peter Rhode.
Most overrated team: Melbourne
Most underrated team: Kangaroos
Biggest issues: TV Coverage in NSW and Qld, Turning football into netball
Biggest non-issue: Anything brought up on 'The Footy Show', changing the Brownlow
Football dream: A Cat premiership
Football nightmare: It happened last year
Furtherest away from the flag: The Pies, Hawks and Blues
Closest to the flag: Eagles, Cats, Saints
Biggest mistake: Hawthorn letting Gary's dad go to Geelong after six games (glad they did tho!)
Best Ground: MCG
Worst Groud: Fargen Football Park. Blow up the joint.

regards,

REB

Rik E Boy (Rik E Boy), Wednesday, 18 May 2005 21:21 (nineteen years ago) link

Can we add - most likely to be a superstar (if not already) - Gary's son, Jared Brennan (Lions), Bo Hansen (WC)

REB, I agree with the netball call. A week for Judd for smacking the pr*ck Baker in the head? Umps should have given him 3 votes instead.

Biggest Issue - f*cking taggers. Anyone doing that whole play the man not the ball should expect at least one elbow in the head, per round.

TV coverage in Southern NSW and ACT is great - if you have Fox. Friday night footy is shown at the same time as Melbourne on Main Event 955 - at no extra cost. Noone knows about it, but it makes the $15 a week Fox costs me worth it over winter....

Bennö (Bennö), Wednesday, 18 May 2005 22:22 (nineteen years ago) link

Most overrated: Tarrant
Most underrated: M.Johnson
Best Jumper: Bombers
Worst Jumper: Brisbane Bears.
Best Coach: Sheedy - we are always there or thereabouts, even with a shit list.
Worst Coach: Tim Watson.
Most overrated team: Geelong
Most underrated team: Kangaroos
Biggest issues: Caffeine LOL
Biggest non-issue: Some of the stats that are thrown up these days are just laughable. Inside 50's, Quarters won. WGAF!
Football dream: Sheedy to coach for another 25 years.
Football nightmare: The day Sheeds leaves.
Furtherest away from the flag: The Pies, Blues and Freo.
Closest to the flag: Eagles and St Kilda.
Biggest mistake: 5 year contracts.
Best Ground: Telstra Stadium (Sydney) = MCG. Can't split 'em.
Best caller:Dennis Commetti.
Best new commentator: Wayne Carey
Best Boundry rider: Tiffany Cherry. Yummy.

chrisso (chrisso), Wednesday, 18 May 2005 23:47 (nineteen years ago) link

Firstly chrisso, you tool, im here win loss or draw, its just unlike some i actually work .

Westy, foot in mouth, hows your form, perhaps you should scroll over a couple of your comments.

Most overrated: Tarrant, Riccuito, Gardiner, Bell, Medhurst,The list is endless really, i think every team has at least 2
Most underrated: R James
Best Jumper: Power
Worst Jumper: Dockers.
Best Coach: Matthews.
Worst Coach: Mark Williams.
Most overrated team: West Coast, Freo, Essendon and St Kilda
Most underrated team: Hawthorn, now it has a coach
Biggest issues: Tribunal bullshit
Biggest non-issue:
Football dream: Sheedy to coach for another 25 years, i agree chrisso, please sign him for a couple more bwhahahaha
Football nightmare: Crows winning the flag.
Furtherest away from the flag: Collingwood, Carlton, Essendon.
Closest to the flag: Geelong.
Biggest mistake: Signing Nick Holland to a long contract.
Best Ground: G.
Best caller:Dennis Commetti.
Worst Caller: R Walls
Biggest Dickhead: R Walls
Best new commentator: ??
Best Boundry rider: Get rid of the lot of them, waste of time, maybe have one of those birds from teh boxing to walk around teh oval in the G

jsa, Thursday, 19 May 2005 00:03 (nineteen years ago) link

Best Players Seen: Ablett, Wanganeen, Harvey, Archer Carey Voss
Best Wife/Girlfriend: Judd
Dirtiest Wife/Girlfriend: Stevens, dont blame carey she was a glamour
Worst Columnist: R Walls
Most Bias in Commentary: R Walls or KG or Eddiewood

jsa, Thursday, 19 May 2005 00:16 (nineteen years ago) link

Most overrated Geelong?? Who rates the Cats in the media?? Sheesh.

regards,

REB

Rik E Boy (Rik E Boy), Thursday, 19 May 2005 00:32 (nineteen years ago) link

Firstly chrisso, you tool, im here win loss or draw, its just unlike some i actually work .

That reminds me, I better get the toilet cleaned.

chrisso (chrisso), Thursday, 19 May 2005 01:03 (nineteen years ago) link

wrong thread chrisso, talking of essenden would remind you of the toilet being cleaned, now get back to tendering to your boss.

REB, its only a bitter twisted bombers supporter who with his secretarial job and crap footy side who would suggest that. Like most REB on this forum, laugh at him and thank god that he isnt making coffee for you.

REB, see your mob norwood won their 2nd game in a row. Maybe dale lewis in teh next big thing in coaches.

jsa, Thursday, 19 May 2005 01:12 (nineteen years ago) link

Nah Jase, we lost to the Yabs between beating the moneybacks and the good old light powder Blues LOL. Now if we beat the Hybrids....

regards,

REB

Rik E Boy (Rik E Boy), Thursday, 19 May 2005 02:01 (nineteen years ago) link

Like most REB on this forum, laugh at him and thank god that he isnt making coffee for you.

Laugh at moi?Lol.

Who were the certainties for the Flag again, Jase? C'mon, we could all do with a chuckle.

chrisso (chrisso), Thursday, 19 May 2005 02:17 (nineteen years ago) link

12/1 is a great price for the flag

jsa, Thursday, 19 May 2005 02:29 (nineteen years ago) link

Only if ya win Jase LOL

REB

Rik E Boy (Rik E Boy), Thursday, 19 May 2005 05:17 (nineteen years ago) link

...with his secretarial job.

UP YOURS !!

Lucy Lion (Lucy Lion), Thursday, 19 May 2005 05:58 (nineteen years ago) link

Now now lucy no offence was meant.

jsa, Thursday, 19 May 2005 06:17 (nineteen years ago) link

Best Team: Brisbane 2001-2004
Best Player: Michael Voss circa '96-02
Most overrated: They've all player more AFL footy then I ever did!!
Most underrated: Brett Voss
Best Jumper: Carlton
Worst Jumper: Brisbane Bears maroon version, WC's drop sheet of blue and orange
Best Coach: Tom Haffey
Worst Coach: Murray Weideman
Most overrated team: Fremantle
Most underrated team: Western Bulldogs
Biggest issues: Friday nights TV Coverage in NSW and Qld
Biggest non-issue: Caffine and number of possessions for each player stats
Football dream: Voss,M. to coach Brisbane
Football nightmare: People listening to McGuire,E.
Furtherest away from the flag: Collingwood
Closest to the flag: Eagles, Cats,
Biggest mistake: Buckley,N. leaving Brsibane to play 'finals football' - Should go down in Australian sports folklore that one eg. "He's done a Buckley!"
Best Ground: MCG and a full 'Gabba
Worst Groud: Carrara

I'd like to add Spider Evertt to the list of best players ? What the !@##@$$@# you say.

Big Bird (Big Bird), Friday, 20 May 2005 01:16 (nineteen years ago) link

BB, Spider is a damn good player, and arguably the best ruckman I've seen in the different game that is modern AFL football, but he doesn't make my top 10 players...

Bennö (Bennö), Friday, 20 May 2005 01:41 (nineteen years ago) link

Just trying to be 'controversy man' in keeping with Westener's request. But I saw him play a SOO game against the Allies at the 'Gabba and God he was good. This footy is a really simple game if you can mark overhead and kick accurately over 55 metres, he was fantastic.

I've seen the wees and poos three times this year and he's been outstanding each time, I wonder what he is for the Brownlow, might be worth $10 investment.

Big Bird (Big Bird), Friday, 20 May 2005 02:39 (nineteen years ago) link

I spose I saw the Dorks at the SCG on Round 1, and Spider was their best player by that far it wasn't funny. He won the rucks, and was the best rover they had on the day. He was also the most effective forward. You've got a point BB!

Bennö (Bennö), Friday, 20 May 2005 04:18 (nineteen years ago) link

Football dream: Voss,M. to coach Brisbane No dream BB he'll be coaching us within 6 years
Worst Jumper: Brisbane Bears maroon version the one with the Koala "Bear"(!!!) was embarassing but I loved the one they used for the Heritage Round last year.

Lucy Lion (Lucy Lion), Friday, 20 May 2005 06:44 (nineteen years ago) link

but he doesn't make my top 10 players...

Who are they Benno( sorry I can't do the squiggle)?

Mine(ones I have seen-admittedly only on TV for some):-

Other than Farmer - in no particular order
Polly Farmer
Ablett
Lethal
Plugger
Glendenning
Akermanis
Kemp
Carey
Stephen Michael
Diesel

Westener (Westener), Friday, 20 May 2005 10:51 (nineteen years ago) link


You must be logged in to post. Please either login here, or if you are not registered, you may register here.